Ghoonghat System imposed on ladies of our Community.

Is the Ghoonghat necessarily required in today's time


  • Total voters
    31
first of all i want to mention that "IMPOSED" is d wrong word used here...

vp singh sir thanx for mentioning d real origin and reason for ghoonghat custom...bt i just want to mention that now ghoonghat custom is so much mixed wd or culture that it has replaced d real reason behind it ,wd orhers reasons that look more realistic nd relevant to our society ...so if anybody want to eliminate this tradition for d reason mentioned by u then that will not be correct.

ghoonghat custom marks d identity of a women in famiy nd that i dont think is wrong....m from liberal family nd doctor by profession, i will not mind if my wife will use ghoonghat for eldres if m visiting my village or in my family
v can be modern nd d same time can follow our customs also.... again i want to mention swami vivekananda followed d custom of "sanyasi" nd was wearing "bhagwa" clothes when he addressed big crowed in chicago...bt according to our points he should be wearing armani suit nd gucci shoes.

..eliminating customs from any community doesnt make it modern...oh! come on men save our culture instead of destroying it wd irrelevent nd impractical reasons..


dr.saab....if the word "imposed" is wrong here then it will mean Jat women are voluntarily want ghoonghat? Is it? but today's women are more exposing.
 
VP Sir, seems like you are referring to Amar Chitra Katha for Indian Mythology..:)..probably the only purpose veil served was to confuse the evil ruler, zamindar, muslim or otherwise if the woman behind the veil was beautiful or not, buy a little time for the woman...else veil was not an invincible armor that could "save" a woman...

You are right, Ann. That was exactly my intention to say. Thanks for making it more clear.
 
jyadatar discussion me bade budhe shaamil nahi ho re hai...es maamle me unki raay bauhat maayne raakh sai.

I request all old members of the JATLAND to share their views regarding history & justification of Ghoonghat and please vote in my poll. female members should also participate to tell the jat society whether they want the ghoonghat or not?
 
dagar sahab to whom u r refering todays women...the women in city or the women in villages...in any case i want to say that ..in city nobody impose any women for ghoonghat...nd in villages women are quite happy in accepting it....thts why i was saying that IMPOSING is d wrong word here...because in any case thay r not imposed for ghoonghat...

because in city women r comfortable without ghoonghat nd in villages they r comfortable in ghoonghat...
 
Kapil, theoretically it may sound logical that the "conflict has to be resolved at family level" but practically it is very difficult to militate against the unwritten and disguised societal conventions. One who dares not to fall in line with the majority opinion has to face a lot of ignominy and psychological torture. I have seen people (I include myself) with lot of exposure of outside world succumbing to the dictates of old brigade. It is not that easy to resolve at family level if you are living in rural areas. In metropolitan cities, I do not think this veil system is in vogue any more. I agree with you that customs gradually wither away in a process when the circumstances responsible for their origin undergo a change. But discussing the issue will certainly spread some awareness and might help in catalyzing the process of withering away.

Agreed it may be difficult or even impossible to militate against. But what can be done?

My point is that old vs new is an everyday conflict, especially now when the rate of change (new becoming old) has increased significantly. Conscious awareness of that will ease a lot of heartburn.
 
Agreed it may be difficult or even impossible to militate against. But what can be done?

My point is that old vs new is an everyday conflict, especially now when the rate of change (new becoming old) has increased significantly. Conscious awareness of that will ease a lot of heartburn.

Fact 1: A girl does not hide her face (a symbol of sexuality) from any man in her pre marriage family.
Fact 2: The same girl hides her face from all male members who are superior in position to her husband (Father in law, all jeth).
Fact 3: This proves that her sexuality must have been attacked by male members (superior in position to her husband) in the long past - hence this custom came into practice among Jats.
 
Fact 1: A girl does not hide her face (a symbol of sexuality) from any man in her pre marriage family.
Fact 2: The same girl hides her face from all male members who are superior in position to her husband (Father in law, all jeth).
Fact 3: This proves that her sexuality must have been attacked by male members (superior in position to her husband) in the long past - hence this custom came into practice among Jats.

???

Not sure why you are responding to my post - don't see a connection.

Although if I have to, I'd say that your fact 3 is not a proof from any angle - it is just a theory - a wild one at that.
 
agar daughter in law aankho mae aankhae daal kae baat karae toh yae bhi kai sasuraal walon ko ganwara nahin - baath ban jaatee hae.

Generally a honest and truthful person will talk looking in your eyes, some time some arrogants also do, in any case veil is not justified at all,
 
Fact 1: A girl does not hide her face (a symbol of sexuality) from any man in her pre marriage family.
Fact 2: The same girl hides her face from all male members who are superior in position to her husband (Father in law, all jeth).
Fact 3: This proves that her sexuality must have been attacked by male members (superior in position to her husband) in the long past - hence this custom came into practice among Jats.
Hahhaha....you are really a BOMB!!
 
Generally a honest and truthful person will talk looking in your eyes, some time some arrogants also do, in any case veil is not justified at all,
Yeap, Ghoonghat/veil is not good for a women's personality. By keeping a women in a comfort zone, veil inhibits her confidence build up.

Though, care should be taken that it does not become an ego issue. There are many other ways as well to build up confidence.
 
Last edited:
Fact 1: A girl does not hide her face (a symbol of sexuality) from any man in her pre marriage family.
Fact 2: The same girl hides her face from all male members who are superior in position to her husband (Father in law, all jeth).
Fact 3: This proves that her sexuality must have been attacked by male members (superior in position to her husband) in the long past - hence this custom came into practice among Jats.

How is number 3 a "fact"? At the best it can be deduction/conclusion. :mad:
Ghoonghat is done mainly for strangers. For elders, it is a kind of showing respect.

Beware, these kinds of statements/deductions/conclusions can create unnecessarily a wrong perception.
 
Last edited:
Fact 1: A girl does not hide her face (a symbol of sexuality) from any man in her pre marriage family.
Fact 2: The same girl hides her face from all male members who are superior in position to her husband (Father in law, all jeth).
Fact 3: This proves that her sexuality must have been attacked by male members (superior in position to her husband) in the long past - hence this custom came into practice among Jats.

Any reference for the fact at no.3, this is too bold statement and reflect the negative mindset towards opposite sex. You may read history and you will get the answer for parda system.
 
GHUNGAT dsnt seems to b a topic f discusn fr male.. its dere custom let dem deside its fate

Right Ratendra.......but here we are discussing its justification. It was imposed by men on women of the community but this practice is going on till today.......so how far it is justfiable in present time keeping in mind the today's exposing world..... i agree that it should be left to women whether they really want it or not but Male dominates our society and their views regarding this practice matters most.
 
What little I know about this custom is that it started after muslims came close to us, I also read some where that in later part of hindu rule, some of kings and their senior officials used to pic up females at their will and took them along, in those days even unmarried girls used viel to protect them from the dirty eyes of such bad people. I do not think that family elders were cause, if family elders were bad people and wanted sexual favours than viel is no protection. I also feel that the viel has nothing to do with respect to elders, infact I feel it is disrespect to elders. In any case, it is not required now. we can abolish this evil.
 
Ghoonghat agar hamara culture hai toh ye garv ki baat nahin srum ki baat hai hamare liye. Nah toh ye hamara culture tha na hai, I agree that about 300 yrs, in past was not so comfortable for our society and this culture was adopted for betterment and well being of our society but there is no reason at all for this now a days. Those who are in favor of this and starting irrational and gender bias discussions they need to clear their minds. These irrational and gender biased discussions and these unreasoned observations connected on the name of culture to lot many threads on JL is too a reason of sex ratio in our community. Hammare culture mein toh naari ko puja jata hai oose gali nahi di jati chahe who Kali ki sakal mein ho ya laxmi, durga ya sarswati.

Budhe chupchap baith ja kone mein ye kahane wali ghooghat wali jayada hongi mere vichar se. Kyunki padhi likhi chhoriyan aissi baat nahi karti haan kam padhi likhi aur jyada oochhalti jaroor aisa karti hain, aur eeska karan khandaan ke background par nirbhar karta hai ghooghat ya padha likha hone par nahi.
 
Fact 1: A girl does not hide her face (a symbol of sexuality) from any man in her pre marriage family.
Fact 2: The same girl hides her face from all male members who are superior in position to her husband (Father in law, all jeth).
Fact 3: This proves that her sexuality must have been attacked by male members (superior in position to her husband) in the long past - hence this custom came into practice among Jats.

Dont you think that this is for no reason at all, you may be trying to know about our culture but issueing this type of statements are not going to help our culture in any sense. we are born and brought up in this culture and now we are learning all these huoooom, where are the facts and from where you got these informations, we never came across of any such incident in our life and our surroundings or in village or in whole district or state, which state u r talking abou brooklyn in USA
 
Urmila Ji You came out with your honest perception about fact 3, so please read some facts if you want to wash out perceptions from your brain about this fact 3 for elders.
Fact 1. We the Jaats are very rich in moral values.
Fact 2. Before entering in the house where presence of ladies are expected the male elder always give an indication by coughing that he is entering to avoid any embarrassment to any family members.
Fact 3. If at all any unawareness by female members of this sound took place (there may be lot many reasons busy or concentration in a job or other conflicting sounds), in that case elderly male members go in to veil with his eyes down, just for the same reason to avoid embarrassment of any kind to the family members who are not used to it.


Though I already mentioned that there is no need of this system now a days.
 
Dont you think that this is for no reason at all, you may be trying to know about our culture but issueing this type of statements are not going to help our culture in any sense. we are born and brought up in this culture and now we are learning all these huoooom, where are the facts and from where you got these informations, we never came across of any such incident in our life and our surroundings or in village or in whole district or state, which state u r talking abou brooklyn in USA

They are not the same thing.
 
Back
Top