jagmohan said:
The idea of IDEAL VILLAGE was tried a long time back. Those of you who were reading The Hindustan Times in the 70s would remember that they had adopted a village, CHHATERA (Chhatera – Majra) and a weekly article was published in the paper. I have a very close friend from that village, Sumit Kumar, now Secretary Haryana Vidhan Sabha. I don’t know the present condition of the village but I fear it is no different from any other village in that area. Why an Ideal Village in the first place? Please make your home an ideal home and there you have an ideal village without any extra effort.
No CM or MP can help. At the most they can facilitate. God helps those who help themselves.
Col. Chacha:
Great to hear that you are heading back home and playing a role
in our communities.
It is true what you say about the feeling of dejection. Just
yesterday a friend of mine came back from India, and everytime that
happens we get a healthy dose of reality...which, of course, doesn't
last too long. The running joke amongst us is that whenever India beckons
and nostalgia sets in take a 2-week trip back home, and that should take
care of it.
One of the comments that my friend made which struck me was that any
Jats who amount to anything are leaving the villages and leaving behind the
good-for-nothings. He was sort of implying that the other communities
will see greater presence and influence in the villages. I don't
know how valid that is but still the comment was striking.
But I guess some of the dejection is the reason why some of us spend
our time and energy discussing it. And hopefully
these discussions spur us to play a role in whatever way we can. Even if
this means starting at "home" and never going beyond that. Sometimes,
I feel that in itself is a major accomplishment in tha face of old
die-hard views in our own families.
I don't know how others feels but I do feel that slow and gradual
change is taking place...in education and gender issues. Maybe I
get that impression because I see more and more urban Jats and I see the
girls in these families being better educated, more assertive, and
seeking a productive life. Perhaps I am seeing the proverbial glass
half-full.
While I also feel that changing lives of some children is a worthy effort
and is one way for us to do our part, there are times I wonder if that is
indeed the most effective way. Could it be that all we are doing is focussing
on a few select children who end up being successful and then move on
to their own successful and materialistic lives and indeed (gasp!) foreign
lands with nary a though for those they leave behind.
It was interesting that you mentioned Village Chhatera. It is my grandmother's
village. And my dad had spent considerable time there. If I remember
correctly he might even have studied there. So I gave my dad a call to
ask him if he knew anything about that. He had very positive comments
to say about that original effort in the 70s. He said it resulted in a lot
of good things...infrastructure improvements, primary schools and so on.
I asked him if the good things lasted. He said that is hard to make
a comment. The village is near Delhi so it might be better off anyways.
I can't comment on what exactly the idea was and how exactly the "model"
village concept was implemented, but a lot would really depend
on that. I was doing some browsing on the web and read
about some model village efforts by UN agencies and saw some very
positive things to read about them.
But, no matter what, I would agree that the key measure of success has to
be that, after the focus shifts from the "model village", is the village
still able to continue with the measures that were implemented. It is
well and good that nice things happen when there is special
focus on the village (as by Hindustan Times in 70s), but key question
is what happens when that focus moves on. Anything
that is implemented has to be sustainable. And that is my key interest
in this whole thread. I wanted to see if something can
be suggested that can be sustainable when the single minded
focus on "Harya" is no longer there (perhaps more on that in a later
post).
It would be interesting to know if anyone has any more information
on the Chhatera effort.
I think the key comment in your post was:
No CM or MP can help. At the most they can facilitate. God helps those
who help themselves.
This is exactly what I am trying to drive towards.