Is reservation a root cause of prevailing Caste-ism ??

prikshit

New member
Reservation has played a very big role is widening the gap or bringing disparity in the society or we can say a major cause of prevailing caste-ism ? How many of you agree or disagree to this ?

Please share your views on it.
 
Reservation has played a very big role is widening the gap or bringing disparity in the society or we can say a major cause of prevailing caste-ism ? How many of you agree or disagree to this ?

Please share your views on it.


Acc. to me..

Caste can be ones.. identity but.. should.. be a reason for disparity...

And coming to reservation(reservation jobs, concession facilities in traveling, special training institutions etc.)
it should not be categorized on caste it should only for physically/mentally challenged...
 
Caste is nothing but various forms of occupations done by different group of people and same trade become their identity. Reservation based on caste system is spreading hatred atmosphere among castes. This is also an ace card of divide and rule policy of politicians.


Albeit I agree that some castes had faced exploitation/humiliation from what we call upper caste peoples though I consider them peoples of lower most moral values.
 
Reservation has played a very big role is widening the gap or bringing disparity in the society or we can say a major cause of prevailing caste-ism ? How many of you agree or disagree to this ?

Please share your views on it.

Yes,

Off late, it is playing havoc to our national unity and communal harmony.

Time has arrived to abolish caste based reservation.
 
Caste is nothing but various forms of occupations done by different group of people and same trade become their identity. Reservation based on caste system is spreading hatred atmosphere among castes. This is also an ace card of divide and rule policy of politicians.


Albeit I agree that some castes had faced exploitation/humiliation from what we call upper caste peoples though I consider them peoples of lower most moral values.

Sir,

Please discuss the post independence scenario.

Regards,
 
Acc. to me..

Caste can be ones.. identity but.. should.. be a reason for disparity...

And coming to reservation(reservation jobs, concession facilities in traveling, special training institutions etc.)
it should not be categorized on caste it should only for physically/mentally challenged...

Could you please come up more clear on this.
 
.

Time has arrived to abolish caste based reservation.

डॉक्टर साहब आपकी सलाह तो श्यानी हैं पर न्यू और बताओ के इस पर हकीक़त में अमल क्यूकर हो ? अगर आपने इसके लिए कोई योजना बना रखी हो या इसकी शुरुआत कर रखी हो तो हमे भी बताइए आपका साथ देंगे इसमें |
खाली ख्याली बातो से क्या फ़ायदा , आपको भी पता होगा की आज के वक़्त में संसद में इस आरक्षण के समर्थको का बहूमत हैं तो फिर क्या यह संभव हो सकता ऐसे हालात में ?
हमारा सिस्टम ही ऐसा बना दिया गया हैं की इस काम के लिए बहुत हांगा लगाना पड़ेगा नतीजे की उम्मीद नहीं |
इसका शोर्ट कट तो योहे स के जाटों के लिए आरक्षण ले लो , अर्र जिस दिन त जाटों ने मांग शुरू करी स उस दिन त ये बाह्मण, बनिए .,रिफ्यूजी ,ठाकर सब लाइन में आ लिए इस आरक्षण की मांग में |
आपको याद हो के 1990 -91 में भी एक ऐसा प्रयास किया गया था, पुरे देश में आग लगी थी इस आरक्षण के विरोध में, कई बालका ने आत्मदाह किया था | सबसे पहला अपने आप को आग लगाने वाला दिल्ली का राजीव गोस्वामी था उसके बाद तो लाइन सी लग गई थी आत्मदाह की , बसे जलाई कहीं टेलीफोन एक्सचेंज जलाई गई | माहरे भी बांगड़ लागे थे चंडीगढ़ के सेक्टर 17 में पर इतना सब होने के बाद नतीजा जीरो ही रहा |
 
डॉक्टर साहब आपकी सलाह तो श्यानी हैं पर न्यू और बताओ के इस पर हकीक़त में अमल क्यूकर हो ? अगर आपने इसके लिए कोई योजना बना रखी हो या इसकी शुरुआत कर रखी हो तो हमे भी बताइए आपका साथ देंगे इसमें |
खाली ख्याली बातो से क्या फ़ायदा , आपको भी पता होगा की आज के वक़्त में संसद में इस आरक्षण के समर्थको का बहूमत हैं तो फिर क्या यह संभव हो सकता ऐसे हालात में ?
हमारा सिस्टम ही ऐसा बना दिया गया हैं की इस काम के लिए बहुत हांगा लगाना पड़ेगा नतीजे की उम्मीद नहीं |
इसका शोर्ट कट तो योहे स के जाटों के लिए आरक्षण ले लो , अर्र जिस दिन त जाटों ने मांग शुरू करी स उस दिन त ये बाह्मण, बनिए .,रिफ्यूजी ,ठाकर सब लाइन में आ लिए इस आरक्षण की मांग में |
आपको याद हो के 1990 -91 में भी एक ऐसा प्रयास किया गया था, पुरे देश में आग लगी थी इस आरक्षण के विरोध में, कई बालका ने आत्मदाह किया था | सबसे पहला अपने आप को आग लगाने वाला दिल्ली का राजीव गोस्वामी था उसके बाद तो लाइन सी लग गई थी आत्मदाह की , बसे जलाई कहीं टेलीफोन एक्सचेंज जलाई गई | माहरे भी बांगड़ लागे थे चंडीगढ़ के सेक्टर 17 में पर इतना सब होने के बाद नतीजा जीरो ही रहा |

Friend, You have raised very valid points. I will try to produce before you what I think on the issue.

Kindly note that my point of view is not related with OBC reservation for which you had to face lathi blows.

Secondly, no individual is authorized to make a plan because planning power in invested with the government.

Third, you are aware that first of all ideas germinate in the minds of people and when these ideas spread among the people and are accepted by majority of them, they are taken note by the policy makers i.e. bureaucratic machinery and the political leadership.

Fourth, the founding fathers of our constitution were very wise people and they had taken the 1931 census records of population for providing reservation to certain people to enable them to bring them at par with the other caste/community people. But it is worth note that they had provided the reservation only for a period of 10 years from the date of constitution coming into force i.e. from 1950 to 1960 and had provisioned to get the policy reviewed.

Fifth, Neither enumeration of castes was taken nor review of the policy took place and reservation for SC/ST continues to be implemented by extension after extension till date on the basis of the census data collected in 1931.

Sixth, MANDAL Commission also based their recommendations for granting OBC status to some castes and denied it to others on the basis of the 1931 Census data in 1990's which caused the chaos referred to by you in your post.

Seventh, in view of the gamut of the reservation policy based on the social hierarchy of various castes in 1931 has lost its locus standi, every caste and community has valid right and clamour to raise voice against its partisan implementation does not mean that they are doing so against any other caste or community. Because, the dependence on government Jobs has increased many fold and there is scarcity of vacancies, so this hue and cry to corner the benefits of reservation by every caste and community.
In view of this situation, the government has to rise to the occasion to provide equal opportunity to weaker sections of the society irrespective of their caste or community and there can be no better yard stick to measure the 'weak' category aspirants but their economic status. This is more important to adopt an all inclusive development policy to make India a greater economic power than to adopt 'patch up' policy to provide short term solutions to tackle the problems caused by reservation demand here and there.

Hope that the policy makers would take holistic view of the reservation policy and look afresh on the present obsolete policy to provide succour to the really deserving weaker sections of society sooner than later.

These are my random views, not necessarily acceptable to others.

Regards
 
Friend, You have raised very valid points. I will try to produce before you what I think on the issue.

Kindly note that my point of view is not related with OBC reservation for which you had to face lathi blows.

Secondly, no individual is authorized to make a plan because planning power in invested with the government.

Third, you are aware that first of all ideas germinate in the minds of people and when these ideas spread among the people and are accepted by majority of them, they are taken note by the policy makers i.e. bureaucratic machinery and the political leadership.

Fourth, the founding fathers of our constitution were very wise people and they had taken the 1931 census records of population for providing reservation to certain people to enable them to bring them at par with the other caste/community people. But it is worth note that they had provided the reservation only for a period of 10 years from the date of constitution coming into force i.e. from 1950 to 1960 and had provisioned to get the policy reviewed.

Fifth, Neither enumeration of castes was taken nor review of the policy took place and reservation for SC/ST continues to be implemented by extension after extension till date on the basis of the census data collected in 1931.

Sixth, MANDAL Commission also based their recommendations for granting OBC status to some castes and denied it to others on the basis of the 1931 Census data in 1990's which caused the chaos referred to by you in your post.

Seventh, in view of the gamut of the reservation policy based on the social hierarchy of various castes in 1931 has lost its locus standi, every caste and community has valid right and clamour to raise voice against its partisan implementation does not mean that they are doing so against any other caste or community. Because, the dependence on government Jobs has increased many fold and there is scarcity of vacancies, so this hue and cry to corner the benefits of reservation by every caste and community.
In view of this situation, the government has to rise to the occasion to provide equal opportunity to weaker sections of the society irrespective of their caste or community and there can be no better yard stick to measure the 'weak' category aspirants but their economic status. This is more important to adopt an all inclusive development policy to make India a greater economic power than to adopt 'patch up' policy to provide short term solutions to tackle the problems caused by reservation demand here and there.

Hope that the policy makers would take holistic view of the reservation policy and look afresh on the present obsolete policy to provide succour to the really deserving weaker sections of society sooner than later.

These are my random views, not necessarily acceptable to others.

Regards

Sir,

Very well summarized, excellent views. We hardly see a post with many paras from you as you one or two lines from you says too much. Keep us enlightened with your vast experience and knowledge.

Regards,
 
Friend, You have raised very valid points. I will try to produce before you what I think on the issue.

Kindly note that my point of view is not related with OBC reservation for which you had to face lathi blows.

Secondly, no individual is authorized to make a plan because planning power in invested with the government.

Third, you are aware that first of all ideas germinate in the minds of people and when these ideas spread among the people and are accepted by majority of them, they are taken note by the policy makers i.e. bureaucratic machinery and the political leadership.

Fourth, the founding fathers of our constitution were very wise people and they had taken the 1931 census records of population for providing reservation to certain people to enable them to bring them at par with the other caste/community people. But it is worth note that they had provided the reservation only for a period of 10 years from the date of constitution coming into force i.e. from 1950 to 1960 and had provisioned to get the policy reviewed.

Fifth, Neither enumeration of castes was taken nor review of the policy took place and reservation for SC/ST continues to be implemented by extension after extension till date on the basis of the census data collected in 1931.

Sixth, MANDAL Commission also based their recommendations for granting OBC status to some castes and denied it to others on the basis of the 1931 Census data in 1990's which caused the chaos referred to by you in your post.

Seventh, in view of the gamut of the reservation policy based on the social hierarchy of various castes in 1931 has lost its locus standi, every caste and community has valid right and clamour to raise voice against its partisan implementation does not mean that they are doing so against any other caste or community. Because, the dependence on government Jobs has increased many fold and there is scarcity of vacancies, so this hue and cry to corner the benefits of reservation by every caste and community.
In view of this situation, the government has to rise to the occasion to provide equal opportunity to weaker sections of the society irrespective of their caste or community and there can be no better yard stick to measure the 'weak' category aspirants but their economic status. This is more important to adopt an all inclusive development policy to make India a greater economic power than to adopt 'patch up' policy to provide short term solutions to tackle the problems caused by reservation demand here and there.

Hope that the policy makers would take holistic view of the reservation policy and look afresh on the present obsolete policy to provide succour to the really deserving weaker sections of society sooner than later.

These are my random views, not necessarily acceptable to others.

Regards

Excellent post. Although, I didn't know the facts like you. But I have views similar to you. Reservation is necessary but on the basis of economic status not on the caste and religion basis.
 
Hope that the policy makers would take holistic view of the reservation policy and look afresh on the present obsolete policy to provide succour to the really deserving weaker sections of society sooner than later.

These are my random views, not necessarily acceptable to others.

Regards

Sir, I think 60 years is enough time for policy makers to realize this caste reservation system is not effective.


So the question is "Should we wait for another 60 -100 years and keep suffering from this system." And who will pay for this injustice.
 
So the question is "Should we wait for another 60 -100 years and keep suffering from this system." And who will pay for this injustice.

I agree bhai. And who will pay for the injustice being already done to "General" from last 60 years? Reservation for first 20-25 years post-independence to uplift their economic status is somewhat agreeable, but beyond that it has been sheer advantage to those who are under reservation. General has to pay 500/- for filling a form while others have either have to pay NO FEE or hardly Rs.50. Aadhe log to is fees ki wajah se kahi apply bhi nahi kar pate. Upar se agar merit list me reservation wale achi rank laate hai to pahle wo "General" ki seat khaate hai, reservation wali to General ke khatam hone ke baad bharni shuru hoti hai. Matlab ki totta to baithe-e-baithe General ke.Is reservation ka dukh us "General" wale se poocho jo bus 1 number se cut-off me aane se rah gya, or reservation wale 15-15 number kam hote hue bhi job/interview ke liye eligible ho gye. Sare competetion ki jimmedari bus "General" ki hi hai??

Reservation bahut badi problem hai. Or har problem ka solution, problem ke ander jaa ke nikalna padta hai. Jab tak bahar se sookhi hawa lagaaoge ki reservation khtam honi chaiye, kuch nahi hone ka. If we get reservation, we can witness a radical change in reservation system for sure, kyuki mirch lagne pe ye upar baithe neta kuch na kuch parpanch to rachenge reservation ke baare me.



PS : These are my own views. Others may agree or disagree.
 
I personally feel, though the intention of our leaders at the start of the independance, may be correct, but few things went wrong as mentioned below:-
a) The idea of reservation was wrong and based on caste was totally wrong, we are seeing the results, I think, instead of reservation, resources, facilities and opportunities should have been provided to the needy for ecconomical and social upliftment.
b) Declaring land of farmers surplus and distributing among SC people was also a wrong decision, Many business men had huge property but they were not touched, why poor kissans were deprived of their land, very small quantity of land was alloted to the reciver of land, neither one family can survive on one acar of land nor resources like tractor/water arrengements etc can be created on such small holding, Also many of such land recivers didnot have experience/knowledge of managing land. Why couldnot Govt provide resources/facilities to develop their origional professon.
c) WORST WAS THE IMPLEMENTATION OF POLICY, keeping low standard in education qualification, different cariateria for qualifying a test, interview, joining, promotions including dealing with indiscipline cases etc, was totally wrong.
d) Instead of reviewing and stopping the practice of reservation after 10 years, more castes/people were included in the reserve catagory.
e) The tree of reservation is getting longer day by day and it has crossed education & Govt job and entered into elections at various levels, private jobs, quota, permits, contracts, loans, allotment of houses/shops/vehicles/agencies etc.
f) The reservation has lowered the standard of all professions/post, killed natural justice and finished the healthy competition.
In brief I feel the system of reservation must be ended as early as possible and if required help in terms of resources/opportunities/facilities be given based on economical condition of the person concern as one time measure and such individual must achieve a laid down standard, otherwise forced to return the help amount back to the Govt.

But as long as the reservation is existing for others, reservation for jats is totally justified
 
no individual is authorized to make a plan because planning power in invested with the government.
Who is government is first question? In a democracy, people form a government and therefore, they should do the planning, if they want the government to go in the right direction. Any political should not get prerogative to dictate their rules to us.

Third, you are aware that first of all ideas germinate in the minds of people and when these ideas spread among the people and are accepted by majority of them, they are taken note by the policy makers i.e. bureaucratic machinery and the political leadership.
Policy makers never take note of anything until people make protest and make world a hell for them.
 
यो आर्थिक आधार वाला आरक्षण पंचायती राज , विधान सभा , संसद में भी लागू होना चाहिए ......आज के टेम म इन्ते बढ़िया कमाई का जरिया किम्मे नहीं स .....एक बार में सात पीढ़ी का टोटा धू जा स ;)
 
Sir, I think 60 years is enough time for policy makers to realize this caste reservation system is not effective.


So the question is "Should we wait for another 60 -100 years and keep suffering from this system." And who will pay for this injustice.

Policy makers are playing Dirty politics to woo votes based on caste.
 
Who is government is first question? In a democracy, people form a government and therefore, they should do the planning, if they want the government to go in the right direction. Any political should not get prerogative to dictate their rules to us.

Policy makers never take note of anything until people make protest and make world a hell for them.

Only those who suffer raise their voice, sooner or later they get it based on the fact how much role their votes play in elections.
 
Rajpal Sir ,

you are right the caste based reservation has lost its relevance after 65 years of Independence . In order to abolish this we have to stop the madness in our house first.
 
Last edited:
Is reservation a root cause of prevailing Caste-ism ??

.


No Not really. The root cause was something else and that prompted this caste based reservation(The idea of reservation was British). But yes, this reservation in the present form is going to divide the society further and would be a hinderance to seamless integration. If people dont act wisely then in future the county could be further divided on caste lines after religious divisoin.


Caste and ehtnicity is a reality but these type of issues make one caste enemy of other. Pak was created because each community wanted to earn bigger peice of cake for themselves.

Sometime you have to compromise in life for a bigger cause.
 
Back
Top