Reality of FDI, beyond politics

desijat

New member
I have been hearing a lot of myths about FDI, people who dont know much morphing assumptions without any base. I came across a very well analysed article by PPI and sharing the same for everyone's enlightenment and enhancement of knowledge.



The idea of this article is to take the view of the average citizen also called the ‘aam admi’.
The fundamental premise of a multi-brand retail organization is of ‘economies of scale’- economies of scale in every sphere of their operation. They procure in large quantities, store and distribute through large warehouses and complex logistics supply chain and then of course the large stores which is the tail end of the entire chain that you and I are likely to see.

While we hope that the efficiencies that are being talked about in the procurement and distribution chains happen, guess we can leave it safely to the experts.

What we should be concerned about are a few pertinent questions with respect to what will motivate us to buy in a large store like say Wal Mart :
· Convenience of the store from where we reside or work

· Choice and quality of products available satisfying different price ranges

· Price

There is no ‘one size fits all’ method in determining an individual’s motivation to buy in a large store.
Let us take a different cut at this. Why did large stores like these become successful in the US ?
· Everybody in the US has a car (200 million and counting in a population of 300 million)

· On an average the US home is large on a per capita basis as compared to India.

What has been the experience in other Western countries ?
· Other Western countries like UK, Australia and many countries in continental Europe also share similar demographics to the US and therefore the multi-brand retail stores have become successful.

Have they ‘killed’ the kirana stores in these countries ?
· Not at all. The ‘kirana type’ stores have continued to survive and thrive. The stores have morphed into providing more and more of the goods and services for e.g. many of them offer postal services too.

· The multi-brand stores have also created an economy of specialist stores. For e.g. if you are a bicycle enthusiast you might get a few and inexpensive choices of bikes in a Wal-Mart but if you are a bicycle aficionado you would rather visit a specialist bicycle shop who can sell you bikes from $100 to $10,000.


Therefore how is it likely to play out in India ?
The average Indian owns a 2-wheeler and some a 4-wheeler too. The average home in India is small and limited space available to stock goods in quantities to take advantage of the price and quality benefits offered by a multi-brand retail store.

What this means in our view is both will co-exist. As and when the multi-brand retail come into play, they will bring down prices due to competition and everybody will benefit. Kirana stores are agile, driven by the Marwari and Gujarati communities and you can trust them to transform their businesses to add-on differentiating goods and services to consumers near their location.
As India’s population becomes more and more Middle Class, it will also create a discerning populace. More and more Indians will aspire for goods and services which will be in line with their pursuits (e.g. a super sports bike). While the multi-brand retail outlets will cater for the large base aspirations of the population, the more ‘picky and choosy’ ones will gravitate towards specialist type goods and services. One can expect therefore a significant growth in specialty stores arising out of the multi-brand retail boom.

Net net, ignore the politics behind this move and this will benefit every stakeholder in the chain.


While debate is always open, I would wish debate of facts and not emotions/assumptions or political inclination.
 
Darker side of FDI

Over the past week the topic FDI in multi brand retail has become a platitude with most of us professionals painting a rosy picture of the supposed benefits that such a policy will usher and the sweeping change it will bring. However, I hold a little divergent view on this reformist measure and I have my own strong arguments for it. For those obsessed with the geographical reach and demographic boundaries that multi brand FDI in retail will help to cross, we must remember that such FDI will only aid the establishment of stores in urban agglomerations whose cumulative population as per 2011 census comes to 14,06,87,573, which is approximately merely 11.5% of our 120 crore population. As such its target area seems to be to limited in the medium term Secondly, we have seen many experts holding the view that it would bring in the much needed finance in the retail sector. However, we must not ignore the fact that many of India's leading business houses such as Reliance, Tatas, Bharti, Aditya Birla have already jumped into the retail bandwagon and by no stretch of imagination do they seem to be in short supply of funds. Therefore, I don't agree with the idea that the funds to fuel the retail boom into our economy needs to be imported from outside. Thirdly, while we draw parallels with the western economy to forecast the potential economic benefits of opening up the multi brand retail segment to foreign investors, we must understand that there is a chalk and cheese difference between the composition of the Indian and western economy. For a labour surplus economy like India such standalone retail stores, perhaps, provide the most convenient means of self employment. Therefore, while we speak about the employment opportunities such organized retail would bring we must not forget that the fact that it seeks to convert a large chunk of our populace into the salaried class, in the process crushing the entrepreneurial spirit of our country and further widening the already rising inequality.
 
Negative Impact of FDI in retail sector in India

1. The most important factor which is against allowing FDI in retail sector is that small traders will not able to compete with the big players and thus cease to exist. These traders don’t have the capital and expertise to compete with big retail chains. They will not be able to buy goods at a lower price from suppliers while big players who have a strong supply chain network across the world which gives them a high bargaining power to buy goods at the lowest price. The big chains also have a capacity to sustain losses for a longer period therefore able to undercut prices of goods which will lead to desertion of small traders.2. It is assumed that Initially foreign stores would keep the prices of their products low in order to attract their customers & eliminate their competitors. But with the time they would establish their monopoly in Indian markets & hence quality and price of products would be compromised. It would be like “Bringing back East India Company. “3. Also in a country like India where millions of people are semi-skilled, it is the retail sector which offers them source of earning as one can easily open a small shop with a little capital. The government should understand that before approving any policy reform in the retail sector it must create jobs in other sectors which can accommodate these people.4. “Only 1 employee is recruited in 400 yards of a Wall-Mart’s showroom”. So it is estimated that on an average only 1 will be able to get job in Multi-brand stores while at least 10 people would be losing their jobs due to FDI.If foreign stores are able to set up their monopoly, then even farmers would have no other option than selling their crops to Multi-brand stores at low prices. This would exploit farmers.5. Some economist give the argument that policies of Globalisation & Open Trade across the border initiated by Dr. Manmohan Singh during 1990s has not been so effective in controlling inflation & price rise . Moreover, the problem of unemployment is still persists in India.
 
6. Opening of Multi-brand stores, setting up of infrastructure , recruitment of staff & maintenance of quality of products during initial stages would force the foreign retailers to sell their products at higher price. So Government’s plea,that Inflation would be controlled to a larger extent, does not convince majority of Indians.
7. Advocates of FDI in retail give China has an example, which witnessed enormous growth in retail sector after allowing FDI. But they don’t inform that China allowed a gradual increase in FDI in retail — it allowed an FDI of up to 26 per cent in 1992 and increased it to 49 per cent in 2002 and allowed 100 per cent in 2004. It is also not justifiable to compare India with China: China is a communist country where job market is regulated in contrast India is a democratic country where people have an option to start their own business. In China, manufacturing sector offers numerous employment opportunities but this is not the case with India.
 
Alternative steps to counter negative impact of FDI

Change in Economic policies has become a necessity now. There must be a proper survey regarding actual position of demand & supply ration in India.

  1. Although by allowing FDI in retail the biggest gainer will be the consumer who will get more choices attractive prices, if this is achieved by rendering millions unemployed and denying them their livelihood, then such benefit are worthless. The government should realise that its prime responsibility is to create more jobs for unemployed people. It would make sense that any policy which leads to reduction in jobs should be put on hold until new sources of employment are created.
  2. Instead of opening the sector for FDI in urgency, the government should invest in training of small retailers and traders to guide them on the subject of storing, grading, and refrigerating of perishable goods. Institutes like ITIs and NGOs can be very helpful for implementation of such schemes. Infrastructure of local mandis also need to be upgraded and all kind of facilities and training should be provided to the management of local mandis to reduce the wastage of goods and increase efficiency.
  3. Proper Land Acquisition policies,socio-economic facilities to farmers & proper infrastructure for cold storage & transportation of grains should be on main agenda of Government.
  4. Strengthening of Public Distribution System (PDS) would allow a proper chain of demand & supply.
 
The case is made for allowing FDI in retail on the basis of the need to develop better supply-chain network for supporting activities like warehousing, cold storage, transportation and logistics services. It is said that about 40 per cent of fruits and vegetables rot before they can be sold due to lack of cold storage facilities and poor infrastructure. While the facts may be true and infrastructure and development needs are also undeniable, the belief that it can be developed only by allowing FDI is unfounded. It is the failure of all governments since the last green revolution that they are not able to provide any major reform in agriculture and related sectors. Now to hide their failure and inability to provide better infrastructure they are taking the help of foreign players whose very existence is based on making profit for their shareholders. Studies suggest that wherever these retail chains have opened the growth of nearby areas have come down compared to the average growth of the region. So the government should be more cautious to open the retail sector for FDI as the odds of losing is much higher. Thus, to conclude I can just say that it is a mixed blessing where perhaps, the disadvantages far outweigh the advantages as things stand today in our economy. We need to open up those areas to foreign investors where there is shortage of funds or domestic investors are apprehensive about investing such as infrastructure, power, etc. The need of the hour is to expand our economy and not just to increase the competitive environment without any real growth as with such FDI in retail the consumption side is not likely to rise but the sellers are merely replaced. We need to make our vision clear before we embark on such reforms which according to me will not bring any real growth to our economy.
 
और बात छोडो लिखन को तो ग्रंथ लिखा जा सके इसपे ..जाट जो सबसे जायदा गन्ना किसान है नॉर्थ इंडिया में उसका गान्डा यो वालमार्ट कुकर उठावेगा ..? या उस ईख में ते चीनी वही खेत में से काढ के वाल मार्ट में बिकेगी| चीनी तो शुगर मिल से ही जायेगी वाल मार्ट में या किसान के खेत में से ? फायदा मिल मालिक का है या किसान का ? क्योकि वाल मार्ट चीनी सस्ते में बेचेगा और जब चीनी सस्ते में बीके गी तो गान्डे का भाव यो मनमोहिनी देगी या वोह सोनिया ?
 
When we say Walmart sells cheap doesnt mean it downgrades the market value and then sell it. Secondly, an assumption that is made right now is that existing parallel mandi will go away, no it wont and who ever will give the best price sugar will be sold there.

Take it this way, Walmart or Tesco are adding competition to an existing system in which of a case the seller enjoys more choices and better prices. Walmart will make money on supply chain cost cutting and better inventory management in this specific case.

और बात छोडो लिखन को तो ग्रंथ लिखा जा सके इसपे ..जाट जो सबसे जायदा गन्ना किसान है नॉर्थ इंडिया में उसका गान्डा यो वालमार्ट कुकर उठावेगा ..? या उस ईख में ते चीनी वही खेत में से काढ के वाल मार्ट में बिकेगी| चीनी तो शुगर मिल से ही जायेगी वाल मार्ट में या किसान के खेत में से ? फायदा मिल मालिक का है या किसान का ? क्योकि वाल मार्ट चीनी सस्ते में बेचेगा और जब चीनी सस्ते में बीके गी तो गान्डे का भाव यो मनमोहिनी देगी या वोह सोनिया ?
 
we must not ignore the fact that many of India's leading business houses such as Reliance, Tatas, Bharti, Aditya Birla have already jumped into the retail bandwagon and by no stretch of imagination do they seem to be in short supply of funds. Therefore, I don't agree with the idea that the funds to fuel the retail boom into our economy needs to be imported from outside.[/FONT][/FONT]


Nobody is still stopping Tatas or Ambanis. Point is, none of them have been profitable till now for a simple reason, they lack expertise to manage the system.
Secondly, the article speaks about how kirana stores will not go anywhere for the ease and comfort they give. Have you seen local dhabas go away because of McD?
 
Why only foriegn players, you think Indian companies dont do so? Ambanis or Tatas or Birlas play fair game and create value for society instead of share holders?

they are taking the help of foreign players whose very existence is based on making profit for their shareholders. [/B]
 
Tatas or Ambanis. Point is, none of them have been profitable till now for a simple reason, they lack expertise to manage the system.

No offence---don't u think u r underestimating indians tycoons------u r accusing them that they could not manage systemmmmmm
now the question is why-----just coz they are indian

ghar ki murgi dal brabar
 
Not at all, infact I trust them so much and I am sure they tested the markets long time before and that is why are not coming into it. Aditya Birla and Reliance had already tried their hands and failed. Bharti has been gathering expertise in a tie up with Walmart.

We must understand that retailing is not as simple as it sounds, technical capabilities and know-how is what we aim to achieve through those who have been big worldwide. Also, 49% of the market is still controlled by Indian players and no one still still stopping them if they want to go solo.

To give you another example, look at our airline industry which has been bleeding because govt was late to allow foreign investments by global players who have been managing better airlines. Due to the delay in implementing the policy a lot of our airlines(Kingfisher for one) have been bleeding money and Air India is nothing more than a money sucking parasite. Having said that, Indigo is the only profitable player and that is because of their know-how and business acumen which is separate from rest of them all.

Same way, Walmart, Tesco have their expertise which can put us on an rampant growth without waiting for another decade to build capacities.

Tatas or Ambanis. Point is, none of them have been profitable till now for a simple reason, they lack expertise to manage the system.

No offence---don't u think u r underestimating indians tycoons------u r accusing them that they could not manage systemmmmmm
now the question is why-----just coz they are indian

ghar ki murgi dal brabar
 
In short ek he baat kehna chahta hu ki

FDI lagu hone se jo aam aadmi jaise ki kissan h, uski re re matti banegi.....
aur jo bichare apni chotti chotti dukan khol k apna ghar chala re se unki pait pe latt lagegi.....
 
Darker side of FDI

Over the past week the topic FDI in multi brand retail has become a platitude with most of us professionals painting a rosy picture of the supposed benefits that such a policy will usher and the sweeping change it will bring. However, I hold a little divergent view on this reformist measure and I have my own strong arguments for it. For those obsessed with the geographical reach and demographic boundaries that multi brand FDI in retail will help to cross, we must remember that such FDI will only aid the establishment of stores in urban agglomerations whose cumulative population as per 2011 census comes to 14,06,87,573, which is approximately merely 11.5% of our 120 crore population. As such its target area seems to be to limited in the medium term Secondly, we have seen many experts holding the view that it would bring in the much needed finance in the retail sector. However, we must not ignore the fact that many of India's leading business houses such as Reliance, Tatas, Bharti, Aditya Birla have already jumped into the retail bandwagon and by no stretch of imagination do they seem to be in short supply of funds. Therefore, I don't agree with the idea that the funds to fuel the retail boom into our economy needs to be imported from outside. Thirdly, while we draw parallels with the western economy to forecast the potential economic benefits of opening up the multi brand retail segment to foreign investors, we must understand that there is a chalk and cheese difference between the composition of the Indian and western economy. For a labour surplus economy like India such standalone retail stores, perhaps, provide the most convenient means of self employment. Therefore, while we speak about the employment opportunities such organized retail would bring we must not forget that the fact that it seeks to convert a large chunk of our populace into the salaried class, in the process crushing the entrepreneurial spirit of our country and further widening the already rising inequality.

That is good if these Non Tax payer shopkeeper converted to Tax payer employees. I think it is positive
 
FDI in retail: A step in the right direction!

Indians should not be mislead by conspiracy of protectionism. We had this protectionism for years but no good happened in the country. Licence Raj, rigid labour laws and monster bureaucracy(where No accountability exists) let down the economy and kept millions of Indians away from jobs. I think more substantial reforms are needed in order to strengthen the economy!
 
In short ek he baat kehna chahta hu ki

FDI lagu hone se jo aam aadmi jaise ki kissan h, uski re re matti banegi.....
aur jo bichare apni chotti chotti dukan khol k apna ghar chala re se unki pait pe latt lagegi.....
विकास,किसान नै तो ये छोटे आर मझले व्यापारी सुथरी ढाल लूट रहे सै I 100 रूपये गज के कपडे का भाव् 500 रूपये बता के फेर उसमे 100 रुपये घटा के 400 रूपये गज बेच रहे सें और भोले भाले किसान ब्याह शादी के टेम पै शहर मै खूब लुट-पिट के आते हैं I न्यू ए पंसारी, सुनार, हलवाई ...कौन से किसान का भला सोच रहे सें जो हम उनके लिए इतनी हमदर्दी दिखा रहे I मल्टी ब्रांड बड्डी दुकान खुलने से कम से कम सौदेबाजी कम हो ज्यागी, चीज़ भी कुआलिटी की मिलैगी आर ताई धापाँ आर सुनेहरी काकी भी ब्रांड के टॉप आर स्कर्ट पहन लेंगी I तन्नै बेरा ए सै ये व्यापारी बोट किसने दिया करैं I इसलिए यो बोटां का रोला सै, किसान की आड़ मै I पाछले साल पंजाब मै आलू ५० पैसे से भी कम मै बिक्गे आर फेर किसान भाईयाँ नै फैंकने भी पड़े थे, जब ये देशी व्यापारी आर उनके हिमायती कहाँ थे I

वैसे भी ये छोटी छोटी दुकान अर रेहड़ी गलियाँ मै इतनी गन्दगी फैला देते हैं की शहर का सारा गेट-अप और शोभा बिगाड़ के रख देवें सें I सारी दुनिया मै एक designated जगह पर सुपर मार्केट या multibrand मार्केट का कांसेप्ट तेज़ी से बढ़ रहा है और यह आधुनिक शहरी प्रणाली एवं बढ़िया town -planning के कांसेप्ट के भी अनुकूल है I इसमे आम आदमी का कोई नुक्सान नहीं, बल्कि कई फायदे हैं I Organized sector में नौकरियों की भी सुरक्षा बनी रहती है और यह संभावना कम हो जाती है कि अगर नत्थू पंसारी को कोई कर्मचारी पसंद नहीं आया तो अगले दिन उसे निकाल देगा और कोई छोटा दुकानदार किसी छोटू को गाली देकर संबोधित नहीं करेगा I
 
Last edited:
एक और बात.. जो ये बड़ी दुकाने देंगी. ये किसानो को नये और उन्नत बीज, कीत्नाशक और तकनीक देंगे और किसान को फल सब्ज़ी बोने को कहेंगे जो एक दम से ख़रीदेंगे. इसका तत्प्राय ये हुआ की किसान की फसल बर्बाद नही होगी.

दूसरी बात, फसल का मूल्य तब तक घटता बढ़ता है जब तब वो प्रोसेस ना हो जो की बीचोलो का तरीका है परंतु ये दुकाने कोल्ड स्टोरेज पर फसल प्रोसेस करेंगी और वो होते ही फसल का मूल्य तय हो जाएगा.
 
ज्यादा तो नही जानता इस विदेशी मुद्रा निवेश के बारे मे, कही ये पठा तो सोचने पर जरूर मजबूर हुआ कि क्या सच मे कोई फायदा होगा किसी का या फिर जनता को बेवूफ बना दिया जाएगाl

Post by ravishndtv एक किराने वाले की कहानी:

ध्यान से पढ़ें। किराना दुकानदार से मिलकर आ रहा हूं।उनकी जानकारी पर हैरान हूं। जो कहा वो लिख रहा हूं। उसने एक मिसाल दी। तीन चार साल पहले जब आशीर्वाद आटा आया तो थोक में गेहूं 11.50 रुपये प्रति किलो गेहूं मिल रहा था। उसी दाम पर हम आटा चक्की वाले आपको 130 रुपये प्रति दस किलो बेच रहे थे। तब हमारा 140 रुपये प्रति दस किलो था। चूंकी आशीर्वाद के पास पूंजी थी तो कम में बेचा और बाज़ार पर छा गया। लेकिन आज आशीर्वाद दस किलो आटा 240 रुपये का बेचता है और हम 180 रुपये का। थोक में गेहूं 15.50 रुपये प्रति किलो है। तो किसान को कहां ज़्यादा मिला। उपभोक्ता तो ज़्यादा दाम पर ही ख़रीद रहा है। इसलिए किसान के भले की बात पल्ले नहीं पड़ रही है। इतने सालों में दस किलो ग्राम आटे का दाम हमारी चक्की पर 40 रुपये बढ़ा और आशीर्वाद ने 110 रुपये बढ़ाये। इसने जमे जमाए शक्तिभोग की कमर भी तोड़ दी। उसी तरह से टाटा ने मूंग दाल लांच किया है। हाई क्वालिटी की है जो बाज़ार में 80 रुपये प्रति किलो में मिल रही थी । इससे खुदरा मूंग दाल वाले ग़ायब हो गए और अब टाटा की नई पैकेट 100 रुपये प्रति किलो की आ रही है। उसने कहा कि बड़ी कंपनियों के पास घाटा सहने की शक्ति है। जब पड़ोस में मोर का सुपर स्टोर खुला तो हम बर्बाद हो रहे थे लेकिन मंदी आ गई तो लोग दाम का हिसाब लगाने लगे। तब हमारा बिजनेस पिक अप करने लगा लेकिन तभी एक दूसरा मल्टी स्टोर ईजी डे में आ गया। हम पर फिर दबाव बढ़ गया। हम खत्म नहीं हो जायेंगे मगर ज़रूरत क्या है। यह क्यों कहा जा रहा है कि उपभोक्ता और किसान को फायदा होगा। जहां ज़रूरत है वहां निवेश करो। मेट्रो में निवेश का किसी ने विरोध किया। यह भी सही है कि मेट्रो के आने से कारों की बिक्री कम नहीं हुई लेकिन किसी की पूंजी की ताकत से हम कब तक लड़ेंगे। वालमार्ट जहां पर ताकत से खुलेगा वहां हम बर्बाद हो जायेंगे। अभी जो स्टोर खुलते हैं वो ज्यादा दिन नहीं टिक पा रहे हैं। इसलिए हम डूबते उतराते रहते हैं।

एक दुकानदार अपनी समझ से बोले जा रहा था। पूछा कि आपको जानकारी कैसे मिलती है। कहा कि टीवी पर बकवास चलता है हम पेपर ध्यान से पढ़ते हैं
 
Last edited:
Back
Top