Anna Hazare is replicate of Mahatama Gandhi

dahiyavijay7

New member
Our media has popularized the Anna Hazare as new Hero, a Demi God and a crusader against corruption. No doubt the fast and other activities for strong Lokpal bill by the Anna team would have positive impact in the fight against corruption. But there is a work of caution. The similarity with Mahatama Gandhi. Mahatama Gandhi was a Congress leader. The Congress was established by a Retired Englishmen to contain and control the freedom struggle against Britishers. The usual way of Mahatama Gandhi was to initiate a satyagrah, keeping fast and Non-violent protest march. Most of these protest were not long lasting. Mr Mahatama Gandhi was given the title of “Sir” by the britishers. A lot of privilege and special concessions were granted to Mr Gandhi.
The ways of Mr. Anna is similar. Anna kept fast ostensibly against the ruling class. The people were angry against the politicians. Some section of the society were demanding bringing back the black money from swiss banks. Some section were demanding right to recall. Some section wanted the corrupt people be debarred from fighting elections. Some were demanding the hanging of afjal guru, Kasab etc. Mr. Anna contained all angst of the people and the media forecasted him as a God and solution of all the evils in the country. Then angst was then channelized for a Lokpal Bill. The Fast breaks. Anna Hazare, breaks his fast but drinking the juice offered by Muslim and Harijan Girls. This also reflects the minority appeasement policy of Gandhi, which resulted into partition and responsible for casteism and terrorism.
Not a single demand is met till date. Further, howmuch stronger the law is, if the person sitting as Lokpal is corrupt, nothing shall change. These ways were also followed by Mahatama Gandhi. The people like Bhagat Singh, who died for the country have no place in Indian history, but the people like Gandhi, who actually deceive the country became the Hero.
No lokpal can solve the problem of poverty, unemployment and lack of resources in the country, the root cause of corruption. Lokpal can not build roads. Lokpal can not generate Electricity. Lokpal can not contain terrorism. The Reservation policy of the country is also corrupt. The unnecessary bias against Ramdev and in favor of Anna is also corrupt. What lokpal shall do about it.
 
Our media has popularized the Anna Hazare as new Hero, a Demi God and a crusader against corruption. No doubt the fast and other activities for strong Lokpal bill by the Anna team would have positive impact in the


ये सब "भाड़े के टट्टू" लिखते हैं |
 
ये सब "भाड़े के टट्टू" लिखते हैं |[/QUOTE]

I think Mr Ravinderjeet, you are a devotee of Mahatama Gandhi and believe in his principles of non-violence.
Do you think Mr Hazare or his Lokpal Bill could ever bring down corruption? We do not need any law in the first place. We only need good leaders. There is no need to change any system. All the system, be it monarchy, Communism or capitalism are fine as long as good leader governs the system, otherwise all system fails. There were times, when even dictators like hitler have done so much for their country, that nobody else could even imagine. Many kings with absolute powers have done finest justice and done so much for the well being of the common people. Law and order situation was great during the reign of many ancient kings. There were kings, who relinquished their arms to uphold the religion of humanity. There is no dearth of rules in the country. In fact, we have plethora of complicated rules only to harass the common people. The Lokpal shall become JOKEPAL, if an insincere and corrupt person is installed there. How would Mr Ravinderjeet shall select Lokpal? People can not even replace the fraud and corrupt politician. The judiciary is independent, still as per the newspapers report Mr Shashi Bhushan was able to prove that most of the CJI have remained corrupt. CJI balakrishnan was promoted out of seniority. Everybody knows the sorry state of justice in the country. A 10[SUP]th[/SUP] grade policemen is enough to bring shivering to a poor person, the judge do not waste time in sending innocent to gallows arbitrarily. Police can make fake encounters of innocent, but can not kill the terrorists like kasab, afjal guru. Mr. Arvind Kejriwal was once protesting with many other people against corruption outside tehsildaar’s office. The police came and arrested the people and presented before the Majistrate. The Magistrate thundered on police official why they did not handcuffed the accused and remanded the protestors to custody without any sufficient reason. The police and Magistrate were not aware that they Mr arvind kejriwal were amid the protestors. As soon as they realized they freed them. It was the case of Mr Arvind Kejriwal, who is a famous person. If it was a case of common person, this magistrate and police had spoilt their life.
As regards, Anna Gandhi & Co, people are still tolerating the congress in the name of Gandhi. However, Sonner or Later, time shall SOON come when all the congressmen shall be thrashed in the streets by the common people.
We got independence, due to the people like Bhagat Singh and not due to the mediator like Gandhi, whose at times was not desirous to get full independence from the British rule, but only wanted better treatment and lower level autonomy under their rule.
 
Our media has popularized the Anna Hazare as new Hero, ....
...
Not a single demand is met till date. Further, howmuch stronger the law is, if the person sitting as Lokpal is corrupt, nothing shall change.
Yeah, the demands have not been met and that is why people are agitating, the very own people whom they had sent to the law making body as their representatives are not listening to them. I will be surprised if you meant that, "don't expect any demands to be met". Look at the world, "people power is the supreme power".

Hasn't the RTI changed things? Hasn't the reservation changed things? Which law has not changed things? Till recently, Jat's were demanding changes in the marriage act, why?

Are you so ignorant about the law and the governance system or are you trying to deceive people by casting a pessimistic image of the IAC movement?

These ways were also followed by Mahatama Gandhi. The people like Bhagat Singh, who died for the country have no place in Indian history, but the people like Gandhi, who actually deceive the country became the Hero.
Oh! So it was Gandhi who deceived people and since Anna is another Gandhi, he is the one who is deceiving the people and not you? Please go and stand in front of a mirror, you "yourself" would know who is deceiving and who is a hero. People are much more intelligent.

No lokpal can solve the problem of poverty, unemployment and lack of resources in the country, the root cause of corruption. Lokpal can not build roads. Lokpal can not generate Electricity. Lokpal can not contain terrorism. The Reservation policy of the country is also corrupt. The unnecessary bias against Ramdev and in favor of Anna is also corrupt. What lokpal shall do about it.

Yes, lokpal can solve all these problems. The root of these problems is corruption and the lokpal hits at this root. People are poor because funds and resources meant for poor are pocketed midway. People are unemployed, because the funds for growth, which could generate employment, are instead spend on dubious things. CWG scam is a live example.

Yes, lokpal can built roads. If today, 1000 rs are granted for constructing one foot of raod, only 300rs are actually put the real use. without corruption that same 1000 will construct 3 feets. Thats 2 feet of extra road because of lokpal. The same is the case of other things that you have mentioned. A strong lokpal bill, along with other much needed changes to the laws, together have the potential to turnaround the county from a developing nation to a developed nation.
 
Last edited:
Yeah,
"Hasn't the RTI changed things? Hasn't the reservation changed things? Which law has not changed things? Till recently, Jat's were demanding changes in the marriage act, why? "
The RTI has not changed anything for your kind information. I have been dealing with this act for the last 5 years. I have also filed so many applications under this act to various departments and also gone to State/Central Information Commissioner. I know, what kind of information is provided. In most of the cases, PIO provides only misleading information. I have plethora of examples where State Information Commissioner/Central Information Commissioners have refused information on flimsy and ridiculous grounds. Further, RTI Act covers the information recorded in the office record whereas the people is desirous to know what is taking place illegally. Most of our ministers have shown paltry wealth of few lakhs, while even a slumdweller is Crorepati in places like delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata etc given to higher land rates. Under the rule the ministers are correct. Nobody is fool enough to record their wrongdoing. Further, the Govt has issued directions that Creation of information which is not available in the record, Interpretation of rules is not part of RTI Act-05. If one Govt. record states that there are 100 flyovers in Delhi, it shall be treated as correct information under RTI Act-05, even if actually there are 10 flyovers in Delhi. Got it.
Therefore, essence is that efficacy of all the rules just depend on the attitude of the authority empowered to exercise any statute and not the statue itself.
If the good governance is there, there is no need of even RTI Act as it is the duty of public servants to provide all the guidance and assistance to the people.

"Are you so ignorant about the law and the governance system or are you trying to deceive people by casting a pessimistic image of the IAC movement?"
You seems to be more ignorant about the law and governance. Buddy I have first hand experience of the mindlessness and arbitrary behaviour of executive, parliament and judiciary.




"Yes, lokpal can built roads. If today, 1000 rs are granted for constructing one foot of raod, only 300rs are actually put the real use. without corruption that same 1000 will construct 3 feets. Thats 2 feet of extra road because of lokpal. The same is the case of other things that you have mentioned. A strong lokpal bill, along with other much needed changes to the laws, together have the potential to turnaround the county from a developing nation to a developed nation.
"
It is your hypothetical misconception. What is the tool available in the Lokpal bill to ascertain the actual cost of the material? 1000 Rs are granted for constructing One foot of road and actually 1000 Rs are put in the real use in the official record and Lokpal can not deny it? Who shall decide the actual cost? Mr Lokpal? If Lokpal is an insincere person, he shall only take it for granted.

If you go by the rules, Mr. Anna Hazare is also proved corrupt. In fact, by rigidly applying the rules anybody can be termed corrupt, it all depends on the person deciding on it.
It is only a mind wash of the people.
 
"
It is your hypothetical misconception. What is the tool available in the Lokpal bill to ascertain the actual cost of the material? 1000 Rs are granted for constructing One foot of road and actually 1000 Rs are put in the real use in the official record and Lokpal can not deny it? Who shall decide the actual cost? Mr Lokpal? If Lokpal is an insincere person, he shall only take it for granted.

If you go by the rules, Mr. Anna Hazare is also proved corrupt. In fact, by rigidly applying the rules anybody can be termed corrupt, it all depends on the person deciding on it.
It is only a mind wash of the people.

Today, on an average, only about 30% of the total money is spent on the final intended use and rest is lost in the chain of corruption. Rs 1000, was an example of the same. A strong Lokpal bill substantially reduce corruption and would bring this figure to about 80-90%.
 
What's the solution you are offering, Buddy? Criticism is the easiest part & we all do it :) However, if we can't offer a solution ourselves, let us atleast let the ones who are working on it carry on their way. If somebody has better ideas than Anna, why not join him & try to give your solution from inside.

Even gandhi in present day world would not have survived this government tactics. The present govt. just seems to have bought time to cut down on Anna's support. Now, their subordinates are working hard to cutdown on the support of Anti corruption movement. We (Indians) are not brave enough to follow Shaheed bhagat singh's methods. Our history speaks in volumes about it. So, the only way which suits us is the peaceful way.
 

While using RTI it is important to question very specifically. In my experience, I have found the RTI Act very helpful. But you are right, wrongdoers in the government try to dodge the questions especially if it harms them - so put forth questions very specifically.

Regards,

Urmila.
 
What's the solution you are offering, Buddy? Criticism is the easiest part & we all do it :) However, if we can't offer a solution ourselves, let us atleast let the ones who are working on it carry on their way.

Some solutions are not really solution, but creator of another kind of problems. The problem by associating with the Gandhi and Anna was that such movements channelize the anger among common people and then direct the anger to one unfit solution and hence subdue the anger of common people. for example Gandhiji initiated Non-cooperation Movement. The movement could have been successful, because Mahatama Gandhi associated the public sentiment with the movement. Then, Mahatama Gandhi withdrew the movement ostensibly in the name of Chauri-chaura incident.

People associate with these movements because they want end to their miseries, these leaders like Gandhi and Anna associate the public sentiment with their movement for success and later deceive them.

There is not one but many examples that just making rule is not going to change anything. The police and administration still have tremendous powers but they exercise these powers only to harass innocents. Unless we are able to change the regime and replace the wrong people with good leaders every rule is futile.
 
Respected Madam, If we read the RTI Act OR any other act, all are very powerful. The problem is that the Public Information Officer, Ist Appellate Authority and Information Commissioners have discretionary powers to decide and many times they decide against the spirit of the Act and nobody can challenge their decisions. They Judiciary has similar problems. We contested one case in CAT and won 2 times, then the matter reached the High Court. The High Court overruled the verdict of tribunal on flimsy ground. The Bench at High Court give decision only hearing one side and starkly ignored the arguments made by us. The High Court stated that the head of the department has given affidavit that there was no backdoor entry in the selection procedure and accepted the affidavit as true. The High Court just ignored the strong evidences provided by us. The CAT had given the decision by considering both side arguments and giving the proper reasoning of believing or rejecting every argument, whereas the decision given by the High Court was quite arbitrary. We made an appeal before the apex court and the apex court did not entertain our request.
 
Back
Top