The Black Tuesday- Indira Gandhi Shot

Dear all,

Thanks for raising this topic. I was a little kid when this happened with Mrs Indira and our sikh brothers. I still remember one days a house near our home was burnt and I could see the smoke coming out. My mother asked me not to go out. I asked what happened? She said people are killing sikhs !! The rest of the knowledge i have about this is through newspapers and internet as no one takes about it.

So, just want to know from you guys, Was the operation blue star a mistimed and mishandled operation?. Could this have been done in a different way. Why this happened so late when the Govt knew from the very start that militants were hiding in the holy temple?. Should Indira have talked to the Sikh brothers especially The gurudwara comittee first. Were the pilgrims given time to evacute the temple? Did the army make sure that they have tried all other options before firing inside? I have heard that the army mishandles harminder shaheb and the pilgrims there. Some say Amry was training for this for a long time? Why the Army chief was sacked and why he advised against the operation? Please let me know what you guys think especially the people who are closely related to this ( I am not trying to hurt those who are already hurt so badly but just want to know the truth and listen to both the sides before i make an opinion). I know most of the people (from other states)just believed what the govt said that time but I dont trust the Govt propaganda that Blue star was a victory however I think militants should be punished where ever they are. If we can kill militant on the road we can kill them in temple as well. Because I think God is everywhere. Those who think God resides only in temple don't know GOD( I think). But still the Govt should respect the fellings of the people.
I think the congress will never let the truth come out as they did for China-India War as they did for Netaji.

The main crititism of blue star is not the blue star itself but the timing of it and the way it was executed. The media wasn't allowed to report it hence raised many doubts.

How irresponcible and disgusting for Rajiv Gandhi to say those words. I know he has lost his mother but he was speaking as the main leader of the congress not as a wounded son( I don't mind if he say so inside his house).



Hi Guys,

Its a very sensitive topic please let me know if you want me to delete this.
 
Last edited:
Dear,

Q: Was Operation Blue Star a mistimed and mishandled operation?
A: Yes, both.

Q: Could this have been done in a different way?
A: Mrs Gandhi & Congress Leaders of Punjab propped up Mr Bhindrawala as a non constitutional power centre in order to keep the Akalis down and away from political power.

Q: Why this happened so late when the Govt knew from the very start that militants were hiding in the holy temple?
A: The Government helped Mr Bhindrawala and his supporters in every which way including allowing them to get armed to the teeth.

Q: Should Mrs Gandhi have talked to the Sikh brothers especially The Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee first?
A: By Jun 1984 Mr Bhindrawala was too powerful and out of control. The Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee was rendered impotent by then.

Q: Were the pilgrims given time to evacuate the temple?
A: Yes, announcements were made but the militants inside forcibly used pilgrims as human shields.

Q: Did the Army make sure that they have tried all other options before firing inside?
A: There was no other option and force had to be used if the Golden Temple was to be freed from these militants.

Q: I have heard that the army mishandled Harminder Sahib and the pilgrims there. Some say Army was training for this for a long time?
A: A lot of rumors floated around those days. The troops on the ground were given direct orders not to fire towards the Golden Temple and Akal Takht but then things got out of hand and both these holy places were damaged.

Q: Why the Army chief was sacked and why he advised against the operation?
A: Gen Vaidya was the Army Chief then. He was not sacked and he retired after completing his tenure. The Army was given orders to clear the Golden Temple of these militants by the political leadership.

You must read a book on all these issues written by Mr Mark Tully, the then BBC Correspondent in India. He gives the most unbiased view

Best regards,

Jagmohan

PS: I have used the word militants for those fundamentalists who ran a parallel government of sorts from the Golden Temple that threatened the unity & integrity of the country. OP BLUE STAR will always be viewed as one of the low points historically.
 
Dear,



Q: Why the Army chief was sacked and why he advised against the operation?
A: Gen Vaidya was the Army Chief then. He was not sacked and he retired after completing his tenure. The Army was given orders to clear the Golden Temple of these militants by the political leadership.

Thanks Jagmohan ji, I will go through the book. I just want to make a little correct instead of Amry Chief I meant GOC of the Indian Army S.K Sinha.

Thanks
 
She deserved that treatment

Sorry Sir,
I totally Disagree with this "Black Tuesday". We have a fashion to declare (adopted from West) any incident Black. For me and most of the Nationalist Indians it was a proud day we get rid of a Tanashah leader who Polluted indian Politics. She got power because of her family background and she tried to be in power till her last breath by all means(hook or crook). And she got that. She stayed in power till her last breath...

JaiHind


The Black Tuesday- Indira Gandhi Shot

I t was on 31st October 1984 when just back from the foreign otur and busy finalising the report that one of the staff came rushing in my office in Sena Bhawan blurting the incredible news in an agitated voice ‘Mrs Gandhi has been shot’. Though stunned I refused to believe it and told him not to spread rumours. However, it was true she had been shot and that too by her own guards.
Early morning, the next day, coming out of my house in Dhaula Kuan Part II, I noticed in far-distance large columns of smoke bellowing high in the sky. Alarmed I rang up Gyan Bains the Commander, a Sikh Brigadier, of a unit technically under me albeit administratively under Delhi Area.
‘…What are you doing sitting there with Delhi burning’ I asked in an agitated voice.
‘We are preparing for Mrs Gandhi's funeral’ was the reply I got.
Feeling helpless and traumatised, that was the sum total of my initiative on that fateful day

[FONT=&quot][1][/FONT]I was also destined to play a minuscule role in this sad and sordid episode in standing as part of an inter-service guard along with another officer of my rank, in shifts. The body of Indra Gandhi lying in state in Teen Murty Bhawan, me blankly watching, the unending line of humanity with people with folded hands and agony written on their faces silently and slowly shuffle by.
One image from those days still remains etched in my mind is that of a Sikh couple riding, break-neck, on a scooter whom I over-took near the Buddha Jayanti Park one afternoon, when the mayhem had not yet died. They had dared to be on the road, possibly the errand was more important that the perceived risk to life.

Even at this late stage can someone enlighten me, a Hindu married to a Sikh as to how I should have reacted to the events of the day mentally if not physically. Sadly to what depth the so-called civilized human beings can sink!
We learn nothing otherwise such sudden and gruesome incidents, some planned others spontaneous, the emotionally charged and insane crowds mostly lead by criminal elements always on lookout for opportunities like Godhra and what happened subsequently in Gujarat as also immanently forgettable events earlier and later in India and abroad, would not have happened.

bls31




[FONT=&quot][1][/FONT] Indira Gandhi had numerous bodyguards, two of whom were Satwant Singh and Beant Singh, both Sikhs. On October 31, 1984 British Peter Ustinov filming a documentary for Irish television, she passed a wicket gate, guarded by Satwant and Beant. According to information available immediately following the incident, Beant Singh shot her thrice using his side-arm and Satwant Singh fired twenty-two rounds into her using a Sten submachine gun. Beant Singh was shot dead and Satwant Singh was shot and arrested by her other bodyguards.. After her death, sectarian unrest engulfed New Delhi and several other cities in India, including Kanpur, Asansol and Indore, leading to the death of thousands of Sikhs.

they assassinated Indira Gandhi with their service weapons in the garden of the Prime Minister's Residence at No. 1, Safdarjung Road in New Delhi. As she was walking to be interviewed by the actor
 
Back
Top