Here we go again. Moderation is a pet peeve at JL. I banned myself from visiting the site more than 2 months back after 6-7 of my posts were deleted. To be clear, there was no infraction and I did get responses when I questioned moderators. In fact, one or two posts were also un-deleted. Yet, I couldn't help the feeling that I was being unfairly targeted for publicly taking issue with a moderator or two and thought it was best to leave (before getting kicked out

). Then out of the blue, I got an email from someone here and felt like checking out the site again. Only to find out that we are still discussing moderation...
If Satyeshwar's response betrays a sense of exasperation, I don't blame him. There are rants when there is moderation (why was my post deleted type rant practised by yours truly as well), and there are complaints when there is no moderation (how is this stuff allowed here types rant). Damned if you do and damned if you don't. So although I don't like the hint of "my way or the highway" approach, I think moderators/administrators position is unenviable. You can't really please all the people all the time. And though the rest of my post may be critical in parts, let me be honest. I don't think I'd ever do the thankless job of being a moderator/administrator.
The debate about moderation is, for most of the time, restricted to individuals. And there in lies the flaw, I think. I appreciate Vishal's attempt to put the debate in context of the
"system" rather than individuals. The first part for both the owners/administrators as well as users/well-wishers of the site is to realise that it is an important question that needs consideration. That the site is attractive to its target audience is undeniable- most participants are much more active and involved than on any average social networking site. Where the site falters is in retaining the enthusiasts- infact, many people leave with more than a tinge of bitterness. It can't be denied that over a number of years, lots of enthusiastic participants have left for good (or else people get absent for prolonged periods), because of "bad experiences". If user satisfaction and retention is an objective, then it is a problem and accepting that is the first step. Now, as an owner/administrator, one is very much in his/her right to say that it is a private site- I own it- take it or leave it. But then one can't be really ambitious about
user satisfaction/retention which would make the site what it claims/wants to be-
an attractive social platform. I proceed with the post assuming that is the real objective.
I see the moderation issue from 2 perspectives- on
WHAT principles should moderation be done and
HOW it should be done. Let's look at WHAT first. There are 2 types of moderation errors that can be made-
Type A (allowing something that should not be allowed) OR
Type B (not allowing something that should be allowed). In my opinion,
the goal should be to minimize Type B errors, even if you commit some type A errors. While there would always be cribs on the content of certain posts/threads (Type A errors) that were left unmoderated, it is unlikely to generate such strong feelings as to make someone quit JL in disgust. What peeves people the most is when their freedom of speech is violated, that is there posts are deleted or they are infracted/banned. It not only peeves the person concerned, but others too who are his/her friends or generally in favor of what he/she was saying. Even on principled grounds, censorship contravenes freedom of speech only in the most extreme cases. In my opinion, the approach should be not to intervene, unless it is absolutely necessary (abusive, threatening language or trolling, etc.). What is absolutely necessary should be defined (most of it is already done on forum rules), ensuring it is specific.
Let's look at the more important HOW part now. What peeves people is a perception of
moderation bias. The feeling that my post was selectively targeted. I feel that having a bias is but natural for anyone. The problem arises when bias leads to selective moderation. One can debate whether bias exists in reality or not. But what can't be denied is that such a perception exists and that in the court of public opinion, perception matters more than reality. The perception becomes stronger when one sees similar or worse cases that were left unmoderated. Even if one assumes perfect and unbiased moderators, this is bound to happen as there are a number of posts everyday and only a few moderators. This is not a day job- it is volunteer work that can only be done in leisure time. It would be stupid to expect moderator(s) to go through each and every post. What follows is a piecemeal approach. Like someone may tell moderator about a particular post (or the mod finds it on his own) and quick action follows. In most cases, that is shift+delete, as the approach is that of firefighter- throw a ton of water at what is a mere spark. As one is trying to prevent a bigger fire. Then apparently an eye is kept on the "accused", that is his posts are given special focus. So even a mild "crime" by this person is punished while bigger ones (applying same yardstick) go unpunished. In case of follow-up "crimes" by the same person, easiest option is to infract/ban the person. This is equivalent of sending an errant child outside the class so that he doesn't infect the others with his dissent (some of who may have been naughtier but just escaped the teacher's attention). Also note how a moderator has become a party in conflict here-
can one really practise objective unbiased thought on a conflict that one is part of? Theoretically, the option to escalate to moderator committee exists. But by then in most cases, the embittered user has taken up cudgels against everyone involved in running the site. In such a partisan environment, it is unrealistic to expect a mod committee to undermine its own authority by taking action against its own member. It may have happened in exceptional circumstances earlier, but the norm appears to be much different.
The point I am trying to make here is that
this is an issue of how the system is set up. The best of moderators would have to use the same approach in the current system. So any solution has to deal with the system. One system, that in my opinion, targets all the issues above is to have a
two-tier moderation. At the first level, the
moderator right should be with the owner of the thread (the person who started it). Instantly, you take care of the volume issue. This person is most incentivised to look at the health of his/her thread. He is the one most likely to be following it in detail. Moreover,
he doesn't have to adopt the "policeman" approach of moderation. If he thinks someone is derailing the thread, he can afford to discuss it with the person to resolve it mutually without resorting to brute force (shift+delete). In case of abusive language, he can afford to spend time to edit the post and explain it to the poster. In case he thinks that the thread has been hijacked or derailed or that it has served its purpose, he can conclude and lock the thread. He would still have the "delete" option. But his "delete" would
trigger the matter to the forum moderator (current moderators) who would then decide on the matter. The forum moderator could be approached by members if they think their posts have been unfairly edited or that some bad posts have been left unmoderated.
There are some checks and balances in the two-tier system that the current system lacks. Right now, if you think a moderator is selectively targeting you, you can probably complain. But if no merit is found in your case (and let's be honest that there is an insider-outside equation here), you have no option left on JL. In the two tier system, if an individual targets your posts selectively, you have a right to appeal. If the appeal finds no merit, you have reason to introspect (two unrelated people at different levels finding the same issue is better than one person/group finding an issue). But even in this case, your participation option goes away only on that thread. You are free to start your own thread and if you had a genuine grouse on the way the thread was run that other users share, then your thread would become more popular. Basically
the system allows for healthy competition. If someone wants good participation on his thread, better moderate it well. The forum moderators, on the other hand, get specific cases, as opposed to their extremely general mandate of finding, investigating and correcting "deviant" behavior. The new situation would allow them to act more as peacemakers and arbiters between individuals rather than making them a party to every conflict (like in the current system). The new system would also provide an avenue to identify moderator talent. Those who moderate well would get more participation and would be complained against less, thus providing useful information to decision-makers on who to "promote" as forum moderators. Last, but definitely not the least, it e
nhances user experience by making everyone a stakeholder. Users are bound to feel happier and more involved with a more active role to play.
I hope I am not stepping on anyone's toes with this. Criticism is welcome. The idea could be brainstormed and improved/discarded. I honestly think it could be a game changer.
Disclaimer: It may not be an original idea. May have been suggested in this or slightly different form earlier. Merit of the idea is more important than ownership.