shailendra
New member
Bhai...ek baat to hai, the images that are being beamed across the world about the tragedy in New-Orleans and of the other close regions affected around it....are horrendous and are almost as bad as any recent tragedies (By the way; don't you just hate it when they keep repeating the word 'Third World Countries' in the news here...as if the word 'third-world' is some kind of a disease or a stigma!?!...)
But anyways, without trying to get into a debate about wat is happening here in the US (it's a tragedy no matter where it is) and/or what is being done or not being done (Articles in the news about racism; for example how the ones affected being mostly blacks, Bush admnistration not worried about helping them etc etc...of course the Urban Planning aspects; New Orleans was always below sea level and reciepe for perfect disaster forever etc etc)...I am gonna stay away from all that [maybe a discussion for some other post]...
But will just quote-unquote here from a recent Times of India article that caught the lighter (but at the same time true) side of the whole scenario. I mean really, look at the Tsunami in Asia, or the earthquake in Gujarat, and the recent floods in Mumbai....and then consider this natural disaster in the US, ....comparing the reactions of the people affected directly; one just wonders if the Americans are just super laid back, spoilt, complacent individuals that cannot tolerate undergoing even the smallest difficulties? I mean I can myself personally relate to you the oh poor me 'horror' stories that fellow colleauges in my office would relate about losing electric power in the house for a few measley days! (for those who don't know; the storm had gone thru Florida before it Hit New-Orleans with more strength)
Well, who knows!?! But anyways..here is some food for thought; read on:
'In New Orleans there was shooting and looting when the floods came last week. When a similar inundation struck Mumbai a month earlier, there was no violence, just free vada-paav.
Residents say street vendors passed out the vada-paav to their fellow citizens wading through waist-high water in a sign that the disaster brought the city together rather than tearing it apart as appeared to happen in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina.
The response seems to symbolise what South Asians say is the region’s familiarity with, and resilience in the face of, numerous natural calamities.
Would it be a fair assessment to say that many of the problems arose in the US as the people here are not used to facing calamities. They expect complete efficiency and find it difficult to cope if it does not come about.
Incidentally; Mumbai police commissioner AN Roy confirmed there were no cases of looting, arson or violence when the floods hit Mumbai.
"Even stray cases of robbery were not heard or reported," he said.
India has regularly faced natural disasters from earthquakes, storms and floods during monsoon. As a result, it has developed rapid responses for shelter and relief that while not wholly successful for long-term rehabilitation, have enabled them to handle immediate needs quickly.'
But anyways, without trying to get into a debate about wat is happening here in the US (it's a tragedy no matter where it is) and/or what is being done or not being done (Articles in the news about racism; for example how the ones affected being mostly blacks, Bush admnistration not worried about helping them etc etc...of course the Urban Planning aspects; New Orleans was always below sea level and reciepe for perfect disaster forever etc etc)...I am gonna stay away from all that [maybe a discussion for some other post]...
But will just quote-unquote here from a recent Times of India article that caught the lighter (but at the same time true) side of the whole scenario. I mean really, look at the Tsunami in Asia, or the earthquake in Gujarat, and the recent floods in Mumbai....and then consider this natural disaster in the US, ....comparing the reactions of the people affected directly; one just wonders if the Americans are just super laid back, spoilt, complacent individuals that cannot tolerate undergoing even the smallest difficulties? I mean I can myself personally relate to you the oh poor me 'horror' stories that fellow colleauges in my office would relate about losing electric power in the house for a few measley days! (for those who don't know; the storm had gone thru Florida before it Hit New-Orleans with more strength)
Well, who knows!?! But anyways..here is some food for thought; read on:
'In New Orleans there was shooting and looting when the floods came last week. When a similar inundation struck Mumbai a month earlier, there was no violence, just free vada-paav.
Residents say street vendors passed out the vada-paav to their fellow citizens wading through waist-high water in a sign that the disaster brought the city together rather than tearing it apart as appeared to happen in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina.
The response seems to symbolise what South Asians say is the region’s familiarity with, and resilience in the face of, numerous natural calamities.
Would it be a fair assessment to say that many of the problems arose in the US as the people here are not used to facing calamities. They expect complete efficiency and find it difficult to cope if it does not come about.
Incidentally; Mumbai police commissioner AN Roy confirmed there were no cases of looting, arson or violence when the floods hit Mumbai.
"Even stray cases of robbery were not heard or reported," he said.
India has regularly faced natural disasters from earthquakes, storms and floods during monsoon. As a result, it has developed rapid responses for shelter and relief that while not wholly successful for long-term rehabilitation, have enabled them to handle immediate needs quickly.'