Khap Relaxes Gotra Marriage Norms

Jiske parivar mai Hooda, Malik aar Dahiya gotra ho ja uhh ka byah muskil ho ja sai. Samasya aade bhi koni rukti baki gaam guhand ke gott bhi chhodne pade sain. Kitte kitte to 8-10 gott chhodne padd jaya sain.
 
Last edited:
Maybe this thing has made Jats more weaker in Utter Pradesh. We must not forget, Jats are agriculturists and Utter Pradesh has one of the largest farm area. Farm landholdings in Jat agricultural areas is decreasing very rapidly. To maintain the agricultural land area, Jats should migrate to outer regions capable of good agriculture, this migration must always be in form of groups and must be backed by structural organizations like Khaps, Village units etc. Jats from all the areas like Punjab, Rajasthan, Haryana, Western Utter Pradesh must join hands to expand agricultural area.

.......................

It would be good if you could suggest/identify the outer areas where the migration of Jats in the form of groups could take place ? Do you suggest inside India or outside the country migration. Is it possible in the present conditions prevailing all over the country and the world that mass migration could take place? Ponder over this aspect and share your views accordingly.

Thanks
 
Agreed!

In Rajasthan still Jats avoid 4 gotras (includes Nani gotra) whereas in Haryana or UP Jats generally avoid 3 gotras and that too being shrinked to 2 gotras. This is certainly not in good taste. What happened to our advocating of avoiding gotras earlier? What about scientific reasons which we always use to back it. In helplessness if this decision has been taken then at-least please don't welcome it.

Btw, why not Jat khaps come with proposal to marry Jats of different region, I mean we should start promoting marriages inter-state. Rajasthani Jats have lot of unique gotras so is with UP Jats. I believe it's better idea than relaxing gotra of Dadi.

your thoughts ..

2 Gotras??

Read this:-

In my region, we leave gotra of ususal 4, plus any other gotra in village (No matter how small or big that is).
The Cultural reason is gaon me kai sare khede (dadda khede) hote hain, pehle kue hote the, to wahan agar wo mahila pujne jayegi, to use beti mana jayega un gotra ke logo ki najar me , ya bahu.
This creates hotpotch, and objections. So if by mistake/knowingly, kahin rishta kar dete hain, to objection raise hone ke bad cancel karna padta hai.

Also, guhaand gotra's (we call them guhandi bhai's), if we have bhaichara with them. Cultural reason is: Wahan ke bujurg hamare bujurgo ke pas ayenge baithenge to kya unhi ki beti (by gotra), unki ke samne bahu bankar ollha kaadhti dikkhegi. And this becomes embarassing n awkward moment. So we leave these gotras also.

On top of that, some gotra's have bhaichara (b/w them). Some are derived from one to another. Now, all this could add to 10/15+ gotras.

Also, Vicky pointed correctly, If the prospect has gotras of Malik, hooda, dahiya, it becomes very painful task to find a match in that region. As people of that region don't prefer to go much beyond that region.

Interstate marriages are also in place for border districts. In my family (chacha & tau), childrens' are married in hindu jat villages of Sangrur, Patiala of PB, two in sikh jat families.
Similary way on Maussi side (Tosham), they're married in churu, jhunjhnu of RJ.

Inter-faith marriages should also be promoted by Khaps.

In my opinion, Sikh jats don't like give their daughters to hindu jats.But reverse is seen. May be, Swaich can throw some light, why is it so.

Logistical regions also restricts elders to go across the state boundaries. Thare Rajasthan ke culture me aur yahan difference hai, tumhare yahan beti byahi aur bhool gaye (virtually). Haryana me kaafi aana-jaana rehta hai rishtedariyo me because of customs tht extend well beyond marriages.
 
Last edited:
+

Poore haryana ka to pata nahi. Par hamari taraf (barwala-narnaund tehsil, hisar). Agar kahin baraat me bhi jaate the, to customs hai ki. Us gaon me na sirf apne kunbe (parivar) ki ladki, balki aur gaon ki ladki jo wahan bahu hai, uske wahan jata hota tha, raji khushi puchni hoti thi. Aur das das rapiye (seems akward, but aisa hota tha) de ke aane hotte the. Aur agar taadad jyada hote hai, to unsabke mila ek ek ko de diye jate the, wo aage de deti thi. Aajkal shayad ye sirf apne gotra ke ladkiyo ke liye reh gaya ho.

Abb Rajsthan ki aap batayein.
 
+

Poore haryana ka to pata nahi. Par hamari taraf (barwala-narnaund tehsil, hisar). Agar kahin baraat me bhi jaate the, to customs hai ki. Us gaon me na sirf apne kunbe (parivar) ki ladki, balki aur gaon ki ladki jo wahan bahu hai, uske wahan jata hota tha, raji khushi puchni hoti thi. Aur das das rapiye (seems akward, but aisa hota tha) de ke aane hotte the. Aur agar taadad jyada hote hai, to unsabke mila ek ek ko de diye jate the, wo aage de deti thi. Aajkal shayad ye sirf apne gotra ke ladkiyo ke liye reh gaya ho.

Abb Rajsthan ki aap batayein.

सही कहा आपने | मेरठ ओर बुलंदशहर क्षेत्र में भी यही रिवाज है | किसी दुसरे गाँव में जाना हो तो घरवाले बता देते है की भाई फलाने के घर भी हो आना , हाल चाल पूछ आना , कोई बुआ लगती है कोई बहन लगती है | ओर ये १० -१० वाली बात भी बिलकुल सही है |:tears_of_joy: जब छोटे थे तो घरवाले १०-१० रूपये सबके नाम के गिनकर देकर भेजते थे | अब तो कह देते है की भाई खली हाथ मत जाना ओर आती बार कुछ दे आना | एक बार तो मेरी गेल बहुत बुरी बनी | घरवालो ने कह दिया की फलानी तेरी बुआ लगती है , हो आना | वहा जाकर, में कोन हु उन्हें समझाने में मेरे पसीने छुट गये |:(
 
An editorial on the role of the Khap Panchayats on the issue under discussion has appeared entitled : Social Change- At last, Khaps begin to respond.

Read the newspaper for further details:

The Tribune, Chandigarh ed. Vol. 133 No. 170, Haryana edition, dated july 21, 2013, p. 8.


Or

Log in : www.tribuneindia.com



And share your comments on the issue please.
 
Maybe this thing has made Jats more weaker in Utter Pradesh. We must not forget, Jats are agriculturists and Utter Pradesh has one of the largest farm area. Farm landholdings in Jat agricultural areas is decreasing very rapidly. To maintain the agricultural land area, Jats should migrate to outer regions capable of good agriculture, this migration must always be in form of groups and must be backed by structural organizations like Khaps, Village units etc. Jats from all the areas like Punjab, Rajasthan, Haryana, Western Utter Pradesh must join hands to expand agricultural area.
Times are changing, due to land pressure and population pressure India will soon need lot of food. Right now due to bad logistics and supply chain grains/food get wasted but as soon as this logistics of food supply gets better, good times for farmers will start. In next few years India will not be able to afford bad logistics for food/grain supply.
Another point is the way we do agriculture will also change due to climatic conditions and economics of Agriculture. Right now India farmers are following a traditional scientific way of crude farming. This will not sustain much longer, newer scientific ways of farming will come into action as population pressure and commercialization of human life happens.

दादी के गोत्र में शादी से उत्तर प्रदेश के जाट कैसे कमजोर हो गए? समझ से परे वाली बात है | खेती की जमीन की कमी और अवैज्ञानिक तरीके से की जाने वाली खेती तो पूरे भारत के किसानो की समस्या है
 
Agreed!

Btw, why not Jat khaps come with proposal to marry Jats of different region, I mean we should start promoting marriages inter-state. Rajasthani Jats have lot of unique gotras so is with UP Jats. I believe it's better idea than relaxing gotra of Dadi.

your thoughts ..


भाई जीत बात तो तेरी ठीक से, आर कुछ रिश्तेदारी होवे भी से सुन्पत आला की यूपी में। न्यू ऐ बागड़ आला की राजस्तान में भी रिश्तेदारी होवे है। पर मोटी-मोटी सी बात या है अक लोग थोड़े हिचके सै न्यू रिश्ते बनान में। मिजाण सा घाट बैठे सै भाई।
 
Bhai baat to teri jamma theek hai .. har koi aas paas hi riste dekha karae .. aade log Rajasthan main hi door door na kara karte byah Haryana aur UP to ghanni door ki baat hai.

Baaki muje lagta hai ye ek 'Compromise' hai jise aisa badhawa aur 'welcome' na karna chahiye, Nahi to fer ke fayda kaal mama ke gotra ke liye bhi aage compromise kar le ye Khaap aale.


भाई जीत बात तो तेरी ठीक से, आर कुछ रिश्तेदारी होवे भी से सुन्पत आला की यूपी में। न्यू ऐ बागड़ आला की राजस्तान में भी रिश्तेदारी होवे है। पर मोटी-मोटी सी बात या है अक लोग थोड़े हिचके सै न्यू रिश्ते बनान में। मिजाण सा घाट बैठे सै भाई।
 
In my opinion, Sikh jats don't like give their daughters to hindu jats.But reverse is seen. May be, Swaich can throw some light, why is it so.

Sikh jats do give their daughters in Hindu jats. I can confirm that , if the gotra are not same.

I am actually unaware of any instance of a marriage between Sikh and Hindu jat families. So it is new information for me.

With respect to why its doesn't happen often, or why do Sikh jats do not like to give their daughters in marriage to Hindu jats, I would say maybe its linguistic and religious barriers.

Generally speaking, this might be a little controversial to say, but Punjabi Jats do consider Hindi speaking Jats backward - economically and socially. I think this is because there is very little interaction between the two groups apart from those living on state borders.
 
I am actually unaware of any instance of a marriage between Sikh and Hindu jat families. So it is new information for me.

With respect to why its doesn't happen often, or why do Sikh jats do not like to give their daughters in marriage to Hindu jats, I would say maybe its linguistic and religious barriers.

Generally speaking, this might be a little controversial to say, but Punjabi Jats do consider Hindi speaking Jats backward - economically and socially. I think this is because there is very little interaction between the two groups apart from those living on state borders.

There seems to be some truth in what u say.
I would not put it as "Hindu Jats", Jats are not based on religious fundamentalism. Those who are into religious fundamentalism do not know, who "Jats" really are. In recent decades after independence the need of "Jat Clanship deteriorated" as they did not have to fight any wars from Invading armies. Therefore the coming generations which were born in villages and far off areas were detached from "root knowledge of Jat struggle" or the "struggle of their ancesstors", " root of Jat ancesstors" so on. U can still see this absence of knowledge even in educated families who are residing in cities. So one can imagine, what kind of knowledge exists in village area. This lack of knowledge leads to infighting and lack of trust with in community and in time breeds false pride. This kind of attitutde is then exploited by people who either of bad character or out of community.

Jats are based on their characteristics of work, clan, duty, honor, weight of word etc.
 
There seems to be some truth in what u say.
I would not put it as "Hindu Jats", Jats are not based on religious fundamentalism. Those who are into religious fundamentalism do not know, who "Jats" really are. In recent decades after independence the need of "Jat Clanship deteriorated" as they did not have to fight any wars from Invading armies. Therefore the coming generations which were born in villages and far off areas were detached from "root knowledge of Jat struggle" or the "struggle of their ancesstors", " root of Jat ancesstors" so on. U can still see this absence of knowledge even in educated families who are residing in cities. So one can imagine, what kind of knowledge exists in village area. This lack of knowledge leads to infighting and lack of trust with in community and in time breeds false pride. This kind of attitutde is then exploited by people who either of bad character or out of community.

Jats are based on their characteristics of work, clan, duty, honor, weight of word etc.

Just use a simple question in a village and ask them "what do you know about your past? You send your children for the defense of the nation, Why?" They might have a economic answer to it but they do not have any historic answer to it, although the same farmer who is sending his children to Army might have built a small place at the corner of his farming area to remember his ancestors (we all have seen those small white houses of few bricks that the farmer makes at the corner of the field to remember his ancestors) but he does not know, what his ancestors stood for, how they led their lives and where the came from.
 
I am actually unaware of any instance of a marriage between Sikh and Hindu jat families. So it is new information for me.

With respect to why its doesn't happen often, or why do Sikh jats do not like to give their daughters in marriage to Hindu jats, I would say maybe its linguistic and religious barriers.

Generally speaking, this might be a little controversial to say, but Punjabi Jats do consider Hindi speaking Jats backward - economically and socially. I think this is because there is very little interaction between the two groups apart from those living on state borders.
The examples I know are from Haryana. The girls family is Haryanvi Sikh jat. Religion was not an issue In this marriage. The main reason why there is not much relationship between Haryana and punjab is the language and distance.
 
The examples I know are from Haryana. The girls family is Haryanvi Sikh jat. Religion was not an issue In this marriage. The main reason why there is not much relationship between Haryana and punjab is the language and distance.

Distances between Jats of Punjab and Haryana due to language must be overcome through common history and, family names,clan and family relationships. One of the major drawbacks that "Jats as a community" are facing today is "False Pride", "common understanding", "lack of vision", etc. There are two major kind of people in "Jat community". One who are still trapped in small scale farming(as big farmers are becoming less and less) and those who are highly educated. Due to hardships of life both these groups are struggling at the own level and have to face different kinds of social and economic pressures. Lot of these families give in due to different social and economic pressures as they do not get community support which in the old times was provided through clan support, village level support or other social units based on community.

Jats of Punjab region faced such situations long time back and therefore migration from Punjab in search of better life became a way of life and they had to face different kind of social and economic evils due to this migration and displacement. Now the same situation is being faced by Jats of other regions. Migration and displacement of close knit farming communities leads to lot of social changes which are not good in long run. Due to the change in land use/acquisition policies of government at state and central level, displacement of villagers/farming people is becoming a common everyday phenomenon. There are no social or local institutions to help the displaced farmers.
If such Farmers/people move to a new area they become easy victim to different social elements of the society. A simple case can be seen in terms of Jat girls marrying people of other communities, who do not share any roots with "Jat history" in terms of life or "Jat Struggle of the past", "Jat Clan names", etc.
 
Last edited:
It would be good if you could suggest/identify the outer areas where the migration of Jats in the form of groups could take place ? Do you suggest inside India or outside the country migration. Is it possible in the present conditions prevailing all over the country and the world that mass migration could take place? Ponder over this aspect and share your views accordingly.

Thanks



There are different kinds of Jats. When i say, different kind, i mean there are Jats who are at different level of their educational background. Right now, the major displacement of Jats is from village level. Such Jats usually have more then two kids, who are semi educated or totally non educated seeking unskilled work. If such Jats loose their land they become most vulnerable to exploitation leading to pressure and wrong habits and wrong company. In villages such people usually lived in small close knit communities, so the exploitation was not easy. So secure movement and settlement of such population is essential. Good agricultural land for such population will help to maintain and sustain "Jat population".
Well "Barailley" in Utter Pradesh is a nice place to start and then there is lot of space towards north east and east.
 
There are different kinds of Jats. When i say, different kind, i mean there are Jats who are at different level of their educational background. Right now, the major displacement of Jats is from village level. Such Jats usually have more then two kids, who are semi educated or totally non educated seeking unskilled work. If such Jats loose their land they become most vulnerable to exploitation leading to pressure and wrong habits and wrong company. In villages such people usually lived in small close knit communities, so the exploitation was not easy. So secure movement and settlement of such population is essential. Good agricultural land for such population will help to maintain and sustain "Jat population".
Well "Barailley" in Utter Pradesh is a nice place to start and then there is lot of space towards north east and east.

Again a single family migration is not the best option, rather combined migration of several families is the best thing.
 
Khaps are the best organization for the source of change in the society at the local levels. These changes must be for the betterment of community, living conditions, etc. Conserving Jat blood and gene pool must be one of the main goals of the community.
 
Back
Top