Rahul Malik (Jun 01, 2004 11:49 p.m.):
Respected Dr. Birbalji,
I'm not writting this post to support BJP/RSS or caste based system of hinduism. Never voted for BJP till date. I studied in a school run by one RSS child organisation for 1 year and saw there what they really are. They say something and do totally different when it comes to religion part.
What i feel is that jatland is not proper platform to teach such things. Not because it not the right forum to discuss such stuff, but as most of the peoples are educated here and everybody must be having an opinion. Its really difficult to change jat's opinion (applies to all concerned parties on jatland).
Anpadh jat to phir bhi samajh sakta hai, par padha likha kaabuu main aana muskil hi hai.
Its better u put your point than let other think over it and decide on their own rather than saying same thing again and again.
Few humble requests:
Each time you post something to uplift the jat community, you talk about what E.V.R. Naicker did in Madras state (now Tamilnadu). Why can't we have one such fellow who start here in jats? In my opinion the person who should start this revolution, should be the one who knows in & out about 'Naicker'. It’s time for us to practice rather than preach, preach and just preach.
As per your statement, Muslims are not treated fairly in india, so they are perfectly right if they are celebrating pakistan victory. Greaaaaaaaaaaaaaat.....
And no comment on gujrat riots and godhara incident, as i have never gone through all the information (As i don't have access to that classified info). But what i feel is that whatever happened in godhara was wrong and the riots were worst and gujrat gov. could and should have controlled that or otherwise vajpayee should have acted strongly by removing modi.
"I feel disgusted when I see a Jat praising Hinduism. There is nothing in it to be praised."
First of all can you define what is hinduism? As anil rightly pointed out you are mixing hinduism and caste system. Most of the jats follows Arya samaj and even if not you can't force religion on someone.
regards,
Rahul
Dr. Birbal Singh (Jun 01, 2004 02:36 p.m.):
Dheeraj,
The basic reason behind my posts is for the uplift of the Jat community and raise members' awareness of the evils of Brahmanical Hindu Religion represented by BJP/RSS/Shiv Sena. More than 50 years ago when E.V.R. Naicker started doing this in Madras state (now Tamilnadu) one of the arguments used by his opponents was that the state's progress will suffer without the Brahmins. Well, look back and you find that he literally eradicated this evil religion and the state is now lot better off. Of course, when the people say 85% of India is Hindu, they include Tamilnadu as Hindu state but it really is not. The Northern India is today far behind the South because of the rising influence of these crooks.
If you have seen some Muslims celebrating Pakistani victory, I would ask you a simple question - are the Muslims truly treated fairly in India? The massacre in Gujerat was sponsored by the government with the excuse of a phony incident in Godhra (I have gone through all the information and found no evidence of that incident being a Muslim activity).
The propaganda artists of BJP/RSS have devised these kind of questions to divert attention of people from real issues. There is no need for us to regress to the past as it has been done by some Muslim countries.
You should also realize that India's superiority in nuclear research over Pakistan can be credited to Dr. Homi Bhabha and Dr. Kalam, both non-Hindus.
People like Bal Thakrey have used innocent/trusting people to serve their own cause. Only a couple of weeks ago I read an article that all the leaders of Shiv Sena send their kids to English medium schools but they preach Hindutva for the rest of us.
One of the direct result of the evils of Hinduism is the wretched poverty in the lower castes of India. The country can not progress unless every child has a reasonable access to education and opportunities. From now on I tell you just look carefully at the crowds on TV news in various countries and you will find how pathetic is the general situation is in India even compared to Pakistan. I feel shocked when I look at images on tv of Indian people and see basically a sick looking populace. Is India really "shining"?
I feel disgusted when I see a Jat praising Hinduism. There is nothing in it to be praised.