Naxalism

Status
Not open for further replies.

chhillar

New member
The Centre has added four new states to the list of Naxalite-affected areas. The final list -- Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chattisgarh, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Orissa, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Uttaranchal, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal.

Naxalism kahan se aya, zaroorat kya thi iski, where are we all heading with it...koi ellaaj?
 
jatland me bi ek NAXALITE he....true 2 his core (no pun intended). he is nt around now a days--so, expectin him 2 throw sum light on dis topic,,wen he comes bk !!:)
 
deepshika said:
jatland me bi ek NAXALITE he....true 2 his core (no pun intended). he is nt around now a days--so, expectin him 2 throw sum light on dis topic,,wen he comes bk !!:)
You are a funny girl...
 
Is it Haryana's trun to be painted red?

chhillar said:
The Centre has added four new states to the list of Naxalite-affected areas. The final list -- Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chattisgarh, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Orissa, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Uttaranchal, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal.

Chillar ji you pre-empted me in raising this hair-raising issue. The naxalites, i feel are outsmarting the goverment and even as the centre is issuing the list naxal-affaected states, it has no idea that the problem is spilling over to otherwise unassuming states including, hold your breath Haryana as well.

Yes the the red brigade is eyeing the social conflict (read mainly Jat-Dalit conflicts) in the state to gain a foothold in immediate vicinity to the national capital. Former Hindustan Times journalist Sony Sangwan unearthed this story for CNN-IBN:

''Union Home Secretary V K Duggal met top police personnel and bureaucrats from 13 naxal affected states on Friday, January 13. The spread of left wing extremism to other parts of the country was discussed in passing. But when CNN-IBN Correspondent Soni Sangwan traveled to Haryana, she found out the problem is knocking on Delhi's doors.

Gurgaon (Haryana): You could have dismissed this as yet another routine Naxalite training camp in People's War Group territory. The only problem is that the CD used for training is now available at the Capital's doorsteps — in Haryana.

Jatland villagers are being inspired with propaganda smuggled in from far off Andhra Pradesh. And suddenly Left extremism seems quite close at hand, a stone's throw away from where the Home Ministry packages its policies on Naxalites.

An exclusive intelligence report titled A Brief Note on the Activities of CPI (Maoists) in Haryana in CNN-IBN’s possession shows why the administration has to be really concerned.

The report states that, "Maoists appear to have chosen to engineer caste conflicts as a part of their strategy to further their movement in Haryana. This they are attempting to do by choosing soft targets like the Dalits, labour class and students".

Flashback to the clash at the Honda factory in Gurgaon.

Glass panes were shattered and motorcycles on display, damaged when the Honda showroom was attacked

The owner of Honda Showroom, Ravi Jaitley, says that he did not step out of the showroom when they were attacked. "I do not know who these people were — they could have been terrorists or someone who hated us for some reason we don't know."

The repercussions of the clash at the Honda factory in Gurgaon on July 29, 2005 were felt in the sleepy town of Kaithal, Haryana.

The incident served as a wake-up call for the government, alerting it to the existence of Left wing extremist organizations in Haryana.

Ravinder, one of the men who was picked up from the spot for attacking the showroom, belongs to the Krantikaari Mazdoor Kisan Union — a Left Wing Organisation.

He is now in Jind Jail alongwith Rajesh Sandeel, the state president of the organization.

A look at the manifesto of the organization leaves no doubt as to its Maoist agenda.

The Krantikaari Mazdoor Kisan Union and other such frontal organizations are active in the Jind, Kaithal, Kurukshetra, Yamunagar, Hisar, Rohtak and Sonepat areas of Haryana.

Among these are the Jaagruk Chhatra Morcha, Shahid Bhagat Singh Mazdoor Morcha, Navjawan Dasta and Disha Sanskritik Manch.

These organisations cannot be linked to any of the known Communist Parties like the CPI or the CPI(M).

"CPI is a political party and all political parties have a right to try and establish a base," says Haryana Chief Minister, Bhupinder Singh Hooda.

On the face of it, these organizations are talking about a social revolution of sorts. But the recovery of the pamphlets of these organisations reveals a secret agenda that is linked to the Maoist organizations of Andhra Pradesh and Jharkhand.

However, Haryana Transport Minister Randeep Surjewala says, "The material that has come in — the pamphlets — have definitely not been printed here. It has come from other states. It is up to the police to find out more. If need be, we will call in other agencies as well."

What seems obvious is that the Red Corridor connecting Nepal to Andhra Pradesh now seems to be passing through the outskirts of Delhi.''

-Ends
 
Last edited:
Origin of the (Naxalite) Species

chhillar said:
Naxalism kahan se aya, zaroorat kya thi iski, where are we all heading with it...koi ellaaj?

Naxalism is the Indianised version of social struggles and draws its inspiration from the Chinese Civil War and Bolshevik Revolution 1917.

According to the Old (Naxal) Testaments, it started in a North Bengal village, Naxalbari, where a local revolt by farmers was fanned by an extremist faction of CPM and soon the problem spreaded its tentacles in almost whole of the rural part of the state.

Why it happened?
West Bengal, at that time, was one of the most industrialised states in the counrty. However, what the complacent Congress govenment couldn't see was that chasm between the rural and urban prosperity was increasing to dangerous proportions.

On China's behest, the extremist faction was working to organise its caders in the rural part to ''awaken'' the landless farmers.

On March 3, 1967, a group of such peasents in Naxalbari forcibly grabbed a peace of a Zamindar's land and began harvesting. In the subsequent clashes, dozens of people from both sides were killed. However the culmination came in March 25, literally a ''Red'' letter day in Indian history, when a full scale arm rebellion against the establisment got under way after police opened indiscriminate fire in the village killing unarmed women and children -- nine of them.

It was the turning point in the movement and immediately drew whole nation's attention. While the govt tried to quell the revolt, a vast number of students -- surprisingly many of them from the so called Burgeois -- joined the naxalites.

After createing much furore both in Indian and international media, the revolt lost its sting as, problably in that year itself or in 1969, the never-ending rule of CPM began in WB. Land reforms were executed and many other steps to placate the revolutionaries were taken by the new govt. Development as it happens in communist state became a taboo and the production touched its nadir in the state in 1990s.

The New Testament (How the movement was resusticated): Experts are divided on the issue. However, one school os thought says the movement spilled over from Nepal to caste-conflict ridden Bihar. Simultanousely, there was a latent discontentment amongst farmers in AP, tribals in Orissa, Chhatisgarh and Jharkahnd and extremist left forces, which were in hibernation, capitalised on the opporutnity to ressurect themselves. As a result we have whole of red corridor from Nepal to Andhra.

One pattern is, however, uniform in both the testaments: the so called development was not reaching the masses and small pockets were reaping rich benefits while the majority was starving.

Suicides by farmers in Andhra or Vidarbha, deaths due to hunger and starvation in Orissa and oppression of the Dalits in Bihar were not addressed by the media and government when they were basking under a Shining India and now find them overwhelmed by the magnitude of the problem.

I won't comment on the solution as of right now, I would like to see the response of the fellow Jatlanders first.
 
Last edited:
Naxalism arises from the "have-nots" jealousy for those who have everything. It is all rotten Bullsh*t that the rich exploit the poor. Such exploitation happens only in countries where there is no individual freedom, like in the old days in America when slavery existed. No one would perform any services if they really felt exploited. Try to force a rickshaw-walla to give you a ride at anything below what he expect for his services. He wont do it. He had rather move in.

It is true that naxalism arose from communism. It is more of a tool of the power hungry bast*rds to achieve power. Since, they operate in poor areas, the majority of voters get drawn to their bullsh*t agendas. Communists will never get a foothold in a prosperous state like Gujarat.

These naxals are twisted people. If you find them, save your ammo, and lynch them instead. And make sure you put them through hellish agony before you noose them.
 
I am a Marxist....

dahiyarules said:
Naxalism arises from the "have-nots" jealousy for those who have everything. It is all rotten Bullsh*t ....
It is more of a tool of the power hungry bast*rds......
bullsh*t....
These naxals are twisted people. If you find them, save your ammo, and lynch them instead. And make sure you put them through hellish agony before you noose them.

It is not that there aren't poors in Gujarat, but the poors there are not commiting suicides like in Vidharbha and Marathwada (Maharashtra) or Telengana and Rayalseema (Andhra). Nither the region is perpetually stricken with acute famine like in the KBK (Kalahandi-Balangir-Koraput) region in Orissa.

When the things become that bad, it's doesn't remain just jealousy against the "Haves". It becomes the natural struggle for survival.

Sitting here in the AC environs of my office, it is easy for me to dismiss the Naxalites. But atleast they are doing one thing very right, which had the government done, there wouldn't have been this problem -- that is REACHING OUT TO THE PEOPLE.

With regards from
-Daksh (I am a Marxist, a Groucho Marxist)
 
Ok dude!

You wont be saying that you were a Marxist, if you really understood the whole concept clearly.

People in those places you mentioned are committing suicides becuase the government has failed them. Government has failed everyone, the world over. There is not one place in the world where everyone who votes is happy with the government they have.

My point is that if your life sucks, it does not mean that you will rob and kill those whose life is better than your. Or I guess, it is not justified to destroy public property. I admit I am not a big fan of public property, but I also do not suppor tthe destruction of something that does not belong to you. Till date, the naxals have been a total menace in the sense that they have destroyed numerous public properties and killed thousands who got nothing to do with their nuisance. What about people not being able to take a train to work next morning, becuase te naxals blew up the railway line. What about the people seeking protection not having a police station, becuase the naxals blew it up. What about the parents who want to take their sick child to a hospital not being able to do so, becuase the naxals blew up the hospital. There is so much more I could say.

All this communist-Che Guevara kind of rhetoric make you feel good, but so do drugs. But most people dont do drugs, becuase they know it hurts them personally. But most people fall for the communist or for the matter of fact any anti-liberty agenda because it does not hurt them as personally. Look at yourself. You sympathize with these communists, but you had rather sit in your airconditioned office, most probaly working for some capitalist, offering services to people who pay your capitalist boss who in turn cuts out your pay check. If someday these communists were to come and seize your private property and put you on a comunal farm instead of this nice office job you got, for the sake of collectivism, you may not appreciate all the communist bullSh-t anymore.

The most important thing in this world is individual liberty. Look around you. If anything threatens individuals liberty even in the remotest possible way. it may not be the right thing. Communism is just one of them. It is plain and simple built upon oppression of individual liberty.


panward said:
It is not that there aren't poors in Gujarat, but the poors there are not commiting suicides like in Vidharbha and Marathwada (Maharashtra) or Telengana and Rayalseema (Andhra). Nither the region is perpetually stricken with acute famine like in the KBK (Kalahandi-Balangir-Koraput) region in Orissa.

When the things become that bad, it's doesn't remain just jealousy against the "Haves". It becomes the natural struggle for survival.

Sitting here in the AC environs of my office, it is easy for me to dismiss the Naxalites. But atleast they are doing one thing very right, which had the government done, there wouldn't have been this problem -- that is REACHING OUT TO THE PEOPLE.

With regards from
-Daksh (I am a Marxist, a Groucho Marxist)
 
Those are my principles.....

Dear Sumit,

The govts have failed me and you and I quote you ''everyone'', but it is not a question of survival for both of us. We know from where our next meal is going to come. Majority of people in the areas I mentioned are so sure.

And when the hunger eats up their logic, the naxalites come into action. They provide them arms and don't provide the food but show the easiest way (and I am not saying the right way) to get it.

We are discontented coz we feel the govt is not doing what's desired, they are reacting coz they feel the govt is doing nothing.

My point, and I stated it clearly earlier as well, that if naxalites can reach these tribals or farmers or dalits, why can't the govt?. Why can't it pre-empt them?

And our problem is that we just sympathise with 'em while they (the people sufferin and not the naxalites) need out empathy.

While the Indian media was going gung-ho over model Carol Gracias' ''top slip'' in the Lakme Fashion Week recently, eight farmers committed suicide in Vidharbha and did not get either the airtime or the column centimeter space they, I feel, deserved.

The most important thing is: Live and Let Live. Unfortunately, instinctively, it comes in that order of preference. I mean, if one is dying, he wont let me live either.

Lastly, I will still say that I am a Marxist, not Karl Marxist but Groucho Marxist.

Nota Bene: Those are my principles. If you don't like them.....well I have others. -- Marx, Groucho Marx.

With regards from:
Daksh

dahiyarules said:
Ok dude!

You wont be saying that you were a Marxist, if you really understood the whole concept clearly...........

...............The most important thing in this world is individual liberty. Look around you. If anything threatens individuals liberty even in the remotest possible way. it may not be the right thing. Communism is just one of them. It is plain and simple built upon oppression of individual liberty.
 
naxal word comes from the village of naxalbari. these people are hard core communist, who follow the principle that communism would be achived by killing the haves or the system who produced these haves.
 
Last edited:
Violence is a means to achieve political gains in a situation when the violent sides ideals and pricniples are inferior to those of the other side.

Communism was inferior to just anything else. It did not last even a century.

But, one thing is for sure. Communism is a good recruiting tool in a society that has a lot of "have note," to seize power. Look at any communist country, form the past or the present. The government becomes so strong, that the common man is not even a mere particle of sand in front of it.

Communism, naxalism, socialism, whateveryou may want to call it. It uses poor people against those who have power. Once these so called "peoples war groups," achieve power they totally distance themselves from the suffering. After the iron curtain fell in the Soviet Union and the eastern block , the world was witness to widespread suffering and poverty. If communism really was founded to get rid of poverty, then I would say it failed grandly.

Look at any prosperous society. It is the rich who create opportunities. After all, only the rich have the initiative to invest in capital and create jobs, because they want returns. Labor standards in "Captialist USA" are far better than the labor standards of any communist countries. People come here in millions every year by jumping the fence, and are willing to provide labor, even at standards below what could be considered legally feasible.

The rich need to be left alone. If the rich really did exploit the poor in a free society, the poor would have moved on to some different place or employer where they wont feel exploited. The secret behind a successful enterprise is a healthy workforce. Any capitalist would be more than glad to have a healthy work force, to get higher returns.

Private media is a for profit organization. They really do not have any obligation to report something that does not help their viewership. And ina free society, you are free to switch to the media that fulfills your need. I am sure you came to know about the farmers' suicides from somewhere. So there is a mdia outlet that is serving your needs.

The problem is the government. We agree on that. But the solution is to decentralize government and let those provide the services who have an incentive to remain in the business as a service provider, as their profits are at stake.

You get rid of the government, and replace it with another government. But government is just as it sounds. No government ever has had a good incentive to serve the people. The only govenrment that fits your desires is the fictional one that I can think of: Ram Rajya. ood government has never happene din reality. Give me one example of good government. I am waiting.
 
Jat Association

Hello JAT BHAIYON
i m an active JATLAND MEMEBER.
i need ur help... if u can do i'll be highly grateful to u .
Can u give me any idea that HOW I CAN JOIN JAT ASSOCIATION?
i wanna to be da member of JAT Association.
plz suggest me
any JAT association centre is thr in Bangalore or not ?
plzzzzzzzzzzzz reply me soon

waiting for ur reply

bye n thanx

App sabka Chhota Bhai

shivraj Choudhary
 
started frm naxalbadi {w.b}

chhillar said:
Naxalism kahan se aya, zaroorat kya thi iski, where are we all heading with it...koi ellaaj?
.If some one examines the issue ,,,,, my views are valid...:) The problem of naxals is not a new one. Infact, it started just after few years of Independence.,,,,,,,Naxalism is not a problem, it is a solution.” It indicates how the left-extremists are pushing ahead their 'solution' ,...' poor people have considered naxalism not as a problem but as a hope for solution to their problems of food, clothing ,, shelter ,,,,, for bringing Justice, Equality, Liberty ,,,,,,,,Two dozen Naxalite groups are active, not just in Andhra Pradesh, but eight other States as well.,,,, aur iibey too aur bhi pakkan laag rahey sey,,,,,,,,:)

This naxal groups r not the representaives of the citizens. These forces r running a parallel government ....... As of now the naxals even collect tax(extortion) from the contractors (20% for the road and 10% for the building work). They also collect Rs.50/- and 2 k.g of rice per house per month in the name of house hold tax. Anyone, who creates obstacles for the naxals or disobey them is being sentenced to death. Where as three persons were brutally murdered in a village on the charge of opposing naxals; another five persons were subjected to capital punishment on the charges of being police informers.................................jahanabad incident aur naidu landmine blast ,,naxaliyaan ki, sabtey baddi achievement thee,,,,,,,,, naxli,,,, naidu ney "world bank agent " kehyaa karein,,,;)

..Govt of AP has started talks with Naxalites to solve the issue......The halting of police action against Naxalites, inviting the Naxalites for talks and lifting of the ban ,,,and conveying the impression that the state is now eager to pamper criminals.On the eve of the talks, , a Naxalite leader was quoted as saying: 'By going to the talks, we are not declaring any ceasefire... Talks are a part of our tactical line............
I wonder, how many more years the administration of India will take to uproot the problem completely :confused: :confused:
 
Article on Maoist influence in India

.
I thought it worthwhile to bring to the attention of worthy members an article which appeared in today's press.

Maoists who menace India
Philip Bowring
TUESDAY, APRIL 18, 2006
INTERNATI0NAL HERALD TRIBUNE


HONG KONG If the murderous mess in Nepal can be said to have any silver lining, it is that it is finally spurring India to recognize the danger that Maoist rural insurgency poses to India too.

Naxalism (as this movement is referred to in India, after the district where it originated in 1967) is a serious menace in states stretching from the Nepal border through the most backward states of north-central India - from Bihar to Jharkand, Chhattisgarh and parts of Orissa, Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra.

Summoning ministers of six affected states to Delhi last week to discuss the problem, the ever-realistic Prime Minister Manmohan Singh declared that Naxalism was the "single biggest security challenge ever faced by our country."

Singh was not indulging in hyperbole. In the first three months of this year at least 235 people were killed in actions by or against Naxalites.

According to a former senior official of the Research and Analysis Wing, Indian's intelligence agency, some 20,000 Naxalites now have arms and are an important factor in states comprising 20 percent of India's population. There is no doubt now that the extent of Maoist success in Nepal has directly strengthened and emboldened the Naxalites, who can also claim to deliver votes in some rural areas and thus become a factor in state politics.

For a nation which has endured the running sore of Kashmir for decades, and more briefly faced a bloody Sikh secessionism in Punjab, the prime minister's remark was a remarkable admission of the extent of divisions within India between the burgeoning prosperity in many areas and the disorder and lack of progress in others.

It should be an even greater shock to foreigners who believed that Islamic fundamentalism was in India, as everywhere, the main security threat. Maoism now has more followers in India than China.

Until recently, official Delhi - which includes much of India's news media - tended to look on Nepal's problems as specific to that kingdom and ignore those in rural Bihar and other states. These were seen as isolated outcomes of their chronic underdevelopment and corrupt politics.

Instead of admitting the problem of homegrown insurgency, much was made of allegedly foreign-inspired security threats such as the hill-country tribal unrest in the northeastern states or Islamist threats from Pakistan or Bangladesh.

Ironically, the conditions that have given rise to Naxalism are a reflection of one of the pillars of India's political stability - the decentralization that enables huge variations in language and social culture to be accommodated within a single nation but also leads to mammoth differences in social and economic conditions.

Bihar and Jharkand, for example, are not only among the poorest states, but also, according to the 2001 census, have literacy rates of only 47 percent and 54 percent, compared with 93 percent in Kerala and a national average of 65 percent.

Naxalites do not form a single group. They include committed ideologists and local brigands. But they find ready recruits among the weak and dispossessed, generally including low castes in rural areas oppressed by higher-caste landlords, and in tribal areas by those whose lands have been appropriated by the politically influential.

Low-caste and tribal Indians sense they have not been receiving the equality in theory offered by the law and constitution. Victims include landlords and money lenders, and railroads are a particular target of attack on the state. In short, class and caste warfare are both cause and effect of lack of social and economic progress.

It is not easy for the center to address abysmal state governance standards. Central rule can be imposed, but only for emergency purposes, which is not long enough to correct deep-seated problems. In any event, India's fragile multiparty coalition governments may require political alliances with some none-too-holy state- and caste-based parties.

That said, Delhi now seems to be waking up to the need to pay more attention both to security issues in these states and to find ways of using money and administrative influence to promote law, development and social justice.

It would be gross exaggeration to suggest that the revival of Naxalism poses a threat to India as a whole. Nepal is not its future. Nor should it cause investors to doubt India's performance and potential. But it is a reminder of just how diverse the nation is, and just how much effort needs to go into reducing inequalities while allowing state identities and cultural differences to flourish.

*
 
Hey Rupi Bhai!

I do not understand something. These Naxals are imposing their tyranny even before being elected to power by forcibly impsoing taxes, and executing people without any trial. If this is the state of their affiars before coming to power, one can only imagine what things will be like if they actually achieve power. So, how can you call these people the solution. I think they are wo

Everyone who knows me even slightly know how anti-government I am. I completely agree that government is the problem. Naxalism is a good example of government failure. Infact governments always fail. Hardly any government ever walks its talk. But Naxalism would be just like replacing one problem with another.

We elect governments to provide us with some basic services. In exchange we pay taxes. Just like we would go to a grocery store and pay 50 rupees for some stuff, we expect to get the worth of 50 rupees in return from the shopkeeper. If we get anything less than what we deserve, we would not take it easily. How many people would buy stuff for 40 rupees, and give a 50 rupee note to the shopkeeper and would just walk home after being told by the shopkeeper that he wont give them back their change. I dont know of one such person. So why does everyone keep mum and keep giving the government chance after chance when the govenrment fails to keep its word and give us services in exchange for the taxes that we pay?

Every successful society has a strong spirit of entreprenership. Private enterprise has the incentive to provide the best value for the money in order to remain competitive. Just like we would switch gorcery stores, if the previous grocery store provided inferior quality goods for our money, we as the consumer will have the power to switch serivices provider when the previous owner fails us. Those who support social viruses like "naxalism" as the solution for any nation are true enemies of the nation that they claim to love. Socialism, communism, or naxalism, whaever you may want to call it, is a social cancer that has been the reason of demise for several nations. Even the greatest communist power of all times, Soviet Union, fell like a house of cards, and adopted a free market system as the solution. China the modern day communist power has realized from the mistakes of the Soviet Union and has opened up its economy and is the fastest growing economy in the world. Nort Korea is the last standing true communist nation in the world. People are dying by thousands because of hunger and poverty in that country. While people need food and medicine, the government of North Korea is building nuclear bombs and missiles. The communists' priorities are totally screwed up. Communism claims to be for the people, but when it actually comes to practice it is not for the people anymore. It is just for the government. That is why communist nations have single party governments. They do not desire any opposition. They want to take the nation down the path to destruction without any obstruction.

I have written a lot on the "evils" of socialism. But I realize that Socialism is like a drug that disconnects a persons brain from their reasoning ability. People hardly use logic when they openly support socialism. If this is not the reason, then anyone who supports socialism in full senses is simply an evil person.

downtoearth said:
.If some one examines the issue ,,,,, my views are valid...:) The problem of naxals is not a new one. Infact, it started just after few years of Independence.,,,,,,,Naxalism is not a problem, it is a solution.” It indicates how the left-extremists are pushing ahead their 'solution' ,...' poor people have considered naxalism not as a problem but as a hope for solution to their problems of food, clothing ,, shelter ,,,,, for bringing Justice, Equality, Liberty ,,,,,,,,Two dozen Naxalite groups are active, not just in Andhra Pradesh, but eight other States as well.,,,, aur iibey too aur bhi pakkan laag rahey sey,,,,,,,,:)

This naxal groups r not the representaives of the citizens. These forces r running a parallel government ....... As of now the naxals even collect tax(extortion) from the contractors (20% for the road and 10% for the building work). They also collect Rs.50/- and 2 k.g of rice per house per month in the name of house hold tax. Anyone, who creates obstacles for the naxals or disobey them is being sentenced to death. Where as three persons were brutally murdered in a village on the charge of opposing naxals; another five persons were subjected to capital punishment on the charges of being police informers.................................jahanabad incident aur naidu landmine blast ,,naxaliyaan ki, sabtey baddi achievement thee,,,,,,,,, naxli,,,, naidu ney "world bank agent " kehyaa karein,,,;)

..Govt of AP has started talks with Naxalites to solve the issue......The halting of police action against Naxalites, inviting the Naxalites for talks and lifting of the ban ,,,and conveying the impression that the state is now eager to pamper criminals.On the eve of the talks, , a Naxalite leader was quoted as saying: 'By going to the talks, we are not declaring any ceasefire... Talks are a part of our tactical line............
I wonder, how many more years the administration of India will take to uproot the problem completely :confused: :confused:
 
only way out

dahiyarules said:
Hey Rupi Bhai!

I do not understand something. These Naxals are imposing their tyranny even before being elected to power by forcibly impsoing taxes, and executing people without any trial. If this is the state of their affiars before coming to power, one can only imagine what things will be like if they actually achieve power. So, how can you call these people the solution. I think they are wo



need food quote] sumit bhai,,,,, it is good to see the coin on both sides.naxals are right in their perception that a change will bring some betterment .....I agree with them, when they say we don’t have the basic needs accomplished.......On the other hand I’ll ask to think why few people are stinking rich when many are struggling with the poverty. Look at the economical differences .........they r working in their own fields but the prfoit goes to smbdy else.........:rolleyes: sm people r becomnig rich with doing nothing,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, if they feel that government is not putting any efforts,,,,,,,,,,,the only way is left,,,,,,I’ll appreciate the naxalities for their efforts in accommodating their people with the basic needs,,,,,its a fight for their dignity rights,n self respect............

if naxals destroy telephone exchange and railway track or railway stations,,,,,,i knoy that village wont get telephone exchange for another 5 years.....but,.wot is the use of an exchange and station if they r starving for roti,kapra ,aur makan...........:rolleyes: ,,, exchange aur stations fukna galat sey,,,,, lakin apni baat sarkaar laag pahuchaan ka yuey jariya hai,,,,,,,,bhagat singh ney bhi nuey assembly mein bamb pardya thaa....................

The youth needs to come forward to think on this to leading themselves, to acquire whatever they need.....i believe naxals need young,, sincere and innovative leader5ship.
 
Why are some people rich, while others are poor?

Let me answer your question by highlighting the fact that there are ample number of "rags to riches" stories that we know of. But, such stories happen in free/capitalist societies only. Why? Because free socieities provide wings to fantasies. If someone has an idea and an inititiative to capitalize on the idea, free societies provide them with the opportunity to do si.

So, prosperity has 4 prerequisites: Free Socieity, innovation, initiative and opportunity.

No one is rich because they broke into the bank one night (there might be one or two cases, but who knows ;-) ). People are rich because they have worked hard. Every rich person whether it is Ambani, Shahrukh Khan or Tendulkar, or even Bill Gates have their sob stories of struggling rich. Wealth did no fall on them. They struggled for it.

I would also like to point out that people work for rich capitalists out of their own will. Infact, right now so many youngsters are fighting for a limitied number of job in some private enterprise. Rich people do not enslave other people adn make them work. People will work for any wage that is above what they value themselves. No one would work at a wage that is below their worth. When people find their wages to be below their worth, they switch to higher paying jobs. The point is that people are not exploited by entreprenuers who are getting richer. People work for rich entreprenuers out of their own will and would continue to work happily as long as the wages are consistent with their worth. When it ceases to be the case, they move to different jobs.

Have you noticed something? The common hing between all poor people is that they rely a lot on the government. People are poor because they are not willing to perform to thier fullest potential. They trust the government watch their back. A farmer expects the government to set fair prices for his crops. He further trusts the govenrment with fertilizer, seeds, electricity and irrigation. Government is a highly inefficient entity. Government is the last institution that needs to be trusted with anything. When the government fails, is there a higher authority that a farmer can take his grivances to? No. Because when we trust the government too much with everything, government is the god. So what does the farmer do? The poor guy comsumes poison pills and dies. There is no recourse for his miseries.

On the other hand if the same farmer was being supplied seeds, electricity, irrigation and fertilizers by private providers, he would have a certain legal recourse in case the suppliers failed him. If the suppliers failed him the farmer would instead of consuming poison pills would sue the providers' a$$, and get monetary compensation for his damages. I am talking about a person being compensated for the disruption of his livelyhood. Isnt that too much for people getting 50 million dollars from McDonalds just for hot coffee being spilled on their laps. Only free society has the solution for peoples' grivances. Government is the problem.

Finally, my point is why would these people take their frustration out on public infrastructure like railway lines, telephone exchanges, hospitals etc when they have a problem with the government. There are people out there who are willing to pay for those services, and are not responsible for the naxals' miseries. But they have to suffer the naxals' wrath. This is totally unfair and unjustified.

Look dude, these guys have learned to kill to get what they want. I would never trust such people because someday they really wont care killing me or you to get what they want.

As I have always said, only those who have an inferior thought would raise arms to make their point. Because if their ideology was superior to others' it would have been accepted with open arms. Thats why communism wasalways forcefully imposed wherever it went. It was never accepted with open arms. Becuase people knew that it was an inferior school of thought. The disastrous second half of the last century proves my point.



downtoearth said:
dahiyarules said:
Hey Rupi Bhai!

I do not understand something. These Naxals are imposing their tyranny even before being elected to power by forcibly impsoing taxes, and executing people without any trial. If this is the state of their affiars before coming to power, one can only imagine what things will be like if they actually achieve power. So, how can you call these people the solution. I think they are wo



need food quote] sumit bhai,,,,, it is good to see the coin on both sides.naxals are right in their perception that a change will bring some betterment .....I agree with them, when they say we don’t have the basic needs accomplished.......On the other hand I’ll ask to think why few people are stinking rich when many are struggling with the poverty. Look at the economical differences .........they r working in their own fields but the prfoit goes to smbdy else.........:rolleyes: sm people r becomnig rich with doing nothing,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, if they feel that government is not putting any efforts,,,,,,,,,,,the only way is left,,,,,,I’ll appreciate the naxalities for their efforts in accommodating their people with the basic needs,,,,,its a fight for their dignity rights,n self respect............

if naxals destroy telephone exchange and railway track or railway stations,,,,,,i knoy that village wont get telephone exchange for another 5 years.....but,.wot is the use of an exchange and station if they r starving for roti,kapra ,aur makan...........:rolleyes: ,,, exchange aur stations fukna galat sey,,,,, lakin apni baat sarkaar laag pahuchaan ka yuey jariya hai,,,,,,,,bhagat singh ney bhi nuey assembly mein bamb pardya thaa....................

The youth needs to come forward to think on this to leading themselves, to acquire whatever they need.....i believe naxals need young,, sincere and innovative leader5ship.
 
still favouring naxals

dahiyarules said:
Why are some people rich, while others are poor?.



bhai sumit,,,,,, merea yu matlab koni thaaa,,,key y r sm people rich in india,,,,,,,, i wanted to say ......................
dat, rich are growing richer amassing huge benefits by exploiting the masses in the remote areas........... aur bhai,,,, jitney india mein rich sein ,,, wo saarey hard work koni kardey,,,,,,,,,,,most of them r involved in HAWALA and they r selling this country to imperialism,,,,,,,,,, b coz only a rich can afford hawala job........:rolleyes: ,,,,, garib aadmi ka too byoont sey koni hawala karan ka,,,,,,,

It is correctly being observed as 50 years of Pepsi independence than the People's independence............ The People are yet to have achieved that independence........... naxlis have choosen an alternate path,,,,Naxalbari movement has taken inspiration from the Chinese Cultural Revolution, ,,,,,,,,. The objective conditions in India were ripe for revolution at dat time,,,,,,,,, 30 years ago in Naxalbari and they are waging their struggle to achieve real independence. ......As dreamt by people like Bhagat Singh. :)

sumit,,,, when poor raise their problems,nobdy is there to help,,,,,,,,,,aur jab woo dusra raastey pey jaa le sein,,,,, jab saarey negotiation karan pahunch jein sey,,,,,,,,,,,,:rolleyes:

dude,,,, It's not so simple to understand or define revolution by using the word killing.........dont worry....;) :p ....

No revolutionary will kill anybody who opposes their ideology. In fact, killing is not the philosophy of any revolution. Revolution is to stop and resist exploitation.............dats it,.,,,,,,:) ,,,,, bhai sumit woo aapney tey ghanney badhiya sein,,,,,, apney ki dhaal aarey kagaz kaaley to na kartey,,,,,, at least they r fighting for their encroached rights...........
 
Being born as poor is not entitled to left out of mainstream and basic government benefits.
there is nothing for them, no food , no house,no education, nothing.
so first hand it appears that they are killing for these things. but it's not like that. they are fighting to be described as equal to anybody.
marx rightly desribe solution(revolution) for rule of man(capitalist govt) over man.
they are fighting at least for a cause they believe in.
here people fighting over the petty issues.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top