There should be no reservation for anybody.
These reservations are in.......
1) All educational institutions where government has a say.(which is almost all of them)
2) All government jobs.
Well Sidchhikara sir, You are either not well informed or you are just trying to twist it in the direction where you seemingly presume to have an upper hand. The Manmohan Singh Government has already in the year 2004 (Which happens to be its first year of tenure) issued notifications for reservations in private sector bodies as well. And it will not be just a dream of the political masters, in the coming days to see this as a reality.
Reservation has always been an activity to encourage people come out of their fixes, which they have been living into since the development of society.
Let me not look into the situation of other castes or tribes, but jats. Jats have always been suppressed through out the north western India. Ahmed Shah Abdali and party started this in the modern history and the brahmins did it ways back. Jats as a tribe had always had an edge over others. We did not believe in the strongest force developed by Brahmins, the God, and so we always stood against them. Budhissm, Sikhhism, Jainism all are examples of our open challenge to the might of the so called God of Brahmins.
Alas, despite being so strong in resolve, we have never been able to converge at one point and act collectively, which gave others an edge over us, to kill us, our very identity. Aurangzeb, Ahmed Shah Abdali, and others assaulted the Jats the most. And if you have the slightest of impression from history, we were not killed or suppressed by Moughals; but by our own people who had prejudice among self!! Thakur badan Singh and CHuraman episode, all of us know what conspired and then Jats were suppressed.
So sire' in a country where we have always been living in a state of fragranced S*IT, it is not detrimental to get out of it, and with grace through ENCOURAGEMENT. This, which people here, i am not gonna name who, say is a decree of our status, is rather not a decree... Its rather getting out of that Sh*t which we have been living for ages and folling ourselves to be at the top of it.
So I strongly come in favor of a Jat reservation, not because other castes are getting benefited, but because we need to get out of the black hole we have been living in! And in a democratic country, its better to fight for your cause, than to succumb to the plans of political masters.
Here's the solution....
1) Government needs to get out of education all together - from elementary education to college. CBSE, NCERT, Haryana board, all regional boards should be immediately gotten rid of. Let schools teach what they want to teach. Private Colleges should not be forced to be affiliated to govt univ's and follow their sh*ty coursework - it is detrimental to any scope for research work - makes no sense.
Sir, Just imagine the state of your village, with no gram panchayat, and no pradhan! imagine your home, with no leader to tell right or wrong, imagine a road with no traffic signals, imagine a power station with no control on supply, imagine a hydro electric power station with no limits on production. A school without a Government intervention would be in no better a condition. How do you think you are gonna give a logical support to different education patterns at different places.
Let us see as an example, a very simple case. The education pattern in India and in the US is pretty different. A student who wish to go to the US for further studies need to go through a troublesome process which in inevitable so as to meet the expectations of the host institute. Do you want that troublesome process to exist within the country? Do you want a student to grill himself through troublesome exams every time one gets out of school and wants an entry in a college? This will create mayhem and nothing else.
2) There should not be any governmnet jobs available to anybody except defense and law enforcement (I wish there was some other way to do law enforcement - our courts and police are worst in the world - total mockery of democray - I like to call it cargo-cult democracy)
Great!! You seem to be a perfect reactionary! You don't even want the Government to carry a responsibility of the basic employment. OK, let us make an arrangement, let all of us know a way of law enforcement in the naxalite prone districts of country. where 16% of districts are full of reactionary forces like you, what could be a better way to get rid of them? Its easy to criticize than to act!!!
Discussing who should get reservations will not help anybody - this is just a weapon in the hands of evil government to keep people divided and take care of special interest groups. Even if you get reservations the government will f*ck you over in any other way. Government is BAD for you and you should try to sind ways to get them out of your life.
Yeah sure, the Government wants to and NEEDS to take care of special care groups, and we JATS are no better, we need special care, we have been living in a state of expat for ages, we have seen all trepid times, right from the start of Governance in the form of Turks till the modern Government. Albeit we don't accept it and are happy in the illusion that we are the KINGS!!! We are a SPECIAL CARE group and we need to converge and DEMAND STRONGLY for our care.
In May of this year came a movie, Apna Sapna Money Money, a dialog fits in. "jahan haq na mile, wahan loot sahi. Jahan sach na chale wahan jhooth sahi"
A serious appeal to all jat brothers and sisters, Please join hands to either get what is just or to snatch it!!!!! United we stand, divided we fall!!!
What gujjars did in Rajasthan is just a trailer of how harsh they could be, we need to learn it from them!!
Regards,
Sam.
