Reality of FDI, beyond politics

Brother,

I did not relate Licence Raj to retail. All I meant was, In 1991, People whinged, caused ruckus in the country, as they are doing right now. People claimed that country will be soon sold to foreign companies. In the same way, now people are are whining about FDI in retail.

FDI is all good for India.

This FDI will:

1. Create Jobs

2. Strengthen the Supply Chain (Half of the food does not get to the market due to lack of storage, transport and other infrastructure bottlenecks)

3. Will also help small retailers to buy cheap products and sell them. (Large retails have B2B options).

4. Good Tax collections.

5. Cheap and good quality products to the consumer.

6. Since FDI will encourage competition, it not only benefit consumer but also Farmers. Farmer will get good rates for the what they produce. It will also help in getting rid of middleman and the hoarders who are main cause of inflation and high prices!!

There is nothing wrong in this FDI. Don't buy these fake stories and conspiracy of poisonous protectionism.


I'm well aware of the situation before 1991 and well aware about Licence Raj or the Permit Raj.

For your help you have to read about Licence Raj or the Permit Raj and develop a basic understanding How the abolition of Licence Raj or the Permit Raj is different from allowing FDI in retail.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licence_Raj

Abolition of Licence Raj was meant for the removal of restriction on private player before setting up any business.

Private player were allowed to collaborate with foreign companies. So that Indian companies get the latest technologies and help the manufacturing sector and which have created lots of employment.
Here read the word collaboration carefully. Like Maruti and Suzuki collaborated with each other. Sector like Telecom and Power has opened up for private players after 1991.

Now compare the situation with FDI in retail. The retail sector was never restricted for private participation. In Retail sector private player already exist in big numbers and FII has also invested in those companies as well. So there was no protectionism in retail sector

Now instead of encouraging the Private player to collaborate with foreign player to get the latest technology and system. Govt giving the free hand to foreign player to become the master in India in retail sector. These foreign retail chain allows to import 70% of their item from outside of India. Such companies not only kill the existing small retailers but will also destroy the manufacturing sector which already struggling to sustain.

So your comparison before 1991 situation in retail sector is just an hogwash!
 
As far as manufacturing is concerned, it is a different topic. Even without FDI in retail, manufacturing is still struggling in India. And it will struggle in future. There are number of reasons for it.Survival of manufacturing depends upon lot of factors.

Manufacturing in India struggles due to Infrastructure bottlenecks, lack of reforms in bureaucracy as well as in the policies. Tough and rigid labour laws protect businesses to employ people. Government inefficiency adds fuel to fire.

Governments policies and procedures are so crap and outdated that they don't encourages manufacturing to flourish. The overlap in government policies and procedures stop businesses to make profits. Government business practices are very poor. Simple changes in them can make a lot of difference. As far as bureaucracy is concerned, it is inefficient as well(To a certain extent. Again this topic is big, I can provide 100's of reasons why Governance is weak in India).

As decision makers as well as the implementers don't know what to do, how to do, you will see poor results, which is quite evident. One needs to understand: The difference between Developed and Poor countries is Governance. Developed countries governance model is far better and effective than developing and poor countries. And that is the main reason why developed countries progress!!

Such companies not only kill the existing small retailers but will also destroy the manufacturing sector which already struggling to sustain.
 
Last edited:
You are again missing the basic difference. Allowing private partner to enter into the restricted sector with partnership is different from allowing foreign player to become the master.

There is a difference between partnership that helps Industry grow and allowing Foreign brands to control the local market ; partnership is what was allowed in the Joint-venture between Maruti and Suzuki, monopoly of brands is allowed under FDI schemes of the kind UPA is promoting whereby a Brand with good money buys and kills the local brand like coco cola did.

Brother,

I did not relate Licence Raj to retail. All I meant was, In 1991, People whinged, caused ruckus in the country, as they are doing right now. People claimed that country will be soon sold to foreign companies. In the same way, now people are are whining about FDI in retail.

FDI is all good for India.

This FDI will:

1. Create Jobs

2. Strengthen the Supply Chain (Half of the food does not get to the market due to lack of storage, transport and other infrastructure bottlenecks)

3. Will also help small retailers to buy cheap products and sell them. (Large retails have B2B options).

4. Good Tax collections.

5. Cheap and good quality products to the consumer.

6. Since FDI will encourage competition, it not only benefit consumer but also Farmers. Farmer will get good rates for the what they produce. It will also help in getting rid of middleman and the hoarders who are main cause of inflation and high prices!!

There is nothing wrong in this FDI. Don't buy these fake stories and conspiracy of poisonous protectionism.
 
Manufacturing is not at all a different topic. It's very much related with retail sector. The down trodden manufacturing sector already struggling and these foreign giant will kill them completely. The GDP of any country increase when you manufacture more and export more. By Killing the manufacturing industry and importing more item How It will help the GDP and well help the local. I failed to understand it.

As far as manufacturing is concerned, it is a different topic. Even without FDI in retail, manufacturing is still struggling in India. And it will struggle in future. There are number of reasons for it.Survival of manufacturing depends upon lot of factors.

Manufacturing in India struggles due to Infrastructure bottlenecks, lack of reforms in bureaucracy as well as in the policies. Tough and rigid labour laws protect businesses to employ people. Government inefficiency adds fuel to fire.

Governments policies and procedures are so crap and outdated that they don't encourages manufacturing to flourish. The overlap in government policies and procedures stop businesses to make profits. Government business practices are very poor. Simple changes in them can make a lot of difference. As far as bureaucracy is concerned, it is inefficient as well(To a certain extent. Again this topic is big, I can provide 100's of reasons why Governance is weak in India).

As decision makers as well as the implementers don't know what to do, how to do, you will see poor results, which is quite evident. One needs to understand: The difference between Developed and Poor countries is Governance. Developed countries governance model is far better and effective than developing and poor countries. And that is the main reason why developed countries progress!!
 
It is Hillary Clinton, US secretary of state now and Walmart director till 1992, who has been lobbying for foreign direct investment (FDI) in retail in India, the visa Walmart needs to enter India.
Obama has clearly asked India to invite Walmart.
What drives the pressure on New Delhi for FDI in retail? Walmart lobbyists, Yes. However, the drive is deeper. Obama is desperate to lift the falling sentiments of US economy.


if China does well by more exports to US, that would actually do down the US.
.
Obama believes that India opening its retail will lift market sentiments and business confidence in the US. He talks of additional jobs in US with Walmart in India. He is keen to show to American voters the FDI-in-retail trophy from India and promise more jobs to Americans. It is the presidential candidate Obama, more than President Obama, acting now.


Before Obama, Mike Duke, Walmart CEO came to India, met all concerned and left, optimistic about a Walmart entry.India Inc and the Indian media began pushing Duke’s wish, shedding tears for the Indian farmer, for his plight at the hands of the Indian traders.
.
If it opens the retail sector to FDI, it would be acquiescing to Obama.
.
QED: Obama’s self-goal has torpedoed all possibilities of an Indian visa to Walmart in the near future.


Read the entire article it's a good detailed read.
http://newindianexpress.com/opinion/article569785.ece?pageNumber=2
 
Off topic.

Bhai tarzon, do you know why rupee has strengthened by almost 4% in last two trading sessions? And what impact does a strong currency has on our/any economy?
 
I think you are unnecessarily debating it as you have not read my post fully or you simply do not know the simple concepts of economics. I probably rest my case here and let you enlighten others.

Thank You

Manufacturing is not at all a different topic. It's very much related with retail sector. The down trodden manufacturing sector already struggling and these foreign giant will kill them completely. The GDP of any country increase when you manufacture more and export more. By Killing the manufacturing industry and importing more item How It will help the GDP and well help the local. I failed to understand it.
 
You don't know the meaning of protectionism(Simple concept of economics). I do not see any reason for debating with you further!!

You are again missing the basic difference. Allowing private partner to enter into the restricted sector with partnership is different from allowing foreign player to become the master.

There is a difference between partnership that helps Industry grow and allowing Foreign brands to control the local market ; partnership is what was allowed in the Joint-venture between Maruti and Suzuki, monopoly of brands is allowed under FDI schemes of the kind UPA is promoting whereby a Brand with good money buys and kills the local brand like coco cola did.

There is not protectionism in retail. Big Indian retail chain already exist.

Govt have to take the decision in the interest of India not in the interest of foreign masters.
 
It's mear trading. Rupee won't get down below 50 now and in coming days if same policy will continue then you'll see rupee at 60 soon.

Off topic.

Bhai tarzon, do you know why rupee has strengthened by almost 4% in last two trading sessions? And what impact does a strong currency has on our/any economy?
 
Last edited:
Indeed I'm not expert of economics but have the basic understating. I've read your complete reply and you are just trying to prove your point with random phrases instead of supporting the FDI in retail with proper fact, figure and references.

FDI is this,,FDI is that...FDI is GOD it doesn't stand.

I think you are unnecessarily debating it as you have not read my post fully or you simply do not know the simple concepts of economics. I probably rest my case here and let you enlighten others.

Thank You
 
It's OK sir. You know everything! Hope you are satisfied now.

Indeed I'm not expert of economics but have the basic understating. I've read your complete reply and you are just trying to prove your point with random phrases instead of supporting the FDI in retail with proper fact, figure and references.

FDI is this,,FDI is that...FDI is GOD it doesn't stand.
 
protectionism refers to policies or doctrines which protect businesses and workers within a country by restricting or regulating trade with foreign nations.

Sir, You are great!!!!

Oh Really...seems like mine MBA is a waste:sorrow: Please enlighten us what is protectionism???
 
So how does FDI in retail related with "regulating trade with foreign nations"????

protectionism refers to policies or doctrines which protect businesses and workers within a country by restricting or regulating trade with foreign nations.

Sir, You are great!!!!
 
Back
Top