maddhan1979
Banned
Is India's middle class really a middle class or there are only two classes in India "The poor" and the "The Rich"?
So called Middle class
- Thread starter maddhan1979
- Start date
maddhan1979
Banned
There is nothing like middle class in India. So called middle class is the "real poor class", how?
Last edited:
maddhan1979
Banned
Middle class means small families. In context of India, small families means uncertainty in life or someone else deciding about your life.
maddhan1979
Banned
Good quality education is getting out of hands of middle class. Just loud speeches from politicians and mass media mind adulteration is being imparted by current political thought
Last edited:
there are many classes of population. It depends which context you are taking to talk/share about. If you say, poor or rich....I add two more to it on the basis of GDP defined in our economy ...i.e. middle class and upper middle class.
If you talk about classes based on strata, again there are many which includes social, political, educated and literate and so on.
If you talk about living standards, then again it gives you variety.
You forget to link the thought behind the starting line. Could you please, or I need to make it on my own?
Thanks for sharing views!
maddhan1979
Banned
There are only two classes. e.g. if a person is travelling on a road in an expensive car and there is an accident, this person and his car has the same result as a home less person lying on side of any road. This is a society that everyday person lives in. Crowds passby or stand by to watch the event and wait for the person to die, this is a fact of society that we live in. So, the person travelling in an expensive car is as poor as a homeless person lying on side of any road. Then there is a section of people who do not travel on such roads or use other means of transport or have loads of people in other cars travelling along with them. The example stated here is a glimpse in one part of life of everyday person. This sort of life is present in almost all parts of life of everyday person.
There is a need for fundamental changes in India otherwise the concept of "chalta hai", will keep on happening.
There is a need for fundamental changes in India otherwise the concept of "chalta hai", will keep on happening.
Last edited:
If a dog barks and chase any car, being human we cannot do the same. On other aspect, being human, we should not keep mum if we see any two single men fighting with each other, giving a free show to crowd on roadside. Here, little street dog is better who make noise and let crowd seperate which even human beings rarely think to do either to escape or be a viewer.
So, its our personal character.
Last edited:
maddhan1979
Banned
Hard to understand what the above statement means
maddhan1979
Banned
Middle class is a victim and prisoner of wrong policies and criminalisation.
I just mean to state that it is all political thought that you are taking ahead. Let yourself be free like an individual citizen and then make authorities handle the situation if anywhere you find wrong. You have freedom of speech. Why to think, one comes from middle class or upper middle class.
maddhan1979
Banned
Statement above sounds like a puppetry show.
maddhan1979
Banned
Middle class which strives on savings will find it hard to save its savings from the new economic, criminal, sociopolitical situations in the country. This middle class comprises of all the salaried and educated people striving to earn their living through their education and jobs.
Majority of India's sociopoliticaluneducatededucated sections thrive on mass accumulation of people in form of "Jan rath", etc., which is used to create a chaos and override reasoning and any other educated thought process. This mentality also gives rise to a thought process of mob mentality being stronger than given scientific thought or reasoning process. This also leads to vast accumulation of wealth or resources which supersedes any middle class of small earning/saving people. Middle class are also supposed to have less number of children as the burden of education and taxation, unpredictable life, no medical security, etc., comes on middle class, while sociopolitical sections(religion being one part of sociopolitical section) thrive on mass accumulation of people or "Jan sailab/ Jan Rath/etc.) i.e. the power of "we" being greater than the power of any individual, reason, education, thought process, etc., creates a scenario where middle class is bound to be overrun by masses of mobs driven by these sociopolitical sections.
Majority of India's sociopoliticaluneducatededucated sections thrive on mass accumulation of people in form of "Jan rath", etc., which is used to create a chaos and override reasoning and any other educated thought process. This mentality also gives rise to a thought process of mob mentality being stronger than given scientific thought or reasoning process. This also leads to vast accumulation of wealth or resources which supersedes any middle class of small earning/saving people. Middle class are also supposed to have less number of children as the burden of education and taxation, unpredictable life, no medical security, etc., comes on middle class, while sociopolitical sections(religion being one part of sociopolitical section) thrive on mass accumulation of people or "Jan sailab/ Jan Rath/etc.) i.e. the power of "we" being greater than the power of any individual, reason, education, thought process, etc., creates a scenario where middle class is bound to be overrun by masses of mobs driven by these sociopolitical sections.
Last edited:
I agree, as your answer is very much reflective!
anil_rathee
Member
As Neel mentioned India is very complex society and its really hard to clearly classify in modern western terms of social classification. But at the same time they can not be just classified as poor and rich, we have a lot more and complex division in between and even beyond both these boundary points. Poor is the one who struggle for his bread and butter but one level below is the one who also suffer social discrimination, and one level above you have the one who can manage bread and butter but can not get anything which middle class can manage, such as education, medical, then middle class itself can be lower and upper, rich can be super rich and social and political affluence mixed with these create more classes.
maddhan1979
Banned
Everyone suffers from discrimination at certain point. It is a religiously driven society facilitated by out of India interests and inside India interests.
Last edited:
maddhan1979
Banned
These religiously driven societies have politicallyreligiously driven gangs involved in crime which intrude in personal privacy and personal decision making.
These are socioreligiouspolitical gangs which are connected throughout the world with different networks.
Last edited:
Anil aapka kahne se koi fayada nahi.....Shantanu ji ne thaani hai ki chapter pura karna hai ....hehe
so, carry further Mr. Maddhan with flooding thoughts
maddhan1979
Banned
So, the real poor are the middle class, which despite being educated will be subjected to majority of the problems which will affect their lives making life more unpredictable and influenced by uneducated, corrupt and sociopolitical mob driven societies. While the poor at the lowest end and not being educated might be at a better side as ignorance will be saving them from the biggest troubles.