How does Arun Jaitley make so much money??
Arun Jaitley filed his nomination papers for the Rajya Sabha re-election, and stunned everyone by reporting a wealth of Rs 158 odd crores, of which Rs 120 crores is in his personal name (the rest is in his wife’s name, which actually means the same). The only reason I ask this question is because the BJP keeps asking Congress leaders the same question. It’s only fair then that Jaitley provides us an answer.
But before we get into the details, I think a clarification is in order. If one reads the media reports, it appears as if Arun Jaitley’s income has soared from Rs 24 odd crores to Rs 120 crores in just 1 year and 7 months (from Nov 2011 till now). That’s not true. The Nov 2011 report, attributed to ADR – Association for Democratic Reforms – only quotes the figure that Jaitley mentioned in his 2006 RS nomination papers. So the correct time period for this spurt is 6 years, not 1 year and 7 months. Even so, its quite a fantastic performance that Jaitley has delivered! Even better than Gayle’s, some would say!
I initially thought that his “immovable assets” (mostly property) would have soared, and given the economic growth in the last six years (despite the last year’s slowdown, and despite what the BJP criticizes), it would have been a good explanation. Except that the filing gives a fairly detailed break-up of his wealth. And immovable assets have grown only from Rs 8 odd crores to Rs 35 odd crores – substantial but hardly enough to explain the overall growth. In fact, even if we take this part out, the growth from Rs 16 odd crores (24 less 8) to Rs 85 odd crores (120 less 35) is huge; in fact, more than 5 times. Clearly, this cannot be on account of regular “business”.
Talking of business, Jaitley is pretty much doing nothing substantial these days. He has stopped “practicing”, now that he has become a “master” of politics! He is not available as legal counsel any longer. Even if he does practice, it must be for a very limited number of cases or on political cases. He is also not on the Boards of any corporation (“remunerative directorships” as its called in the filings), as per his own filing. Nor for that matter, does he declare anything under “regular remunerated activity” or “shareholding of controlling nature” or even “paid consultancy”. Even if he were practicing, his income would have been around Rs 10 crores per annum (a figure he declared under “professional engagement” in 2005-6). That like I mentioned earlier has pretty much stopped.
None of Jaitley’s known sources of income explain the growth in wealth. But all of a sudden, there is the appearance of a loan of Rs 30 crores that Jaitley has apparently given to someone. Rs 30 crores? That’s serious money. Where did that come from? It wasn’t there six years back in 2006. And let’s not forget, wealth creation happens after the payment of taxes. To accumulate Rs 30 crores, Jaitley would have had to earn Rs 45 crores or so. Where did this come from?
It’s also not as if he’s taken on external liabilities that could possibly explain his capacity to extend such a loan? Sometimes people do that – borrow on their own personal credibility, and lend to others in the family or friends. But that’s also not true. There are no liabilities mentioned in Jaitley’s filing. Nor has he sold off any land or Jewellery, which in any case is not worth so much. This is truly a conundrum that only he can answer!
And answer he will. If someone asks him. For now, I don’t want to allege anything, only seek an explanation. For me, the more interesting part of all this is how deftly he will possibly explain it all away, while at the same time, how steadfastly he will refuse to accept similar explanations given by his rivals! If Vadra’s land appreciates by 6x, it is unacceptable to the BJP; if Jaitley’s does, it’s cool!
Before I end, just a comment on the way our media operates. None of the publications thought it necessary to do some homework. The details of Jaitley’s filings are all readily available online. They took the short cut and published the press release that ADR provided. All that that press release mentioned was that in Nov 2011, Jaitley’s declared wealth was Rs 24 crores. That declared wealth was as of 2006, but everyone missed that point. Shouldn’t someone have aksed how his wealth could go up by so much in such a short time? Shouldn’t that have led to some research? But our media is prone to sensationalism; and poor quality of journalism. They found it convenient to just shoot!
The real truth is that every which way you look, the BJP is no different from the Congress or any other party. They are all the same. They all source their funding illegally. They all want to stay outside of RTI. They hurl accusations against each other in public; then hug each other in the Central Hall (metaphorically; as MJ Akbar mentioned in one of his recent articles). It’s not the corruption in the BJP that angers me; it’s their double-speak….
Source: Opinion article published on the Times of India
Arun Jaitley filed his nomination papers for the Rajya Sabha re-election, and stunned everyone by reporting a wealth of Rs 158 odd crores, of which Rs 120 crores is in his personal name (the rest is in his wife’s name, which actually means the same). The only reason I ask this question is because the BJP keeps asking Congress leaders the same question. It’s only fair then that Jaitley provides us an answer.
But before we get into the details, I think a clarification is in order. If one reads the media reports, it appears as if Arun Jaitley’s income has soared from Rs 24 odd crores to Rs 120 crores in just 1 year and 7 months (from Nov 2011 till now). That’s not true. The Nov 2011 report, attributed to ADR – Association for Democratic Reforms – only quotes the figure that Jaitley mentioned in his 2006 RS nomination papers. So the correct time period for this spurt is 6 years, not 1 year and 7 months. Even so, its quite a fantastic performance that Jaitley has delivered! Even better than Gayle’s, some would say!
I initially thought that his “immovable assets” (mostly property) would have soared, and given the economic growth in the last six years (despite the last year’s slowdown, and despite what the BJP criticizes), it would have been a good explanation. Except that the filing gives a fairly detailed break-up of his wealth. And immovable assets have grown only from Rs 8 odd crores to Rs 35 odd crores – substantial but hardly enough to explain the overall growth. In fact, even if we take this part out, the growth from Rs 16 odd crores (24 less 8) to Rs 85 odd crores (120 less 35) is huge; in fact, more than 5 times. Clearly, this cannot be on account of regular “business”.
Talking of business, Jaitley is pretty much doing nothing substantial these days. He has stopped “practicing”, now that he has become a “master” of politics! He is not available as legal counsel any longer. Even if he does practice, it must be for a very limited number of cases or on political cases. He is also not on the Boards of any corporation (“remunerative directorships” as its called in the filings), as per his own filing. Nor for that matter, does he declare anything under “regular remunerated activity” or “shareholding of controlling nature” or even “paid consultancy”. Even if he were practicing, his income would have been around Rs 10 crores per annum (a figure he declared under “professional engagement” in 2005-6). That like I mentioned earlier has pretty much stopped.
None of Jaitley’s known sources of income explain the growth in wealth. But all of a sudden, there is the appearance of a loan of Rs 30 crores that Jaitley has apparently given to someone. Rs 30 crores? That’s serious money. Where did that come from? It wasn’t there six years back in 2006. And let’s not forget, wealth creation happens after the payment of taxes. To accumulate Rs 30 crores, Jaitley would have had to earn Rs 45 crores or so. Where did this come from?
It’s also not as if he’s taken on external liabilities that could possibly explain his capacity to extend such a loan? Sometimes people do that – borrow on their own personal credibility, and lend to others in the family or friends. But that’s also not true. There are no liabilities mentioned in Jaitley’s filing. Nor has he sold off any land or Jewellery, which in any case is not worth so much. This is truly a conundrum that only he can answer!
And answer he will. If someone asks him. For now, I don’t want to allege anything, only seek an explanation. For me, the more interesting part of all this is how deftly he will possibly explain it all away, while at the same time, how steadfastly he will refuse to accept similar explanations given by his rivals! If Vadra’s land appreciates by 6x, it is unacceptable to the BJP; if Jaitley’s does, it’s cool!
Before I end, just a comment on the way our media operates. None of the publications thought it necessary to do some homework. The details of Jaitley’s filings are all readily available online. They took the short cut and published the press release that ADR provided. All that that press release mentioned was that in Nov 2011, Jaitley’s declared wealth was Rs 24 crores. That declared wealth was as of 2006, but everyone missed that point. Shouldn’t someone have aksed how his wealth could go up by so much in such a short time? Shouldn’t that have led to some research? But our media is prone to sensationalism; and poor quality of journalism. They found it convenient to just shoot!
The real truth is that every which way you look, the BJP is no different from the Congress or any other party. They are all the same. They all source their funding illegally. They all want to stay outside of RTI. They hurl accusations against each other in public; then hug each other in the Central Hall (metaphorically; as MJ Akbar mentioned in one of his recent articles). It’s not the corruption in the BJP that angers me; it’s their double-speak….
Source: Opinion article published on the Times of India