Jatland and Sikh Jats

  • Thread starter Thread starter rajeshsindhu
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
"I tend to agree with those who want Jatland to essentially remain a Hindu Jat forum. But why cant we offer an observers facility to all other Jats who may visit the site but not comment on members debates and discussions. They could however leave their comments and opinions on a special Visitors book type of page."

I think what Amit Ji has suggested should be a fine solution for the time being??
 
Bhai Rajesh

You have put some very strong point which helps all to agree(some may be still disagree)
that A JAT IS A JAT IS A JAT.

In haryana or UP you never say I am from Haryana Or UP,you just say first that you are a JAT.

In Punjab Also a Jat will never say He is a
Sikh.He will say assi jatt Haa !!

So A JAT IS A JAT IS A JAT.

DHANYAWAAD
Tsaaya Maanash
 
bhai,
saare bhaiyaan ke vichaar padhe.kuchh iske paksh me bolen se to kuchh iske virudh bhi se .
par bhai main to nu a kahoongaa ki ya jatland jaatan ki rahe to badhiyaa se.
baaki bhai mahre te bade ghane a baithe se phaislaa lena unka kaam se.hum to khaalee salaah de sakan saan.
 
I dont think we have anything in common with sikh jats , let it be a hindu jat site.
We are more sensible than them
 
.... and after looking at www.jatt.com.... we should not even consider them as jats they are senseless traitors who should be kicked out of india.

my opinion is :NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
1.they stand for khalistan
and we are for bharat, akhand bharat
deviod of bania-brahminical tyranny.
2.they can share water with pakistan
but not with haryana,they cannot be us.
3.they find hinduism stupid and it is not
acceptable for us .
4. and last but not least for them
jat history starts with sikhism
for us it is long journey from
scynthea to plains of ganga
and yamuna.... our struggles
and our triumphs
salute to jat courage and values for which
we stand and live!

JAT BALWAN JAI BHAGWAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
This is to tell my jat brothers & Sisters that it was the daughter of a Brahmin(Indira Gandhi) that Prmopted them to seek Khalistan by playing one against another. Bhinderawale was her creation. SYL is a issue that no politcal part want to resolve but using it play Punjab/ haryana game for their own benefits. It was under the unselfish leadership of Ch. Chottu Ram that all Jats(Hindu, Muslim, Sikh) stood together.Don't let one website make your opinion change.We Jats(Hindu/ Sikh) are 3-4% of population but how many ministers / army chief we have or had. It has been and wil be a brahmin/ Bania SARKAR because we are divided and play in their hands.
 
Jats are Jats. They may be from any faith. In the progressing in 21 centuary we should not have reservation like this.

We share common great history. We may have followed various paths but now with the advent of more and more knowledge we have to get rid of such narrow attitudes.

Why only Jats, I dare to say that anyone having genuine interest in Jat culture or history should be allowed to participate.
Knowledge is not any one's patent right. If some one wants to contribute in positive manner why not?

Let us learn from each other.Show maturity. Accept criticism. In modern times unfounded rigidity among the castes has to go.

We can surely make a bigining by including Sikh and muslim Jats in Jatland.com. In fact when I wrote about origin of jats, many of the postings as given in one of sikhnet site gave me a totally new and realistic insight. The strength in modern and democratic setup is in unity not in division. We Hindu Jats have to show some political maturity.

Bharatpur kindom was in real sense strenthened by Raja Badan Singh who for 14 yrs stayed in Jaipur Darbar and who's son was Sooraj Mal. It the time we show political maturity.
 
Bhai mein bhee katee Seema ji er Ompati Ji ki haan mein haan milaaonga.

Baat nyun sai ek eeb taahin jitne bhee sikh jatt mille sain unki gail baith kai batlaawan mein itna swaad na aaya jitna Hindu jaatan ki gail aaya. UP ka, Haryaane ka er Rajasthaan ka...ye teen jat sain jo milte hi connect ho jaawein sain.....

Doosra..ek pehlu yo bhee sai ek eeb to hum sab Humour section mein sardaaran ke chutkale post karlya saan er pad kai raajee bhee ho lyan saan. Eeb socho, er jai sikh jatt bhee aa gaye tai ke banegee....

Baajre ki khichdi mein to swaad sai par aade site pai jo khichdi banaigee usmein wo swaad konya millegaa....

-Anurag
 
Ya baat to bhai samajh mein na aawe. Jat sikhon ku doosre sikh to sikh hi nahin maante aur tum unhe hindu nahain maante. Unke baalkan ke byah bhi jaaton mein hi howen hain. Unka mhara khoon to ek hi hai, boli badle pai bhaichara to na badalta. yahan sabko aana chahiye. Jat ka dil bahut bada hota hai.
 
Dear All,

I may not be able to point out any view on this discussion.....BUT I Thanks to all of you for such an important conversation .....I have learned a lot.............

So thanks again and .......... Keep the Jat Sprit up.

Jai Hind
 
Its been a much prolonged discussion now without any concrete result. I am of the view, since we belong to this country we do have common things with almost all north indian communities, then why are we talking only for Sikh Jats. Is it because they have the word Jat there ?? That way if we go on finding common things then we could find many many similarities with other communitites as well. Then why not add them all.
I see many of our members saying that we should think progressive and should not be back laid in 21st century etc. etc. So Dear All, if that is the case and we already are so progressive, then why is there a need of any Jatland at all ???????
In the next session - how about comparing ourselves with the Rajputs, we do have common things with them and of course the marriages take place between jats and rajputs...
Going through all views I feel still there is not much substance is adding up the Jat Sikhs and if there is at all, then Jatland doesn't make any sense. ABHISHEK, I do agree with you. What you said is so true !
 
hi all

we earlier also had debate about mulla jats in the site, i think reading all views common consensous is that this site is for jats only and if any other community will be allowed here then it will dilute the importance and charm of the site
rohit
 
This site is for JATS not JATTS! and that should close the topic once for all.
 
bhai sandhu.. m teri bat t puri trha agree hu..jat ar sikh jat m beshak bhasha ke lahje ka antar to.. pr h to ek hi..jato me yhi kmi rhi h.. kaththe hon tai phlai..zagda... sikh jato ne jat nam ko universal recognition diya h..ye dunia me hr jgha phunche h..aap inke punjabi gane suno.. jato ki kitni badai gate h jato ki.. gurdas man.. harbhajan man..they all are jats..and they all are very proved on being jat... maf kriyo bhaiyo..pr mumbai me 10 saal ke anubhav se bta rha hu ki desi jat to kitne hi aise h jo bahar aate h to btane se ktrate h ki wo jat h... pr in sikh jato ne to london ho ya NY har jgah jato ka nam roshan kiya h...
 
I agree 100% with Harvinder. Also they will be rather mix with Hindu Jats than Punjabi Hindus. They have lots of respect for Jats of Haryana.
 
I believe Jats can be most logically represented by a race sharing a common gene pool. Faith, region and religion may change with time but blood/gene is really a stable entity.

If we try to divide on different bases, then we may end up as individual. I favour a respect to Jat race while discussing such issue.

So called other jats may have their own such sites, but if somebody wants to go with us should be welcome.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top