Present Economic Tide in Asia and its repercussions

Status
Not open for further replies.

rkumar

Active member
Dear Friends,

These days you read any news on world economy; you will find India and China always in limelight. Figures on China's consumption of raw material are mind boggling when it comes to items like steel, Copper, Aluminium and cement. President Bush is alarmed at the India China factor being responsible for the global Oil price rises. It’s very heartening to read India's name at last among the list of powerful nations. Very countries that ignored us till few years back, are now taking first available flights to cultivate new relations. We will be hearing some very exciting news during coming months and years about the progress made by India in various fields.

However, this pace of development, which is directly related to the consumption of natural resources, brings very important questions, which I am sure any economist would already know. Let me quote Mahatma Gandhi on development;

"God forbid that India should ever take to industrialism after the manner of the west... keeping the world in chains. If [our nation] took to similar economic exploitation, it would strip the world bare like locusts".

Think of above quote when applied to China. I have very strong conviction that India and China will strip the world bare of all natural resources in not too distant future and this is going to become a major cause of International conflicts in very near future. While present economic development of India is very important and must take place by all means, we better start applying our minds to the next phase of development, which will have to take place in the absence or under sever competition of natural resources. India should start mobilising more funds for research and development of new technologies, which would not require conventional raw materials as inputs. Use of Hydrogen as fuel, solar energy for most of domestic use, water management to the highest possible degree of recycling etc will all become essential for nations to survive. I can see the world already preparing for third world war...I can see it round the corner, first in the form of economic wars and then who knows what all...

Rajendra
 
Rajendraji,

Without going into the intricacies of economics, I may add that "jo dikhta hai so bikta hai". India and China "dikh rahe hain" and the momentum should be maintained at all costs if we have to really reach somewhere. Time is in our favour, we have the talented, educated and skilled youth manpower. Most of the developed countries (especially G-8) are facing the problem of aging population. This should be taken advantage of and turn the bane of over-population into a boon.
 
ramksehrawat said:
Rajendraji,

Without going into the intricacies of economics, I may add that "jo dikhta hai so bikta hai". India and China "dikh rahe hain" and the momentum should be maintained at all costs if we have to really reach somewhere. Time is in our favour, we have the talented, educated and skilled youth manpower. Most of the developed countries (especially G-8) are facing the problem of aging population. This should be taken advantage of and turn the bane of over-population into a boon.

I totally agree with you as far as present phase of development is concerned. We have to join the league of developed nations on present terms and conditions. However, at the same time we must be ready to face the next pahse of challenges as pointed out in my post. USA has already started feeling the pinch of resources being diverted to China and India. Bush has started talking of energy efficieny in developing countries. I am sure this will become the focus of all future international trade talks in coming years.. Looks like India and China will force the world to think green and act green..

Rajendra
 
These days almost every second article on economy is on India and China. I have been following almost every single article on the subject. Most interesting part is how Chinese have started taking of India. I can see a flip flop in Chinese position on their support for India's UNSC membership. In Valadivostak they support us and in NY they oppose. I can see some sort of rattling in their ranks and file.

This is that they have to say on India China comparison in economy;

http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2005-06/02/content_3034481.htm

They are talking of complimentary role of each other. This is almost like calling Hindi Chini Bhai Bhai once again. Emerging India should never become complecent. There will be many eyes once again on India. Almost every MNC is rushing to open its shop here and there will be trade wars among MNC fought over India soil. Hope this time India does not become the commercial fodder of MNC like what happened in 18th centuray when East India companies of every brand fought here. Without denying freedom of business to anyone, India must ensure that they play by rule and do not eat into our national interests. Our national interst must remain supreme. Debate should eneter smaller towns and villages now, who ultmately bear the burnt of all problems. India needs to be awakened to the remotest village level. awakened India is the need of hour.

Rajendra
 
rkumar said:
Almost every MNC is rushing to open its shop here and there will be trade wars among MNC fought over India soil. Hope this time India does not become the commercial fodder of MNC like what happened in 18th centuray when East India companies of every brand fought here. Without denying freedom of business to anyone, India must ensure that they play by rule and do not eat into our national interests. Our national interst must remain supreme. Debate should eneter smaller towns and villages now, who ultmately bear the burnt of all problems. India needs to be awakened to the remotest village level. awakened India is the need of hour.
Rajendra
I fully agree with you. India should convince the MNCs to establish their plants in rural and backward areas to take full benefits. So that the resources of employment and other basic infrastructure can be improved in these areas. It really helps to bring these backwards and rural areas to equal with all other developed states.
 
mukesh_kumar007 said:
I fully agree with you. India should convince the MNCs to establish their plants in rural and backward areas to take full benefits. So that the resources of employment and other basic infrastructure can be improved in these areas. It really helps to bring these backwards and rural areas to equal with all other developed states.

I can almost see the retail sector being opened to FDI. If big players like Wal Mart enter in food sector, they will go literally at the farmers level to purchase the food products and then deveop cold storage and packaging facilities...I have been writing to our PM almost continuously on this. I can see some movement on this already..

RK^2
 
I read Friedman's book, longitude and attitudes, based on his artcles in New York time. Good book, He seems to know stuff. He seems to have some soft corner for India. This article seems to go well with the french president propaganda for a YES vote, in which they were saying that EU and this constitution is to save Europe and france in particular, from emerging asian giants India and china and ofcourse USA. But this must have been the first instance where India was mentioned like that, still the Indian leadership uses the same old tone of poor, developing, third world country for forirgn affairs.

On the cost of slight digression, to know other covert activities that the wester countries and USA in particular, have been engaging you should have a look at the book

The confessions of an Economic Hit Man (EHM)

by

John Perkins

EHMs are high profile US agents in foriegn countries, whose job is manupulate the economy of these countries for US corprate system and US in the long run.

Nice article.
 
anujkumar said:
I read Friedman's book, longitude and attitudes, based on his artcles in New York time. Good book, He seems to know stuff. He seems to have some soft corner for India. This article seems to go well with the french president propaganda for a YES vote, in which they were saying that EU and this constitution is to save Europe and france in particular, from emerging asian giants India and china and ofcourse USA. But this must have been the first instance where India was mentioned like that, still the Indian leadership uses the same old tone of poor, developing, third world country for forirgn affairs.

On the cost of slight digression, to know other covert activities that the wester countries and USA in particular, have been engaging you should have a look at the book

The confessions of an Economic Hit Man (EHM)

by

John Perkins

EHMs are high profile US agents in foriegn countries, whose job is manupulate the economy of these countries for US corprate system and US in the long run.

Nice article.

There might be some truth in such books. However, I would take that with some amount of doubts as many of these authors add elements which add commercial values to their books. Look at the latest book being written by Gohar Ayub of Pakistan. Unless they add such stuff, who will buy their books.

Anyway here is the latest from Don Rumsfield on India...makes a good reading..

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1131875.cms

RK^2
 
rkumar said:
Dear Friends,

These days you read any news on world economy; you will find India and China always in limelight. Figures on China's consumption of raw material are mind boggling when it comes to items like steel, Copper, Aluminium and cement. President Bush is alarmed at the India China factor being responsible for the global Oil price rises. It’s very heartening to read India's name at last wars and then who knows what all...

Rajendra
HI uncle. I would like to say one thing no doubt india had done pretty well in software industry but when it comes to industrialzation where are we if u see india's share in world export its still nothing camparing to the china i give u the details of india's share in world export and i think it's not camparative atall on the growth level china made in manufacturing industry

http://indiabudget.nic.in/es2001-02/chapt2002/tab75.pdf


I personaly think the only thing china is lacking is the global communication (English) which plays important role in growth of business relations and economy which india is good at may be becoz we stayed british colony for long anyway atleat we indians have good command over English thats one of the reason china did'nt did well in software industry and india arise as world software valley offcourse we have lot of talent in our country which is required.what i want to say is if we want to develope and compete, i m refering to the qoute of gandhi ji which u have given, than we have to develope overall growth from manufacturing industry to other industiral units coz basic of any economy starts from manufacturing and than eventually it grows towords developement and by maintianing quality and transforming the manufacturing in to service industry which developed nations are doing now by growing more and more service industry.For india it's time to grow in manufacturing like china had captured all the developed countries market so badly that from a simple shirt to spair part of engine are imported from china so to compete with china and to stay in focus we have to do our all over growth.
 
Last edited:
Hi Amit,

There is no doubt that China is far ahead of us in manufacturing. Basic axiom on which two nations' cultures and philosophies are based, are somewhat different. Historically India has always been an open society, while china has always been a closed society. Both philosophies have their own advantages and disadvantages. An open society is always friendly to new ideas. Being an open society, India has been open to almost every culture on the Earth. Almost every major language of the world has been spoken and used in India. This gives India a very distinctive advantage over any other nation on the Earth, leave aside China. What India really needs is good governance and responsive beaurocracy. Everything else will fall in line in no time. More than ever, India is today on the move and is putting its act together to catch up with rest of the world. If one looks at long history of India and China, both countries have gone through up and downs. India has always dominated China culturally and knowledge wise. Quote by Chinese ambassador to united nation that " India controlled China through centuries without ever firing a bullet", is an interesting admission. Of course India has no option but to become very strong militarily and economically. This can be possible with public participation. Indian public must demand a strong India from its rulers. This demand must come from every corner and from every Indian..

RK^2
 
India will be very powerful country by 2010

India is growing very fast and now as per earlier discussion of 18th century east india came in India same way MNC are coming but difference is that this time Indians are running the show and MNC are more of funding.The way we are controlling the IT throughout world same way slowly all MNC top management is being filled by Indian mangers. FDI in retail sector also have been allowed and which is going to improve the small scale industries and rural economy.Infact now because of US allegation for china that they are keeping their currency low and because of this there may be some restriction on large exports from china , the chinese companies are planning to start manufacture in India.
By 2010 all vhicles of US will have almost 70 % of parts imported from India. so we are on right track.
 
I really dont understand why there is so much buzz about Wal-Mart coming to India. Ofcourse I agree that it'll bring a lot of moolah in terms of forign investment but try to look at the downside of it. Wal-mart all over the world is criticized for bringing the prices low and destroying the local retailers. Think of your nieghborhood shopkeeper who's bread n butter depends on his small shop.

I am not saying that it'll be all bad. Wal-mart and the likes do bring a lot of benefits to the retail industry. Like one point sourcing of products, an organized structure for supply chain, but at the same time they kill the local shopkeepers and thier livlihood. think of the crisis that they will face.

(in my future posts, in the same thread, i'll try to bring some interesting points regarding the crisis for local shopkeepers and the opportunity that they can extract from Wal-Mart entry; but first would like to hear your comments
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top