Do you know!

puneetlakra

New member
Govt jobs representation by communities in haryana other then JATs

population % holding govt.jobs in haryana...%

Baniya > 5% ...................12.54%
Panjabi/arora/khatri > 8%....................26.91%
braminas >7%....................12.00%

In class I and II
Baniya .....................15.33%
panjabi/arora/khatri .....................36.94%
braminas .....................10.54%
why jats is not represents in majority while we are around 29.0% of the total population of haryana, this shows our need of reservation in OBC
quota, some critics says CM is mostly Jat in haryana , but this data shows we are legging behind of all other communities , just because
of unwillingness of our leaders, they want to shows themselves as a moderators , which is a trait of jat , they don't know how to help their
community , this is also a symbol of backwardness .:(
 
Interesting. Could I ask where did you get this data from? Do govt. institutions give out community based data?
 
interesting. Could i ask where did you get this data from? Do govt. Institutions give out community based data?

जसप्रीत भाई ,
इस तरह की पोस्ट आते ही , फट दे सी पुछे है की डाटा कान्हा ते लिया
उस ias रिजल्ट वाली पोस्ट मे भी पुछया था , काल ही

जाटा के बारे मे कुछ अच्छा लिखया जा तो, के कुरकुरी सी उठे है
 
जसप्रीत भाई ,
इस तरह की पोस्ट आते ही , फट दे सी पुछे है की डाटा कान्हा ते लिया

Balyan sahib,

Question galat to koni. Is tarah ke data ki authenticity ka bera to hona chahiye..kisnai publish kari hai ye report.
 
Balyan sahib,

Question galat to koni. Is tarah ke data ki authenticity ka bera to hona chahiye..kisnai publish kari hai ye report.

All right, none has the right to deny cross questioning the posts.

Though this type of posts need authenticity yet other members are free, if they feel that this data is wrong, to refute it. Coming up with statistical position to reveal the real position would be the right course of reply !!!

Thanks
 
Absolutely. That's what I said. Where did he get this data from? No harm in sharing the source. I am also keen on this report.

If statistically sound based, very alarming news!! He must share it as the transparency of source will add further force to his argument. Thanks
 
जसप्रीत भाई ,
इस तरह की पोस्ट आते ही , फट दे सी पुछे है की डाटा कान्हा ते लिया
उस ias रिजल्ट वाली पोस्ट मे भी पुछया था , काल ही

जाटा के बारे मे कुछ अच्छा लिखया जा तो, के कुरकुरी सी उठे है
Bhai..mai apni community ka bahut bada dushman hoon..isiliye..! :)

Data source jaane ke peeche mere ek hi maksad hota hai ki authenticity pata karna. Hamein apne logon pe proud hona chaiye. Par reliable figures par hi. Nahin to yahi pride mazak ban jaati hai. Aur aaj kal internet pe aise kayi data aate rehte hain jinka kahin source nahin likha hota hai. Jaisa ki maine abhi kal hi pada "Sikhs contribute 33% of the country's income". Now we all know that is fake but some Sikh guy might believe it also. Is liye its always good to share references and sources whenever we share any data or supposed fact. This is a standard practice in academic research and also in professional world.

Par agar aapko iske peeche mera koi aur reason lagta hai to aapki marzi.
 
Interesting. Could I ask where did you get this data from? Do govt. institutions give out community based data?
Dear,
This data is authentic , i collected it from the well known Gurnam Singh commissions(1990) report this report aprroved by commission and cabinet of haryana govt in 22 jan 1991 and notified and its no is 395-sw(t)-91 on 2 april 1991.
At that time mr bhajanlal was the head of state but due to his biasedness he dumps that report and in result jats of haryana suffering till today

All most all party leaders who are not from our community are biased and those who are from us they are not willing ,

" Thabhi toh Jats ke OBC status Ke liye dohara maapdand banaya hua hai"

State me jat backward hai anpni root jaghe par lekin agar woh bus ya train pakadkar delhi jata hai job ya admissions ke liye delhi aata hai toh is journey mei uska vikas ho jata hai, aisa central govt. ka mat hai,
hai yeh keysi hai vidambana , mare gaye jat, sakar ki galat soch se.

Even bihar ke jat ko OBC reservation ka benefit bihar state me hai par center me nahi , how they become forward for central govt?
 
Dear,
This data is authentic , i collected it from the well known Gurnam Singh commissions(1990) report this report aprroved by commission and cabinet of haryana govt in 22 jan 1991 and notified and its no is 395-sw(t)-91 on 2 april 1991.
At that time mr bhajanlal was the head of state but due to his biasedness he dumps that report and in result jats of haryana suffering till today

All most all party leaders who are not from our community are biased and those who are from us they are not willing ,

" Thabhi toh Jats ke OBC status Ke liye dohara maapdand banaya hua hai"

State me jat backward hai anpni root jaghe par lekin agar woh bus ya train pakadkar delhi jata hai job ya admissions ke liye delhi aata hai toh is journey mei uska vikas ho jata hai, aisa central govt. ka mat hai,
hai yeh keysi hai vidambana , mare gaye jat, sakar ki galat soch se.

Even bihar ke jat ko OBC reservation ka benefit bihar state me hai par center me nahi , how they become forward for central govt?

Thanks for providing the source.

Since my views on Jat reservation are well known I will not go on about it in this thread. However if we take this section of the post as central to deciding of Jats need reservation a few points we must consider:

1. The report is from 1991. 20 years have passed. Are the stats still the same? Are the Jats still under represented in Govt. jobs as in 1991? I feel there is a need for latest figures.

2. I reckon there will be some areas where Jats will be over represented. eg. Police. Does the section you quoted take into account police posts?

3. Why should only govt. jobs be taken into account for deciding quota? There are other fields of occupation - private and self employed that decide one's economic well being.
 
Thanks for providing the source.

Since my views on Jat reservation are well known I will not go on about it in this thread. However if we take this section of the post as central to deciding of Jats need reservation a few points we must consider:

1. The report is from 1991. 20 years have passed. Are the stats still the same? Are the Jats still under represented in Govt. jobs as in 1991? I feel there is a need for latest figures.

2. I reckon there will be some areas where Jats will be over represented. eg. Police. Does the section you quoted take into account police posts?

3. Why should only govt. jobs be taken into account for deciding quota? There are other fields of occupation - private and self employed that decide one's economic well being.

Your points also apply to other castes who are enjoying the benefits of this reservation. First of all, apply them to castes who are already in the reservation quota. It would be unfair, if you apply these points to Jats only.
 
Your points also apply to other castes who are enjoying the benefits of this reservation. First of all, apply them to castes who are already in the reservation quota. It would be unfair, if you apply these points to Jats only.

I agree, but we are trying to evade the answer to those questions, aren't we?

I am in favour of collecting economic data for all castes and communities and then re-evaluating the need for reservation. Those that have reaped enough benefits to rise up should be excluded or have their quotas reduced. At the same time new quota should be awarded to other deserving communities.
 
I am in favour of collecting economic data for all castes and communities and then re-evaluating the need for reservation. Those that have reaped enough benefits to rise up should be excluded or have their quotas reduced. At the same time new quota should be awarded to other deserving communities.

Bhai, I am also in favour of that. But that re-evaluating will never happen. Everyone knows the ground reality. But removing any caste from Reserved categories will never happen in India. So waiting for this re-evaluation and suffering is not a wise idea. The only way this reservation can end is when every caste gets the reservation.
 
Thanks for providing the source.

Since my views on Jat reservation are well known I will not go on about it in this thread. However if we take this section of the post as central to deciding of Jats need reservation a few points we must consider:

1. The report is from 1991. 20 years have passed. Are the stats still the same? Are the Jats still under represented in Govt. jobs as in 1991? I feel there is a need for latest figures.

2. I reckon there will be some areas where Jats will be over represented. eg. Police. Does the section you quoted take into account police posts?

3. Why should only govt. jobs be taken into account for deciding quota? There are other fields of occupation - private and self employed that decide one's economic well being.
yes you pointed the issue correctly but don't forget that our population is increasing very fast and you can see that no of graduates and more is also increases , as i know in 1960-1980 those who get only just graduation degree they are hardly any who won't get type of job, you just have to access it your own village but now in these days you found educated youths in every house and what the really shocking is that you can count the no of youths who get the job only on your fingers , i mean that the actual situation is get worsen then before .

self assessment will give your answer .
How many youths and mature persons are self employed , its only few .

yes police department is also included in that commissions report.
 
Thanks for providing the source.

Since my views on Jat reservation are well known I will not go on about it in this thread. However if we take this section of the post as central to deciding of Jats need reservation a few points we must consider:

1. The report is from 1991. 20 years have passed. Are the stats still the same? Are the Jats still under represented in Govt. jobs as in 1991? I feel there is a need for latest figures.

2. I reckon there will be some areas where Jats will be over represented. eg. Police. Does the section you quoted take into account police posts?

3. Why should only govt. jobs be taken into account for deciding quota? There are other fields of occupation - private and self employed that decide one's economic well being.

Friend,

I think you are aware, the Mandal Commission Report, which was accepted by VP Singh Government in 1991, had based its recommendations on the data provided by Census Report of India, 1931.

Is the report of 1991 not better reflection of reality in comparison to 1931 report!

Has your 3 point taken into consideration while granting OBC status to other farming communities, I do not think it is so!

Rest everything is in the hands of the government how it settles the issue.

Thanks,

PS: Any thing can happen in the case of the Jats as is evident from the exclusion of Jats of two districts of Rajasthan viz Dholpur and Bharatpur who have not been included in the OBC list of Rajasthan because the two Jat Principalities happened to have ruled in that area. Are all the Jats of these two districts are forward than the Jats of other districts of Rajasthan. This shows special treatment of the OBC categorisation of the Jats and other communities in India!
 
.........

I am in favour of collecting economic data for all castes and communities and then re-evaluating the need for reservation. Those that have reaped enough benefits to rise up should be excluded or have their quotas reduced. At the same time new quota should be awarded to other deserving communities.

Good but do you think the beneficiaries of the Reservation Policy and their leaders ready to listen to your plea. It is just day dreaming that they would allow re-evaluation of the existing policy. Thanks
 
we have capacity to Grab any job

Puneet sir
You have collected some data which is partially true . You must know the interest of Jat,BOYS was in defense services ,in delhi police ,Haryana police , if you can collect that data and tell all of us , we represent just double % of our strength . Demand of reservation is a separate issue, we have capacity to Grab any job. In civil service examination Result post there was a positive thought .but today post is not satisfactory. Firstly get the data of that jobs in which Jat are interested. One more thing I have no drought on the efficiency of our community. A jat boy get the job in his early age of 16-20 in Navy, air force ,army , CISF,BSF ,ITBP, you can refer NDA result also. We have strong Body and mind we get what we desire .i thank the reservation should be based on economic condition not cast based.
 
Absolutely. That's what I said. Where did he get this data from? No harm in sharing the source. I am also keen on this report.

Govt authorities jo Data Jari karti hain woh purre viswas karne layak hote hain? Planning commission na abhi haal mai kafif authentic Data jari kiye thhe.

Kammal ke Data thhe, aur Aise authentic Datas par viswas karne walon ke baare mein kya kahena.
 
Puneet sir
You have collected some data which is partially true . You must know the interest of Jat,BOYS was in defense services ,in delhi police ,Haryana police , if you can collect that data and tell all of us , we represent just double % of our strength . Demand of reservation is a separate issue, we have capacity to Grab any job. In civil service examination Result post there was a positive thought .but today post is not satisfactory. Firstly get the data of that jobs in which Jat are interested. One more thing I have no drought on the efficiency of our community. A jat boy get the job in his early age of 16-20 in Navy, air force ,army , CISF,BSF ,ITBP, you can refer NDA result also. We have strong Body and mind we get what we desire .i thank the reservation should be based on economic condition not cast based.
Dear,
before (1991-1996) term of central govt. Jats getting the qouta 60% in core and infantry but during HD deve gowda's govt it cut down to 40% and later on in vajpaye's govt make it 20% why? On other hand % of casualties from our community in wars is more then 70% even in kargil war is around 75% why?

If we accept your way that we represent just double % of our strength , lets take a example delhi's jat population % is 7-8 means 2 lakhs families including migrant jats also.
Total delhi police strength is > 1 lakh , delhi have only 200 jat villages it menas 200-500 jat families per village and rest are in other colonies, which village you can name who have 50 policemen and the answer is no one . you get the figure is 10-15 or less in some what the % you get is only 5-7.5% then how can we say double. just cross check my way by regularly asking of delhi resident's representing any village , apply this in Haryana you get the right answer . may be you can name few who have armymen but don't forget the army's total strength .
 
Back
Top