Railway Budget and General Budget 2014-15

Leaving aside political likes and dislikes as well as regional prejudices, Overall both Railway Budget and General Budget have features to attain long ranging targets aimed at development and progress of the country in the years ahead by laying down strong economic and fiscal policy.
 
Friend,

The times are different hence the costs of the two cannot be compared properly.

To preserve heritage and culture large sums are spent over the globe by the Governments. Sardar Patel , the Deputy Prime Minister of india and a Freedom fighter of note, made merger of 562 native states into India possible which seemed impossible at that point of history. If this statute of Unity reminds the generations to come forges sense of belongingness to the basic values of Indian Freedom Movement and leads to greater sense of unity and harmony among the people and also develops as a Tourism destination the costs seems not too high !

Thanks and best wishes,

I was saying govt. gave 200 crore. but project cost is 2000 crore. But some local people against it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statue_of_Unity
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Kadian bhai, probably rest of the amount will be arranged by Gujrat govt. This is a long term project and will help India in future. Kuch cheeze immediately utni achi nhi lagti hain, jitni wo hoti hain, unke long term benefits hote hain. In future, it might be a godd tourism place which gives substantial return in India's growth. Now, regarding 100 crores for women safety, probably, you remember that UPA govt. made Nirbhaya fund of 1000 crores but not a single rupee was spent. Fund banane se kuch ni hota, use dhang se implement karna important factor hai. Present govt. kitna implement kar paegi, ye time bataega.

Regarding inflation, tax has been reduced on all the items of basic necessity like edible oil, packaged food (it contains packaged flour also), medicines (most important), electronics items (jisse sale badh sake and economy ko growth mile). This is the first time that 500 crore fund has been sanctioned for inflation (atleast kuchh dhyan to dia, otherwise aap kisi congressi bhai se puchho ki last year jab onion price was Rs. 100/kg in Delhi tab govt neend se jaagi thi). This year, onion price is still between 20-25 /kg, jo 2, 3 months pehle bhi tha (hardly, a price rise of 5 to 10% up, I know because kai baar office se ghar jate hue market se sabzi le jata hoon). Inflation ki problem aisa ni hai ki abhi Modi govt aate hi bani hai, ye to bahut purani problem hai or itni jaldi kabu me ni aegi.

Salaried logo ko thodi rahat jarur mili hai, jinhone home loan le rakha hai unhe bhi kafi fayda dia hai. Isse bhi market me kuchh liquidity aegi and economy speed pakadegi. Baki to future me pata chalega ki 'uunt kis karwat baithta hai'. Baki bhai PPP and FDI to honi hi chahiye, sarkari log kaam na karte chahe kitna hi jor laga lo.

Agar bahut acha budget ni hai to nirash bhi nhi kia hai. Last 10 years me congress ne isse bhi kharab budget diye hain. First time tax slab me 1.5 lakh (50 k in tax, 50k in 80C, 50K in home loan interest) ki rebate di gai hai, otherwise kabhi bhi 20k se jyada ni milta tha wo bhi kai saalo me ek baar.

Baki bhai har kisi ko to khush kar ni sakte.
 
Kadian bhai, probably rest of the amount will be arranged by Gujrat govt. This is a long term project and will help India in future. Kuch cheeze immediately utni achi nhi lagti hain, jitni wo hoti hain, unke long term benefits hote hain. In future, it might be a godd tourism place which gives substantial return in India's growth. Now, regarding 100 crores for women safety, probably, you remember that UPA govt. made Nirbhaya fund of 1000 crores but not a single rupee was spent. Fund banane se kuch ni hota, use dhang se implement karna important factor hai. Present govt. kitna implement kar paegi, ye time bataega.

Regarding inflation, tax has been reduced on all the items of basic necessity like edible oil, packaged food (it contains packaged flour also), medicines (most important), electronics items (jisse sale badh sake and economy ko growth mile). This is the first time that 500 crore fund has been sanctioned for inflation (atleast kuchh dhyan to dia, otherwise aap kisi congressi bhai se puchho ki last year jab onion price was Rs. 100/kg in Delhi tab govt neend se jaagi thi). This year, onion price is still between 20-25 /kg, jo 2, 3 months pehle bhi tha (hardly, a price rise of 5 to 10% up, I know because kai baar office se ghar jate hue market se sabzi le jata hoon). Inflation ki problem aisa ni hai ki abhi Modi govt aate hi bani hai, ye to bahut purani problem hai or itni jaldi kabu me ni aegi.

Salaried logo ko thodi rahat jarur mili hai, jinhone home loan le rakha hai unhe bhi kafi fayda dia hai. Isse bhi market me kuchh liquidity aegi and economy speed pakadegi. Baki to future me pata chalega ki 'uunt kis karwat baithta hai'. Baki bhai PPP and FDI to honi hi chahiye, sarkari log kaam na karte chahe kitna hi jor laga lo.

Agar bahut acha budget ni hai to nirash bhi nhi kia hai. Last 10 years me congress ne isse bhi kharab budget diye hain. First time tax slab me 1.5 lakh (50 k in tax, 50k in 80C, 50K in home loan interest) ki rebate di gai hai, otherwise kabhi bhi 20k se jyada ni milta tha wo bhi kai saalo me ek baar.

Baki bhai har kisi ko to khush kar ni sakte.

And 4 lakh crore went to corporate and Industry because they didn't spend the whole money. Kaam kia nahi.


Jately ji ki statement.

m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/raise-it-slab-from-rs-2-lakh-to-rs-5-lakh-demands-arun-jaitley/articleshow/34013531.cms?intenttarget=no
 
All is okay except that 200 Crore for statue for unity? and half of that for women safety?


जिन को सरदार पटेल की मुर्ति पर 200 करोड़ खर्च करना पैसे की बर्बादी लगता है उन महानुभावों को संभवतः पता नहीं कि केवल 46 मीटर की "statue of Liberty" से आज अमेरिका प्रति वर्ष 700 करोड़ कमाता है!


तनिक सोचिये कि जब केवल 46 मीटर की एक मूर्ति अमेरिका को 700 करोड़ दिलवाती है तो 180 मीटर की सरदार पटेल की मूर्ति से भारत सरकार को कितनी कमाई होगी?
 
मुमताज़ बानो ऊर्फ ममता बनर्जी यदि रेल मंत्री होती तो एक बुलेट ट्रेन हावड़ा से बांग्लादेश को चलवाती, इधर से खाली, उधर से भरी आती।
 
I too agree that 200 Cr should NOT be spent on a statue. All material and labor work will bring nothing to society. Even the statue will laugh on the lookers "how fool you are" !!

If a project to commemorate the contribution of the Great Freedom fighter and all time great home Minister is built, no amount of money is big. Moreover, the place will be developed as a heritage tourism destination which will make it possible to recover all the investment incurred in a short span of time. Hence the Statue of Unity Project dedicated to Sardar Patel must be completed without loosing much time.
 
Agreed in toto

If a project to commemorate the contribution of the Great Freedom fighter and all time great home Minister is built, no amount of money is big. Moreover, the place will be developed as a heritage tourism destination which will make it possible to recover all the investment incurred in a short span of time. Hence the Statue of Unity Project dedicated to Sardar Patel must be completed without loosing much time.
 
Shiv bhai, as a citizen your concern at spending huge amounts on statues is understandable.

However, what also needs to be understood is the fact that it not only honours the true son of India who was not given his due share of the glory either during his lifetime or afterwards, but also it would be a huge revenue generator for the nation. It is time that India moves beyond the fixation with Nehru and Gandhi schemes, yojnas and pariyojnas.

Of course, construction of the above mentioned statue/memorial would entail huge costs, the same would be recovered in terms of tourist footfalls in some years after it being ready. One thing is for sure - it would not be an elephant (or elephants) patronised by Maya memsahib.

I too agree that 200 Cr should NOT be spent on a statue. All material and labor work will bring nothing to society. Even the statue will laugh on the lookers "how fool you are" !!
 
Last edited:
Apart from just a statue, the entire concept envisages a huge project which includes a research institute focusing on theme close to Sardar Patel Ji vision, museum, memorial center to name a few. Looking at this entire project this amount is not much and will surely return many times once it completes.

Below is link for a short movie on this project.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgcGf0YGvSQ
 
Rs 200 crore on Loh Purush statue and the pseudo liberals are making noise. Rs 200 crore comes to roughly Rs 1.60 per Indian. Can't shameful Indians spend even this amount per head for the memory of a man who brought warring Indian states together and saved us of the huge money we would have been spending fighting each other? Think of similar projects in other countries and even in India in past. How about Taj Mahal, Qutub Minar, Eifel Tower, Statue of Liberty, Bamyan Buddha and 100s of others. Today they are the symbols of pride for the people of the area. Hypocrites would spend millions on a wedding and lacs on a birthday, but won't spare Rs 1.60 for the memory of a man who gave India as we see it today. Shame on such people.

RK^2
 
I was saying govt. gave 200 crore. but project cost is 2000 crore. But some local people against it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statue_of_Unity

Could not make out who these so called "Some People" are. I wonder if these "Some People" raised even one finger when "Rajiv Gandhi Memorial, Sriperumbudur" was constructed ? Did India not have other priorities that time ? I am not able to get the exact cost incurred on Rajiv Gandhi Memorial. However, going through the pictures posted by a blogger (http://rahul-aggarwal.blogspot.com/2012/08/a-visit-to-rajiv-gandhi-memorial.html) I can easily put it to 100s of crores. Then you have Rajghat lined up with Nehru family memorials, all at exchequers cost. Why no words from pseudo liberals ? In my view Modi government is doing right and Rs 200.00 is peanuts for a country like India.

RK^2
 
जिन को सरदार पटेल की मुर्ति पर 200 करोड़ खर्च करना पैसे की बर्बादी लगता है उन महानुभावों को संभवतः पता नहीं कि केवल 46 मीटर की "statue of Liberty" से आज अमेरिका प्रति वर्ष 700 करोड़ कमाता है!


तनिक सोचिये कि जब केवल 46 मीटर की एक मूर्ति अमेरिका को 700 करोड़ दिलवाती है तो 180 मीटर की सरदार पटेल की मूर्ति से भारत सरकार को कितनी कमाई होगी?

Sir ji by the way Liberty statue length 93m, Eiffel Tower 324m, and most famous cristo redentor just 40m but it's on hill.




 
rs 200 crore on loh purush statue and the pseudo liberals are making noise. Rs 200 crore comes to roughly rs 1.60 per indian. Can't shameful indians spend even this amount per head for the memory of a man who brought warring indian states together and saved us of the huge money we would have been spending fighting each other? Think of similar projects in other countries and even in india in past. How about taj mahal, qutub minar, eifel tower, statue of liberty, bamyan buddha and 100s of others. Today they are the symbols of pride for the people of the area. Hypocrites would spend millions on a wedding and lacs on a birthday, but won't spare rs 1.60 for the memory of a man who gave india as we see it today. Shame on such people.

Rk^2

चलो स्टेचू तो बणा के खड़या करल्यो बेशक, लेकिन 10 फुट की ऊँचाई भोत थी i दो ढाई लाख रूपये मैं काम बण जाता i कलखंडे साहब पैसे का ब्योंत भी देखणा चाहिये न एफ़िल टावर और स्टेचू ऑफ़ लिबर्टी गाडण तैं पहल्याँ i न्यू मूर्तियाँ पर निरया माल गाडण लाग जाओगे तो काम क्यूकर चालैगा i न्यू तो भतेरे भले माणस देश की सेवा मै न्योछावर हो रखे सैं i म्हारे गाम का सरूपा नाइ, बूजा भगत, भगत फूल सिंह, बाजे नाइ, भैंसवालिया नफे सिंह, खरखोदे आला फत्ते, गांधी महात्मा, सरदार भगत सिंह, अटल बिहारी वाजपेयी, चौधरी चरण सिंह, चौधरी छोटू राम, चौधरी देवी लाल इन सबके भी इतने ऊंचे स्टेचू बणाण लॉगगे तो फेर वर्ल्ड बैंक तैं कर्ज़ा ठाणा पड़ैगा i (वैसे काम मन्नै भी देशभक्ति के भोत कर राखे सैं अर मैं भी सोच रह्या सूं कि मरण तैं पहल्याँ एक 5 फुट का स्टेचू आपणे गाम के चौक मै खड़या करवा द्यूं, घणा ऊंचा होगा तै फेर हर साल बरसी पै माल्यार्पण मैं दिक्कत आवैगी)
 
Could not make out who these so called "Some People" are. I wonder if these "Some People" raised even one finger when "Rajiv Gandhi Memorial, Sriperumbudur" was constructed ? Did India not have other priorities that time ? I am not able to get the exact cost incurred on Rajiv Gandhi Memorial. However, going through the pictures posted by a blogger (http://rahul-aggarwal.blogspot.com/2012/08/a-visit-to-rajiv-gandhi-memorial.html) I can easily put it to 100s of crores. Then you have Rajghat lined up with Nehru family memorials, all at exchequers cost. Why no words from pseudo liberals ? In my view Modi government is doing right and Rs 200.00 is peanuts for a country like India.

RK^2


Wasie India main ager Kiske ek vises admi ke Facebook account, Twitter account, online reputation ki press release band ho jaye to saal main us pasie te 2-3 statue ban jaye.


Jai Hind
 
Everyone know that respect always in heart not in statue. But it's good step. And I am sure it will be famous in whole world. People will come to see it from every part of world.

Excellent step for Gujarat Govt.

But to be honest I didn't find too much for poor people in This Budget. Budget was for Middle, Upper Middle.

Labor don't pay tax, they don't pay installment for house. People who earn more than 10 lakh. could save more.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
BJP Got huge supprot Of Haryana People.

Gujraat got 60000 crore bullet, 200 crore statue, textile mill, Metro in Ahmedabad.Haryana ko kya kya mila news main kuch likkha hi nhi hua.

Pure internet ki news pad di. per Haryana ka name eb tai nhi mila. Someone told me that agriculture university open hogi. Is this true?
 
Rs 200 crore on Loh Purush statue and the pseudo liberals are making noise. Rs 200 crore comes to roughly Rs 1.60 per Indian. Can't shameful Indians spend even this amount per head for the memory of a man who brought warring Indian states together and saved us of the huge money we would have been spending fighting each other? Think of similar projects in other countries and even in India in past. How about Taj Mahal, Qutub Minar, Eifel Tower, Statue of Liberty, Bamyan Buddha and 100s of others. Today they are the symbols of pride for the people of the area. Hypocrites would spend millions on a wedding and lacs on a birthday, but won't spare Rs 1.60 for the memory of a man who gave India as we see it today. Shame on such people.

RK^2

Well reasoned reply.

Integration of 562 native states and this hue and cry on installation of just one statue of Unity in his name !

Where our sense of patriotism has gone !!

Let this belated action be completed before it is too late and the person may be congratulated for his innovative idea initiating its foundation !!!
 
Back
Top