Khap Relaxes Gotra Marriage Norms

drrajpalsingh

New member
Gathwala Khap, the largest Khap of the Malik gotra Jats living in Haryana,

Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and elsewhere, has decided in a meeting not to

take into account the gotra of grandmothers in the marriages. The meeting

is reported to have decided to support stringent punishment for rape accused

and create social awareness against female foeticide. Foundation was laid of

KHAP CHABUTRA at Ahulana village, the nikasi village of the Malik-Gathwala gotra.

for detailed report : www.tribuneindia.com
 
Last edited:
Rajpalji,


I was not able to open the detailed report, firewall restrictions.

Does it have a clause: If grandmother is not alive, then it can be relaxed or how?
Otherwise, rishto ko hotchpotch mach jayegi old grandmother ke liye..
 
Pasting content of link :

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2013/20130618/haryana.htm#12

Gathwala Khap relaxes gotra marriage norm
Our Correspondent
​
Sonepat, June 17
The Gathwala (Malik) Khap, the largest khap of the Malik Gotra Jats, unanimously resolved to relax a norm pertaining to gotra marriages. The khap has decided not to take into account the gotra of grandmothers in
such marriages.
These decisions were taken at a khap panchayat held at Ahulana village near Gohana on Sunday. The panchayat was presided by the khap dada (social head), Baljit Singh Malik, and attended by representatives from different states. The khap also decided to support stringent punishment for rape accused and create social awareness against female foeticide and dowry menace. Malik also laid the foundation of a ‘Khap Chabutra’ at Ahulana village.
Later talking to mediapersons, Malik said the Gotra’s “nikasi” had taken place from Ahulana village and not from Chhichhrana village. He said the khap would take action against those who were allegedly making false claim of ‘nikasi’ from Chhichhrana village.
Prominent among those who attended the panchayat were former minister Ved Singh Malik and Kulbir Singh Malik from Haryana, gotra’s second in command, Dada Har Kishan from Uttar Pradesh, Kanshi Ram from Rajasthan, Baldev Singh from Punjab and Azad Singh, Bhupinder Singh and Joginder from Delhi.

==========================================================================
I also heard something same days back ------it is in case if grandmother not alive as per what I have heard . No such thing mentioned in the article though .
Also somebody help me understand what does " such marriages " indicate .
 
Last edited:
Gathwala Khap, the largest Khap of the Malik gotra Jats living in Haryana,

Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and elsewhere, has decided in a meeting not to

take into account the gotra of grandmothers in the marriages. The meeting

is reported to have decided to support stringent punishment for rape accused

and create social awareness against female foeticide. Foundation was laid of

KHAP CHABUTRA at Ahulana village, the nikasi village of the Malik-Gathwala gotra.

for detailed report : www.tribunechandigarh.com

Excellent. Right now due to changing economic and social circumstances, the main emphasis of community should be marriage of a girls at earliest marriageable age. Girls are the main pillars and strength of our society and community.
If we loose them we loose genes and blood of our ancestors.
We know the good social value that girls carry in our community therefore, it is necessary to preserve these community values within community.
 
Pasting content of link :

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2013/20130618/haryana.htm#12

Gathwala Khap relaxes gotra marriage norm
Our Correspondent
​
Sonepat, June 17
The Gathwala (Malik) Khap, the largest khap of the Malik Gotra Jats, unanimously resolved to relax a norm pertaining to gotra marriages. The khap has decided not to take into account the gotra of grandmothers in
such marriages.
These decisions were taken at a khap panchayat held at Ahulana village near Gohana on Sunday. The panchayat was presided by the khap dada (social head), Baljit Singh Malik, and attended by representatives from different states. The khap also decided to support stringent punishment for rape accused and create social awareness against female foeticide and dowry menace. Malik also laid the foundation of a ‘Khap Chabutra’ at Ahulana village.
Later talking to mediapersons, Malik said the Gotra’s “nikasi” had taken place from Ahulana village and not from Chhichhrana village. He said the khap would take action against those who were allegedly making false claim of ‘nikasi’ from Chhichhrana village.
Prominent among those who attended the panchayat were former minister Ved Singh Malik and Kulbir Singh Malik from Haryana, gotra’s second in command, Dada Har Kishan from Uttar Pradesh, Kanshi Ram from Rajasthan, Baldev Singh from Punjab and Azad Singh, Bhupinder Singh and Joginder from Delhi.

==========================================================================
I also heard something same days back ------it is in case if grandmother not alive as per what I have heard . No such thing mentioned in the article though .
Also somebody help me understand what does " such marriages " indicate .

Usually in the case of Jat marriages, In addition to avoiding the gotras of the boy and girl and the gotras of their Mothers, it was a practice to avoid the gotras of their grandmothers. The violation of this practice was not allowed. Now the condition of avoiding the gotras of the grandmothers [DADI and Nani] has been waived in such marriages as decided by the Malik-Gathwal khap.
 
Rajpalji,


I was not able to open the detailed report, firewall restrictions.

Does it have a clause: If grandmother is not alive, then it can be relaxed or how?
Otherwise, rishto ko hotchpotch mach jayegi old grandmother ke liye..

Friend,

There is no such clause.

Rather, the avoidance of Grandmother's gotra has been removed in toto [This means the grandmothers are alive or not is no longer a condition as reported in the Tribune newspaper under reference. Dada of the Gathwal clan is shown in photograph addressing the media and report has been published ]. Kindly log in this link :
www.tribuneindia.com and read Vol. 133 no 167 Haryana Edition, Chandigarh page 7 dated June 18, 2013.

Thanks and regards,

{The inconvenience caused to you by erroneously typed earlier link is regretted.}
 
Gathwala Khap, the largest Khap of the Malik gotra Jats living in Haryana,

Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and elsewhere, has decided in a meeting not to

take into account the gotra of grandmothers in the marriages. The meeting

is reported to have decided to support stringent punishment for rape accused

and create social awareness against female foeticide. Foundation was laid of

KHAP CHABUTRA at Ahulana village, the nikasi village of the Malik-Gathwala gotra.

for detailed report : www.tribuneindia.com

i think, it is already not considered( grandmother gotra) in some jats from UP/Sonepat and some part of rohtak as well. Rajpalji, do you know what are the others gotar which has allowed the marriage in grandmother gotar?
 
Good step, Hopefully other Khaps will follow. Even though it might have been in practice, but it is official now. It makes a big difference.

Gathwala Khap, the largest Khap of the Malik gotra Jats living in Haryana,

Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and elsewhere, has decided in a meeting not to

take into account the gotra of grandmothers in the marriages. The meeting

is reported to have decided to support stringent punishment for rape accused

and create social awareness against female foeticide. Foundation was laid of

KHAP CHABUTRA at Ahulana village, the nikasi village of the Malik-Gathwala gotra.

for detailed report : www.tribuneindia.com
 
Friend,

There is no such clause.

Rather, the avoidance of Grandmother's gotra has been removed in toto [This means the grandmothers are alive or not is no longer a condition as reported in the Tribune newspaper under reference. Dada of the Gathwal clan is shown in photograph addressing the media and report has been published ]. Kindly log in this link :
www.tribuneindia.com and read Vol. 133 no 167 Haryana Edition, Chandigarh page 7 dated June 18, 2013.

Thanks and regards,

{The inconvenience caused to you by erroneously typed earlier link is regretted.}


Not marrying into your own blood is an ancient way of not doing "inbreeding". Inbreeding is bad and has been scientifically proven by every kind of science, it leads to inferior progeny with genetic problems. Our ancestors were wise and intelligent people who did not allow "inbreeding".

Recent changes are good and will allow Jats to maintain their gene pool and population growth.
 
Last edited:
Not marrying into your own blood is an ancient way of not doing "inbreeding". Inbreeding is bad andhas been scientifically proven by every kind of science, it leads to inferior progeny with genetic problems. Our ancestors were wise and intelligent people who did not allow "inbreeding".

Recent changes are good and will allow Jats to maintain their gene pool and population growth.



अगर इन्ब्रीडिंग को मानते है तो दादी का गोत्र छोड़ना चाइये। ये कहना सही नहीं है की ये फैसला ग्रोथ के लिए गुड है इसलिए लिया है। हकीकत ये है की छोरे रांडे घुमे है। कोए सा न कोए सा गोत आगे अड़ ज्या है। मज़बूरी में लिया गया फैसला है मेरे हिसाब से।
 
Some people were saying HMA is against jats. By this act Jats are trying to get in sync with HMA.
 
i think, it is already not considered( grandmother gotra) in some jats from UP/Sonepat and some part of rohtak as well. Rajpalji, do you know what are the others gotar which has allowed the marriage in grandmother gotar?

I am not aware about this practice adopted or declared openly by any other Jat Khaps.
 
Agreed!

In Rajasthan still Jats avoid 4 gotras (includes Nani gotra) whereas in Haryana or UP Jats generally avoid 3 gotras and that too being shrinked to 2 gotras. This is certainly not in good taste. What happened to our advocating of avoiding gotras earlier? What about scientific reasons which we always use to back it. In helplessness if this decision has been taken then at-least please don't welcome it.

Btw, why not Jat khaps come with proposal to marry Jats of different region, I mean we should start promoting marriages inter-state. Rajasthani Jats have lot of unique gotras so is with UP Jats. I believe it's better idea than relaxing gotra of Dadi.

your thoughts ..


अगर इन्ब्रीडिंग को मानते है तो दादी का गोत्र छोड़ना चाइये। ये कहना सही नहीं है की ये फैसला ग्रोथ के लिए गुड है इसलिए लिया है। हकीकत ये है की छोरे रांडे घुमे है। कोए सा न कोए सा गोत आगे अड़ ज्या है। मज़बूरी में लिया गया फैसला है मेरे हिसाब से।
 
I am not aware about this practice adopted or declared openly by any other Jat Khaps.

पश्चिमी उत्तर प्रदेश में तो दादी के गोत्र को ज्यादातर जाटो ने बहुत पहले (लगभग 20 - 25 साल) ही छोड़ दिया है और पश्चिमी उत्तर प्रदेश में खाप के चौधरियो की ज्यादा ना चलती | खाप तो बस नाम की रह री है इस क्षेत्र में |
 
Agreed!

In Rajasthan still Jats avoid 4 gotras (includes Nani gotra) whereas in Haryana or UP Jats generally avoid 3 gotras and that too being shrinked to 2 gotras. This is certainly not in good taste. What happened to our advocating of avoiding gotras earlier? What about scientific reasons which we always use to back it. In helplessness if this decision has been taken then at-least please don't welcome it.

Btw, why not Jat khaps come with proposal to marry Jats of different region, I mean we should start promoting marriages inter-state. Rajasthani Jats have lot of unique gotras so is with UP Jats. I believe it's better idea than relaxing gotra of Dadi.

your thoughts ..

पढाई करते समय कॉलेज के पुस्तकालय में आयुर्वेद से सम्बधित एक किताब पढ़ी थी नाम तो याद नहीं अब पर जो बात पढ़ी थी वो याद है | उस किताब में शादी और आनुवंशिक रोगों के बारे दिया था| भावी पीढ़ी के शारीरिक और बौद्धिक विकास के लिये निकट सम्बन्धियों में विवाह वर्जित है| आयुर्वेद में कहा गया है पिता की सातवी पीढ़ी तक के विस्तारित परिवार और माँ की पांचवी पीढ़ी तक के विस्तारित परिवार में शादी नहीं करनी चाहिए |

सगोत्र विवाह सिर्फ अनुवांशिक रोगों और विकृतियों से बचाव करने की वजह से निषेध है |
 
पश्चिमी उत्तर प्रदेश में तो दादी के गोत्र को ज्यादातर जाटो ने बहुत पहले (लगभग 20 - 25 साल) ही छोड़ दिया है और पश्चिमी उत्तर प्रदेश में खाप के चौधरियो की ज्यादा ना चलती | खाप तो बस नाम की रह री है इस क्षेत्र में |

सही कह रहे हो आप | लेकिन मैंने पश्चिमी उत्तर प्रदेश (यानि अपने आस पास के इलाको में ) खापो के प्रभाव ओर उनके बारे में जानने की कोशिश की थी पर कुछ खास नहीं पता चला | मुज़फ्फरनगर तक तो खाप का अस्तित्व समझ में आया पर वहा से आगे कुछ नहीं मिलता |

मेरा उत्कंठा अभी भी है ? यहाँ मेरठ ओर आस पास में कोन सी खाप सक्रिय है समझ नहीं आता | ओर में ये भी जानने का इच्छुक हु की हम मतलब (सिरोही ) किस खाप के अंतर्गत आते है ? किसी भाई को जानकारी हो तो बताने का कष्ट करे ?
 
I am not aware about this practice adopted or declared openly by any other Jat Khaps.

Khap bhi saari jagaha kahan Rajpal sahab, they are also between meerut and rohatk only. I ll try to check to get back to you kyunki rohtak side se ek baar kisne ne mere liye rista btaya tha n unhone kaha tha dadi ka gotar hum to nhi taalate.
 
Khap bhi saari jagaha kahan Rajpal sahab, they are also between meerut and rohatk only. I ll try to check to get back to you kyunki rohtak side se ek baar kisne ne mere liye rista btaya tha n unhone kaha tha dadi ka gotar hum to nhi taalate.

What do you say about Sheoran Khap. To the best of my knowledge and belief, they still avoid four gotras.
 
पश्चिमी उत्तर प्रदेश में तो दादी के गोत्र को ज्यादातर जाटो ने बहुत पहले (लगभग 20 - 25 साल) ही छोड़ दिया है और पश्चिमी उत्तर प्रदेश में खाप के चौधरियो की ज्यादा ना चलती | खाप तो बस नाम की रह री है इस क्षेत्र में |

Maybe this thing has made Jats more weaker in Utter Pradesh. We must not forget, Jats are agriculturists and Utter Pradesh has one of the largest farm area. Farm landholdings in Jat agricultural areas is decreasing very rapidly. To maintain the agricultural land area, Jats should migrate to outer regions capable of good agriculture, this migration must always be in form of groups and must be backed by structural organizations like Khaps, Village units etc. Jats from all the areas like Punjab, Rajasthan, Haryana, Western Utter Pradesh must join hands to expand agricultural area.
Times are changing, due to land pressure and population pressure India will soon need lot of food. Right now due to bad logistics and supply chain grains/food get wasted but as soon as this logistics of food supply gets better, good times for farmers will start. In next few years India will not be able to afford bad logistics for food/grain supply.
Another point is the way we do agriculture will also change due to climatic conditions and economics of Agriculture. Right now India farmers are following a traditional scientific way of crude farming. This will not sustain much longer, newer scientific ways of farming will come into action as population pressure and commercialization of human life happens.
 
Agreed!

In Rajasthan still Jats avoid 4 gotras (includes Nani gotra) whereas in Haryana or UP Jats generally avoid 3 gotras and that too being shrinked to 2 gotras. This is certainly not in good taste. What happened to our advocating of avoiding gotras earlier? What about scientific reasons which we always use to back it. In helplessness if this decision has been taken then at-least please don't welcome it.

Btw, why not Jat khaps come with proposal to marry Jats of different region, I mean we should start promoting marriages inter-state. Rajasthani Jats have lot of unique gotras so is with UP Jats. I believe it's better idea than relaxing gotra of Dadi.

your thoughts ..


I have only heard of this sort of "relaxation" in the Rohtak-Sonipat belt. Most people leave 4 Gotras
 
Back
Top