Jat Doctor accused for rape by Medical Student

Status
Not open for further replies.
I just read at http://ibnlive.in.com/news/medical-student-alleges-rape-by-mumbai-doctor/96622-3.html

To me it looks like a very calcuated move by girl to malign/take revenge. To me it looks like a Plot to screw up the career of this guy.

He may need some help in this matter any one of us who live in Mumbai and have access to some kind of adminstrative/legal system.

These cases are hard to prove either way. But women have an upper hand in India in these cases if they can afford a good lawyer and are educated. Not the same for poor women ... who get raped willy nilly.
 
Bhai yeo bhee kerda he kaam say saal bher tai paata hee nahi chalya.

Bhai yea tey nayarey hee case aan lagey bolo saal pechhey report kari hai or police ney bhee wo doctor dher liyea. Bhai key unpadh thee jo eak saal tak chup bethi rahi or doctor ney 10 bar rape ker diya. Ya tey sochi samjhe sajish laagey hai chahey wo docotor kee ho ya us ladkee kee. Ismey jo bhee doshi ho usey kadi saja milnee chahiyea.
I just read at http://ibnlive.in.com/news/medical-student-alleges-rape-by-mumbai-doctor/96622-3.html

To me it looks like a very calcuated move by girl to malign/take revenge. To me it looks like a Plot to screw up the career of this guy.

He may need some help in this matter any one of us who live in Mumbai and have access to some kind of adminstrative/legal system.
 
Poor guy... I think there should be law to protect the identitiy of the accused also until he/she got convicted.

Guys is getting curses from all over the world and we all can see that he is not on fault..
 
Unlikely event….what happens generally boy and girl meet like Harry mat sally…goes for coffee (in this case mausambi juice mixed with seductive as girl claimed) few chat on the phone followed by SMS’s…some daulague of maine pyar kiya…some hanging out in the park or mall….and finally boys says I like u followed by I love u….boy promise to marry her in order to get… u know……..??? after sometime girl feels she is been taken for granted…some confrontation…boy is about to complete his masters and about to move his native palace….now what… dramatic turn of event…..girl file for complaint even before he could fled..

Ya poor guy couldn’t understand the रणचंडी side of women….in most of the cases girls keep mum…boz of defamation of her image…here she taught a good lesson to the guy…wht that guy thought woman is a lolly pop or a candy…you pay nothing for what u get….whatever case may be… my sympathy is neither with the man nor with the woman…both are gone with the wind…
 
Last edited:
Sudeep gave very clear idea about how things work now a days...

I belive these kinda of situation gernally comes because of casual dating..
 
Bhai sahab aajkal aisa hi chal raha hai..
hamare pados main ek jat family hai .
usmain ladke ki wife ne dowry ka case kar diya hai ladke waalon ke khilaaf..
ab ismain interesting bata yeh hai ki ladke ki wife ki age 40's main hai aur inke 3 bache hain bade ladki engg college main pad rahee hai..

ab batao shadee ke 20 saal baad dowry ka case..??

problem yeh thi ki ladke ne apne father ko ek car gift main de dee jo uske wife ko pasnad nahee aaya .. aur jhagadna shuru kar diya..


abhi kuch month pehle ek khabar aaye the noida se jahan ladke ne apni wife ki family pe jabardatsee dowry dene ka case daal diya tha..
 
Talli ek hath teh na bajya karti..........

Bade bhaiyooo....mainne nahi bera ke sach sai......par itna bera sai ....galti us chore ki bhi hogi kimme na kimme teh......rape case chota mota case kona honta.....arrr koi chori aapni bejatti karwa ke rajji na hoya kare......ib usne bhi dhokebazi kari hogi chori gaila jibbe chori ne nyu kara sai.......

Ib ghane swaad len ke chakkara me teh nu e howega....ya teh kise teh kimme vaade na karooo...arrr karo teh usne nibahoooo.....


baki bera e pat jyaga...kon gunhegaar sai.....:cool:
 
Unlikely event….what happens generally boy and girl meet like Harry mat sally…goes for coffee (in this case mausambi juice mixed with seductive as girl claimed) few chat on the phone followed by SMS’s…some daulague of maine pyar kiya…some hanging out in the park or mall….and finally boys says I like u followed by I love u….boy promise to marry her in order to get… u know……..??? after sometime girl feels she is been taken for granted…some confrontation…boy is about to complete his masters and about to move his native palace….now what… dramatic turn of event…..girl file for complaint even before he could fled..

Ya poor guy couldn’t understand the रणचंडी side of women….in most of the cases girls keep mum…boz of defamation of her image…here she taught a good lesson to the guy…wht that guy thought woman is a lolly pop or a candy…you pay nothing for what u get….whatever case may be… my sympathy is neither with the man nor with the woman…both are gone with the wind…

Yeah, I agree .... and by this standard, I think all girls in the U.S. Europe etc are rape victims.
 
Yeah, I agree .... and by this standard, I think all girls in the U.S. Europe etc are rape victims.



Girl is drunk and she says yes - it isn’t rape.
girl is not drunk and she says yes -it isn’t rape.

girl is not drunk and she says no- it is rape.
girl is drunk and she says no- it is rape.
^
^
What is not and is Rape?


However, we all know about 'weekend' under the influence 'fun' when it comes to europe. And we are also aware about Alcohol's effects on human mind, reasoning.

At the end oneself is responsible( alcohol intake) for himself/herself.

He may need some help in this matter any one of us who live in Mumbai and have access to some kind of adminstrative/legal system.

Why we, by the way?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I agree .... and by this standard, I think all girls in the U.S. Europe etc are rape victims.


They may or may not....there sex doesn't come with the promise of the marriage unlike in india...both the partner are very clear right from the beginning wht they want from a relationship...and if it works someone become domestic or spouse.... if not part the ways and move on ....noone carry any baggage...here girls ask do whatever bt promise me the marriage..........though we too have western influence...girls too experiment with their sexuality with no string attached
....
 
Girl is drunk and she says yes - it isn’t rape.
girl is not drunk and she says yes -it isn’t rape.

girl is not drunk and she says no- it is rape.
girl is drunk and she says no- it is rape.
^
^
What is not and is Rape?


However, we all know about 'weekend' under the influence 'fun' when it comes to europe. And we are also aware about Alcohol's effects on human mind, reasoning.

At the end oneself is responsible( alcohol intake) for himself/herself.



Why we, by the way?

I agree....:)
 
I may be getting judgmental.. I am looking into the situation as "Guy is victim"..
Both had fun from last one year.. and now she wanted to offload the baggage.. I am sure she was not kid that she bartered 3 letters words with assurance of marrige.. If she is in bartering then she can't claim rape :(:(
I don't know the guy.. just thought that its a very common situation and anybody can be a vicitim of this kinda of harrassment....
 
kya pata kiski galti ha dono bhi galat they tabhi to yeh kaand ho gaya. aise rape k case ko baareki se dekhna chaiye aur doshi ko saja deni chahiye lekin case ko uperi taur par dekhne se lagta hai ki ladki ko kuch wada kiya gaya tha sex ke badley jo ki pura nahi hua so ek saal baad rape ka case thok diya. waise yeh batao ki ab woh ladki kaise siddh karegi court mein ki uska rape huya.
 
bade bhaiyooo....mainne nahi bera ke sach sai......par itna bera sai ....galti us chore ki bhi hogi kimme na kimme teh......rape case chota mota case kona honta.....arrr koi chori aapni bejatti karwa ke rajji na hoya kare......ib usne bhi dhokebazi kari hogi chori gaila jibbe chori ne nyu kara sai.......

Ib ghane swaad len ke chakkara me teh nu e howega....ya teh kise teh kimme vaade na karooo...arrr karo teh usne nibahoooo.....


Baki bera e pat jyaga...kon gunhegaar sai.....:cool:

भाई कुछ दुष्ट चरित्र की लड़किया नै हथियार बना लिया इस तरह का .
आपने जाट भाइयो को बचना चाहिए इसी लड़कियों से खासकर परदेश में .
आज कल कानून भी मजाक होता जा रहा है . चाहे कोई 75 साल की बुडिया
50 साल पहले के रेप का इल्जाम लगा दे तो भी एक बार तो कानून उसे
गिरफ्तार कर ही लेगा . चाहे अगले दिन उसकी जमानत हो जाये . पर एक दिन
में उसकी इज्ज़त तो माटी में मिल ज्यागी . मैं ये नही कह रहा की डॉक्टर देशवाल
ने उस लड़की से सम्बन्ध नही बनाये होंगे . पर उस लड़की की मर्ज़ी रही होगी और
अब अनुचित मांगो पर आ कर केस कर दिया . शाहनी वाले केस में कम से कम ये तो था
की उसकी नोकरानी ने तुंरत केस कर दिया . एक साल तक इन्तेज़ार तो नही किया . रही
बात कानून की तो अभी कुछ दिन पहले किसी मर्डर काण्ड में पुरे परिवार समेत एक साल
की लड़की का भी नाम लिखवा दिया . और अगले दिन उस एक साल की लड़की की जमानत
कोर्ट से करवानी पड़ी . तो क्या जज साहब के दिमाक का दिवाला निकल गया था जो बिना
जमानत उस लड़की के नाम को इस आधार पर बाहर नही निकाल सकता था की एक साल की
लड़की मर्डर नही कर सकती . और अब उस लड़की पर फसला होने तक केस भी चलेगा .
 
It's not really a good thing to a bias/pre-judgement in such a sensitive case. It might be the case that initially it started with what they thought as love or may be the girl thought as love and the boy always knew he wasn't that serious and the girl could actually feeling cheated etc. There have been reports that the guy is not co-operating with police investigations.
But probably what Yudhvir was trying to point to was the problems with the law but chose a wrong case.
It's true that these laws are being miused quite a lot and people should protest against these.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top