History and Historians on Jat Mauryan Empire[ founded by Chandragupta in c 323 BC]

Rajpalji, G N Sharma is a reputed historian and he has concluded that this Samprati refers to Samprati Maurya. We have Ghanghani Inscription of Samprati Maurya also. Ghanghani is a village in tahsil Bhopalgarh of Jodhpur district in Rajasthan. It is situated near Asarnada railway station on Bikaner-Jodhpur line. There is an ancient Jaina Temple. According to Jaina poet Samayasundara the ancient sculptures bear Inscription of Samprati Maurya, Dasarath Maurya's son and granson of Ashoka Maurya. This indicates that he built a grand Padmaprabhu Jinalaya temple.[Ref: Mathur, Vijayendra Kumar: Aitihasik Sthanavali (Hindi), Vaigyanik tatha Takaniki Shabdawali Ayog, Goverment of India, 1990, p.311]
 
Rajpalji, G N Sharma is a reputed historian and he has concluded that this Samprati refers to Samprati Maurya. We have Ghanghani Inscription of Samprati Maurya also. Ghanghani is a village in tahsil Bhopalgarh of Jodhpur district in Rajasthan. It is situated near Asarnada railway station on Bikaner-Jodhpur line. There is an ancient Jaina Temple. According to Jaina poet Samayasundara the ancient sculptures bear Inscription of Samprati Maurya, Dasarath Maurya's son and granson of Ashoka Maurya. This indicates that he built a grand Padmaprabhu Jinalaya temple.[Ref: Mathur, Vijayendra Kumar: Aitihasik Sthanavali (Hindi), Vaigyanik tatha Takaniki Shabdawali Ayog, Goverment of India, 1990, p.311]

Congrts for information Burdakji,

The leanings of Mauryas towards Jainism and their patronage are well known right from the days of Chandragupta Maurya. If Ghanghani and Nadlai inscriptions bear resemblance and concur in their minute detail, this will open new vistas in construction of History of Jats. Could you guide us to find a reading or fascimile of the first inscription please.

Regards
 
Last edited:
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by ravichaudhary

Dr. Singh



This information is .........

.......there in all puranic literature


Out of pure curiousity, are you not familiar with the puranic time lines?

warm regards

Ravi chaudhary''



Chaudhary Sahib,

First to satisfy your curiosity permit me to say that I do not pretend to be authority on classical Indian literature in general and the Puranas in particular. But being a student of history for the last over four decades am trying to learn their use from the masters of the subject.

Kindly enlighten me for which literature you are using the term 'Puranic literature.'

Perhaps, it comprise 18 Puranas and 18 Upapuranas only.

Have you based your findings on the chronology given earlier by you exclusively on these Puranas and Upapuranas? If yes, kindly quote relevant references so that we could take a look to further enlighten ourselves with contextual study.

Also be kind enough to share the methodology applied for arriving at certain dates of the kings/rulers as per puranic time line mentioned in your post under reference.

Thanks and regards.
 
Last edited:
Congrts for information Burdakji,

....If Ghanghani and Nadlai inscriptions bear resemblance and concur in their minute detail, this will open new vistas in construction of History of Jats. Could you guide us to find a reading or fascimile of the first inscription please.

Regards

डॉ राजपाल जी , डॉ. गोपीनाथ:राजस्थान के इतिहास के स्त्रोत, 1983, पुस्तक मैनें कुछ समय के लिए एक परिचित से प्राप्त की थी. नाडलाई शिलालेख १६२९ ई. का संस्कृत में मूल उसमें से दिया गया है. यह जाटलैंड विकी पर है. सम्प्रति मौर्य या नाडलाई लिंक क्लिक करें, घंघानी शिला लेख का मूल पाठ मुझे नहीं मिला है. यह तथ्य माथुर , विजयेंद्र कुमार : ऐतिहासिक स्थानावली (हिंदी), वैज्ञानिक तथा तकनीकी शब्दावली आयोग , गवर्मेंट ऑफ़ इंडिया , 1990, p.311 पर लिखा गया है. आप इसको आगे बढ़ा सकते हैं.
 
Ravi,

Thanks for sharing this timeline. I am prepared to go with new dates of Mahabharat but feel that new archeological digs are required on the lines of stellar work done by BB Lal years ago. Other noteworthy mention are Brihadratha Dynasty, Pradyota Dynasty and Sisunaga Dynasty.


Here is an alternative chronology

http://nrsrini.blogspot.ca/2012/04/how-can-be-wrong-history-about-ancient.html




Name of the event Orthodox Date of the Event* Indian History Dates@
Age of the Vedas Eternal/4500 B.C.E. 1400—1000 B.C.E.
Upanishads Prior to Mahabharata War 2500—2000 (Ramkrishna Math) 1000—600 B.C.E.
Descension of Lord Krishna 3228 B.C.E. -----
Mahabharata War 3139/3067 B.C.E.(Narahari) -----
Brihadratha Dynasty of Magadha 3139—2130 B.C.E. -----
Ascension of Lord Krishna 3102 B.C.E. -----
Beginning of Kali Era 3102 B.C.E. -----
Pradyota Dynasty 2139—2001 B.C.E. -----
Sisunaga Dynasty 2001—1641B.C.E. 650 B.C.E.
Gautama Buddha 1894—1814 B.C.E. 563—483 B.C.E.
Mahvira Vardhamana 540—468 B.C.E.
Nanda Dynasty 1641—1541B.C.E. 467—362 B.C.E.
Maurya Dynasty 1541—1241 B.C.E.
Chandragupta Maurya 1541—1507 B.C.E.
Bindusara 1507—1479 B.C.E.
Ashokavardhana 1479—1443 B.C.E. Confused as Asoka the Great
Sunga Dynasty 1241 B.C.E. (beginning) 184—72 B.C.E.
Kanva Dynasty 784 B.C.E. (ending) 72—27 B.C.E.
Sankaracharya 509—477 B.C.E.# 788-820 A.D.
Saatavaahana 100 B.C.E.—225 C.E.
Gupta Dynasty 328—83 B.C.E. 320—490 C.E.
Alexander's Invasion 326 B.C.E. 326 B.C.E.
Chandragupta Vijayaditya 328—321 B.C.E. 321—305 C.E.
Samudra Gupta/Ashoka the Great 321--370 335—375 C.E.
Vikramaditya/Chandra Gupta II (Vikrama Era) 102 B.C.E.—15C.E. (53 C.E.) 375—413 C.E.
Shalivahana 25—85 C.E.
Shalivahana Saka (Era) 78 C.E.
 
Ravi,

Thanks for sharing this timeline. I am prepared to go with new dates of Mahabharat but feel that new archeological digs are required on the lines of stellar work done by BB Lal years ago. Other noteworthy mention are Brihadratha Dynasty, Pradyota Dynasty and Sisunaga Dynasty.

Friend,

Since the subject of the thread is limited to History and Historians on Jat Mauryan Empire founded by Chandragupta ....I would be constrained to limit myself to the universe of this topic. Here is produced the time line extracted from Ravi Chaudhary's post:

"Maurya Dynasty 1541—1241 B.C.E.
Chandragupta Maurya 1541—1507 B.C.E.
Bindusara 1507—1479 B.C.E.
Ashokavardhana 1479—1443 B.C.E. Confused as Asoka the Great
Sunga Dynasty 1241 B.C.E. (beginning) ...."

This time line gives 300 years for the rule of the Mauryas but Puranas taken as a whole assign 137 years to the Maurya dynasty. Vayu Purana as per one version assigns 133 and according to another version gives a much bigger total of 240 years. { see, V A Smith, EHI,207 and Puranic dates c.f. Dates of Kali Age, pp.27-29, 70}.

Which one to believe and which one to reject and why?

Hence use of other sources needed like inscriptions and coins .

Could you throw some light on this aspect of the topic under reference.

Thanks
 
Getting confused in this time scale !!!

Friends no confusion at all.

Bear with us, have patience. The last few questions for the protagonists/votaries of Puranic time line on Maurya dynasty to ponder over and respond; and the matter stands settled.

The Majority of inscriptions/Edicts of Ashoka the Great are in Brahmi and Kharosti which means these languages were popular means of communication in those days; however, Pryag Prashsti of Samudragupta is in Sanskrit.

What a drastic as well as fantastic change during the life time of a single man!![Samudra Gupta/Ashoka the Great 321--370.. C.E.]


The coins of Samudragupta and his successors are a testimony of the fact that he and his successors were adherent of Hinduism and same is true of his successors who performed Ashwamedh Yajna and issued coins to commemorate these occasions whereas Ashoka after the Kalinga war was Buddhist in personal life and secular in State Politics as per his Edicts. How the two could be one person at the same time one a self proclaimed Buddhist and another a propagator of orthodox Brahmanical religion.

Then Rock Edict XIII conveys Ashoka's relations with Hellenic emperors/rulers with their names and another inscription tells about his only war [Kalinga].
Prayag Prashsti enumerates in 33 lines of one sentence in Sanskrit his several battles with over two dozen rulers and his relations with Yaudheyas etc.
So how Samudragupta can be accepted as Ashoka or vice versa?

In view of it one can deduce conclusion: They were two Great Jat Emperor of the yore.

Ashoka, the great was third among Mauryan Emperors who ruled from c. 273 BC to 232 BC [detailed discussion will follow on chronology of Mauryas separately] and Samudragupta Dharan Jat ruled over major parts of India from 335 AD to 375 AD.

PS: Discussion based on PRIMARY SOURCES IS WELCOME on the issue of Puranic Time Line [as applied to chronology of Jat Mauryan history ] advanced by B B Law & co.

Thanks and regards.
 
Last edited:
Chaudhary Sahib,

Kindly share with us the Primary Source to prove this date to be wrong.

Thanks

At the outset, allow me to clarify that I am not particularly interested in any ’one upmanship’ activities.

My interest in seeking a history of our people, has revolved around the absence of Jat history in the official history accounts.

I do not have the ability to examine any ‘primary source’.

I do not know Sanskrit, Pali, Brahmi, Kharosthi( or the Aryan language, what ever it supposedly was), and make no claims to do so. My command of even the Hindi language is quite poor.I also know absolutely no Haryanvi, Brij Bhasa, or Khari boli.

Taking all this into account, I would think I am most poorly qualified to comment on any ‘so called ‘ primary source.

I probably would not recognize a primary source, if I saw one, even if it was staring me in the face.

What I do have is a lot of questions.

I see a lot of anomalies in the official accounts of History, as has been put forward and taught to generations of Indians.


As a lay person, ignorant of the finer tools of language etc, I am still raising questions.

I will not engage in puerile debates of ‘ a he said- she said ‘ variety.

Whatever scientific education I have had, teaches me to look for primary evidence.

I will continue to press for it.

It applies as much to official historians' versions, as well as to puranic versions.

Warm regards

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Last edited:
Traditional 'Ashoka Maurya' relations with Greek Emperors>

Considering how much Traditional Historians depend upon EXTENSIVE Greek Sources for their accounts of the Maurya period, does it not strike readers, that it is a bit odd -that no Greek Emperor, makes mention of any of these ambassadors supposedly sent by ' Asoka Maurya'?

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Religion at the time of teh Greek Invasions

The greek ambassador, Megasthenses, who went to the court of Sandrocottus( claimed to be Chandra Gupt Maurya), describes the religion as Bhagvatism or Hinduism or Vaishavism, not Buddhism.

One would have expected Buddhism or Jainism?

Did the religion of Chandragupt Maurya, who we are told was a Jain, and died a Jain, get completely ignored by the Ambassador and replaced by Vaishnavism in the Ambassador's official account?

Sounds a little odd, after all Megasthenes went to Court of the mighty Chandragupta ( conqueror of Greeks, who defeated and took their territory forcefully. Not only that, we are told the that the Greek ruler had to bow his head, and give his daughter in marriage to Chandragupta. The Greek ruler had to send an ambassador to the court of Chandra Gupta.

What do we find?.

We find, that the Ambassador writesb about Vasihnavism as the prevailing religion, and not a mention of Jainism or Buddhism at the Court of the Jain emperor!

There must be a simple explanation of this little lacunae on the part of Megasthenes.

Warm regards



Ravi Chaudhary
 
Last edited:
We have got Inscriptional information on Jatland about 'Eran Stone Inscription of Samudragupta' and 'Allahabad pillar inscription of Samudragupta'. I would request to go to page -

[Wiki]Samudragupta[/Wiki]
 
Last edited:
We have got Inscriptional information on Jatland about Heliodorus pillar, also known as Khamba Baba. A monolithic free-standing column, the pillar bears an inscription which states that it was Garuda Pillar, raised in honour of Vasudeva by Heliodorous, a resident of Taxila, who had been sent to the court of Bhagabhadra as an envoy of Indo-Greek monarch, Antialkidas. This inscription is a valuable historical record, revealing both the relations that existed between the region and the Greek kingdoms of the Punjab, and the fact that the Greek ambassador had become a follower of Hindu god Vishnu. The inclusion of the name of Antialkidas dates the erection of the pillar to approximately 140 BC. I would request to go to page to see details -

[Wiki]Vidisha[/Wiki]
 
Last edited:
At the outset, allow me to clarify that I am not particularly interested in any ’one upmanship’ activities.

My interest in seeking a history of our people, has revolved around the absence of Jat history in the official history accounts.



.......................................................

What I do have is a lot of questions.

I see a lot of anomalies in the official accounts of History, as has been put forward and taught to generations of Indians...............

Whatever scientific education I have had, teaches me to look for primary evidence.

I will continue to press for it.

It applies as much to official historians' versions, as well as to puranic versions.

Warm regards

Ravi Chaudhary

Friend,

We fully share your concern about lack of representation to the community's contribution in history books.

You are very much right in raising valid questions about the use of primary sources in reconstruction of history.

We are here genuinely concerned about the bad shape of or negligence of Jats through the ages in the pages of History books. This could be done by all of us making joint effort; there is no question of one upmanship or anything like that because mission and vision of all is to reach the same destination i e bridge the gaps in the history of India by inclusion of the great deeds of our ancestors. Yes, use of language or style of posting may differ but sole motive of all remains getting historical gaps filled with the help of available and accessible data.
Thanks.
 
Last edited:
You are right. My earlier reply was off topic. Regarding revised dates of Mauryas, it seems like another ghotala which is quite prevalent nowadays.

Friend,

Since the subject of the thread is limited to History and Historians on Jat Mauryan Empire founded by Chandragupta ....I would be constrained to limit myself to the universe of this topic. Here is produced the time line extracted from Ravi Chaudhary's post:

"Maurya Dynasty 1541—1241 B.C.E.
Chandragupta Maurya 1541—1507 B.C.E.
Bindusara 1507—1479 B.C.E.
Ashokavardhana 1479—1443 B.C.E. Confused as Asoka the Great
Sunga Dynasty 1241 B.C.E. (beginning) ...."

This time line gives 300 years for the rule of the Mauryas but Puranas taken as a whole assign 137 years to the Maurya dynasty. Vayu Purana as per one version assigns 133 and according to another version gives a much bigger total of 240 years. { see, V A Smith, EHI,207 and Puranic dates c.f. Dates of Kali Age, pp.27-29, 70}.

Which one to believe and which one to reject and why?

Hence use of other sources needed like inscriptions and coins .

Could you throw some light on this aspect of the topic under reference.

Thanks
 
डॉ राजपाल जी , डॉ. गोपीनाथ:राजस्थान के इतिहास के स्त्रोत, 1983, पुस्तक मैनें कुछ समय के लिए एक परिचित से प्राप्त की थी. नाडलाई शिलालेख १६२९ ई. का संस्कृत में मूल उसमें से दिया गया है. यह जाटलैंड विकी पर है. सम्प्रति मौर्य या नाडलाई लिंक क्लिक करें, घंघानी शिला लेख का मूल पाठ मुझे नहीं मिला है. यह तथ्य माथुर , विजयेंद्र कुमार : ऐतिहासिक स्थानावली (हिंदी), वैज्ञानिक तथा तकनीकी शब्दावली आयोग , गवर्मेंट ऑफ़ इंडिया , 1990, p.311 पर लिखा गया है. आप इसको आगे बढ़ा सकते हैं.

Burdakji,

For your kind attention and further research on Samparti Maurya following para from secondary source reproduced as under:
Samparti Maurya son of Dashratha and grandson of Asoka was a great patron of Jainism, who, according to Jinaprabhasuri ruled at Patliputra as ‘’lord of Bharata with its three continents, and was the great Arhanta to establish Viharas for Sramanas even in non-Aryan countries.” The dominions of Samprati probably also included Avanti and Western India. [Reference cited from (ed.) R.C. Majumdar, The Age of Imperial Unity, pp.89-90]

Thanks
 
Quite informative. If I can nitpick, according to my understanding, most Ashokan edicts were either in Magdhi for the ones found in eastern parts of the country or in a language closer to Sanskrit for those edicts found in the western parts of country. Only those found in northwest seem to be in Khroshti. Brahmi as script seems to the common denominator. One of them found in present Afghanistan was bilingual, in Aramaic and Greek who may have been his subjects.

As far as BB Lal's view on MBh, I would refer to this link, which carries a picture of the trench that he dug in Hastinapur:

http://www.slideshare.net/sfih108/mahabharata-historicity-prof-b-b-lal

Purans, 4 of which are attributed to Jains according to my understanding, build on the 3 dynasties that I referred to earlier, may lead to an earlier date for MBh.

Friends no confusion at all.

Bear with us, have patience. The last few questions for the protagonists/votaries of Puranic time line on Maurya dynasty to ponder over and respond; and the matter stands settled.

The Majority of inscriptions/Edicts of Ashoka the Great are in Brahmi and Kharosti which means these languages were popular means of communication in those days; however, Pryag Prashsti of Samudragupta is in Sanskrit.

What a drastic as well as fantastic change during the life time of a single man!![Samudra Gupta/Ashoka the Great 321--370.. C.E.]


The coins of Samudragupta and his successors are a testimony of the fact that he and his successors were adherent of Hinduism and same is true of his successors who performed Ashwamedh Yajna and issued coins to commemorate these occasions whereas Ashoka after the Kalinga war was Buddhist in personal life and secular in State Politics as per his Edicts. How the two could be one person at the same time one a self proclaimed Buddhist and another a propagator of orthodox Brahmanical religion.

Then Rock Edict XIII conveys Ashoka's relations with Hellenic emperors/rulers with their names and another inscription tells about his only war [Kalinga].
Prayag Prashsti enumerates in 33 lines of one sentence in Sanskrit his several battles with over two dozen rulers and his relations with Yaudheyas etc.
So how Samudragupta can be accepted as Ashoka or vice versa?

In view of it one can deduce conclusion: They were two Great Jat Emperor of the yore.

Ashoka, the great was third among Mauryan Emperors who ruled from c. 273 BC to 232 BC [detailed discussion will follow on chronology of Mauryas separately] and Samudragupta Dharan Jat ruled over major parts of India from 335 AD to 375 AD.

PS: Discussion based on PRIMARY SOURCES IS WELCOME on the issue of Puranic Time Line [as applied to chronology of Jat Mauryan history ] advanced by B B Law & co.

Thanks and regards.
 
Thanks Naveenji,

This gives Mahabharata War to be in 900 BCE generally accepted by historians.

3102 BCE is rejected.
 
Last edited:
Ravi,

Good questions in this post and the earlier one. My understanding of Chandra Gupta's religion as Jain was only in his old age. During his reign as a king, I would claim that I have no idea about his religion but now with your questioning would lean towards Hinduism if what you claim is Magasthenes accounts. Here is a slightly different issue, if we question just this aspect of Greek sources then what other aspects can be rejected from Greek works, who I am sure had their own bards. If we believe them then yes Hinduism can be taken as the prevalent religion during Mauryan period.

The greek ambassador, Megasthenses, who went to the court of Sandrocottus( claimed to be Chandra Gupt Maurya), describes the religion as Bhagvatism or Hinduism or Vaishavism, not Buddhism.

One would have expected Buddhism or Jainism?

Did the religion of Chandragupt Maurya, who we are told was a Jain, and died a Jain, get completely ignored by the Ambassador and replaced by Vaishnavism in the Ambassador's official account?

Sounds a little odd, after all Megasthenes went to Court of the mighty Chandragupta ( conqueror of Greeks, who defeated and took their territory forcefully. Not only that, we are told the that the Greek ruler had to bow his head, and give his daughter in marriage to Chandragupta. The Greek ruler had to send an ambassador to the court of Chandra Gupta.

What do we find?.

We find, that the Ambassador writesb about Vasihnavism as the prevailing religion, and not a mention of Jainism or Buddhism at the Court of the Jain emperor!

There must be a simple explanation of this little lacunae on the part of Megasthenes.

Warm regards

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Quite informative. If I can nitpick, according to my understanding, most Ashokan edicts were either in Magdhi for the ones found in eastern parts of the country or in a language closer to Sanskrit for those edicts found in the western parts of country. Only those found in northwest seem to be in Khroshti. Brahmi as script seems to the common denominator. One of them found in present Afghanistan was bilingual, in Aramaic and Greek who may have been his subjects.


Some writers, e.g K D Sethna " Ancient India in new light' , think that the Greek portion is a later addition.

The greek portion is compressed, as if the inscriber had to inscribe the greek portion into a limited space, and the inscription is compressed to fit in.

That would push the greeks out of the Asoka time space.


Ravi Chaudhary
 
Back
Top