alliance government

Status
Not open for further replies.

mukeshkumar007

Active member
India is a world biggest democarcy. The democratic system of india is very good and it still remain inspirable to other country. India's democratic system is not two parties systems like birten and america. Many parties participated in General Election and make government for five year.
before some year ago Congress was only national party and all polotical activity happend arround it. and one party able to get majority to made government. but after rajiv gandhi senario was completly changed. no one party in the situation to make government independently. many parties arised at local level. they support either congress or bjp and contibute to make a government.
These type of local parties have not a national issue in election. They Fight election on local issue such as pani, nali, sadak, bijali, relegion, cast etc. They spread tide of emotion among the public. and try to do any thing for getting vote either it is welfare for nation or not.
They give ticket to a wrong and bahubali person.
so i think this kind of condition is not good for our country. These kind of parties when they came in government then they try to give importance of his own region. They have not a strong eternal policy.
so i think a government that made from many parties is not able to move government till five year. so a alliance government is not good for future of our nation.
we should elect either congress and bjp ( I mean national parties.)

it's my view if u have any view then welcome.
 
Dear Mukesh,

You have raised a very interesting topic for discussion. I am only wondering as to how come no one has responded to it as yet.

Let me take a lead in responding to this question.

Firstly, the current political system. The structure of our Union is more Central than Federal. Thus the states have very little powers. This is the reason, moment a Govt, changes in Center they try to dislodge the state govts where opposition parties are ruling. When the constitution was written certain ethos of fair practice were expected from the National Leaders. Over a period of time that has eroded. Thus we do need a change to counter this trend. May be a Presidential form of Govt would be more stable and meaningful for our country.

I personally feel that while we don't need whole bunch of parties, the two party system may not be the best one. A third front will always be good. This will keep the ruling party on alert as they have to deal with two equal opponents rather than only one. In two party system, some time, negative vote for one party may bring another party into power.

Similarly at state level also we need to have only a few parties. There should be some educational guide lines as well as Criminal History check for the candidates who could contest the election.

I was in India in Feb this year. What I learnt there was revealing and eye opener. Some parties were charging as much as one Crore Rupees from the Candidates who wanted their party Tickets. This means if a Candidate want to contest election on their party ticket he has to spend one crore to get the ticket, another one or two crore to contest the election. And when he wins the election, then he has to get that money back from the public money. Not only that, he would also aim of getting the same for next election, and that is where our developement money is going.

There is lot that can be written on this subject. The question is what we need to do to solve this problem. I agree with you that a coilation govt may not be in best interest of our country. We have seen couple of them in past and experience has not been good.






mukesh kumar (Sep 27, 2004 02:32 a.m.):
India is a world biggest democarcy. The democratic system of india is very good and it still remain inspirable to other country. India's democratic system is not two parties systems like birten and america. Many parties participated in General Election and make government for five year.
before some year ago Congress was only national party and all polotical activity happend arround it. and one party able to get majority to made government. but after rajiv gandhi senario was completly changed. no one party in the situation to make government independently. many parties arised at local level. they support either congress or bjp and contibute to make a government.
These type of local parties have not a national issue in election. They Fight election on local issue such as pani, nali, sadak, bijali, relegion, cast etc. They spread tide of emotion among the public. and try to do any thing for getting vote either it is welfare for nation or not.
They give ticket to a wrong and bahubali person.
so i think this kind of condition is not good for our country. These kind of parties when they came in government then they try to give importance of his own region. They have not a strong eternal policy.
so i think a government that made from many parties is not able to move government till five year. so a alliance government is not good for future of our nation.
we should elect either congress and bjp ( I mean national parties.)

it's my view if u have any view then welcome.
 
Dear All,

The coalition govenments are here to stay for a long long time. It can't be helped in a sub continental sized country like ours. Another thing that need to be understood is that we are a very young democracy as compared to some western nations (giving it the tag of largest is no indication of being a mature democracy). Even coconut sized countriues, having one language, one religion and one ethos have 3-4 major political parties fighting for political space and acceptance. Bhai mere gaam main bhi takriban teen party hain. Hum to bhai abhi tak gulami ko he nahin bhool payen hain, democracy kaise jad pakdegi. Don't expect Democracy to be a solution to all our problems. As per differentiations of various types of governance, democracy is a bad form of government.

Now the question of democracy taking roots in our country. We must have smaller states, more federated structure, give freedom to states to enact laws to suit their demographical requirements, less central control etc etc. Easier said than done.

We will have to live and survive with the politicians we have because good people, like you and me shall I say, don't want to come into politics. In fact politics has already become family business. You will find three generations of a political family abused for doing nothing by three corresponding generations of voters. And when the time comes to vote they will vote for the same political family because we have 'gutbazzi' in villages. 'Susra vo usne vote dega to main iss a ne dyunga'. Sad but true.

You can't stop the growth of regional parties. It is good in a way. We have seen that even when the centre was powerful, there was chaos. Emergency years. Regional parties too need competition from the mainstream ones lest they get complacent. See what happened in Andhra Pradesh. I am sure next time around when Mr Chandrababu Naidu comes to power, he would be seen to be discussing more grass root issues like water, electricity, farmers, public distribution system and not be seen with a laptop danglng and planning F1 racing tracks. He would need to walk on his feet to know the problems rather than be connected 'Online' with all the districts and Talukas and having video conferences. We now see Maharashtra elections hotting up. Pramod Mahajan now talks about farmers, electricity. Vo 'Feel Good' and 'India Shining' vagera sab bhool gya.

I am sure members will have good views on this topic.

Regards,

JS Malik
 
Dear All,

Col Malik has raised some very important issues. I fully agree with him that we are a young democracy, but I don't agree that it is the worst form of government.

The problem with democracy is that it brings freedom to people and unless they know how to use it properly it is very difficult to reap the full advantage of this system. Again it is easier said than done. The freedom is actually misused by people and that is the curse democracy brings with it. Then what is the solution?

One suggestion could be "Directed Democracy". May be for couple of decades, we need to practice directed democracy. What could be the form of it again is a matter of separate discussion.

I personally, feel that we need to have strong political reforms. Every one that I have talked to has critisized our politicians. If that be the case we really need political reforms. What reforms should we have and how the transition has to be brought about is again a debatable issue. May be we on this site can get some good practical ideas.
 
thankyou col. uncleji. i am also agree with u that democracy is not wrost form a government. every body can realize free and happy in democracy. a dictatorship may be good for a nation but not for countryman because such kind of government does not care about public's right.
so i think democracy is a right and best for of government.
In india democracy is not running on the right path. our politician misuse it. if they will be true and honest for it then good result automatically will come in front of us.
by the way i am thankful to all of u.
 
Dear All,

I did not say Democracy is a 'worst' form of government. I said BAD form of government.

And I am not saying this. I was merely quoting our friend from Greece, ARISTOTAL. He maintained that Democracy was a bad form of government.

Regards,
 
malik uncle u may be right but i think you have a negative think on this side. there is a two part of a coin, one is a positive and second is negative. so go for a conclusion every part shoud be consider.
 
Is it really true. It seems too much to me. These guys must be keeping that sort of lequid money in banks, which is easily tractable. I would be very grateful to you if you can let us know, how exactly it works?

I mean, who take the money, and who actually decide the tickets. What happens to this money (of the order of mangnitude of 100 crores) later on? why is election commison and media keep shut about it.

I am aware that each term a MP is alloted 1~2 crore rupees to spend in his/her constituency, which techanically is spend through district administration. In other words both MP and DM eats it together. If you go to lock sabha website, you can actually find out the money alloted and spend so far ..for each MP.

It is interesting to see, how easily public seems to accept this sort of corruption as very normal things.

Col Virendra S Tavathia(Retd) (Sep 28, 2004 04:36 p.m.):
I was in India in Feb this year. What I learnt there was revealing and eye opener. Some parties were charging as much as one Crore Rupees from the Candidates who wanted their party Tickets.
 
Dear Mukesh,

If you read my posts a bit more carefully you would realise that I am indeed very positive about things. Seeing things more clearly, without prejudice and realistically is not being negative.

If you read articles on Greek history and how governments evolved in the modren states you would know what I am trying to say. May be I have not been able to explain my view points more clearly. After all I am using a foreign language!!!

Dear Anuj,

The business of politics runs like any other business. I am neither aware of its 'How' or 'Why' but may be I can throw some light on the question you have raised. There is something called 'Cost Benefit Analysis'. The politicians calculate as to which party is likely to benefit in the long term and join it. They then work very hard, use all means possible to get into contention for that dream 'Ticket'. And it is a known fact that one has to pay as much as a crore of rupees to get a party ticket from a major political party for the Lok Sabha elections. What is a crore of rupees in any case for these people. The only people who presumably don't pay are the ones who belong to known political families, the Gandhi's, Scindhia's. Pilot's, Chautala's, Badal's etc etc.

Let me give you an example here. I will not name the individual but what I am telling you could be verified by others who are from Sonepat and know a bit about politics. In the 80s (I forget the exact year) assembly elections, Congerss party was approached by one individual (a refugee who used to trade in animals in the 50s, then became a smuggler of cattle, later got into liquor business and then ran a very famous cabret joint in Delhi. He has a massive farm house too). This person offered to fund the complete election campaign for all assembly constituencies for the congress party in Haryana, provided he was made the chief minister after the elections. This is the kind of investment people are ready to make to become an MLA, MP or a minister. Mayawati supposedly took about a crore of rupees from each candidate who got her party ticket form UP. Why do you think she is so important? Money power my friend.

Now please don't ask me to prove these things. I have no proof. If there was proof for such things, CBI would have put all such politicians in jail by now!!!

Regards,

JS Malik
 
Every form of government has some problem. In democracy the vote of an idiot matters as much of most intelligent man. Unfortunately in most democracies the so called intelligent men rarely go for voting and keep on cursing the system sitting in their TV rooms. Look at the voting percentage in most democracies..hardly 40-50% of the people vote.

Best part of democracy is that persons like Man Mohan Singh can also become prime minister and Sonia Gandhi can become the leader in a country where she was not even born. Look in USA, how many non USA born people have risen to top posts. This can never happen in other forms of government. Therefore, with all its short comings, I still feel that democracy is the best form for government. People at least can raise their voice and if required, can send back bad leaders home.

As a whole democracy is way better than any other form of government.

Regards
rajendra
 
Dear malik unclji

i read ur article with full attention and i understood that what u want to say. but unclji problem is not a special thing for india. every country has many problem and she countinuo fight with them. But u know ek marwari maie ek concept hai that is " jito jyada hosi bati hi jyada afat hai. " so same problem with india. the problem is that here public is not so much discipline and to controll such kind of public is a tedious task.
so problem still remain in india. but the main point is that how far we can remove or improve these problem. For this we must need strong politics determenation or desire as well as positive think towards these problem.

by the way i am agree with ur comments.
 
Dear Mukesh,

We Indians tend to find alibis and excuses for everything. If the people in India are not disciplined, who will make them disciplined ? If we are not disciplined, whom can we blame ? No one but ourselves. The answer to all the above questions lie here. If we cannot make our people discplined in 57 years, cannot educate them, cannot feed them, cannot provide them with shelter, employment and even drinking water, it is proof enough that the democratic form of government will not do any good to Indian polity. We Indians have always worked when flogged. We need a strong leader, a strictarian, like Ch. Bansilal. Indian can reach at the desired levels within ten years, if ruled with a firm hand by honest people. But the pity is that honesty has become a rare commodity in our country and dishonests can't rule with a firm hand. Moreover, the more the alliance partners, more resources must be looted to appease them all.
 
Dear Sherawtji
To criticize the of Government is not a final solution. It is also over responsible to do help and support to government in making good policy for public as well as nation. If public is not responsible and disciplin then how it is possible that government will able to change the complete environment.
 
Dear All,

It has been a nice discussion on the topic so far, but we have not come out with any suggestion or a possible solution.

One solution could be to for the Predential Form of Govt. That would help us to elect a leader directly who will also have assurity of his job for the full term unless he does some thing radical that calls for his/her impeachment/ Recall.

This will give our elected leader more credibility in the world and more stability for the government. This will also help us getting foreign investment in the country.

We may have to go for more powers to states, with center controlling, Defense, Foreign Policy, Natural Resources (if possible).

The home department could be given special powers to monitor the state's home departments to ensure homeland security.

We also lay down standards for our law enforcement agencies and compensate them enough for their services so that they live comfortably and are worry free to implement the govt policies.

Judicial reforms could be another aspect, that may need attention.

There is a lot one can write and go on.

I would like to request the members to give their opinion, views and suggestions on this aspect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top