Reality of FDI, beyond politics

Swaich, as i said earlier lobbyist and communicator are lot different. .

Not really, Dilip Cherian is India's leading lobbyist and is known as Image Guru, owns India's biggest PR agency. Radia is no different, owned Vaishanavi Communications. Read further about Prema Sagar.
 
Not really, Dilip Cherian is India's leading lobbyist and is known as Image Guru, owns India's biggest PR agency. Radia is no different, owned Vaishanavi Communications. Read further about Prema Sagar.
Vikas I have explained the difference very well and for you it might be same thing but I still stick that it different. Let you give me one more example, if someone ask to write in favor of BJP( which you never want) by offering some money( which you will never take I think)/ something else, that is lobbying. One of the cabinet minister has to resign because of this lobbying ( Shashi Tharror) in UPA2 when he was criticizes/alleged for that role in IPL bids for kochin franchise
 
Swaich, as i said earlier lobbyist and communicator are lot different. Job of lobbyist is not to communicate rather to influence politicians in there favor and that can never be done with plain communication. A lobbyist can never and in fact should not be called a simple communicator. A communicator just share and exchange information,lobbyist job comes after this exchange is done.

This is how Oxford define lobbyist:-'a group of people seeking to influence politicians or public officials on a particular issue'

Coming to second point, i also said 'let us assume it happened in US' and you also saying 'if it happened in US'.I also know it is legal in US but my point is it is wrong if some outside India are element are doing something wrong to influence our politicians be it from within country or outside. i'm also not too sure and it might have happened in india as well and that is why we witnessed another hue and cry in parliament by BJP to find where and how and by whom.

India doing it in US is fine because it is legal in US but not other way round it is wrong

A policemen slapping a person and mother slapping her child are not exactly same even though they both a doing same thing.

As i said i have my own views on FDI.We both in fact whole worlds knows about Dawood .I was trying to explain a point with that there which you have already got.

Rinku, let me know if I got this right - I think where we primarily differ is that you understand lobbying as unfair, paid influence. While I see it as fair, paid but biased communication. Now it can be legal/illegal based on how the influence is wielded. If it involved bribes and favors, its unfair. If it just involves communicating one-sided information, its fair. The onus is on the decision-maker to make the distinction and read up all sides of the story rather than just relying on the info supplied by the lobbyist.
 
I think you are getting it wrong my friend, we are talking of lobbying as a profession and politicians are not lobbyists. Politicians are the ones lobbyists lobby with and influence. A lobbyist does not lobby for a party but often for changes in policies/licences and it is independent of party favorism

Sashi Tharoor was a minister and not a lobbyist and that is why he was asked to go,

Vikas I have explained the difference very well and for you it might be same thing but I still stick that it different. Let you give me one more example, if someone ask to write in favor of BJP( which you never want) by offering some money( which you will never take I think)/ something else, that is lobbying. One of the cabinet minister has to resign because of this lobbying ( Shashi Tharror) in UPA2 when he was criticizes/alleged for that role in IPL bids for kochin franchise
 
Rinku, let me know if I got this right - I think where we primarily differ is that you understand lobbying as unfair, paid influence. While I see it as fair, paid but biased communication. Now it can be legal/illegal based on how the influence is wielded. If it involved bribes and favors, its unfair. If it just involves communicating one-sided information, its fair. The onus is on the decision-maker to make the distinction and read up all sides of the story rather than just relying on the info supplied by the lobbyist.

that is right but another point where it is done.
 
Back
Top