minorities nd madrasas

Status
Not open for further replies.

ratheetheraist

New member
Isn`t it time , sixty years after becoming independent, for india to give up this business of minoritism nd get on with life like one whole nationand one whole people???

how long are we going to treat muslims, especially as a minoritywith special reservations in govt. jobs and special provisions for admission to educational institutions???
 
Quiet A Good Suggestion!!!!

No doubt things like reservation shd be put to an end now....but how far is it possible???? When constitutional provisions were under construction and debates were going on in the parliament at the time of independence, reservation was considered as one of the remedy to bring backward classes forward and to check its viability parliament approved it for just 15 yrs so as to see the results.
But things turned out totally different, politicians started reaping fruits out of this reservation policy in form of votes and didnt want to loose all those precious minority votes which continuously kept them in power.....so something which was started as a remedy measure became a power consolidater......as a result reservation is extended everytime at such a juncture so as not to face the wrath of minorities.
Now its not that easy to finish it at one go...........ITNI DOOR AANE KE BAAD WAPAS JAANA AASAAN NAHIN HOTA!!!!! SO NEED SOME STRONG MEASURES AND STRONG SOULS!!!!
 
It should be on Economic Factor basis only, BUT NOT any MORE on CASTE BASIS. The reason for this is, the reservations are currently being used repeatedly by the beneficiaries with in the respective sectors, who already benefited out of that but not the new beneficiaries from the very sectors.

If it would be on Economic Factor basis, the benefit will go even to the real needy People with in the current reservation sectors, along with the other real needy People in the remaining society.

How can one decide whom to born? do we have right to chose our parents? how can our government give advantage/disadvantage depending on whom we are born? current reservation system is absured, it should on economical ground or domecile based, people residing in underdeveloped area should get benefit not those who can afford posh bunglows,,,,:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
 
Wasnt going into - Army Census. But is relevant here too

Not just appeasement, but a design to undo India
Wednesday February 22 2006 00:00 IST
‘Swonia Gandhi has asked for a list of minorities – read Muslims – employed in the education, health, telecom and power sectors in the states and also at the Centre. This is not any Bajrang Dal activist accusing Sonia of appeasing Muslims. This is what Priya Ranjan Dasmunshi, the Information Minister in the UPA headed by Sonia Gandhi as the chairperson, proudly claims.

Thus, what would be normally an accusation against Sonia is proudly proclaimed as her programme by her fans! The news report from Kolkata says quoting Dasmunshi that following a ‘‘categorical directive’’ from UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi, the government is working on an ‘identical survey’, that is, headcount in other areas. Thus that she was the one who directed the Muslim headcount in the Army is now admitted by her own UPA minister.

It would be unintelligent to dismiss the ‘categorical directive’ as just another ‘secular’ game for votes. The directive conceals far more. A deeper danger – than mere desire to transform Muslims into ballot papers – is inherent in it. Not just as a consequence, may also be as a design. It needs a closer look as it touches a sensitive issue, the Hindu-Muslim issue.

Balanced Hindu-Muslim relation is key to India’s progress. Yet, it has been mishandled time and again. Tinkering with this sensitive relation on trivial political expediency has cost the nation dear both in the pre-partition India and in free India. Most national issues have been converted by pseudo- secular politics into Hindu-Muslim issues, like Article 370, Common Civil Code, Bangladeshi infiltration, even TADA and POTA.

It is in this background that Sonia is unveiling the agenda of headcount and reservation in the Army. She knows that ‘secular’ India will not oppose it as that will be perceived as opposing Muslim interests. It will fall on Hindus to oppose this anti-national agenda. Once this happens, yet another national issue will be turned into a Hindu-Muslim issue! More. Reservation for Muslims in the Army will be opposed by the Army and by the Hindus and, therefore, will not happen. This will persuade many Muslims to feel that the Army which is a truly secular and constitutional institution is a Hindu outfit.

One can imagine how anti-national the Sonia agenda is. It will not stop here. From there the vote-hungry political parties will poll-promise to the Muslims that they would make what cannot happen to happen. The consequence will be a Hindu-Muslim clash with the ‘secular’ politics taking sides with Muslims.

This is precisely the West would want in India today. The present-day West, which is founded on Christian civilisational values, is in direct clash with traditional Islam. What started of as a political clash has expanded into civilisational and religious clashes and has begun retailing violence even as it incubates more of it.

The West is today seen as anti-Islamic and Islam is seen as anti-West. The cartoon controversy is only the tip of the iceberg. So the West desperately needs to deflect the attention and energies of Islam away from itself. It has to share its anti-Islamic game with non-western geographies. What other geography is ideally suited for this experiment than the India which houses the second largest Islamic population along with overwhelming majority of non-Muslims, essentially Hindus.

So a clash between the Hindus and Muslims in India will suit the western strategists as that will dilute the image of the West as anti-Islamic and also reduce the volume of the threats it faces from Islam. The agenda unveiled by Sonia Gandhi, even though seen as a vote-catching gimmick, has the potential to create clashes between the Hindus and Muslims in India, even if it is not aimed at such result. So what Sonia is doing compliments the agenda of the West for India. So Sonia’s new agenda should not see as just an appeasement of Muslims. It is designed to undo India.


Members may recollect that the West has never forcefully asked Pakistan to stop the terrorist activities in India. If anything, they have been covertly supportive of pakistan not only against India but also Russia.
The West always called J&K a disputed terrritory. UK knows very well, that legally whole of J&K belongs to India.
In their strategic calculations, Pakistan could always be compelled to do their bidding. While, Indians were considered independent minded. They wee not wrong. Today Indian economic might is a threat to their hegemony that has been giving them luxurious lifestyles at the cost of poor third world.
Supporting Islamic militancy against India had another advantage. It kept the Islamic terrorism focussed towards a Hindu India, while the West merrily milked the Arabian oil.
Post 9/11 the situation has become even worse for the West. The frankestien of Islamic fundamentalism has become too big to contain and hatred against the West has only been growing. It was way back in 1905 that Russians had warned the British against jacking up the Islamists in India to contain the Indian Freedom struggle. After a century, their own wicked creation has become a threat to West itself.

Paradoxically, India is at the receiving end of both of their unholy games.
 
Muslim quota must in all jobs and school/colleges

Muslim quota 'a must' in all jobs, schools

Kanchan Gupta/ New Delhi

Sachar Committee note lists demands, says have a Muslim on SSB ---- Muslim "intellectuals, NGOs, activists and academicians" with whom the 'Prime Minister's High Level Committee For Preparation of Report on Social, Economic and Educational Status of the Muslim Community of India' has interacted so far have demanded that "there should be at least one Muslim on each selection board, including the SSB (Services Selection Board)" that conducts recruitment tests for the Defence forces.

The committee, headed by retired Justice Rajinder Sachar, is in the eye of a raging storm over its audacious attempt to gather information about the number and ranks of Muslims in the defence forces by writing directly to the service chiefs.

Muslims have also petitioned the Sachar committee to recommend that "affirmative action should be taken for bringing the representation of Muslims in the police force at par with their population in every State." In other words, they have demanded proportionate representation in the police through the quota route.

These and other demands are listed in a note on "Issues raised at meetings with, intellectuals, NGOs, activists, academicians and district representatives, business community, youth and later discussed with Chief Ministers, Chief Secretaries and other state level civil and police officers" prepared by the Sachar committee.

"Whenever recruitment is going to be made the intention of the Government should be widely publicised through print and electronic media in the local language in the areas of substantial Muslim population," the note says, adding, "The district Superintendents of Police may have meetings with the officers of Employment Exchange and public and service commissions; the latter may organise special registration camps in areas of substantial Muslim presence. The actual process of recruitment should begin after all this exercise is in place."

The committee has also listed the demand that "there should be Minority Cells in UPSC, AICT, CBSE, IITs, etc." At another place, the note says, "Reservation (for Muslims) in jobs and educational institutions is a must."

But, if and when Muslim quota is institutionalised, "In Government employment Muslims who qualify on merit should not be counted against their quota of reservation (general or OBC, as the case may be)," the note says. It asserts, "Clear instruction should be given by the Governments to Public Service Commissions and all others. Rules of procedure should not preempt the policy of reservation given to Muslims."

The note lists several demands for proportionate representation of Muslims in politics through either the reservation route or nominations: "Muslims should be nominated, like Anglo-Indians, to Parliament, Assemblies and municipal bodies, wherever their representation falls short of their population percentage... Autonomous Councils should have Muslim nominees."

There is also a demand to fix a "quota for Muslim beneficiaries of Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan." The committee has been asked to recommend generous funding for madarsas and their registration without following established procedures. "There is a strong case for relaxation of norms of recognition of educational institutions established by Muslims," according to the note.

While "Muslim history has been tarnished in many text books and should be corrected," Muslim NGOs "should be allotted land for building schools" and "those who are in the process of establishing schools for Muslims should be helped out by way of having a soft corner."

Government should "happily and quickly accord minority status to those institutions who apply for it," the note says. As for Aligarh Muslim University, "Central HRD Ministry's order for 50 % reservation for Muslims in AMU is laudable," the committee has been told.

But "the recent Allahabad High Court order nullifying it as well as the minority character of AMU should be undone through parliamentary legislation."

Muslims have demanded, according to this note, that the Union Government should create a corpus fund of Rs 100 crores to be used for giving "loans to Muslims without charging interest".

They want that the "Central Government should pay interest from the education budget."

Moreover, "banks should be advised to simplify the loan disbursement process" for Muslims.

Significantly, these and scores of other demands are likely to form the bulk of the Sachar committee's recommendations to the UPA Government for planning. As well as formulating and implementing specific interventions, policies and programmes for Muslim welfare.

If the note listing the demands is any indication, communal quota could soon be a reality in every sphere of national life in India.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top