Reality of FDI, beyond politics

Is 30% sourcing enough?? and This 30% is not restricted to certain item like food items. The retail chain are free to decide which item they want to source from India. Indian retailers certainly free to import 100% goods BUT are they capable to sale the same item at lower price just like WalMart? NO, They are not. That's why they source more than 70% of their item from India itself.

Law that forces them to source 30%... FYI - if Indian retailers want they can get 100% goods imported, they do not have any law controlling them.
 
I have Walmart here, nearest one is 4 miles away and then there are plenty forward but if you ask me how many times have been to Walmart? Answer is once and that too when I moved it. Reason: I wanted bulk qualtity and thus went to Walmart.

What happened after that? I visit local grocery stores because I realise that most of the items marked on MOP are same unless you buy in bulk and also factor in gas prices.

Do you think this will change in India?

Look around, how many possible HUGE space do you see in cities for these big stores? Of course they will not be anywhere where huge chunk of population is around.


Indeed no one go to buy a bottle of coke, or a pinch of salt to these big stores but Is it possible to survive for these local store by just sailing a bottle of coke, or a pinch of salt??

And Govt without addressing the concern of this large section just singing on the tune of foreign masters.
 
When you visited the WalMart How much crowd was there? Was It empty???

And purchasing land within city for Walmart is not a big deal. Just like in US WalMart exist on big space, It's not necessary that they should come up with same style of store in India as well. They will buy a land equal to any big mall and make store floor wise. Nothing impossible for them they are backed with huge amount of money.

I have Walmart here, nearest one is 4 miles away and then there are plenty forward but if you ask me how many times have been to Walmart? Answer is once and that too when I moved it. Reason: I wanted bulk qualtity and thus went to Walmart.

What happened after that? I visit local grocery stores because I realise that most of the items marked on MOP are same unless you buy in bulk and also factor in gas prices.

Do you think this will change in India?

Look around, how many possible HUGE space do you see in cities for these big stores? Of course they will not be anywhere where huge chunk of population is around.
 
Havent seen much crowd at Walmart because they are seldom near population.

And to let you know, you will never find a Walmart in downtown NYC, Boston and DC(Cities I have lived in) because of financial viabilities. Indian retail is going off the roof and all the good space is already taken.

When you visited the WalMart How much crowd was there? Was It empty???

And purchasing land within city for Walmart is not a big deal.
 
So you are saying WalMart unable to open any store in Delhi and Mumbai due to lack of land???

Then why we allowing FDI in retail?? FDI in retail allows only in cities. Foreign retail chain only allows to setup their store in cities. And if we go by your assumption that in cities there is not much land available then what is the purpose of FDI in retail??:confused:.

Havent seen much crowd at Walmart because they are seldom near population.

And to let you know, you will never find a Walmart in downtown NYC, Boston and DC(Cities I have lived in) because of financial viabilities. Indian retail is going off the roof and all the good space is already taken.
 
No, What I am saying is thtt they will not be as close to a consumer as a Kirana store and and not as many either.

So you are saying WalMart unable to open any store in Delhi and Mumbai due to lack of land???

Then why we allowing FDI in retail?? FDI in retail allows only in cities. Foreign retail chain only allows to setup their store in cities. And if we go by your assumption that in cities there is not much land available then what is the purpose of FDI in retail??:confused:.
 
I don 't think that there is any inch of place left in metro cities and tier 1 cities in India, where people don't lives. these retail chain allows to open up the store in cities only. So my question is that where they will open up the store than???

No, What I am saying is thtt they will not be as close to a consumer as a Kirana store and and not as many either.
 
I think Chetan Bhagat has nailed down the FDI story very well. As in my previous posts, I have mentioned about consiparcy of posioneous protectionism. Opposition parties usually float an idea of protectionism and easily convince a number of people to oppose any right step which could help people to have better life.

It has become a culture to oppose positive reforms by the opposition parties. Be it FDI in multi-brand retail or be it other FDI. People are unwilling to understand anything on positive note. What domestic retailers are doing? How much they pay taxes? How many people they employ and give the right salaries and compensation to the employees.

Nexus between the middlemen and hoarders is so strong that these people have monopoly in the market which is lacking stiff competition. These middlemen and hoarders have been destroying the economy for a long time. High inflation, poor quality of products and food wastage are few of the consequences of lack of competition in the market. But still people are unwilling to understand it.

I just wonder, what these multi-national companies will do differently than domestic corporate retail players with so much restriction. No body really pays an attention to the several simple facts. FDI in retail will eventually help small retailers to buy cheap and good quality products.


Small retailers need not to worry about middlemen and hoarders who make everyone's life hard. FDI in retail will encourage small retailers businesses to flourish. It may also help in strengthning the supply chain. Right now there is a 100 percent FDI in supply chain. But this FDI in supply chain won't be effective unless we give foriegn players an opportunity to make some profits.

There is a lot needs to changed in India. As Linfox( An Australian Supply Chain giant) said, with simple changes into government policies can make a big difference in increasing profits, efficiency and creating jobs. India is full of opportunities. Its just a matter of taking right steps and implement them.
 
Hypocrite Samajwaadi Party, just an example of a typical Indian opposition party which on one hand oppose FDI while on the other hand gives support to UPA government to survive. Such a dual play for no strong reason should be enough for people to understand this dirty politics of opposing FDI.
 
I have Walmart here, nearest one is 4 miles away and then there are plenty forward but if you ask me how many times have been to Walmart? Answer is once and that too when I moved it. Reason: I wanted bulk qualtity and thus went to Walmart.

What happened after that? I visit local grocery stores because I realise that most of the items marked on MOP are same unless you buy in bulk and also factor in gas prices.

Do you think this will change in India?

Look around, how many possible HUGE space do you see in cities for these big stores? Of course they will not be anywhere where huge chunk of population is around.

Who are these local grocery stores? Do you mean other chains or mom and dad type store. Its hard to believe that mom and dad type store would have the same price as a giant supermarket chain. Lot of supermarkets also have free delivery options. They are here to make money and they will do everything possible to make money.

Space is not a problem. A few house will be bought. Redesigned and a new struture will come up.

Someone said it will benifit Jat farmers. I doubt that. It will help Middle class buyers (at least for short term) and job -seekers.
 
.

जो देश भारत में विदेशी किराना की वकालत करता है वहां का प्रमुख अपने देश के लोगों को छोटे दुकानों से खरीदने की सलाह दे चूका है |


View attachment 15494
 
Politics and economics are 2 different aspects of same profession.

Though, small grocery stores dont directly compete with mass retailers. A lot of times these small stores are also customers of same large retail chains.

.

जो देश भारत में विदेशी किराना की वकालत करता है वहां का प्रमुख अपने देश के लोगों को छोटे दुकानों से खरीदने की सलाह दे चूका है |


View attachment 15494
 
In short ek he baat kehna chahta hu ki

FDI lagu hone se jo aam aadmi jaise ki kissan h, uski re re matti banegi.....
aur jo bichare apni chotti chotti dukan khol k apna ghar chala re se unki pait pe latt lagegi.....


Gentleman! According to You, Kissan is in better condition @ now and has been in good condition after Independence." It is a ridiculous statement, so far as I am concerned. He(Kisan) is the only manufacturer or producer in the country who doesn't even have the right to manage the prices of the products he produces.
This is the most dangerous thing that people(s) are following to whom, they shouldn't.
Walmart, Tesco, Carrefore, Metro etc............ के आने के बाद के हालात, हो सकता है इससे बदतर हों, लेकिन आजमाने में कोई बुराई नहीं है। 65 साल में जो हालात हम लोगों के हैं, और वो भी तथाकथित हमारे ही लोगों के कारण, तो उन लोगों पर Illogically इल्जाम लगाने का कोई Logic नहीं बनता है। Reliance, Future Group, Birla, और Bharti, उनसे कहीं अधिक खतरनाक हैं, ये मैं दावे के साथ कह सकता हूँ। और अगर आपको फ़र्क महसूस करना है तो एक बार दोनों के स्टोरों में जाकर वहाँ के किसी भी स्तर के कर्मचारी से उनका Job Satisfaction Level जानिए। I m confident that you'll be surprised.
एक बार आजमा कर देखने में कोई बुराई नहीं है। सिर्फ रंग का फर्क है, वो गोरे हैं, यहाँ भीतर तक काले हैं।

Exceptions are everywhere but in a general way------ सच्चाई हमेशा कड़वी होती है। और आपको एक दिन सच्चाई तो स्वीकारनी ही पड़ेगी। We lack strength in the Pvt. Sector not because of lack of Qualification but because of attitude. We take Education to seek only a Govt. job and nothing.
Jat से सरकारी नौकरी छीन लीजिये। सरकारी नौकरी भी कौन-सी - Roadways(not Transport), Education(Field), and Police. There may be a question mark on his survival. In the name of achievement we've nothing to display.
Very pathetic that we support FDI as Ch. Hooda supports it and we oppose as Ch. Choutala opposes it. But we do not try to understand that both are helpless. Mr. Hooda supports it as he is in Congress and Mr. Choutala opposes it as he is in opposition.
यह जानने की कोई जरूरत नहीं है कि वह क्या बोल रहा है और वैसे भी इसे समझने के लिए लिए आपको अतिरिक्त मेहनत करनी पड़ेगी - हर देशवासी का सिर शर्म से सिर्फ़ इसलिए ही झुक जाना चाहिए कि मुलायम सिंह यादव जैसा अनपढ़ आदमी इस विषय पर प्रेस, मीडिया में बोल रहा है। And at present scenario, he is the key person.... Shame!

"मत पूछ कि क्या हाल है मेरा तेरे पीछे
तू देख कि क्या रंग है तेरा मेरे आगे"
 
Last edited:
Is FDI beneficial for the Agriculture Sector?

As we are the sons of the soil and our roots lie in the fields of our villages, where our forefathers, fathers and families all together have shed the sweat and still shedding in bitterness. They have feed up and defended the nation. Despite the facts, we are loosers, leavings and at limitary at the last. But still, we are alive with full of enthusiasm, Zeal and valour, because of hard work, honesty and faith in God.
Therefore, I have requested you through my face book having more than 3000 educated friends on computer screen, to put forward your valuation on allowing the FDI in agriculture sector. Some of you have given your noteworthy thoughts as well as praiseworthy opinions on the subject, remaining did not touch the matter and run over by emotions and illiberal political linkage. It means, all of us are not fully aware as well as not devoted to the cause of our farming community. Moreover, we should not be carried away with illusion. After going through your valuable opinions, secondly, articles appeared in the Indian leading newspapers on the subject and my personal experience thereto, my conclusion is as under :-
I fully remember the days when my grandfather was a village Namberdar holding 60 acres of land(barren) and the rooms meant for storage were seldom remained full of grains. There was no use of gunny bags at that time. But we have never been able to take required expense and pocket money during the school and college days from the parents due to poverty. I mean to say that our farmer’s life was ever miserable as on today. Why we are loosers and exploited? I would like to narrate a few examples as under :-
Some farmers from my own village, used to grow tomatoes since 15-20 years and were selling in Main Sabji Mandi of Bhiwani town. One day(in April, 2010) I went to purchase vegetables for my domestic use as usual, a few of my villagers were coming out of the Mandi after selling their production( Tomatoes). I have asked them the rate on which they have sold the tomatoes. They have told me that they have sold at the rate below Rs. 5 per kg., as the middleman purchase their production on crate basis not on proper weight, Hence, they could not tell the accurate sale rate. Hardly, after half an hour, I have purchased the same tomatoes from the same shop at the rate of Rs. 10 per kg. under accurate weight. After coming to my residence, I went to a vegetable shop in my sector in the evening and found the rate of the tomatoes Rs. 20 per kg. I remember 5 years ago, the farmers had to throw their tomatoes on the road fin ding no purchaser in the market. It is height of the injustice with the farmer community.
Second example, during 2011, I have purchased 1 kg. Moong Dal from a retail shop in my sector in a very presentable packing at the rate of Rs. 75 per kg. After two days, I was passing through the grain market of Tosham town. I remembered the Moong Dal and I have purchased 10 kg. Moong dal of better quality at the rate of Rs. 45 per kg. Thus there was a difference of Rs. 30 per kg. at the distance of 24 kms only. Moreover, we have seen the rate of Gwar which was sold by the farmers last year at the time of harvesting at the rate of Rs. 3000 per qtl. But the same was sold by the middleman during this year Rs. 33000 by 11 times more. So it is clear that the farmers are exploited class and the middlemen are their exploiters. Late Ch. Chhoturam the Messiah as well as monitor of the farmers repeatedly used to say “recognize your enemies.” So our first enemy is the middleman. Now the question is how the enemy could be eliminated? As we know the farmers are trapped since a long in between higher investment with lower profit. Therefore, at present the FDI is only ray of hope for the farmers, where the buyers will increase with the results rate of the grains as well as vegetables will also enhance subsequently, due to such a healthy competition in the market. In case the export of the grains commodity is allowed in FDI, it would prove a boom for the farmers. So we should not be carried away with fabulous propaganda against the FDI. We should not treat FDI as Govt. capitation but to see it as an antiseptic. The profession of agriculture has since been became a profession of a carnage for farmers resulting into committing suicide across the country. National Agriculture Commission reported the agriculture profession is a profession of deficit those who are s having less then 10 acres of land holding. Moreover, the recommendations of Dr. Swaminathan’s report are still awaiting for implementation by Govts. It is unfortunate that the opposition parties are meant for oppose irrespective of right or wrong and ruling parties are meant for rule by hook or by crook in our democracy.
Punjab and Haryana states are the main contributors toward the central pool whose farmers depend upon the monopoly of the FCI an agency of the Central Govt. and the middlemen of the local grain market. At present, FDI could be introduced in Faridabad, Ludhiana and Amritsar only having population more than 10 lacs. We should have close watch over the scheme for a year and in case FDI is found profitable for the farmers, we should demand to extend it upto Distt. Town level in future. We may hope in a long run, the FDI may create as syndicalism for the farmers.
 
Back
Top