IQ debate

desijat

New member
According to his holiness of BJP Mr. Nitin Gadkari, Swami Vivekanan's IQ is equal to that of Dawood Ibrahim. Same Vivekanand who is often quoted by his team members and is seen in posters all across BJP HQs.

Now I wonder, Rahul Gandhi is a kid who doesnt know how to speak, has a low IQ, is called mandh budhi n blah blah blah considering for which he can be forgiven but what do you do with a man who is grown up, has been in politics for his life, can think, has high IQ and his sharp budhi makes such comments?


P.S. Before blaming me for creating this thread please give me due credit of holding for several hours for someone to even mention this in a comment and I have not anywhere given my personal opinion yet on the thread, so dont judge as always
 
I dont know how this comparison was even thought of. Its highly doubtful if the IQ of these two gentlemen was ever measured. One lived in a time when IQ still wasn't the exalted metric of intelligence as it is today. For the other, I am sure govt agencies will have far better things to do with him other than measure IQ. :)

P.S. Get ready for a barrage of 'you-dont-start a thread-when-Congressis-make-idiotic-comments' posts.
 
Before any comments, Does same IQ of two people indicates/tells that both have/will have same thought process? (yes/no only)
 
IQ is the most researched approach to intelligence and by far the most widely used in practical setting. However, although IQ attempts to measure some notion of intelligence, it may fail to act as an accurate measure of "intelligence" in its broadest sense. IQ tests only examine particular areas embodied by the broadest notion of "intelligence", failing to account for certain areas which are also associated with "intelligence" such as creativity or emotional intelligence.
There are critics such as Keith Stanovich who do not dispute the stability of IQ test scores or the fact that they predict certain forms of achievement rather effectively. They do argue, however, that to base a concept of intelligence on IQ test scores alone is to ignore many important aspects of mental ability.

...the abstraction of intelligence as a single entity, its location within the brain, its quantification as one number for each individual, and the use of these numbers to rank people in a single series of worthiness, invariably to find that oppressed and disadvantaged groups—races, classes, or sexes—are innately inferior and deserve their status.

So above content shows that to define everything based on IQ never serves the purpose.

Also, Where you are using your intelligence ... in creativity or in distruction, varies from person to person...


Before any comments, Does same IQ of two people indicates/tells that both have/will have same thought process? (yes/no only)
 
Ofcourse.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"Yes" :)

Don't you see Digvijay Singh and Raul Baba? Few groups of scientists are working hard to develop "something", which can measure IQ in microns. And their thoughts and thought process is the proof that evolution can go in reverse.

Before any comments, Does same IQ of two people indicates/tells that both have/will have same thought process? (yes/no only)
 
Last edited:
However, although IQ attempts to measure some notion of intelligence, it may fail to act as an accurate measure of "intelligence" in its broadest sense. IQ tests only examine particular areas embodied by the broadest notion of "intelligence", failing to account for certain areas which are also associated with "intelligence" such as creativity or emotional intelligence.

There are critics such as Keith Stanovich who do not dispute the stability of IQ test scores or the fact that they predict certain forms of achievement rather effectively. They do argue, however, that to base a concept of intelligence on IQ test scores alone is to ignore many important aspects of mental ability.

....
....

So above content shows that to define everything based on IQ never serves the purpose.

Also, Where you are using your intelligence ... in creativity or in distruction, varies from person to person...


So, even if IQ score is same for two people, it means they can behave/act/react in totally different manners!

Now, coming to topic, if Vivekanand used his intelligence to serve people for good, Dawood used his intelligence for destruction. Their IQs may not be at same level, but even if they had same IQ level(if it would have been measured), why should they have behaved in same way? The theory of IQ/EQ etc itself is dubious (same way Hawk eye in cricket is dubious). The comparison was not incorrect. though in India, who you are comparing to, can make the news!!

When you cry its DEMOCRACY, then it is right of every person to be compared with any other person, whosoever it may be! And thats why Manish Bhikhari keeps on doing non-sense comparisons that too on national television. For examples search for debates, where he has participated, during IAC movements.

I never support Gadkari, since he also is a very corrupt man and instead of making his party stronger, infact has become a weak link. But he has every right to comapre anyone in the same way as Dogvijay Singh, Raul Vinci, Manish Bhikhari, Abhisex manu chingvi in this so called democracy.



PS : Urmalla ji (Naarad muni ji), aapne to beech me likde todan ki aadat kade te hai.. lage raho! :)
 
Though the intention of Gadkari comment was Good. But still this comparison doesn't looks Good. Unwanted comment.
 
I dont know how this comparison was even thought of. Its highly doubtful if the IQ of these two gentlemen was ever measured. One lived in a time when IQ still wasn't the exalted metric of intelligence as it is today. For the other, I am sure govt agencies will have far better things to do with him other than measure IQ. :)

Precisely why I had put up this topic. Why say something that you cant back up? Most of our politicians(Gadkari, Khursheed, Kejriwal) are suffering from foot in mouth disease.
 
Ya baat to bhai debate suru karan aale batavenge... baki jo apni galti ne accept kar le vo manas bhi badda hoya kare...

Meri nazar main to ye debate hi nahi thi. For me he was trying to show a comparison of attitube but chose wrong words.

The reason why I put up this thread was to see reactions of BJP suppoters and must say, I am very pleased. :tears_of_joy:

P.S.: Halwai ki shakal wala? khi khi
 
He is a professional lawyer. Nothing wrong in defending anyone.

According to him:

"I decide according to my conscience who to defend. A lawyer who refuses to defend a person on the grounds that people believe him to be guilty is himself guilty of professional misconduct."

He is an incredible person. At the age of 90, he is still so energetic and passionate about his work. Such an inspiration!!

He is a funny chap and a loud mouth

He has fought for all criminals and corrupt ministers all his life.
 
Agreed, at 90 he is an inspiration to our elders.

I never said there is anything wrong but he also suffers from same foot in mouth disease as Gadkari, look at this:

After he joined Bharatiya Janta Party in 2010, when he was asked why he had defended Afzal Guru against his death sentence when his party was in support of it, he replied that he had meant "that such indoctrinated elements (like Afzal) shouldn’t be allowed to die easily, but they should made to rot in jails."

He is a professional lawyer. Nothing wrong in defending anyone.

According to him:

"I decide according to my conscience who to defend. A lawyer who refuses to defend a person on the grounds that people believe him to be guilty is himself guilty of professional misconduct."

He is an incredible person. At the age of 90, he is still so energetic and passionate about his work. Such an inspiration!!
 
That's his personal opinion. Nothing wrong in it!

After he joined Bharatiya Janta Party in 2010, when he was asked why he had defended Afzal Guru against his death sentence when his party was in support of it, he replied that he had meant "that such indoctrinated elements (like Afzal) shouldn’t be allowed to die easily, but they should made to rot in jails."
 
I think you are mixing two things here. Working for people and devoting life for them is different from having a personal opinion.
People dont allow politicians to have personal life, how can we expect them to have personal opinions?
 
Back
Top