Here i am !!!
STRONGLY DISAGREE ...
Mere te karo baat....me tha sabte pehalyan vote karaniya...
intially, i didn't want to get any debate....kyunki kimme fayda te sai na tagge kale karan ka....ade tham nare debate karan ke so....
i'm against any kind of reservations of even SC/ST's, put aside OBC , in elite educational institues....
This has caused a brain drain of our talent...they go to (rather i should say, are forced to go) US/UK/Germany/Aus for studies, if they don't get admission into their college of their choices....and don't come back..
Has anybody heard of "SUPER 30".....where a retd IAS Officer in Bihar teaches selective poor RURAL students to polish their talent under TIN SHED....to compete against well coached other wise average students of elite class families, who spends pretty hefty amounts for their wards for coachings..
If govt. want to really uplift SC/SC/OBC's.........make special coaching institues (which already exists, for helping them to get admission into engg/diploma/railway exams/and other competitive govt. exams of Bank PO etc...)........this facility should be improved...
AND THIS YEAR ALL 30 RURAL TALENTED HAVE SECURED ADMISSION INTO IIT'S.....initally there were 18 students selected it IIT'S and rest to other elite institutions...
but now after 5 or 6 years..the sucess rate is 100 %
SO SUCH SPECIALISED classes should be started by Govt....
GOvt. is providing Education Loan faclities.....to all..
and needy reserved students are paid pretty hefty STIPEND...to support their education....(so govt. should increase thier stipend, rather than giving them more undeserved seats)
Taking an example of my own college YMCA Faridabad...each SC student is paid 60K per annum and OBC to 45 K per annum....whereas the annual fees was around 45 K per annum...
TO SUM UP:
Don't kill the talent....Talent is always supported, and make thier own way.....rather govt. should give them free education (to all SC/ST/OBC...n needy general students), if they have talent n potential and can compete...
and our JAT, are no less than any other community.....they are talented, have potential.....but nobody is there to give them a guidence, they don't know what all professional courses are there in Market....
rather we JAT's feel proud agar kisi ka chhorra... Fauj me , JBT me, JE/diplopma...Police me...Vlda....nursing...BEd.....baaki sab apna potential BA wagerah karne me hi kho dete hain...kyunki hamari soch yahin tak hai simit hai....
no body is there to guide them, show the way....
Moreover we apna dimaag faltu kamman me ghana lagaya kare.....chorri bajji, calleg me chaudhrapana, ladai dange....neta bajji...
na te khet ma kassolla thate, na dhang te kitaab thatte...
babbu ne keh de se, ak college me paddhan ja su, babbu bichara nyu socche ak kyun khet me ghalya chhorra, jaan de ne isne paddhan ne...arr we calleg me bidi-cigrate-chorrian ne chhedna, maar-peet, netabajji, taas-patte khel ke aa jya sain....
kitab thatte nahi.....ar last me parchi bana bana paas hoya karein...
dasmi (10th) ek baar me paas karna hi unke liye ek badi acheivement hoti hai...
Talent hai.....par direction nahi hai........dhyaan nahi hai.........
ek baat aur ...... jaaton ko OBC me include karne ka koi khaas faayda nahi hone wala...
jo college (BA etc, jahan admission merit se hota hai)....khud hi jaa ke dekh lena kitna difference aayega...
fer kyun apne-aap ne dedh khuvaan ki tayyari kar rahe so...?????????
jad kimme milan te ala nahi...kime khaas fayda te sai nahi...
rai baat haryana ki sarkari naukari ki.......usme me kime fayda koni mile.....pisse/rishwat/shifarish thamne fer bhi deni padengi......
haan farak bas itna hoga ki SDO ke 20 lakh ki jagah.....12-15 Lakh dene padenge.....par dene jarur padenge.....
tham ke soccho so, ak OBC me hoya pacche thamne nyu e sarkari naukari mil jyagi....sirf rate kam lagega bas....(i have a khatti friend, jisne BVsc, MVsc kara rakkhi thi, ar Vetenary surgeon ki post me pisse khuvane pade the....bas rate thoda kam laga tha...)
ar reservation duva ke admission to karva doge engg etc me.......par naukari private sector me sirf talent dekh ke hi milti hai....(mere gel ke 90 % dedh balkaan ne ib tak naukari nahi mili...mere susare paas hovenge jadd e to milegi...ib tai compartment kle papper reh rahe sein...)
hona yahi hai, jattan ka chaurre ho ke badhiya calleg me admission te ho jyaga.....par paddhe we fer bhi knoi....nyu e compart todte firenge...(jitne jat jugaadi the college me mere gel, we ib tak compart ke papper todte fire sain...bata kunsi MNC un ne apne yahan engineer laan ki socchegi...???....jugaad/jaan pichhan te chhoti motti pribate company me 7-8 hazar ki naukari to kar lenge, par fer un ne kaam karan ka na bera, akkad me reha karenge....promotion na ho...)
fer ye kise 3 grade college te padh ke, ghar alyan ki pisse simadva ke, gharan thalli baith jyange....kime milega faayda.....chori-chakari karan laggenge....drug-peddlers banenge...ghar kyah ne aur kaal karenge...
SO, Please know the ground realities....
We need to change our young talented brothers mindset.....attitude....to stive for excellence.....hard work...and give n support them by giving guidance...about the professional courses, which our market has demand...
mere pa koye nyu pucche se ak chhore ne ke karvau....kimme bata.....makha suddha-paddhra mechanical te dipplomma karva dyo...isa byoont na dikhta iska, yo sar fodega thara BA karke...isne coaching duvaan ghaal dyo.....ar je iska badhiya rank aya...kimme byont sa dikkha.......to agge 12th karva diyo ar Professional Degree ki tayyari karvaiyyo...
So ade tagge kale mat na karya karo.......kise ne uske byont ke hisab te guidance dyo.....
ghane reservation ke chakkar me mat na pado......
samjheeee...ye sab political milege lene wale netaon ke tante hain, inke chakkar me na pado...
bhatera tem kaadh ke ya post liki sai......ib manne bhi kimme daftat me kaam kar len dyo....na te meri jatland.com ne bhi thaa ke BAN marenge ye...pehlyan bhi hange te dubara un banned karvai thi....
ar ghani be chaupaal pe bhi thyaaya su

....ha ha ha
agge kise ne bahas karni sai, te mera phone lumber meri profile me sai....ade thread pe behas karan ka tem konya...