Happy with Moderator(s)???????

Happy with Moderator's workstyle?

  • Yes

    Votes: 19 43.2%
  • No

    Votes: 25 56.8%

  • Total voters
    44
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
ये तागा हालाँकि सभी मोडों के लिए होना चाहिए था पर लगता के सिर्फ़ डाक्टर साहिब के लिए बनके रह गया हे. मेरी पोस्ट्स जिन खातिर मेने आवाज़ थाई थी वे एक ऐसे मोड ने delete करी थी जिसको मेने एक साल मे ऑनलाइन देखा भी नही. मेरी पोस्ट मे ऐसा कुछ भी नही था जो आपतिजनक हो. मेरा कसूर इतना था मे उसके एक दोस्त से सवाल जवाब मे उलाज़ बैठा था. फेर उसने वा थ्रेड लॉक कर दी.

डॉक्टर साहिब ने भी मेरी पोस्ट धोड़ी हे पर कम त कम मे इतना कह सकूँ हूँ के वे निस्पक्श स. राजपाल जी त पहली उन मोड़ ती हटाना चाहिए जो कुछ करते नही हे फेर भी पद पे बैठे हें. उनकी जगह मे भाई रविंदर, वी पी सिंग, अनिल सांगवान, समर सिंग आदि के नाम का परताव करता हूँ . डॉक्टर साहिब की एक खूबी तो हे के वे अपना काम पूरी लग्न से करते हे तो उनको इतिहास और विकी का मोड़ बना दिया जाए.
 
हम इतना सब लिख रहे हैं ,तो कुछ ऐसा भी लिखा जाए की जाटलैंड में सुधार हो जाए ,आखिर लड़ाई का और इस ताग्गे का मुद्दा ही सुधार हे ।
में यहां कुछ सुझाव देना चाहूँगा -----
मॉडरेटर के लिए --------
१) जाटलैंड का बोझ किसी एक के कंधे पर ना डाला जाए,जिसके कारण वो काम के बोझ तले दब जाता हे और अनाप-सनाप निर्णय लेने लग जाता हे । कई मोड़ हिटलर भी बन जाते हैं ।
२) सारी लड़ाइयाँ फोरम में होती हैं और ट्रेफिक भी उसी में अधिक हे इस लिए उसके काम को बाँट दिया जाए ।
३) पुराने सभी मोड़ को हटा दिया जाए । विकी मॉडरेटर छोड़ कर ।
४) जो मॉडरेटर हफ्ते में एक बार अपने सेक्सन की सार संभाल नहीं करता और हफ्ते में एक बार विजिट नहीं करता उसको एक महीने तक देखने के बाद हटा दिया जाए या वो समय के अभाव बता कर स्वयं हट जाए ।
५) जो मॉडरेटर किसी तागे को लोक करता हे , तो कारण के साथ उसी तागे में बता कर लोक करे ।
६) जो मॉडरेटर किसी की पोस्ट में अवांछनीय भाषा को हटाना चाहता हे ,पहले वो उस पोस्टर को खुद हटाने के लिए कहे ,या कारण बता कर हटाये ,केवल अप्रोप्रिएट लेंग्वेज कहने की बजाय उन् शब्दों या वाक्य को बताये जिनके कारण वो पोस्ट हटाई गई हे । ताकि भविष्य में फिर से वो ही गलती और तू-तू में में ना हो ।
७) मॉडरेटर केवल अपने जिम्मेवारी के ही काम करे किसी दूसरे मॉडरेटर के काम में टांग ना अड़ाए ।


पोस्टर के लिए ---------
१) राजनैतिक विषयों पर बहस के दौरान किसी के भी विचार किसी भी दल के साथ हो सकते हैं , और वे समय के साथ बदल भी सकते हैं ,इस लिए उन् पर वयक्तिगत टिप्पणी ना करें । पुरे दल पर या उस दल की विचार धारा पर ही टिप्पणी करें ।
२) गाली गलौज चाहे हिंदी का हो या अंग्रेजी का प्रयोग ना करें । उसकी जगह अनेक उपमाएं / मुहावरे होती हैं ,गुस्सा निकालने के लिए उनका ही प्रयोग करें ।
३) धार्मिक विषयों पर हमें जाट संस्कृति ( हिन्दू /सिख )के नजरिये से देखना चाहिए , दूसरे धर्म की तरफदारी करने के ठोस कारण होने चाहिए ।
४) एक ही विषय पर चल रहे धागे पर अनेक धागे ना चलायें ।
५) ऎसे धागे जिन पर ना कोई लाइक करता हे और ना कोई पढता हे जारी ना रखें ,अपने आप बंद कर दें ।
६) विषय वे ही चुने जो जाट से सम्बंधित हों ,दुनिया भर का अड़ंगा इंटरनेट पर पड़ा रहने दे ।


--------- सद-भावनाओँ सहित ।
 
I strongly recommend RK Uncle for the post of moderator.
He is the only person who can bring back good old JL days.
I think it would be like to ask a active politician for state governor or president job. If it happens then he has to come out from his original ideology and has to wear a secular spectacles to show him unbiased in front of our so called progressive and cool secularists.
I think it'll be like giving the captaincy to Sachin Tendulkar but then the original RK could be missed out completely as we have seen Sachin's individual performance during his captaincy. I guess his natural views and thoughts will be under pressure of moderator job.

However, I'm completely agree on this thing that the kind of person he is as I perceived him, he will be the best fit to moderator job after Rajpal Sir.
 
Yes it gets tricky when a mod has a particular kind of views which are known to members. The other party would always blame him of being biased. However, as suggested by a few dont delete any post just delete the abusive language. That way people will have less to complain.

If it goes off topic let the members decide what they want. In other words, a mod can take a bit passive role here. Unless members complain let them go off-topic. If they are not interested in thread topic then there is no point asking them to stay on the topic.

Strict rules may work on a big forum with lot of members but we have only 15-20 active members.
 
इब्ब इह रोले ने मिटाण खातर में कुछ सुझाव दयु सूं , विकी मॉडरेटर जो से वे न्यू के न्यू रहवें ,अर जाटलैंड के मॉडरेटर खातर न्यू कर्या जावे । पहलम बताऊ सु कोए नाटेगा नहीं , अर जिनके नाम नहीँ से वो रूस्सेगा नहीं । कई दिन होगे सब एक दूसरे के धाप्पा ला दवे से । इब्ब फेर आगे सत्येस्वर की मर्जी ।
१) एजुकेशन एंड कॅरियर ---------सौरभ जागलान ।
२) न्यूज़ एंड वूज ------------------ विपिन ज्याणी ।
३) जनरल टाक -------------------- अनिल सांगवान ।
४) हिस्ट्री ---------------------------- डॉ राजपाल सिंह झ ँगु ।
५) मौजमस्ती ---------------------- रविंदर जीत सिंह बल्हारा ।
६) स्पेसल इंट्रेस्ट ------------------- आशा बडियासर / राजपाल दुलार ।
७) चेपटर एंड इतनीरीज ---------- राजेंदर कुमार कालखण्डे ।
८) अबाउट जाटलैंड डाट कॉम ---- समर सिंह / प्रिक्षित छिल्लर ।




--------- सद भावनाओँ सहित ।
 
Self explanatory Note :


I initially joined as an ordinary member of the site and observed the functioning of the site for some months prior to starting to contribute to the site on its various forums/sub forums and since then have continued to enjoy the same.

This gives me much more sense of satisfaction than the task which I have to undertake as moderator with a mission of duty and responsibility to justify the faith reposed in me.

Therefore, Dear Friends, I have nothing to loose or gain in retaining or leaving the editorship.

Rather, I shall continue to enjoy and feel proud to be associated with the prestigious site even if I am allowed to remain an ordinary member of the site by the 'well wishers'.
 
आज एक पोस्ट डिलीट होगी , और किहे की थी , मेरे धोरे भेजी होड़ जो मैंने छाप्पी थी । कुण्से मॉडरेटर ने करी स न्यू भी कोणी बेरा । न्यू लिख राखी स अक " बड्डे बुड्ढा की इज़्ज़त करणा सीखो " पर उह मॉडरेटर ताहीं जो भी वो स समझ जावेगा ,न्यू बताणा चाहूँगा एक बड्डे बुड्डयाँ ने भी औराँ की इज़्ज़त करणी आणी चाहिए । इज़्ज़त कमाई जाया करे , मोल कोणी आंदी ।


------- सद-भावनाओँ सहित ।
 
ये तागा हालाँकि सभी मोडों के लिए होना चाहिए था पर लगता के सिर्फ़ डाक्टर साहिब के लिए बनके रह गया हे. मेरी पोस्ट्स जिन खातिर मेने आवाज़ थाई थी वे एक ऐसे मोड ने delete करी थी जिसको मेने एक साल मे ऑनलाइन देखा भी नही. मेरी पोस्ट मे ऐसा कुछ भी नही था जो आपतिजनक हो. मेरा कसूर इतना था मे उसके एक दोस्त से सवाल जवाब मे उलाज़ बैठा था. फेर उसने वा थ्रेड लॉक कर दी.

डॉक्टर साहिब ने भी मेरी पोस्ट धोड़ी हे पर कम त कम मे इतना कह सकूँ हूँ के वे निस्पक्श स. राजपाल जी त पहली उन मोड़ ती हटाना चाहिए जो कुछ करते नही हे फेर भी पद पे बैठे हें. उनकी जगह मे भाई रविंदर, वी पी सिंग, अनिल सांगवान, समर सिंग आदि के नाम का परताव करता हूँ . डॉक्टर साहिब की एक खूबी तो हे के वे अपना काम पूरी लग्न से करते हे तो उनको इतिहास और विकी का मोड़ बना दिया जाए.

Friend,


There is a team of four members of moderators of this forum at present. How does it function, is the question which is agitating the minds of a few friends. Let me say a few words on the issue.

I can assure all the members of the site that none of us has personal interest in resorting to unwarranted edit/delete his or her post or to rejoice in awarding 'infraction'. It is done only in case of violation of certain norms.

Infraction is awarded to make one aware that one is not on the right path in one's discussion/post and the infraction ends with passing of the limited time stipulated for the purpose. The cause of 'editing/deletion and infraction' with a piece of advice is forwarded to the concerned member through personal message after the action has met final approval from the 'system'.

Therefore, no chance for a moderator/editor to function against any member in an arbitrary manner. The decision making has several layers and they collectively implement the Site Policy, Rules and Regulations.

It is a welcome step that some of the friends have rightly started to contact senior members to re-activate their participation. who have tried to highlight some of shortcomings/errors of judgement during the course of editing/moderating action,.

All the short comings pointed out or criticism, perhaps, has made the participants wiser and created awareness among them about what they are expected to write and what not to write. In case of doubt members are free to go through three steaky threads on this very sub-forum above.

It is hoped this would minimise the number of complaints in the form of 'Reported Posts' and lead to smooth running of the discussions on the respective sub-forums of the site without intervention of the moderators in the matter.

I may be permitted to add here that due to stalemate generated by us, even today some of the 'reported posts' are waiting attention of the editors.

If such reported posts section remains unattended for unlimited time, a new issue would be raised by the reporters and if intervention is initiated, those whose posts/threads are involved would start to send private messages and would also start contacting on phone to the 'well wisher of the site'.
Present is the period of dilemma for the editors as was faced by one of the protagonist in a famous dramma by Shakespeare: 'to do or not to do, that is the question' !

Could anyone suggest a solution to the situation.

Thanks and regards,
 
Last edited:
चुपचाप आदमी की समझदारी का क्यूकर बेरा पाटैगा ? माणस कुछ बोलैगा जिब्बे तो बेरा पाटैगा i मसलन आपकी समझदारी का पता आपकी इस पोस्ट से ही तो चलता है,वरना फोटो से तो कुछ भी पता नहीं चल रहा I कितनी स्याणी स्याणी बात कह दी आपनै थोड़े से शब्दां मैं I

Good day Bhai sahab, I think sometimes something left unsaid at most tempting moment also fits in the art of conversation. It is not only to say right thing at right time. My Regards to you.
 
Friend,


There is a team of four members of moderators of this forum at present.

If it is a Team of four members, how come you are the only one talking? Where are the other members? Or are you the appointed spokesperson for the team?

Thanks & Regards,
 
Friend,


Present is the period of dilemma for the editors as was faced by one of the protagonist in a famous dramma by Shakespeare: 'to do or not to do, that is the question' !

Could anyone suggest a solution to the situation.

Thanks and regards,

Shakespeare's heroes were always confused. If a Mod doesn't know the answer to this question they should resign and move on.

We dont need Hemlet, we need Krishan.
 
If it is a Team of four members, how come you are the only one talking? Where are the other members? Or are you the appointed spokesperson for the team?

Thanks & Regards,

The thread has been started to discuss me and my functioning as the posts of participants reveal.
 
The thread has been started to discuss me and my functioning as the posts of participants reveal.
It was started with good intent, and for all the moderators. We have noticed a positive out come of it. What's the harm if everybody comes clear of thier part, be it a moderator or a member.
 
The thread has been started to discuss me and my functioning as the posts of participants reveal.

My post mentioned some other Mod as well though I didn't disclose the name as my intent is not to criticise the person but to debate the issue. You are talking on behalf of others claiming they don't play politics or take sides. I very well know why my posts were deleted and regarding reason it was very generic "Off Topic". Thread was locked after that and when I questioned it you Deleted my post and gave me infraction. You were probably doing your job but he was playing games.
 
It was started with good intent, and for all the moderators. We have noticed a positive out come of it. What's the harm if everybody comes clear of thier part, be it a moderator or a member.

My young Friend,

I do not doubt your 'intention' in any way. Rather I am thankful to you as you have provided an opportunity to all the Jatland members and thousands of visitors to Site to know something about me and my style of functioning.

To understand it, kindly read the title of the thread once again. Is it not aimed at discussion about moderator and not moderators !

Nonetheless, I have enjoyed every bit of discussion and thank all the participants in the discussion for having spared time to appraise me and my style of work.

Kindly keep it up.


Thanks and best wishes


PS : Since I have already presented my point of view on the issues raised, it would serve no useful purpose if I continue to interfere with the smooth flow of discussion by the members.

Hence, time to say adieu to this thread discussion.
 
I think this thread's discussion should not be turn into "Moderator Hatao Abhiyaan" . Forum members are from different background, carrying different attitude and ideology so it's quite natural to have differences of opinions. Only one thing is common here and that is all are JAT.
I think few things can be improved by putting some efforts. At moderator's end, transparency in taking disciplinary action should be there as few members have already suggested that what they expect when a particular action has to be taken while members have to make sure not to cross their limit by being personal or offensive specially on a public forum such as JL.
Also I would like to say moderator has been given the privilege to run/monitor this site as per the rule and regulation set by the site administrator. There is no harm in giving the reason to a member for infraction, imposing ban or post deletion. Ultimately It would be considered as a democratic way of work. However, moderator can come up with this justification that why they should give the reasons for every disciplinary step taken when forum guidelines are there. It could be a never ending story.
At the end of the day we all (I hope moderators as well:)) want more active and constructive participation of our forum members on our community related issues on this forum. It can be achieved through creating a more liberal and constructive environment here.
Now moderators are going through "credibility crisis". When we know that they are dealing with the persons who are known for their attitude so the chance of being misunderstood is always there.. It's their call, how to bring the members confidence back on their working style and to this forum which can give the reason to members to come here again and again...
 
anil bhai...bilkul sahi aadmi hai moderatorship ke liye.......par shayad anil bhai moderatorship ke liye time na nikaal paaye...kyoun anil bhai?

VP ji aur RK ji bhi theek rahenge iss kaam ke liye


प्रशांत भाई, धन्यवाद आपने मेरे जिसे अनाड़ी माणस को इतनी बड्डी चौधर के लायक समझा i वैसे तो मैं भी बिना पैसे की चौधर मैं भोत खुश होया करूँ, लेकिन आजकल बखत की बहुत भारी कमी सै I फेर देख ल्यांगे I फिलहाल तो बिना जिम्मेवारी के मज़े लेण मैं सुवाद सा आ रह्या सै I विपिन का भी धन्यवाद I

कलखंडे साहब फिट आदमी हैं
राजपाल जी की भी घणी ए बोट होगी, मेरे ख्याल में अब महाभियोग (impeachment) withdraw होणा चाहिए
रविंदर जीत भी घणा ख़राब माणस नहीं सै, इसकै भी ला दयो छीका सा
राजपाल दुलार साहब तैं बूझण मैं भी कोए हर्ज़ नहीं
बाकी भी जितने नाम भाइयां नै सुझाये सैं वे सारे सज्जन पुरुष लाग्गैं सैं
 
इब्ब इह रोले ने मिटाण खातर में कुछ सुझाव दयु सूं , विकी मॉडरेटर जो से वे न्यू के न्यू रहवें ,अर जाटलैंड के मॉडरेटर खातर न्यू कर्या जावे । पहलम बताऊ सु कोए नाटेगा नहीं , अर जिनके नाम नहीँ से वो रूस्सेगा नहीं । कई दिन होगे सब एक दूसरे के धाप्पा ला दवे से । इब्ब फेर आगे सत्येस्वर की मर्जी ।
१) एजुकेशन एंड कॅरियर ---------सौरभ जागलान ।
२) न्यूज़ एंड वूज ------------------ विपिन ज्याणी ।
३) जनरल टाक -------------------- अनिल सांगवान ।
४) हिस्ट्री ---------------------------- डॉ राजपाल सिंह झ ँगु ।
५) मौजमस्ती ---------------------- रविंदर जीत सिंह बल्हारा ।
६) स्पेसल इंट्रेस्ट ------------------- आशा बडियासर / राजपाल दुलार ।
७) चेपटर एंड इतनीरीज ---------- राजेंदर कुमार कालखण्डे ।
८) अबाउट जाटलैंड डाट कॉम ---- समर सिंह / प्रिक्षित छिल्लर ।




--------- सद भावनाओँ सहित ।
My friend, when these people are taking over Mr Rajpal's work? Any idea or news? Despite name being proposed, I see no action at all. Still one moderator is most active.
 
I am on moderation list since July. Wonder when will this ban be over? A member should not be punished like this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top