Newer Archaeological Finds : Kindly Share

About the richness of the remains burried in the Earth in Haryana Region, A. Ghosh had written in 'Bulletin of the National Institute of Sciences, No. 1, 1952' that ''...the valleys of Saraswati and the Drisshadvati must be regarded as very rich indeed in archaeological remains. But the richness does not consist only in the number of discovered sites, but in their vast chronological and cultural range. For they comprise relics of several millenia of Indian history right from the Harappa period to comparatively recent historical times.''

Over the years, the archaeologists have explored and excavated a large number of sites in this region and have proved the antiquity of the habitation in this region to Pre-Harappan times. In addition to the interest shown by foreign archaeologists in this area, the archaeologists from government department and from the History departments of Kurukshetra, Punjab and Rohtak Universities have brought to light significant data which has proved path breaking in proving many a myth into history and in some cases 'history' into myth !

To the latter statement, the findings at Bhagwanpura about 18 kms from Kurukshetra, the excavations of the ruins standing on the dried up bed of the River Saraswati showed juxtaposition of Painted Gray Ware [PGW] and Late Harappan Wares. This proved that the Aryan emigrants and the earlier inhabitants belonging to late Harappan period lived together there.

The outcome of Rakhigarhi, Meham, Farmana, Mitathal have further enriched the information and data being studied would definitely stand in good stead to further unravel many more mysteries of history buried under the layers of the sands.
 
To the latter statement, the findings at Bhagwanpura about 18 kms from Kurukshetra, the excavations of the ruins standing on the dried up bed of the River Saraswati showed juxtaposition of Painted Gray Ware [PGW] and Late Harappan Wares. This proved that the Aryan emigrants and the earlier inhabitants belonging to late Harappan period lived together there.

Highlighted, is just an empty statement with no basis. Proof dekhao!
 
Highlighted, is just an empty statement with no basis. Proof dekhao!

The juxtaposition of the remains of both the periods i.e. late Harappan and the PGW has been quoted as proof, by the Archaeologists, of the co-existence of these people.

If contrary proofs are there, kindly share.
 
The juxtaposition of the remains of both the periods i.e. late Harappan and the PGW has been quoted as proof, by the Archaeologists, of the co-existence of these people.

If contrary proofs are there, kindly share.

San 1952 mein PGW ko jo Aryon ki nishaani maante thhe 2012 mein veh vaigyanik is baat ko sahi nahi maante. Naye anusandhan padhne ki avashyakta hai. Shri BB Lal ki kitabein padhne se baat kaafi spasht hoti hai.
 
San 1952 mein PGW ko jo Aryon ki nishaani maante thhe 2012 mein veh vaigyanik is baat ko sahi nahi maante. Naye anusandhan padhne ki avashyakta hai. Shri BB Lal ki kitabein padhne se baat kaafi spasht hoti hai.

Kindly reproduce what BB Lal says in this connection and in which book it has come out in 2012 that PGW did not belong to the Indo-Aryans.

Thanks
 
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by Romar

San 1952 mein PGW ko jo Aryon ki nishaani maante thhe 2012 mein veh vaigyanik is baat ko sahi nahi maante. Naye anusandhan padhne ki avashyakta hai. Shri BB Lal ki kitabein padhne se baat kaafi spasht hoti hai.

My question regarding your above post was :

Kindly reproduce what BB Lal says in this connection and in which book it has come out in 2012 that PGW did not belong to the Indo-Aryans.

Thanks

Your reply is :



Jara nahin puri tarah dekh liya aur padh bhi liya.

Lekin koi nai baat dekhne ko nahin mili, BB Lal ne
Jo kuchh kaha bataya gaya hai woh bhi 'tentative' hai, final conclusion nahin !

Kya aapke paas Dr. B B Lal ki koi pushtak hai jisme se hum aur aap PGW ke baare mein kucchh baten share kar saken !!
 
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by Romar

San 1952 mein PGW ko jo Aryon ki nishaani maante thhe 2012 mein veh vaigyanik is baat ko sahi nahi maante. Naye anusandhan padhne ki avashyakta hai. Shri BB Lal ki kitabein padhne se baat kaafi spasht hoti hai.

My question regarding your above post was :



Your reply is :




Jara nahin puri tarah dekh liya aur padh bhi liya.

Lekin koi nai baat dekhne ko nahin mili, BB Lal ne
Jo kuchh kaha bataya gaya hai woh bhi 'tentative' hai, final conclusion nahin !

Kya aapke paas Dr. B B Lal ki koi pushtak hai jisme se hum aur aap PGW ke baare mein kucchh baten share kar saken !!


BB Lal ka apna bayaan:
[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]In my exploration of the sites associated with the Mahabharata story I came across the Painted Grey Ware Culture which fitted the bill. It antedated the Northern Black Polished Ware whose beginning went back to the 6th-7th century BCE, and overlay, with a break in between, the Ochre Colour Ware of the early 2nd millennium BCE. In my report on the excavations at Hastinapura and in a few subsequent papers I expressed the view that the Painted Grey Ware Culture represented the early Aryans in India. But the honeymoon was soon to be over. Excavations in the middle Ganga valley threw up in the pre-NBP strata a ceramic industry with the same shapes (viz. bowls and dishes) and painted designs as in the case of the PGW, the only difference being that in the former case the ware had a black or black-and-red surface-colour, which, however, was just the result of a particular method of firing. And even the associated cultural equipment was alike in the two cases. All this similarity opened my eyes and I could no longer sustain the theory of the PGW having been a representative of the early Aryans in India. (The association of this Ware with the Mahabharata story was nevertheless sustainable since that event comes at a later stage in the sequence.) I had no qualms in abandoning my then-favourite theory[/qu[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]ote]

http://www.archaeologyonline.net/artifacts/19th-century-paradigms.html[/FONT][/FONT]
 
Thanks Dr Rajpal ji for your honest efforts in this regard.

I am ready to share my views with an open mind.


A healthy discussion with an open mind can clear lot of confusion regarding our past.



We must remember in Europe, history revolves more around Christ and after Christ. Before Christ and pre history is little talked about, where as we talk easily about pre history and before Christ history there fore the context of Slavic tribes and other migrating tribes remains very contextual. When i say, contextual, i mean to say, at what point of time, which tribe was where, lived at that place for how much time and what was that tribe doing there at the point of time. Many European tribes irrespective of being called as Slavic, Aryan or whatever else tribes came from East, when i say East, it means Central Asia and Northern India.
 



The given link lists three places recently excavated in Haryana.

http://www.academia.edu/695509/Expl...t_and_Mitathal_Bhiwani_District_Haryana_India


In the meantime, I take the opportunity to inform that the research articles of Dr. Manmohan Kumar, Dr. Vivek Dangi and the members of the team from MDU, Rohtak, who were associated with the excavations at all the four sites, have been presented in a seminar held at MLN College, Yamunanagar recently are being published in the form of book.

This will enable us to have deeper understanding of the ancient habitation and culture of the region and help in removing many misconceptions on several historical important issues.

Thanks
 
Last edited:
The juxtaposition of the remains of both the periods i.e. late Harappan and the PGW has been quoted as proof, by the Archaeologists, of the co-existence of these people.

If contrary proofs are there, kindly share.

Here is a contrary view that you wanted to read. Just posted a link on Mr Ravi Chaudhary's Jat History group, that prooves that Harappan and PGW overlapped and that too from one of the eastern Harappan site, Alamgirpur. Proof that PGW did exist over 5 thousand years ago, ie 3rd millinenium before common era. How long will it take for professional historians to correct their views remains to be seen:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/JatHistory/message/7723

Following quote from BB Lal is most instructive -

Ranbir Tomar said:
BB Lal ka apna bayaan:
In my exploration of the sites associated with the Mahabharata story I came across the Painted Grey Ware Culture which fitted the bill. It antedated the Northern Black Polished Ware whose beginning went back to the 6th-7th century BCE, and overlay, with a break in between, the Ochre Colour Ware of the early 2nd millennium BCE. In my report on the excavations at Hastinapura and in a few subsequent papers I expressed the view that the Painted Grey Ware Culture represented the early Aryans in India. But the honeymoon was soon to be over. Excavations in the middle Ganga valley threw up in the pre-NBP strata a ceramic industry with the same shapes (viz. bowls and dishes) and painted designs as in the case of the PGW, the only difference being that in the former case the ware had a black or black-and-red surface-colour, which, however, was just the result of a particular method of firing. And even the associated cultural equipment was alike in the two cases. All this similarity opened my eyes and I could no longer sustain the theory of the PGW having been a representative of the early Aryans in India. (The association of this Ware with the Mahabharata story was nevertheless sustainable since that event comes at a later stage in the sequence.) I had no qualms in abandoning my then-favourite theory

http://www.archaeologyonline.net/art...paradigms.html
 
For latest researches in Haryana ancient site of Madina in Rohtak district, kindly log :

http://www.academia.edu/695521/Excavations_at_Madina_District_Rohtak_Haryana_2007-08_A_Report

rajpal ji ,madina gaon ki jo site east me bataai gai hein we hamaare gaon ki seemaa se lagti hein ,aur hamaare gaon me bhi do-teen khede hein ,mere khayaal se vahaan par ab tak koi khudaai kaa kaam nahi huaa he ,pahle bhi hamaare bachpan me hamne suna thaa ki vahaan par bartan bhaande nikalte hein ,we dono site thodi oonchaai par hein ,mere khayaal se agar vahaan par khudaai ki jaaye to kaafi kuchh mil saktaa he.
 
rajpal ji ,madina gaon ki jo site east me bataai gai hein we hamaare gaon ki seemaa se lagti hein ,aur hamaare gaon me bhi do-teen khede hein ,mere khayaal se vahaan par ab tak koi khudaai kaa kaam nahi huaa he ,pahle bhi hamaare bachpan me hamne suna thaa ki vahaan par bartan bhaande nikalte hein ,we dono site thodi oonchaai par hein ,mere khayaal se agar vahaan par khudaai ki jaaye to kaafi kuchh mil saktaa he.

Friend,

It is good to learn that ancient remains buried under the earth are available in the vicinity of your village. Kindly send some exact information about their location so that this buried treasure of historical important remains could be got unearthed. It may contain some important clues to our lost links of history.

On receipt of the exact location information of the Khedas, I would ask my friends to explore the sites.

Thanks.
 
What about 8000 or 9000 years before Christ. Or even before that period?

Many chalcolithic cultures have been excavated and studied in somewhat detail for the time period you mention. They are quite distinct from Harappan culture as evidenced from the absence of the use of bricks for construction, absence of citadel etc., absence of script etc.
 
What method was used to show the juxtaposition ?

Not going into technicality of the archaeology, in simple words this could be understood as follows:

The remains excavated from the Ancient sites have been identified and categorised according to their shape, material used, timeline of their formation etc and then assigned to various known phases of ancient civilisation and cultures. When material belonging to two different cultural phases is found burried at one place at the same time, this shows co-existence of two groups of people at the site. Bhagwanpur near Kurukshetra is such one site where the wares, sculptures etc belonging to late Harappan period and Rig vedic times [NBP] have been unearthed. This is juxtaposition of the two cultural phases !!
 
Many chalcolithic cultures have been excavated and studied in somewhat detail for the time period you mention. They are quite distinct from Harappan culture as evidenced from the absence of the use of bricks for construction, absence of citadel etc., absence of script etc.

It would be good if you could quote some examples of the earlier sites for the benefit of the readers .

Thanks and regards
 
Not going into technicality of the archaeology, in simple words this could be understood as follows:

The remains excavated from the Ancient sites have been identified and categorised according to their shape, material used, timeline of their formation etc and then assigned to various known phases of ancient civilisation and cultures. When material belonging to two different cultural phases is found burried at one place at the same time, this shows co-existence of two groups of people at the site. Bhagwanpur near Kurukshetra is such one site where the wares, sculptures etc belonging to late Harappan period and Rig vedic times [NBP] have been unearthed. This is juxtaposition of the two cultural phases !!

By material, I believe you mean pottery. There are more than 1 way that material belonging to different periods let alone phases, can be found together. Earthquake is one exception and a few more are coming to my mind.
 
Back
Top