one liners

Status
Not open for further replies.

shashiverma

New member
Why the hell do we need to write one line in threads.....why can´t we use chaupal or pager or private messages if its one to one response and probably is of no interest for the other people who reads the thread. Sometimes its acceptable when its a general comment but if its something which may not be of relevance to the people who read the thread to find something sensible.....then why can´t we opt for other choices.........
Kabhi kabhar chalata hai......but now its more like a trend.
You do not feel like even looking inside threads now...
Although I was not at all interested to write this....but this is really irritating.
There are many of us who turn towards JL to feel the homely atmosphere when we are sitting away from our homes but nowdays it no longer appear to be homely.
Can´t each one of us take care of our responsibility towards the forum? Most of us are deterioting it everyday knowingly or unknowingly....
 
Last edited:
Why the hell do we need to write one line in threads.....why can´t we use chaupal or pager or private messages if its one to one response and probably is of no interest for the other people who open the thread. Sometimes its acceptable when its a general comment but if its something which may not be of relevance to the people who read the thread to find something sensible.....then why can´t we opt for other choices.........
Kabhi kabhar chalata hai......but now its more like a trend.
You do not feel like even looking inside threads now...
Although I was not at all interested to write this....but this is really irritating.
There are many of us who turn towards JL to feel the homely atmosphere when we are sitting away from our homes but nowdays it no longer appear to be homely.
Can´t each one of us take care of our responsibility towards the forum? Most of us are deterioting it everyday knowingly or unknowingly....

I suggested the same thing last month but for every suggestion there is always an intense reaction :)

http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?p=159723#post159723

Check, how people take it ! :)
 
kya farak padta hai.something is better than nothing.not everybody can participate in serious discussions and if people are interacting through these one liners i do not see any problem.thats the main goal of this site interaction among jats.
 
kya farak padta hai.something is better than nothing.not everybody can participate in serious discussions and if people are interacting through these one liners i do not see any problem.thats the main goal of this site interaction among jats.

Kisi ko Koi farak nahin padta, Ritu Didi. :)

But i suppose that jatland admins have provided better options to chat personally ...... instead of irritating other members.

If people can't participate in some serious discussion that doesn't mean that they must post there to 'interact' with others ........

Staying away is the best option when we don't know what to comment on the topic rather than trying to 'interact' there... and ....... :)
 
Last edited:
There is no point in writing 1000 words if one can't makeanything out of it. If one has to blabber, better it be a one liner.

I personally am averse to reading long essays here -- I get newspaper at home for that (and I don't even read that).

Just as it is upto individuals to write what they wish, no one, I am sure, is forcing the readers to go through every post.

I agree to an extent there should be minimum "bilateral talks" on the public fora, but again, that shouldn't be binding.
 
There is no point in writing 1000 words if one can't makeanything out of it. If one has to blabber, better it be a one liner.

I personally am averse to reading long essays here -- I get newspaper at home for that (and I don't even read that).

Just as it is upto individuals to write what they wish, no one, I am sure, is forcing the readers to go through every post.

I agree to an extent there should be minimum "bilateral talks" on the public fora, but again, that shouldn't be binding.

Well said. There is nothing wrong in writing one line response. If someone gets irritate by this he can ignore but u can't bind anyone.

aur phir bi jyada hi problem hai to filters lagawo do jatland par so one can search out posts by no of words written in this :cool::cool:
 
Title of thread is ambiguous

I feel, its not the length of post that matters. at many times one may sum up in one line better than one long paragraph. It depends on the nature of thread/post also. Sometimes yu just wish to write one line n sometimes yu need to elaborate more. Then it depends on individualistic differences also.

Nor it is about serious discussions or lighter notes. Every discussion/conversation/exchange of thoughts can't be serious.

What I can make out from Shashi's post,,, its not exactly the length of replies,,, rather its about the one to one interactional posts,,, where some members start communicating among themselves irrespective of the content of the thread. That personal dialogue can be avoided to keep the threads more intact, relevant and sensible.
 
ppl get irritated seeing such threads, not from oneliner. JL is not all about that mind boggling serious stuffs:rolleyes: .Come out of this slave mentality and avoid imposing restrictions everywhere.
 
I feel, its not the length of post that matters. at many times one may sum up in one line better than one long paragraph. It depends on the nature of thread/post also. Sometimes u just wish to write one line n sometimes u need to elaborate more. Then it depends on individualistic differences also.

Nor it is about serious discussions or lighter notes. Every discussion/conversation/exchange of thoughts can't be serious.

What I can make out from Shashi's post,,, its not exactly the length of replies,,, rather its about the one to one interactional posts,,, where some members start communicating among themselves irrespective of the content of the thread. That personal dialogue can be avoided to keep the threads more intact, relevant and sensible.

I second ur thoughts Neels Di ... :)
 
I
rather its about the one to one interactional posts,,, where some members start communicating among themselves irrespective of the content of the thread. That personal dialogue can be avoided to keep the threads more intact, relevant and sensible.


most of the time this one to one interaction is derived or based on that particular topic of discussion only…divertion from the topic happens only when the topic is almost dead or serious members are no more willing to discuss in it.… so if someone is enjoying then why the hell other should have a problem with it…

ab us topic ko lekar jisme one to one discussion saru ho jati hai uske liye pager msg karega kya koi.. ki aja bhai is topic ko weha discuss karte hai … rubbish idea…totally impractical..

I enjoy taking part in every type of discussion be it serious or be it humors.. lakin har waqt sensible sensible ke geet gane bi mere bus ki baat to nai hai bhai.... life is not all about speaking serious every time....

10-11 line to ho gai ab theek hai :D
 
Well I am not raising any point against one line if it contributes or is in some sense related to thread.
What i was talking about is one to one chat which begins in thread. I even mentioned kei sometimes chalta hai...but if it is setting a wrong trend..then its a problem.

Anyways discussing this do not bind anyone to stick to it......Everyone is free and sensible enough to move ahead with what they think is right according to them....

Kher.....we all free to move ahead with our choices...........
 
we all free to move ahead with our choices...........

This the most pertinent part....you said it yourself..:)

But, at the same time I feel its okay to voice your concerns if you feel like as you did. Thats the idea, freedom of expression which encompasses also the freedom to choose the way to express be it cartoons, long tedious essays (I,for one, hate reading them but love writing them if have time off hand...hehe:D) or a line (love single lines..:D) or the freedom to be in synch with the issue of the post or be off-track.

Lets leave it to the users judgement...Guidelines fail to last long on portals like this...
 
freedom of expression:) or a line (love single lines..:D) or the freedom to be in synch with the issue of the post or be off-track.

Lets leave it to the users judgement...Guidelines fail to last long on portals like this...

Fully agreed, but, lekin, kintu, Dr. sahiba, this time you seem to be 'awakened':D (not actually! aap to pehle se hi awakened ho! Apar, itna lamba-choda 'bhaashan' likkhan ki ke jaroorat thi;)). Mine seems to be 3 liner!:) Lagge rhao!!

Hail Jats:) (:confused:)
 
Martya Maanav ki vijay ka turya hun main
Urvashi! apne samay ka surya hun main

(I am the trumpet of victory of the mortal man
O Urvashi! I am the Sun of my era)


This is what Pururuva, the hero of the Gyanpeeth awarded 'Urvashi', a milestone poetry of Ramdhankari Singh 'Dinkar', the poet laureate of India, proclaims to Urvashi, his fiancée. However, in the same verse, Dinkar's own personality finds its vent. Dinkar, born in 1908 in a village of Bihar ( India ), is among those great poets of the world whose poems reflect a rare blend of romance and valor. These two seemingly contradictory attributes assimilated in Dinkar. 'Urvashi' culminates this double nature of the poet.
This poetry for which Dinkar received the Gyanpeeth Award, one of the highest literary awards in India , is the love-story of Pururuva, a valiant king who ruled a part of the earth, and Urvashi, a fairy of the heaven. In his entire work, Dinkar glorifies the station of man. In his opinion, a man's rank is even superior to gods. 'Urvashi' is a reflection of the same glory of mankind. While Urvashi represents the kingdom of gods, Pururuva stands for the valor of mankind. The most beautiful immortal maiden of the universe, Urvashi, falls in love with a mortal king and an enamored Pururuva accepts her. The power of love makes a mighty king so docile that though he can fight with a hundred lions but a smile of Urvashi makes him to surrender before her. Thus the earth and the sky meet in the embrace of a powerful love.
However, "Urvashi" goes much beyond this simple love-story. This wonderful poetry is an expression of the same dual nature of romance and valor, beauty and soul, love and reality, knowledge and aesthetic sense. But what the conclusion is? What do we need : truth or beauty? Which of the two leads us to the Supreme Reality? Dinkar combines these two aspects of life in one single philosophy: both lead to the same destination. Those who follow the path of rigorous practice, refrain from the shadow of mortal beauty so that their soul is not sullied, those who meditate and strive to see the Supreme Truth in their inner beings while the entire world is asleep, are endeavoring to find the same 'Object' as the lover finds in the sweet embrace of his beloved. Through a different road, the tides of knowledge transport us to the world of Supreme Reality. Through yet another different road, the waves of beauty take us to that realm where the Most Beloved Beauty is seated.
'Urvashi' declares the victory of love. And victory of love is the victory of this mortal plane, the Earth. We are here in a world where flowers bloom, rivers warble, birds sing, bees hum. Love is the intrinsic force here. How can we remain untouched? Where will we escape? So why not to welcome it? But how? What is love? Is love there in the flesh? Does love reside in hugs and kisses, touches of warmth and desires of physical union? Dinkar says that this physical body is the emerging point of love because a form is needed for love's birth. However, once born on the physical plane, love denies the limits of bodies. Once the fledgling of love is born out of the shell of the physical being, it strives to soar high in the realm of soul. And there it finds the Supreme Reality and there it meets the Most Great Beloved.
 
Indeed a good suggestion!!, especially about the runaway types of one liners which have farthest correlation with what is being discussed and are positioned at "the mere display of Hazirjawabi:rolleyes:". But as always, everyone needs to be self desciplined and restrained enough...and one or the other point of time everyone digresses as well.......Kind of paradox..but still relevant discussion to bring forth the need to minimise this one liner culture.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top