"Should the Govt amend HMA to ban 'same-gotra' marriage"?

Do you support same Gotra marriage?

  • Total voters
    166
V

virj

Active member
As you all know various newspaper and news channel are having their own poll on 'same gotra marriage'. Also our site is read and quoted in the newspaper. So not to confuse 'others' who don't necessarily understand what we are talking about let us have a clear poll on this issue. This way people won't get chance to misunderstand or misquote our discussions. Also this will help them understand our view point on this particular issue.
 
Last edited:
Should the government amend the Hindu Marriage Act to Bar Same-Gotra marriages?

This thread is to share our view on whether there is a need to Amend the Hindu Marriage Act

People who oppose this say whats the need of Amendment when we are already following this. Supports says the Amedment is necessary to discourage such marriages. They say when we have other immoral and incest realtions clearly prohibited in HMA why not this same gotra marriage. They say the definition of "prohibited realtions" under HMA need to be changed or in other words law should recognise this "custom" of JATS.

This Amendment wouldnt/shouldnt affect other Hindus. It will only affect JATS and other north indians communiteis who follow this custom( and that too if they want to be part of this law).

Please vote and discuss below why would you support or oppose this amendment.

PLease note : "Same Gotra here (as called in panchayat as well) is refered as Doodh aur Khoon Ka rista Mean same Gotra from father or mother side

P.S: for this poll sake the Amendment is only refered to in relation to "same gotra marraige". Though many JATS oppose Same village marriage as well.
 
Last edited:
i have requested jakhar ji bhai sahab..
i was too fast to reply and made this error... i wish it could asked me 'r u sure?' before submitting the vote :)
 
This is not for us. This is for other friken 'Journalist' and reporters to understand. One of them said on NDTV " Progressive, young jats are "OK" to marry in the same Gotras
 
vipin80 said:
As you all know various newspaper and news channel are having their own poll on 'same gotra marriage'. Also our site is read and quoted in the newspaper. So not to confuse 'others' who don't necessarily understand what we are talking about let us have a clear poll on this issue. This way people won't get chance to misunderstand or misquote our discussions. Also this will help them understand our view point on this particular issue.
Click to expand...


kise gaam me jaake ar 4 samajhdar aadmiya ke beech me koi yaa baat pooch le to thappad bhi lag sake hai .... this post doesnt hold any validity .....
 
vipin80 said:
This is not for us. This is for other friken 'Journalist' and reporters to understand. One of them said on NDTV " Progressive, young jats are "OK" to marry in the same Gotras
Click to expand...

Bhai NDTV ko office kathe ha....... Aur journnlist ko naam aur e-mail id ke sa....???
Jake hi jawab dena padega use.
 
narwaldeepak said:
kise gaam me jaake ar 4 samajhdar aadmiya ke beech me koi yaa baat pooch le to thappad bhi lag sake hai .... this post doesnt hold any validity .....
Click to expand...
Lol Yes. But this is not a post for discussion. There cant be any discussion about it( in my opinion) and these media houses need to STOP discussing this on TV/Paper. Its just a poll to show other 'nomad' journos who visit this site. I hope after this poll they will shut their A@@ up and stop discussing this thing on their paper or TV.


Anyway I was asked to conduct this poll. If anyone doesnt want it or feel offended this thread can be deleted.
 
vipin80 said:
This is not for us. This is for other friken 'Journalist' and reporters to understand. One of them said on NDTV " Progressive, young jats are "OK" to marry in the same Gotras
Click to expand...

i doubt if they rely on our polls.... they have already setup their mind for what they want to show people of world about us.... still ur motive is nice...
 
vipin80 said:
Lol Yes. But this is not a post for discussion. There cant be any discussion about it( in my opinion) and these media houses need to STOP discussing this on TV/Paper. Its just a poll to show other 'nomad' journos who visit this site. I hope after this poll they will shut their A@@ up and stop discussing this thing on their paper or TV.


Anyway I was asked to conduct this poll. If anyone doesnt want it or feel offended this thread can be deleted.
Click to expand...


.... not at all sir... my only concern was .. arent we putting an extra thought( thought of being some scopes) in young minds who visit this site often.. by such polls.... i know ur idea behind raising this thread is fair
 
If people outside community have a problem in us following our customs… and if they criticize any effort of ours to patronize the our Jat traditions… lets get it legalized . Be it Media or anyone who is non-jat (including some so called ultra modern jats who have deteriorated their minds in effect of these refugees) , should know that Jats hold it right at the top and cannot be culturally contaminated .
 
i was a bit confused over the issue, but YES this makes sense !!!
v
v
narwaldeepak said:
If people outside community have a problem in us following our customs… and if they criticize any effort of ours to patronize the our Jat traditions… lets get it legalized . Be it Media or anyone who is non-jat (including some so called ultra modern jats who have deteriorated their minds in effect of these refugees) , should know that Jats hold it right at the top and cannot be culturally contaminated .
Click to expand...
 
one can not even think about same gotra marriage


vipin80 said:
As you all know various newspaper and news channel are having their own poll on 'same gotra marriage'. Also our site is read and quoted in the newspaper. So not to confuse 'others' who don't necessarily understand what we are talking about let us have a clear poll on this issue. This way people won't get chance to misunderstand or misquote our discussions. Also this will help them understand our view point on this particular issue.
Click to expand...
 
Seriously, M weary of too many polls on same subject. Wasn't that 12 points Khap Panchayat enough.
Where is that guy who was asking me to club my threads on luck and success etc. Dude need ur help here.
 
Lol People wanted these two polls. Didnt have option to put these under one thread. If somone can combine please do so. That mahapanchayat one wasn't clear on this and was misrepresented in the paper.
 
dkumars said:
No boss ... one can think, depends who is one :)
In fact many have made stories, that's why this discussion.
Click to expand...

Bhai banglore jake modern ho gaye kya.......... Jo asli jat ha wo to aisa soch nahin sakta........ Baki apwad har jagha hote hain...... Unko follow karne ki jarurat nahin ha....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top