Huge row erupts over allegations against unit set up by Gen VK Singh

sumitjattan

New member
NEW DELHI: A huge controversy erupted on Friday over allegations that an intelligence unit set up by ex-Army chief Gen VK Singh misused secret funds to try and topple the Omar Abdullah government in Jammu & Kashmir with the Centre promising action if any serving or retired officer is found involved.

As the allegations in a secret Army report that the controversial Technical Services Division (TSD) was involved in unauthorized operations and financial wrongdoings triggered a political slugfest between Congress and BJP, a Union minister on condition of anonymity said a CBI probe into the "extremely sensitive" matter is not ruled out.

The defence ministry said it will take a decision about action on the Army report on TSD after its careful examination while asserting it had measures in place to prevent any such undesirable activities.

Stating that the report "impinges on matters of national security", the ministry in a statement, however, said it has not yet taken a decision on going for a CBI inquiry,

BJP questioned the timing of the report and claimed that Singh was being "hounded" for sharing the dais with its prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi at the Rewari rally five days ago.

The report was prepared by director general (military operations) Lt Gen Vinod Bhatia as part of a board of officers inquiry formed by Army chief Gen Bikram Singh to review the functioning of the top secret unit set up during the tenure of his predecessor.

The report submitted to defence ministry in March this year is understood to have recommended a probe by an external agency like the CBI.

The Union minister, who spoke of a possible CBI probe, said the government has taken serious note of the report.

Information and broadcasting minister Manish Tewari told reporters that the facts brought out in the report are "extremely sensitive" and if any person — retired or serving — is found involved in the matter, action will be taken.

"The contents of the report which have been mentioned in a newspaper are under active consideration of the government. If any malfeasance is found against any serving or retired officer, appropriate action would be initiated.

In J&K, political temperatures rose with parties including ruling National Conference demanding a thorough probe into the role of state minister Ghulam Hasaan Mir, who figured in reports of having allegedly received funds from TSD unit to topple the Omar government.

Mir, at present agriculture minister in the Omar government, termed these reports as "blatant lies".

A media report quoting an Army document said Gen Singh had allegedly misused the secret service funds to destabilise the Omar government, to pay off an NGO to try change the line of succession in the Army top brass, to buy off-air interception equipment and to conduct "unauthorized" covert operations.

Replying to a question on possible action against the retired Army chief and his team involved in this matter, Tewari said this is not a question of being individual specific, but it is more of a systemic and structural issue "wherein there are alleged actions which impinge upon the larger ambit of national security."

Tewari said the government does take such matters extremely seriously as it is its duty to do so and asserted that action would follow "after a probe".

"The facts mentioned in the report are in the cognizance of the government. If it is found after the probe that facts are true, then action will be taken against those who are allegedly involved in it, whether they are in service or have retired," he said.

Rejecting the charge that Gen Singh was being hounded after the Rewari rally and the Army report was politically motivated, Tewari said, "It is extremely surprising that whenever there is an allegation with regard to alleged subversion of an institution, you always find BJP prematurely jumping to the defence of such individuals.

"I am quite struck by the fact ... I hope that behind all these incidents there is not the invisible hand of the BJP," he added.

BJP spokesperson Nirmala Sitharaman said the allegations against Gen Singh sound absolutely curious and odd not just because of the timing but the contents of the report.

"It is obvious that the hounding of the retired army chief is being done because he was seen seated beside Narendra Modi at the Rewari rally," she said.

Lt Gen (retd) Raj Kadyan said allegations against TSD are serious and needs to be probed but raised questions, observing its contents are coming out just days after Gen Singh and Modi shared the dais. Maj Gen (retd) GD Bakshi also shared Kadyan's views.

The TSD was formed in May 2010 during the tenure of Gen VK Singh and its existence came to light in March last year when it was alleged that the unit had tapped the phones of defence ministry officials at the height of the controversy over the then Army chief's date of birth.
 
NEW DELHI: A huge controversy erupted on Friday over allegations that an intelligence unit set up by ex-Army chief Gen VK Singh misused secret funds to try and topple the Omar Abdullah government in Jammu & Kashmir with the Centre promising action if any serving or retired officer is found involved.

As the allegations in a secret Army report that the controversial Technical Services Division (TSD) was involved in unauthorized operations and financial wrongdoings triggered a political slugfest between Congress and BJP, a Union minister on condition of anonymity said a CBI probe into the "extremely sensitive" matter is not ruled out.

The defence ministry said it will take a decision about action on the Army report on TSD after its careful examination while asserting it had measures in place to prevent any such undesirable activities.

Stating that the report "impinges on matters of national security", the ministry in a statement, however, said it has not yet taken a decision on going for a CBI inquiry,

BJP questioned the timing of the report and claimed that Singh was being "hounded" for sharing the dais with its prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi at the Rewari rally five days ago.

The report was prepared by director general (military operations) Lt Gen Vinod Bhatia as part of a board of officers inquiry formed by Army chief Gen Bikram Singh to review the functioning of the top secret unit set up during the tenure of his predecessor.

The report submitted to defence ministry in March this year is understood to have recommended a probe by an external agency like the CBI.

The Union minister, who spoke of a possible CBI probe, said the government has taken serious note of the report.

Information and broadcasting minister Manish Tewari told reporters that the facts brought out in the report are "extremely sensitive" and if any person — retired or serving — is found involved in the matter, action will be taken.

"The contents of the report which have been mentioned in a newspaper are under active consideration of the government. If any malfeasance is found against any serving or retired officer, appropriate action would be initiated.

In J&K, political temperatures rose with parties including ruling National Conference demanding a thorough probe into the role of state minister Ghulam Hasaan Mir, who figured in reports of having allegedly received funds from TSD unit to topple the Omar government.

Mir, at present agriculture minister in the Omar government, termed these reports as "blatant lies".

A media report quoting an Army document said Gen Singh had allegedly misused the secret service funds to destabilise the Omar government, to pay off an NGO to try change the line of succession in the Army top brass, to buy off-air interception equipment and to conduct "unauthorized" covert operations.

Replying to a question on possible action against the retired Army chief and his team involved in this matter, Tewari said this is not a question of being individual specific, but it is more of a systemic and structural issue "wherein there are alleged actions which impinge upon the larger ambit of national security."

Tewari said the government does take such matters extremely seriously as it is its duty to do so and asserted that action would follow "after a probe".

"The facts mentioned in the report are in the cognizance of the government. If it is found after the probe that facts are true, then action will be taken against those who are allegedly involved in it, whether they are in service or have retired," he said.

Rejecting the charge that Gen Singh was being hounded after the Rewari rally and the Army report was politically motivated, Tewari said, "It is extremely surprising that whenever there is an allegation with regard to alleged subversion of an institution, you always find BJP prematurely jumping to the defence of such individuals.

"I am quite struck by the fact ... I hope that behind all these incidents there is not the invisible hand of the BJP," he added.

BJP spokesperson Nirmala Sitharaman said the allegations against Gen Singh sound absolutely curious and odd not just because of the timing but the contents of the report.

"It is obvious that the hounding of the retired army chief is being done because he was seen seated beside Narendra Modi at the Rewari rally," she said.

Lt Gen (retd) Raj Kadyan said allegations against TSD are serious and needs to be probed but raised questions, observing its contents are coming out just days after Gen Singh and Modi shared the dais. Maj Gen (retd) GD Bakshi also shared Kadyan's views.

The TSD was formed in May 2010 during the tenure of Gen VK Singh and its existence came to light in March last year when it was alleged that the unit had tapped the phones of defence ministry officials at the height of the controversy over the then Army chief's date of birth.

Ultimately Truth only will prevail... "Satyamev Jayte"... Ye raste me kanate aata rehte hain ... yehi to eik bahadur ka test hota hai...

RK^2
 
How the Congress is weakening and breaking the country brick by brick (one institution after another).

Now it is the turn of the Army. Congress supporters would be very happy how their Congress is tearing apart the country.
 
Its good that this thakar ka beej is getting the taste of his own medicine. He did everything to stop Gen Suhag, first jat to become the Army Chief through his totally biased reports.
 
Its hard not to sense some foulplay by Congress here. The timing of this event immediately after he shared the dais with Modi points towards an attempt to tarnish the Gen's reputation. Lets see what other news and articles tell us.
 
He has aa image of a very very honest person in Army :) , hesaid no to bribe money offered by one ex Lt Gen to pass the deal of Tartra Trucks

Its hard not to sense some foulplay by Congress here. The timing of this event immediately after he shared the dais with Modi points towards an attempt to tarnish the Gen's reputation. Lets see what other news and articles tell us.
 
Gen Suhag has some bad deals while he was head of SFF and I am again repeating an honest Thakar is far better the a corrupt Jat :)

http://www.dnaindia.com/india/1668992/report-promotion-recommended-for-lt-gen-dalbir-singh-suhag

For you might be. Not for me. I am castist man openly to be honest. It doesnt bother me what Gen Suhag is was or would be. What matters for me is that Ge Suhag is going to be first Jat to head the army. I feel and think that Jawans and JCOs who makes most from Jat fraternity in defence would feel great with this feat. Further I would be more happy if this Thakar spend all his life pension less.
 
I respect your honesty .. but Samar when Jats fought against Temur then also they didnt nominate a Jat as Senapati of their army ..i think a Gujjar was the head of that volunteer force ..and for some nation comes first then their caste

For you might be. Not for me. I am castist man openly to be honest. It doesnt bother me what Gen Suhag is was or would be. What matters for me is that Ge Suhag is going to be first Jat to head the army. I feel and think that Jawans and JCOs who makes most from Jat fraternity in defence would feel great with this feat. Further I would be more happy if this Thakar spend all his life pension less.
 
Sumit, I am confident and can guarantee you that Gen Suhag is an upright and honest officer with an impeccable record.


I would request fellow Jatland members not to write FOR and AGAINST Gen Suhag on this or any other forum as the internet is a very open media and any unintentionally wrong comment/opinion may prejudice his chances. Let us keep our fingers crossed and hope that we get the first Jat army chief without any hiccups. As it is, the world around us is not too happy to see Jats climb the ladder.

I thank all of you in advance for playing your part in ensuring your bit by not bringing up the General's name.
Gen Suhag has some bad deals while he was head of SFF and I am again repeating an honest Thakar is far better the a corrupt Jat :)

http://www.dnaindia.com/india/1668992/report-promotion-recommended-for-lt-gen-dalbir-singh-suhag
 
Abhik , i can understand your feelings to see a jat as COAS but giving such clean chits by only considering his caste is not correct . I am not passing any judgement i am just referring to one link of DNA .

Sumit, I am confident and can guarantee you that Gen Suhag is an upright and honest officer with an impeccable record.


I would request fellow Jatland members not to write FOR and AGAINST Gen Suhag on this or any other forum as the internet is a very open media and any unintentionally wrong comment/opinion may prejudice his chances. Let us keep our fingers crossed and hope that we get the first Jat army chief without any hiccups. As it is, the world around us is not too happy to see Jats climb the ladder.

I thank all of you in advance for playing your part in ensuring your bit by not bringing up the General's name.
 
If he did so then why govt of India is not putting him behind the bars , Dalal sahab he was born in military hospital Pune and i still believe no one can fake the DOB in MH but he was thrown out by considering one error in his NDA form what you call it a justice .

Sumit
Vk Singh is not honest he compromised national security for his own gains.
 
भष्टाचार के इस दौर मैं ईमानदारी की अपेक्षा न करे
 
Those allegations were ever proved?..was he proven guilty? now allegations are on gen. singh and you are saying he is a honest man?..how ?

Very simple. Because he is supporting the Rambo. The atmosphere is so charged that if LeT Chief or any other dreaded terrorist comes in support of Rambo, some enthusiasts and spin doctors can go to the extent of condoning their criminality also.
 
I am saying he is honest because he said No to a bribe of 14 crore ruppes offered to him to pass the Tatra Trucks ... in which son of Chidambram was involved
and Govt was not starting an inquiry in his allegations against that Lt Gen , as Prashant you have some power to analyze the facts do it on your own and conclude it :) why i am saying he is honest

http://www.thehindu.com/news/nation...s-14-crore-says-army-chief/article3223758.ece

Those allegations were ever proved?..was he proven guilty? now allegations are on gen. singh and you are saying he is a honest man?..how ?
 
Cool now we are reaching to this level of discussion .........and SHAME ON YOU BY CONSIDERING A EX CHIEF WITH A TERRORIST.

I think you should be ashamed of yourself for not being able to make it out properly. This is not a comparison. This was to highlight the height of irrationality. Keep your cool.
 
Sumit bhai, dont over react like politicians.

Let me rephrase, even if a criminal comes out to support Modi, his followers will try and prove him a saint too.
Cool now we are reaching to this level of discussion .........and SHAME ON YOU By COMPARING A EX CHIEF WITH A TERRORIST.
 
Vikas let me tell you i have started this thread just to make clear that how easy to corner a person , and just support some one blindly as he/she belongs to some caste is not right way .... your argument on blind support to modi i think is based on the same philosophy
Sumit bhai, dont over react like politicians.

Let me rephrase, even if a criminal comes out to support Modi, his followers will try and prove him a saint too.
 
Back
Top