Changing Chinese Tone

Status
Not open for further replies.

rkumar

Active member
Dear Friends,

Lot has changed since 1962 Chinese invasion of India. India has undergone from the position of ridicule to food shortage and then to that of a slow self-realisation. Chinese who were open critic of India at every possible world forum, are now turning to look at India differently. Lately I have been scanning lot of world media about how India is viewed by different countries. Following is a link from Official Chinese New s Agency;

http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2005-02/24/content_2612358.htm

Though I don't give much importance to it as its more like a diplomatic write-up just before the state visit of Chinese premier to India. However, if a wide search of world media is taken an indicator, the views of world towards India are changing much faster than what most of us think. I have read many US policy documents lately submitted to US congress. All have the same contents...'' Watch India’’.

In the same context I read a historical analytical research paper (Early Modern India and World History, John F. Richards, Duke University,
April 24, 1996), which makes a very interesting reading. As per this paper, India was always a much more free society than China. It remains true even today when whole world is comparing two countries.

While reading all this makes one feel elated and happy, it throws another issue. What will be the place of people living in rural India when Urban India is moving ahead to join the league of developed world? In my views, if Rural India does not wake-up and move in tandem, it will be left far behind. Most people in Rural India are totally unaware of happenings and need to be awakened. Let some of us join hands and create such action groups.

Regards
Rajendra
 
Last edited:
rkumar said:
Dear Friends,
Most people in Rural India are totally unaware of happenings and need to be awakened. Let some of us join hands and create such action groups.

Regards
Rajendra
Dear Uncleji
Rural India are not totally unware about happenings. Now a days many villages are running on path of development. (may be spped slow but going). By the way before some days ago you have written in your post that you are working in a rural developing project(model). Is it tested or will take some time.
If it is successfully tested then let it put here. I too much curious to know about it.
thanks
 
changing chinese tone

A lot of progress has been made by chins since her Independence in 1950 where as we got freedom in 1947 and are far behind China . WHY? Let us think and answer.Lot of unequal distribution is there in many areas inIndia. One divide is rural and urban but we should have in mind that there are poor people in urban areas and rich people in rural areas.Of course a lot is needed to be done for realisation of the potential of the people to become an self reliant developed country.We are doing some work in the society as a whole at grass root level.

R.S.Dahiya
 
Economic Growth in China and India: Much to Learn from Each Other

Dear Rajendra Ji,

Please see the latest issue of the Economist (March 5- March 11) for a comprehensive survey of the economic indicators of the two countries, the propsects for future economic growth, their strengths and weaknesses, etc
The bottomline however is that it is too premature for us to start thinking that we are giving China a run for their money (as we are particularly wont to do these days). Even a cursory look at the socio-economic, demographic, indicators of the two nations, and the enormous gaps therein, can bring one back to the terra firma. Even the change in China's posturing towards its neighbors is driven by their attempts to be recognized as a super power with a difference. The idea is to demonstrate that power can be wielded in a non-threatening way (unlike, of course, we all know, whom). The Chinese realize that they cannot be a super power unless they resolve their issues with their neighbors, or at least acheive a level of detente with them (something which continues to totally elude our Chanakyas, who are totally obsessed with Pakistan). That is why China is trying to project a non-confrontational.threatning tone towards all its neighbors, except, of course, Taiwan, which it regards as a renegade province, and a core strategic issue. Again, the bottomline is that there is a lot of room for cooperation between India and China without going into these judgments about motives and intentions. Also, with increase in trade and economic exchange, the resolution of other outstanding problems will only become easier.

One factor that is contributing to the hype about India as an emerging superpower (yeah right with 1/3 of its population chronically malnourished and female literacy of 47%, China's figures are 10% and 87% respectively) is the emergence of an English-speaking, highly vocal (actually, shrill), upper-middle class, which craves and clamors for international recognition(that also explains this endless obsession with national prestige, honor and, so forth, coupled with a total lack of social conscience: all fascist tendencies). As far as they are concerned, the poor in India be damned, they are just an embarassment and should all be taken somewhere and disposed of. (That's why we have people writing about how beggars spoil the look of our cities. Not that we should do something to help them, but how can we get rid of this menace!)
The incessant, monotonous, and rather deafening, drumbeat proclaiming the arrival of India, that we hear in our media and portals like this, emanates from the living rooms of this euphoric section of our population and should not be confused with actual and substantive change on the ground.
 
nvedwan said:
The incessant, monotonous, and rather deafening, drumbeat proclaiming the arrival of India, that we hear in our media and portals like this, emanates from the living rooms of this euphoric section of our population and should not be confused with actual and substantive change on the ground.


This kind of stuff is readily available in Outlook,Hindu and other similar publications. I really wonder how many of us come to Jatland to read "politically correct" sermons. There are enough forums/journals/magazines/think-tanks/societies where such ideas are immensely appreciated.
 
abhishek said:
This kind of stuff is readily available in Outlook,Hindu and other similar publications. I really wonder how many of us come to Jatland to read "politically correct" sermons. There are enough forums/journals/magazines/think-tanks/societies where such ideas are immensely appreciated.

Abhishek !If I am not wrong, Most of your threads are based upon a link from news paper stories followed by a question to members. What makes you feel that what you post from news papers is important and what others post, is not so important ? May be this tpoic is not as sensational as you post most of the time.

Would you please enlighten us as to what should be discussed on Jatland and what should be left to be discussed at other forums?

RK^2
 
How to avoid the dreaded stigma of "political correctness"

Dear Rajendra Ji,

Maybe I can attempt to answer your question, although I have to confess to being incorrigibly afflicted with "political correctness"!!

I think following the formula, given below, can help one avoid the charge of political correctness (translation: concern for the human condition, tolerance, of diversity, broadly):
1. Make at least one ethnic slur in your writing: e.g. Italians are considered the scumbags of Europe (actual quote).
2. Launch into at least one tirade against Muslims (call them fundamentalists, etc)
3. Use words like "loony-left", "commies" especially when one is completetly unware of the history of the left in Europe and elsewhere and their contribution to things that we take for granted today: eight hour work day, principle of equal work and equal wages, gender parity, the fight against Nazism and Fascism, and so on.
4. Frequently, while launching into one of the typical hateful tirades against Muslims, or someone else, justify genocide and mass murder ("only a few hundred Muslims were killed").

In general, talk about things that you are completely ignorant about and only in terms of invectives, epithets, and muckraking. Promote intolerance and bigotry. VOILA!!! You are all set. No one will ever call you politically correct.
 
rkumar said:
Would you please enlighten us as to what should be discussed on Jatland and what should be left to be discussed at other forums?

RK^2

Sorry sir that's not my prerogative. Moreover I responded to Mr. Vedwan`s post. I am really wondering why did you take it so personally. You are free to post whatever, afterall it's a free world . :)
 
nvedwan said:
3. Use words like "loony-left", "commies" especially when one is completetly unware of the history of the left in Europe and elsewhere and their contribution to things that we take for granted today: eight hour work day, principle of equal work and equal wages, gender parity, the fight against Nazism and Fascism, and so on.

Why should I gauge left by what it has done in Europe/Americas? Left has been creating havoc in India for decades. Keywords : Kerala, West Bengal, Naxalites, trade unions .
And I believe majority governments in Europe are center-right. Spain was perhaps an abberation and CDU/CSU is poised to come to power in Germany. Labour party in UK is leaning miore towards center than left and is giving Conservative party run for their money ( pun intended) . US of A well lesser said is better. China , I really wonder if that can be classified as a leftist government,but we will you benefit of doubt. There isnt much to discuss about South Americas and Africa.
nvedwan said:
In general, talk about things that you are completely ignorant about and only in terms of invectives, epithets, and muckraking. Promote intolerance and bigotry. VOILA!!! You are all set. No one will ever call you politically correct.

Well name-calling, personal attacks have always been old weapon. Anybody and everybody who happens to disagree with leftist ideology (however reasonable/logical he/she may be) is a fascist, deranged, ignorant, bigot, communalist. And on top of that if you happen to be a god-fearing patriotic hindu then you better watch out.

nvedwan said:
4. Frequently, while launching into one of the typical hateful tirades against Muslims, or someone else, justify genocide and mass murder ("only a few hundred Muslims were killed").
cliché.

PS : I would appreciate if a rejoinder is based on facts then personal attack. I know personal attacks are chic on jatland these days but I hope I am not expecting too much.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top