Reviews on books

BOOK REVIEW​
A Soldier’s Journey through Life with Two Wives. By Brigadier Lakshman Singh VSM (Retd) (NOIDA : BLS Publishers, 2009) pp..306, Rs. 450, ISBN 978-81-901855-1-6.
It is difficult to classify this book – it is neither a love story, nor an autobiography, nor an historical saga, nor a personal narrative. Perhaps, it is a combination of all these and more. In spite of the suggestive title, it is in essence the tale of a man torn between his two loves – his wife and his calling, a dilemma faced not only by soldiers but many others who are wedded to their careers, some even more demanding than the profession of arms. It is not easy to reconcile the demands of one’s family and his job, a point the author has highlighted in his narrative.
Written in an earthy style, the book traces the story of a young boy born in a middle class family in Western Uttar Pradesh, his early education, graduation from college and university, training at the Indian Military Academy, service in various units and training establishments, stints in the DRDO and RAW, retirement from the Army and life thereafter. There are vignettes of village life, ‘boot camp’ during cadet training, the first experience of battle during 1962, and the slow but steady rise up the ladder in the military hierarchy. To keep the reader’s interest alive, the author has peppered the narrative with personal anecdotes. A parallel theme is the poignant story of two people deeply in love - the author and his wife Rosie, also called Jeet. Starting from their courtship and marriage, the book takes us through their intimate moments, separations, reunions, tribulations, the pain suffered by both in her fight with cancer, and her death in his arms.
Though it is a commonplace tale of an ordinary person, there are a few things that make it extraordinary. The book gives an insight into the challenges faced by a military leader, the strong bonds between an officer and his men and the loyalty and grit of the Indian Jawan in the face of adversity.
The only jarring note is the presence of numerous grammatical mistakes and mis-spelt words, which detract from the readability of the book. Notwithstanding this flaw, the book will interest both soldiers and civilians, and will be a valuable addition to libraries as well as personal collections. It is especially recommended for young officers, who will find valuable lessons in command at a sub unit level.
Maj Gen VK Singh

This review speaks volumes about the various fronts a defence man encounters. One need a observatery mind and sensitive heart to pick small to small incidents and corelating them to various aspects of life. Undoublty, Brig Sir has been a soldier with marvelous pen.

Just want to convey through this post that it would be nice for the scope of this book if translated in Hindi and other languages so that a common soldier can keep it with him for valuable words.
 
Really a very good book..must read book.

Another book i m reading nowadays is " Think and Grow rich" by Nepoleon Hill. Here rich doesnt related to only monetory matters but enrich of overall growth of mind and soul.

Monk Who Sold His Ferrari - A must read book
 
just finished reading "The White Tiger" by Arvind Adiga.....

was ok but not worth the hype n booker...

right now reading "Alchemy of desire" by Tarun Tejpal...
til now it has been pretty borin but the reviews had said it was gud....

one all time fav is "Zoya" by Danielle Steel...really amazin n grippin book...especially the central character...

"the monk who sold his ferrari" had all the techniques which v all also know...but hardly follow...stil it was nice n worth a read...

better than "Da Vinci Code" i liked "Angels & Demons".....but didnt get the same hype as the earlier one..stil i wud advice ppl to read it....

"Alchemist" was very nice n i hav heard "Zahir" is even better...though m yet to read it....

if sumbody likes psychatry then they can read books by Dr. Brian Weiss...really nice....n espcially so since they r based on true accounts....hav read "many lives many master", "only luv is real" and "same soul many bodies" n luved each of those...

bas abhi ke liye itna hi bahut hai...will keep updating :)..

p.s. sorry for the long reply...but after ages i luved a thread on JL
 
I wonder no body has said anything about Nietzsche's works yet!!!
I have Thus Spake Zarathustra and Ecce Homo sitting in my office for more than 6 months, haven't found time to start them.

Nietzsche attracted me when I had read one of his quote somewhere,'' God is dead and we humans killed Him.'' He rationalised the above statement with the reason that Human has enough will to be responsible for each and every deed[karma].He emphasised that existence of God prove human to be a shallow creature. Extension of these thoughts came in the book mentioned by Chillar 'Thus Spake Zarathustra' and 'Will to Power' Zarusthustra is known as the Prophet of Persian Jews. He established religious guidelines 600 years before Christ for Jews. To humanise this Zarathustra , Nietzsche, brough him to the city from mountain and introduced him to an old man. Old man asked Zarathustra,'' Now you wake up otherwise whats your significance among sleeping population?'' Then Zarathustra addressed people ,'' I have come to tell you about Super human. You only have tried to be a human, nothing else. Super human will laugh at you like you laugh at moneky. Come!! I will teach you to become a super human. You soul is shallow and downtroden. Super human is vast and an infinite sea and you humans are a narrow sewer. You will have to become a sea where all sewerage and filth becomes purified.'' He added,'' A human becomes great when he becomes a bridge not destination. He deserevs respect and and love who uplift underprivilged and downtroden humans.''

Will to Power by Nietzsche inspires humans to be superhumans by rising above petty lives and life styles. Probably Nietzsche wrote this work in response to Schopenhauer's Will to Live.

Interestingly the character of Super Man and Super Race[ of Hitler, Musolini] has been inspired from Nietzsche's works. He has written several other works as well but above mentioned two are greatest in my opinion.

=====

Can you guys write or imagine a sentence without any vowel. Probably, No. But there is one 5000 plus words book which has been written without vowel E. Such works are called Lipogram which excludes a certain letter from content.

This interesting book is ''Gadsby'' by Ernest Wincent Wright written in 1939. Glance at a paragraph from this book without letter E and wonder:

But, just as funds had grown to what Mayor Gadsby thought would fill all such wants, a row in Council as to this fund’s application got so hot that “His Honor” got mad ; mighty ,mad!! And said:- “Why is it that any bill for appropriations coming up in this Council has to kick up such a rumpus? Why can’t you look at such things with a public mind; for nothing can so aid toward passing bills as harmony. This city is not holding off an attacking army. Branton Hills is not a pack of wild animals, snapping and snarling by day; jumping, at a crackling twig, at night. It is a city of humans; animals, if you wish, but with a gift from On High of a brain, so far apart from all dumb animals as to allow us to talk about our public affairs calmly and thoughtfully. All this Night School rumpus is foolish. Naturally, what is taught in such a school is an important factor; so I want to find out from our Organization —”

At this point, old Bill Simpkins got up, with: “This Organization of Youth stuff puts a kink in my spinal column! Almost all of it is through school. So how can you bring such a group forward as ‘pupils?’”


Kaisa laga?
 
Last edited:
This review speaks volumes about the various fronts a defence man encounters. One need a observatery mind and sensitive heart to pick small to small incidents and corelating them to various aspects of life. Undoublty, Brig Sir has been a soldier with marvelous pen.

Just want to convey through this post that it would be nice for the scope of this book if translated in Hindi and other languages so that a common soldier can keep it with him for valuable words.

Thanks for he suggestion The book is already being translated in Hindi, later I also plan an audio versiom. Bls31
 
Nietzsche attracted me when I had read one of his quote somewhere,'' God is dead and we humans killed Him.'' He rationalised the above statement with the reason that Human has enough will to be responsible for each and every deed[karma].He emphasised that existence of God prove human to be a shallow creature. Extension of these thoughts came in the book mentioned by Chillar 'Thus Spake Zarathustra' and 'Will to Power' :mad: He established religious guidelines 600 years before Christ for Jews. To humanise this Zarathustra , Nietzsche, brough him to the city from mountain and introduced him to an old man. Old man asked Zarathustra,'' Now you wake up otherwise whats your significance among sleeping population?'' Then Zarathustra addressed people ,'' I have come to tell you about Super human. You only have tried to be a human, nothing else. Super human will laugh at you like you laugh at moneky. Come!! I will teach you to become a super human. You soul is shallow and downtroden. Super human is vast and an infinite sea and you humans are a narrow sewer. You will have to become a sea where all sewerage and filth becomes purified.'' He added,'' A human becomes great when he becomes a bridge not destination. He deserevs respect and and love who uplift underprivilged and downtroden humans.''

Will to Power by Nietzsche inspires humans to be superhumans by rising above petty lives and life styles. Probably Nietzsche wrote this work in response to Schopenhauer's Will to Live.

Interestingly the character of Super Man and Super Race[ of Hitler, Musolini] has been inspired from Nietzsche's works. He has written several other works as well but above mentioned two are greatest in my opinion.

=====

Can you guys write or imagine a sentence without any vowel. Probably, No. But there is one 5000 plus words book which has been written without vowel E. Such works are called Lipogram which excludes a certain letter from content.

This interesting book is ''Gadsby'' by Ernest Wincent Wright written in 1939. Glance at a paragraph from this book without letter E and wonder:

But, just as funds had grown to what Mayor Gadsby thought would fill all such wants, a row in Council as to this fund’s application got so hot that “His Honor” got mad ; mighty ,mad!! And said:- “Why is it that any bill for appropriations coming up in this Council has to kick up such a rumpus? Why can’t you look at such things with a public mind; for nothing can so aid toward passing bills as harmony. This city is not holding off an attacking army. Branton Hills is not a pack of wild animals, snapping and snarling by day; jumping, at a crackling twig, at night. It is a city of humans; animals, if you wish, but with a gift from On High of a brain, so far apart from all dumb animals as to allow us to talk about our public affairs calmly and thoughtfully. All this Night School rumpus is foolish. Naturally, what is taught in such a school is an important factor; so I want to find out from our Organization —”

At this point, old Bill Simpkins got up, with: “This Organization of Youth stuff puts a kink in my spinal column! Almost all of it is through school. So how can you bring such a group forward as ‘pupils?’”


Kaisa laga?

galat bilkul galat. Zarathustra jews ka prophet nahe tha. itni badi galti:eek:
woh zorastrian religion ka founder tha.
yahan koi complex hae kya? apni matr bhasa mein bhi log ligte hae, unmeein se kisee ka koi jikar nahe hae.
Aree angreezoon tum bharat jod kar kab gayee? abhi bhi bharat mein ghulami hae dusroon ke literature ka inferiority complex hae. angreezon tumari zuban hamari bediyaan ban gayeen haeen. kya civilzed, advanced, cultured, sophisticated dikane(dhong) ke liye angrezzon ki bhasa ki ghulami karna jarrori hae?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just completed two books by Anurag Mathur:
Inscrutable Americans - about the experience of an indian student on Americal soil......
Making the Minister Smile - About the beurocracy in Indian system.....

Both are good read..... especially the first one,,,,.....
 
The Old Man And The Sea -- Hemingway, Ernest

Just started reading this book .... any comments by whoever has already read it????? By the way I visited the place where Ernie wrote this last book of his in Key West, FL in 2001.
 
Last edited:
Maharanis by Lucy Moore...based on the lives of 4 indian queens, including Gayatri Devi.....
History and not fiction, a peek in the lives of Indian Royalty, its decline......an interesting read..
 
Just completed two books by Anurag Mathur:
Inscrutable Americans - about the experience of an indian student on Americal soil......
...

especially the first one,,,,.....


hahaha......Very funny book....Gopal had it in the End...:D:D

I liked Randy and Gopal's thought of his name's meaning.:D:D
 
The Kite Runner

Book Title: The Kite Runner
Author: Khaled Hosseini

Its a good work of Hosseini about lives, relationships in third world of cotemporary Afghanistan. In the end book goes flat but message is important through the book that power is a pretty lie.
 
Book Title: The Kite Runner
Author: Khaled Hosseini

Its a good work of Hosseini about lives, relationships in third world of cotemporary Afghanistan. In the end book goes flat but message is important through the book that power is a pretty lie.

I've seen the movie, I really liked it.
 
exceptions are always there friend, but mostly people appreciate the work written by mr. robin sharma

Devender, I don't think this was a worst work (guess I've read worse, no just kidding) .... in my fair opinion in this book the guy compiled all the major concepts around Hinduism and draped them in this book, so being an Indian and Hindu I think its not an original work in the true sense except the name but that being said it was a good reminder to the fast pace life to slow down.

Also, there is a good chance that it might enthrall someone from western world about being relinquishing things and still be able to enjoy.

It reminds me a lot about Deepak Chopra
 
Last edited:
Ram ram to all after a long long time. Good to be back to jland and to see some good books being discussed here.

Amit, as is the case with lots of movies based on books, this book is way better than the movie. Read it quite a while ago.

Have been out of the book reading loop for a while now and looking forward to some suggestions for latest worthwhile fiction/nonfictions that can keep the grey cells stimulated while on mat leave...

I've seen the movie, I really liked it.
 
Back
Top