Newer Archaeological Finds : Kindly Share

drrajpalsingh

New member
Archaeology is playing a very important role in filling the gaps in the history of Pre-Historic and Proto-Historic era all over world. Many myths have been proved to be historical events and their significance verified by this field of study as is the case with the Mahabharata. Initially, the scholars were reluctant to accept the Epics as historical recording of events and personages but with the help of archaeological findings many places have been verified as true representations.

Scholars are invited to share their newer findings on this aspect in Indian history.
 
Archaeology is playing a very important role in filling the gaps in the history of Pre-Historic and Proto-Historic era all over world. Many myths have been proved to be historical events and their significance verified by this field of study as is the case with the Mahabharata. Initially, the scholars were reluctant to accept the Epics as historical recording of events and personages but with the help of archaeological findings many places have been verified as true representations.

Scholars are invited to share their newer findings on this aspect in Indian history.

There are several aspects of archaeology. One of them is educational material, which in the past used pamphlets and fliers. Presently, better methods are being used, such as videos, graphic animation and virtual reconstruction accompanied with commentary to recreate the past. So far one of the best such efforts that I have seen to come out of India is from Dholavira, Gujarat, another important city of Harappan civilization.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bj1yUD7dnKs

I suggest similar efforts should be made about Sindu-Saraswati sites in Haryana, Raj UP and Punjab. Interestingly, Dholavira had what Jats would recognize as johad. It appears that people at Dholavira in the past made good use of existing technology for water harvesting, storing and supplying, which is made evident from this animation/video. A good model from water conservation, harvesting and usage from the past which can effectively be utilized in present situation. Local solution to a local problem. Water table is a big issue every where and will only increase with time. I think a small solution is shown in this video from Dholavira. Seems like our ancestors are showing us a way to deal with this issue.
 
Last edited:
There are several aspects of archaeology. One of them is educational material, which in the past used pamphlets and fliers. Presently, better methods are being used, using video and graphic animation and commentary to recreate the past. So far one of the best such efforts that I have seen to come out of India is from Dholavira, Gujarat, another important city of Harappan civilization.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bj1yUD7dnKs

I suggest similar efforts should be made about Sindu-Saraswati sites in Haryana, Raj and UP. Interestingly, Dholavira had what we would call johad probably but they made good use of existing technology for water harvesting, storing and supplying, which is made evident from this animation/video.

Indeed very good ! Thanks for the post and hope more such informative will trickle in future for use of all concerned.
 
Yeh aur lijye. More news on archaeology from Farmana, Haryana.

i) This one deals with evidence of cooked meals with probably the very first evidence ever of cooked हलदी और अदरक in meal from digs at Farmana. This practice of making meals with Haldi, adrak is still in use even today almost all over India. In fact this small paper reveals quite a bit. Another factoid, from Pakistan shows that cows and other animals also had residue of same food, which means they ate food which was either thrown away or dumped. In India, it is a common practice even today where people leave food outside their house for cattles. Ravinderjeet had posted some very good photographs of it some time back and I am sure most people will easily identify and confirm this scenario.

Even phytoliths of banana have been found from Farmana and 2 other sites in Pakistan, meaning that even if banana was not grown in this region, it was brought here from areas where it was grown, meaning from further east. This confirms that Harappans were in direct contact with people from east. To me this is a huge discovery, when we discuss the geography of Vedic and Aryans.

http://simulpast.imf.csic.es/sp/images/stories/Science-2012-Lawler-288.pdf

ii) This one deals with use of various plants in diets and meals and also their processing in Farmana.

http://antiquity.ac.uk/projgall/kashyap326/#author

iii) 3-4 years back, I had posted a small note on Ravi's Jat History group about digs at Farmana:
(one of the links in that posting is not working but here is a much improved and better version of it)

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/JatHistory/message/5551
For the RIHN link please use this - http://archives.chikyu.ac.jp/archives/AnnualReport/Viewer.do?prkbn=P&id=15&jekbn=E

I think that MDU students were involved in this research. Also noted is Jeewan Singh Kharakwal from JRN Rajasthan Vidypeeth, Udaipur who was also involved.

Students of archaeology at MDU, KUK and other local universities and colleges should be encouraged to publish and share their results. This area is practically their backyard. I know all current digs which were earlier conducted by BHU and Cambridge is now being continued by MDU, Rohtak. Would like to see their results also.
 
Last edited:
I think that in RIHN project conclusion Dr Toshiki Osada, Project leader of RIHN Japan, a group which was involved in digs at Farmana and Kanmer, Guj makes extremely good observation -

"I just summarize the outcome of our project in several points, and suggest a set of criteria which would help understanding the Indus civilization.
(1) The natural environment of the Indus civilization is diverse. The Indus civilization is not simply dependent on a large river.
(2) The crop system of the civilization could be divided into three types: winter, summer, and mixed.
(3) Complex trade networks existed between diverse societies within the Indus regions, and also with outside regions such as Mesopotamia.
(4) The decline of the civilization was not caused by a single event but by multi-dimensional factors.

From these points I propose the following criteria for understanding the Indus civilization.

(A) Continuity vs. Discontinuity. We tend to look at the Indus society by drawing an analogy with its contemporary civilizations such as Egypt and Mesopotamia. Instead of doing this, we should rather investigate the later Indian society. I think that an analogy can be drawn not with its contemporary societies at remote places but with the later societies at the same place.
(B) Multiplicity vs. homogeneity. The Indus society was a multi-ethnic, multi-linguistic, multi-cultural society just like the modern Indian society is. There coexisted people of diverse professions such as agriculturalists, pastoralists, merchants, artisans and so on.
(C) Regionalization vs. Centralization. When we talk about an ancient civilization we generally focus on its centralized system rather than on its regional hegemony. The Indus society, however, had no centralized power to govern the whole region. Thus we should rather look at the society as a network of highly diverse regional hegemony.
(D) Abrupt change vs. gradual change. General readers familiar with the literature on the ancient civilizations expect the causes of decline of civilizations to be abrupt change. Environment determinists tend to emphasize a natural collapse or disaster as a main factor while social determinists tend to think a conquest or an invasion as a prime factor. We should reconstruct the Indus society on the basis of facts. Thus we avoid putting forward a hypothesis based on environmental and social determinism.

His observations A-D are most instructive, which I have highlighted in bold.

Once again the link that I have used is:
http://archives.chikyu.ac.jp/archives/AnnualReport/Viewer.do?prkbn=P&id=15&jekbn=E

Yeh aur lijye. More news on archaeology from Farmana, Haryana.

i) This one deals with evidence of cooked meals with probably the very first evidence ever of cooked हलदी और अदरक in meal from digs at Farmana. This practice of making meals with Haldi, adrak is still in use even today almost all over India. In fact this small paper reveals quite a bit. Another factoid, from Pakistan shows that cows and other animals also had residue of same food, which means they ate food which was either thrown away or dumped. In India, it is a common practice even today where people leave food outside their house for cattles. Ravinderjeet had posted some very good photographs of it some time back and I am sure most people will easily identify and confirm this scenario.

Even phytoliths of banana have been found from Farmana and 2 other sites in Pakistan, meaning that even if banana was not grown in this region, it was brought here from areas where it was grown, meaning from further east. This confirms that Harappans were in direct contact with people from east. To me this is a huge discovery, when we discuss the geography of Vedic and Aryans.

http://simulpast.imf.csic.es/sp/images/stories/Science-2012-Lawler-288.pdf

ii) This one deals with use of various plants in diets and meals and also their processing in Farmana.

http://antiquity.ac.uk/projgall/kashyap326/#author

iii) 3-4 years back, I had posted a small note on Ravi's Jat History group about digs at Farmana:
(one of the links in that posting is not working but here is a much improved and better version of it)

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/JatHistory/message/5551
For the RIHN link please use this - http://archives.chikyu.ac.jp/archives/AnnualReport/Viewer.do?prkbn=P&id=15&jekbn=E

I think that MDU students were involved in this research. Also noted is Jeewan Singh Kharakwal from JRN Rajasthan Vidypeeth, Udaipur who was also involved.

Students of archaeology at MDU, KUK and other local universities and colleges should be encouraged to publish and share their results. This area is practically their backyard. I know all current digs which were earlier conducted by BHU and Cambridge is now being continued by MDU, Rohtak. Would like to see their results also.
 
Yeh aur lijye. More news on archaeology from Farmana, Haryana........................
------------------------------------------

Students of archaeology at MDU, KUK and other local universities and colleges should be encouraged to publish and share their results. This area is practically their backyard. I know all current digs which were earlier conducted by BHU and Cambridge is now being continued by MDU, Rohtak. Would like to see their results also.

Friend,

We are doing our humble bit to encourage the publication of the research findings. Kindly permit me to add here how we do it in somewhat detail.

With a view to share the research experiences and scholarly activities of the research scholars and faculty members from across the Universities and Colleges from Haryana, Punjab, HP, UP, Rajasthan, Delhi and of course from Haryana are going to meet at a 2-Day National Seminar on ''Historiography and History of Haryana'' at Mukand Lal National College, Yamunanagar - Haryana. The response to our invitation has been tremendous.

The papers in four technical sessions will be presented, including using power point system and traditional research paper reading. Ancient, medieval modern and contemporary sessions will be chaired by eminent authorities on the subject. Several good archaeology scholars are also going to grace the occasion.

The proceedings of the seminar would be shared during the course of seminar and would be printed/published, after the quality of papers receive approval of the concerned experts/referees . This would surely boost the morale of the budding research scholars as they would get weightage for their paper presentation in this seminar in their future career.

As Convener of the Seminar I extend a hearty invitation through this post to all the readers of the post kindly to make it possible to join us on 22-23 February, 2013 as per your convenience and suitability.

Thanks
 
Friends,

On several archaeological sites in Meham Block of Rohtak district including Farmana, Dr. Vivek Dangi from AIJH College, Rohtak presented a very good paper supported by so many slides in the seminar at M L N College, Yamunanagar, the other day.

The details of the paper would be shared in the form of post here because it is very informative research. I will also share many other good research articles with all of you in a couple of days after getting them in presentable form.

Prof. Devendra Handa, former Head of the Department of History, Punjab University and former Director, Haryana, Archaeology Department and Prof. Manmohan Kumar from MDU and Dr. Rajpal from KUK-- who have supervised many sites' excavations also gave very important insight into rich heritage buried in the earth in Haryana.

Three research scholars from Haryana and One from Himachal Praddesh University Simala also presented good papers concerning pre-historic and proto-historic times of Haryana.

More than 30 papers related to Ancient, medieaval, modern and contemporary history of Haryana were presented and discussed.

Hope to share more information soon.

Thanks
 
Last edited:
यह हुई ना बात । Look forward to seeing the materials presented. Even if presentations are minor, this is really a good step.

Just a suggestion, this should be made an annual event. May be name it as Dr Suraj Bhan memorial annual seminar or something like that.

Friends,

On several archaeological sites in Meham Block of Rohtak district including Farmana, Dr. Vivek Dangi from AIJH College, Rohtak presented a very good paper supported by so many slides in the seminar at M L N College, Yamunanagar, the other day.

The details of the paper would be shared in the form of post here because it is very informative research. I will also share many other good research articles with all of you in a couple of days after getting them in presentable form.

Prof. Devendra Handa, former Head of the Department of History, Punjab University and Director, Haryana, Archaeology Department and Prof. Manmohan Kumar from MDU who have supervised many site excavations also gave very important insight into rich heritage buried in the earth in Haryana. Three research scholars from Haryana and One from Himachal Praddesh University Simala also presented good papers concerning pre-historic and proto-historic times of Haryana.

More than 30 papers related to Ancient, medieaval, modern and contemporary history of Haryana.

Hope to share more information soon.

Thanks
 
यह हुई ना बात । Look forward to seeing the materials presented. Even if presentations are minor, this is really a good step.

Just a suggestion, this should be made an annual event. May be name it as Dr Suraj Bhan memorial annual seminar or something like that.

Thanks friend.

No doubt, Professor Suraj Bhan's contribution as pioneer Archaeologist, and must be suitably remembered. If all the friends and well wishers co operate in the effort we can do something to immortalise his contribution. How it can be done suggestions are invited.
 
In a recently held Seminar, Professor Devendra Handa from Punjab University, Dr. Manmohan Kumar from MDU, Dr. Rajpal from Kuruksehtra University, Dr. Arun Singh from HPU and many young archaeologists presented their Research on the explorations and excavations of the present day Haryana state/ region. They told that hundreds of the sites from Haryana belonging to earlier times from the Harappan age have come to the notice and some of them yield signs of unbroken continuity of habitation.

These studies/papers are being updated/revised in the light of the discussions and suggestions made by the seminarians and likely to be received back in a couple of weeks by us from the concerned scholars after they make them fit for publication.

All of them have brought to the notice that this region has a rich history which lies buried beneaath earth. Very few sites that have been excavated have shown that in the old belt of Ghaghar which comprises region of Rohatak, Bhiwani, Hisar districts of Haryana has been found inhabited by people for a long time; to say in common parlance from the times when man learnt to live a settled life at one place. In Meham block of Rohtak very intensive exploration has been carried out by Mr. Vivek Dangi of Rohtak and he has arrived at the conclusion that the sites of archaeological importance in and around Meham, Madina, Farmana and several other places are very rich in their remains.

We have asked the authors of the research papers to supply us consent to put their papers [open for discussion] on this site for the benefit of readers and hope to get it shortly after which fuller details including the photos of the yields from the sites would be available to all of us.
 
Last edited:
A paper which talks about climate change which may have resulted in decline of cultures around Indus river basin:

"... We find that Indus Valley experienced extreme floods around 1750 BC with the increased frequency of 8 and 12 years compared to 39 years of frequency in complete record of varves proxy. Failed flood mitigation may have ultimately resulted in the decline of Indus Valley civilization."

http://conferences.futureocean.org/index.php/YSC/YSC3/paper/view/11

Interestingly it is in line with climate change model of decline around Saraswati (Ghagghar-Hakra). Indus saw increased intensity of flooding, Gagghar-Hakra (Saraswati), saw increased intensity of drying up, pointing to climate change, albeit of different kinds, in both places.
 
Last edited:
There are several aspects of archaeology. One of them is educational material, which in the past used pamphlets and fliers. Presently, better methods are being used, such as videos, graphic animation and virtual reconstruction accompanied with commentary to recreate the past. So far one of the best such efforts that I have seen to come out of India is from Dholavira, Gujarat, another important city of Harappan civilization.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bj1yUD7dnKs

I suggest similar efforts should be made about Sindu-Saraswati sites in Haryana, Raj UP and Punjab. Interestingly, Dholavira had what Jats would recognize as johad. It appears that people at Dholavira in the past made good use of existing technology for water harvesting, storing and supplying, which is made evident from this animation/video. A good model from water conservation, harvesting and usage from the past which can effectively be utilized in present situation. Local solution to a local problem. Water table is a big issue every where and will only increase with time. I think a small solution is shown in this video from Dholavira. Seems like our ancestors are showing us a way to deal with this issue.


Mr. Rao, please look into climatic conditions when these north western civilizations existed. The was harvesting things comes very late, rather at the end of this civilization. It will be interesting.
 
A paper which talks about climate change which may have resulted in decline of cultures around Indus river basin:

"... We find that Indus Valley experienced extreme floods around 1750 BC with the increased frequency of 8 and 12 years compared to 39 years of frequency in complete record of varves proxy. Failed flood mitigation may have ultimately resulted in the decline of Indus Valley civilization."

http://conferences.futureocean.org/index.php/YSC/YSC3/paper/view/11

Interestingly it is in line with climate change model of decline around Saraswati (Ghagghar-Hakra). Indus saw increased intensity of flooding, Gagghar-Hakra (Saraswati), saw increased intensity of drying up, pointing to climate change, albeit of different kinds, in both places.

Very informative and interesting contribution, indeed !
 
nrao said:
There are several aspects of archaeology. One of them is educational material, which in the past used pamphlets and fliers. Presently, better methods are being used, such as videos, graphic animation and virtual reconstruction accompanied with commentary to recreate the past. So far one of the best such efforts that I have seen to come out of India is from Dholavira, Gujarat, another important city of Harappan civilization.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bj1yUD7dnKs

I suggest similar efforts should be made about Sindu-Saraswati sites in Haryana, Raj UP and Punjab. Interestingly, Dholavira had what Jats would recognize as johad. It appears that people at Dholavira in the past made good use of existing technology for water harvesting, storing and supplying, which is made evident from this animation/video. A good model from water conservation, harvesting and usage from the past which can effectively be utilized in present situation. Local solution to a local problem. Water table is a big issue every where and will only increase with time. I think a small solution is shown in this video from Dholavira. Seems like our ancestors are showing us a way to deal with this issue.

Mr. Rao, please look into climatic conditions when these north western civilizations existed. The was harvesting things comes very late, rather at the end of this civilization. It will be interesting.

I am sure you will agree, I have provided some links to climatic conditions in this link and Rakhigarhi links. Lot more is needed.
It will be very interesting to know which harvesting things came late and towards the end of this civilization. Please provide some papers or links. I also think that in some places civilization never really ended and we see a continuity from past till now.

The link to that video was provided so that similar efforts could be made on these lines that is all. Jat areas contain lot of these sites that belong to Saraswati-Sindhu or Harappan civ therefore it would be easier to create such pedagogical material about these sites. It will benefit everybody, government agencies can promote tourism, maybe it will give rise to a small animation or studio companies in these parts. Young software engineers can be roped in for such efforts as well. Also provide avenue for young history and archaeology scholars to showcase their research.

Since this is an archaeology thread, I also want to share some relevant material and not have just some discussion, so here are two excellent papers/reports from MDU Rohtak, RIHN and Deccan college faculty:
- http://www.academia.edu/695509/Expl...t_and_Mitathal_Bhiwani_District_Haryana_India

- this excellent excavation report from Madina, Rohtak, talks of possible overlap of Harappan and PGW (contains excellent photographs):

http://www.academia.edu/695521/Excavations_at_Madina_District_Rohtak_Haryana_2007-08_A_Report

A quote from the paper - "Although the feasibility of this theory is not discussed here in this paper, so far as our site is concerned, it is clear that there is a continuation of the Harappan tradition until the onset of the PGW culture towards the end of second millennium BCE. Some percentage of the total red ware pottery is the Harappan pottery. It means that the inhabitants continued to use the Late Harappan pottery during the PGW period but they did not copy the shapes of the Late Harappan Pottery as at Bhagwanpura." pg. 114.

Dr Dangi reports about 50 Harappan sites (pre, early, late or mature, as of 2006) just from Meham block of Rohtak alone. Which is quite amazing.

Good articles and reports coming from MDU. MDU धिमे-धिमे छा रहा है, किमि लठ सा गाड रहा है। :)

No doubt MDU can easily become world class institute as far as archaeology is concerned, since there are so many site in Haryana and MDU is producing good results.

It needs to get into more scientific areas like latest dating techniques, DNA analysis, forensic studies, starch grain analysis to study plant use, food preparation, ceramic residue analysis and tool use etc.
 
Last edited:
I am sure you will agree, I have provided some links to climatic conditions in this link and Rakhigarhi links. Lot more is needed.
It will be very interesting to know which harvesting things came late and towards the end of this civilization. Please provide some papers or links. I also think that in some places civilization never really ended and we see a continuity from past till now.

The link to that video was provided so that similar efforts could be made on these lines that is all. Jat areas contain lot of these sites that belong to Saraswait-Sindhu or Harappan civ therefore it would be easier to create such pedagogical material about these sites. It will benefit everybody, government agencies can promote tourism, maybe it will give rise to a small animation or studio companies in these parts. Young software engineers can be roped in for such efforts as well. Also provide avenue for young history and archaeology scholars to showcase their research.

Since this is an archaeology thread, I also want to share some relevant material and not have just some discussion, so here are two excellent papers/reports from MDU Rohtak, RIHN and Deccan college faculty:
- http://www.academia.edu/695509/Expl...t_and_Mitathal_Bhiwani_District_Haryana_India

- this excellent excavation report from Madina, Rohtak, talks of possible overlap of Harappan and PGW (contains excellent photographs):

http://www.academia.edu/695521/Excavations_at_Madina_District_Rohtak_Haryana_2007-08_A_Report

A quote from the paper - "Although the feasibility of this theory is not discussed here in this paper, so far as our site is concerned, it is clear that there is a continuation of the Harappan tradition until the onset of the PGW culture towards the end of second millennium BCE. Some percentage of the total red ware pottery is the Harappan pottery. It means that the inhabitants continued to use the Late Harappan pottery during the PGW period but they did not copy the shapes of the Late Harappan Pottery as at Bhagwanpura." pg. 114.

MDU dheere dheere chaaa raha hai, kimme lath sa gaad raha hai :)

No doubt MDU can easily become world class institute regarding archaeology, since there are so many site in Haryana and MDU is producing good results.

It needs to get into more scientific areas like latest dating techniques, DNA analysis, forensic studies, starch grain analysis to study plant use, food preparation, ceramic residue analysis and tool use etc.


What about 8000 or 9000 years before Christ. Or even before that period?
 
If you have some archaeological finds or paper then please share them here, else start another thread just for discussion sake.

I hope, u are not feeling frustrated. I felt it by your statement. I asked that question because i most of the time, history of this area is discussed in times after 5000 BC. Whereas existence of cities have been there in this same area even before that time period. I will see,what i can locate.
 
I hope, u are not feeling frustrated. I felt it by your statement. I asked that question because i most of the time, history of this area is discussed in times after 5000 BC. Whereas existence of cities have been there in this same area even before that time period. I will see,what i can locate.

Friend,

You are welcome to share your knowledge about the cities of 5000 B.C. or of earlier than this time line.

But kindly note that everyone is not aware about such excavations or exploration, so enlighten us please !

Yes, come, join and discuss posts, not the persons [who happen to post them].
 
Back
Top