Taliban beheaded two Sikhs and deported their heads to a gurudwara !

  • Thread starter Thread starter sihagjat
  • Start date Start date
We can't do a THING except than showing a discomfort about whatever happens in Pakistan. It's a pity that our Politicians are still willing to have PEACE TALKS with THEM.

Problem with India is that Congress is still not trying get out of Nehru-Gandhi point of views which is five-six decades older and totally insignificant now. Congress believes in creating Bhindrawala's to counter attack the opposition but ultimately harming themselves and the Country. That's shameful politics but they are doing is now and then without any regrets. After Bajpayee, opposition seems almost paralysed. Advani lost his stature and Narendra Modi is being projected as a Hindu Dictator ( he is not though). Communists are solving their own problems or China's instaed of thinking about India. So, it's almost a political vacuum in India.

Rahul Gandhi ....... maybe or maybe not ....... !

If you people are just talking about just the incident of killing two sikhs by Talibans .... yeah it's bad thing that happened ... but who were looking at Pakistan to create Khalistan. The people who got murdered maybe innocent but not the whole community. They are harvesting what they sow decades back. To be precise, a common sikh is not a gulity one but the majority had some fancy dreams at that time.
 
Last edited:
If it is aired, atleast it is going to bring attention and help in saving lives. Why do you think it's an insult to Sikh community? They are victims not the ones carrying out such heinous acts.


No help comes. When Kashmiri Pandits were being ousted from the valley, who did what? Such incidents bring nothing but insult as others get a chance to jeer at. 2 Sikhs were beheaded by Talibans in Pakistan and a chapraasi will pass a comment on any Sardaar guy in Delhi office 'Hello Sardaarji, what are you doing here, your brother Sardaars are being killed there.'
Sikhs claim to be brave and martial race. And you are saying them 'victim'. Those people should be appreciated who don't get victim, but make the attackers 'victim'.
 
2 Sikhs were beheaded by Talibans in Pakistan and a chapraasi will pass a comment on any Sardaar guy in Delhi office 'Hello Sardaarji, what are you doing here, your brother Sardaars are being killed there.'

A Jat couple was/is killed or forced to live as brother/sister by the Khap Panchayats. My non-jat friends so often comments on me. What i can reply ?



Sikhs claim to be brave and martial race. And you are saying them 'victim'. Those people should be appreciated who don't get victim, but make the attackers 'victim'.

No doubt that Sikh is a brave community and martial race. They are residing all over the world and defining their presence at there. Two Decade back they were joining hands with Pakistan, Afganistan and rest of the World to free Punjab from the paws of India to CREATE a Khalistan. Almost every sikh family in Punjab saw blood and rest communities just tried to run away from the scene. Easy to read but hard to face.

Greats Sikhs residingng in US, Canada, Pakistan and Germany raised money to free the POOR SIKHS from the paws of MERCILESS INDIA. There was blood everywhere in the streets of Punjab with the help of Pakistan and Afganistan. Now, the time is changed and the old friend become a foe and The hunter become haunted.

Innocents always pays the price !!

People used to raise money to appreciate terrorism in Punjab from Pakistan, Afganistan, USA, Canada, germany to fight for the poor sikhs living in India. Let's see how they react now ?

Don't they ( Sikhs) ever realize that India is their own home 'since their evolution' ?
 
Last edited:
My reply is in blue;

A Jat couple was/is killed or forced to live as brother/sister by the Khap Panchayats. My non-jat friends so often comments on me. What i can reply ?

I am amazed that you can't reply for such comments to your friends. Here is the reply-''If a Jat couple was/is killed or forced to live as brother/sister by the Khap Panchayats, then it means mostly Jats are still attached with their roots and if some Jat couple (such guys are influenced with western culture in fact) tries to defy the Jat traditions then they get punished. Your friends should be told that such Jat couples are punished by the 'Jats'. If such couples are punished by Muslims or Christians or others then there should be no reply left for we Jats.

No doubt that Sikh is a brave community and martial race. They are residing all over the world and defining their presence at there. Two Decade back they were joining hands with Pakistan, Afganistan and rest of the World to free Punjab from the paws of India to CREATE a Khalistan. Almost every sikh family in Punjab saw blood and rest communities just tried to run away from the scene. Easy to read but hard to face.

Greats Sikhs residingng in US, Canada, Pakistan and Germany raised money to free the POOR SIKHS from the paws of MERCILESS INDIA. There was blood everywhere in the streets of Punjab with the help of Pakistan and Afganistan. Now, the time is changed and the old friend become a foe and The hunter become haunted.

Innocents always pays the price !!

People used to raise money to appreciate terrorism in Punjab from Pakistan, Afganistan, USA, Canada, germany to fight for the poor sikhs living in India. Let's see how they react now ?

Don't they ( Sikhs) ever realize that India is their own home 'since their evolution' ?


Your mostly points are right, but we should not forget that they were also Sikhs who were/are against the formation of Khalistan. K.P.S. Gill and many other Sikhs killed thousands of Khalistani militants when terrorism was on high in Pujab. If some Raj Thackeray tries to separate Maharashtra from India then I doesn't mean that all Maharashtrians are traitor. A bunch of bad people doesn't represent the whole country or state provided it has not been chosen by voting.
 
Last edited:
I am amazed that you can't reply for such comments to your friends. Here is the reply-''If a Jat couple was/is killed or forced to live as brother/sister by the Khap Panchayats, then it means mostly Jats are still attached with their roots and if some Jat couple (such guys are influenced with western culture in fact) tries to defy the Jat traditions then they get punished. Your friends should be told that such Jat couples are punished by the 'Jats'. If such couples are punished by Muslims or Christians or others then there should be no reply left for we Jats.

That's an strange answer. Roots ? What does that means ? Why don't you wear dhoti instead of a trouser ?

It's silly that some so called Chaudharys are deciding the fate of some poor peoples. ..... OK leave it as this is not the right thread to discuss about this.

Your mostly points are right, but we should not forget that they were also Sikhs who were/are against the formation of Khalistan. K.P.S. Gill and many other Sikhs killed thousands of Khalistani militants when terrorism was on high in Pujab. If some Raj Thackeray tries to separate Maharashtra from India then I doesn't mean that all Maharashtrians are traitor. A bunch of bad people doesn't represent the whole country or state provided it has not been chosen by voting.

Brother, i have so many close sikh friends and don't have any grudges against them. 'We' discuss things with open heart and conclude that so called 'Thekedaars' of the community always play games for their personal preferences. The same happenened in Punjab. Self declared Prime Minister, President and Cabinet Ministers of Khalistan did all that but not any innocent Sikh citizen. Any innocent sikh is paying the price of that like our neighbourhood Muslim may be considered as a terrorist. As simple as that.
 
Last edited:
Correct me if I am wrong, but one of the news read that-
Taliban had captured and killed the 2 men for money....by chance, these two unlucky men also happenned to be "Sikh".....
 
That's an strange answer. Roots ? What does that means ?

It means rules & regulations, set by Jat community. If 99% Jats are following those guidelines (e.g. No marriage in same gotra), they why some 'modern & educated' couple challenge the whole Jat community?
Why don't you wear dhoti instead of a trouser ?

Along with dhoti-kurta, Jats' traditional dress is also kurta-pajama and I like that, though I don't put that all time. If there is some Khap Panchayat making it mandatory to put only traditional Jat dress then I may quit wearing trousers, T-shirts or pants etc.
It's silly that some so called Chaudharys are deciding the fate of some poor peoples. ..... OK leave it as this is not the right thread to discuss about this.
No, no, it is the right thread. Go on. I am afraid Vijay Ji you may support Jats' intercaste marriages too. Before you say such marriages are still there, then my answer is 'the % is very low (in Jat girls cases)'.
Brother, i have so many close sikh friends and don't have any grudges against them. 'We' discuss things with open heart and conclude that so called 'Thekedaars' of the community always play games for their personal preferences. The same happenened in Punjab. Self declared Prime Minister, President and Cabinet Ministers of Khalistan did all that but not any innocent Sikh citizen. Any innocent sikh is paying the price of that like our neighbourhood Muslim may be considered as a terrorist. As simple as that.
I can be sympathetic for Sikhs, but not for neighbouring Muslims. That's a quite different case. Though my sympathy or hatred doesn't matter.
 
Last edited:

If you people are just talking about just the incident of killing two sikhs by Talibans .... yeah it's bad thing that happened ... but who were looking at Pakistan to create Khalistan. The people who got murdered maybe innocent but not the whole community. They are harvesting what they sow decades back. To be precise, a common sikh is not a gulity one but the majority had some fancy dreams at that time.


You know Vijay, exactly similar logic has been given by fanatics or their apologists belonging to any community since time immemorial. Even Bin Laden and his colleagues have lots of stories on how "Western community" had sowed the seeds for their destruction.

The Americans in North who won the civil war against the South (who were against the current United States of America) don't use that to beat down the Southerners. Englishmen don't take an issue with Irishmen for Sinn Fein's fight for independent N. Ireland. Your above statements reads as "Oh, once upon a time these idiots wanted an independent country, so there and then they sowed the seeds for anyone from their community being executed anywhere in the world in future for no crime". I wonder in which world this would be correct.
 
No doubt that Sikh is a brave community and martial race. They are residing all over the world and defining their presence at there. Two Decade back they were joining hands with Pakistan, Afganistan and rest of the World to free Punjab from the paws of India to CREATE a Khalistan. Almost every sikh family in Punjab saw blood and rest communities just tried to run away from the scene. Easy to read but hard to face.

Greats Sikhs residingng in US, Canada, Pakistan and Germany raised money to free the POOR SIKHS from the paws of MERCILESS INDIA. There was blood everywhere in the streets of Punjab with the help of Pakistan and Afganistan. Now, the time is changed and the old friend become a foe and The hunter become haunted.

Innocents always pays the price !!

People used to raise money to appreciate terrorism in Punjab from Pakistan, Afganistan, USA, Canada, germany to fight for the poor sikhs living in India. Let's see how they react now ?

Don't they ( Sikhs) ever realize that India is their own home 'since their evolution' ?

It may be a tad difficult for them to realize that India is their home if they are reminded about Khalistan when two Sikhs are executed by Taliban!!! You are actually telling them that a Khalistan would have been much better as a separate home for Sikhs (just like Israel is for Jews).

I am not sure how you come to the conclusion that all Sikhs wanted Khalistan. There are idiots in every religion and they are the most vocal as well. Why do you think the Sikhs who fought for Khalistan represented all the Sikhs? By the same measure, did the idiots who went on a rampage in Delhi to kill 3000 Sikhs, represent you? By the way, how did terrorism finally end in Punjab? It was Punjab Police, containing Sikhs in majority and led by a Sikh, who rooted out the militancy.

Sikhs have always considered India as their home "since their evolution". There is a Sikh regiment that has fought for India in god knows how many battles. It is a pity if you STILL have to judge them against the Khalistan brush.
 

Along with dhoti-kurta, Jats' traditional dress is also kurta-pajama and I like that, though I don't put that all time. If there is some Khap Panchayat making it mandatory to put only traditional Jat dress then I may quit wearing trousers, T-shirts or pants etc.

Basically, you are admitting that you don't have a brain of your own. Or may be you don't want to use it. If tomorrow Khap tells you to kill someone, would you do that? Human beings would have still been living in caves had no one ever questioned authority.
 
Basically, you are admitting that you don't have a brain of your own. Or may be you don't want to use it. If tomorrow Khap tells you to kill someone, would you do that? Human beings would have still been living in caves had no one ever questioned authority.


To kill someone is much different than quitting to wear some particular dress. I have been enjoying being Jat. If I were a chamaar, this cruel world would have harassed me calling 'chamaar...chamaar.'. Being Jat saved me from that humiliation. It's my duty that if Jat community makes it mandatory that wear only traditional Jat dress, then I accept that. If it is the need of hour that somebody has challenged the Jat's pride and deserves to be killed, then I may also go for that. I repeat again 'I have been enjoying being Jat.'

Killing is not a big issue for the Jats. I don't know how much Jatism has left in you but for your kind information mostly murders are committed by the Jats in Delhi, NCR, Western U.P., Haryana etc. and I feel very proud whenever I find any Jat involved in killings.
 
Last edited:
To kill someone is much different than quitting to wear some particular dress. I have been enjoying being Jat. If I were a chamaar, this cruel world would have harassed me calling 'chamaar...chamaar.'. Being Jat saved me from that humiliation. It's my duty that if Jat community makes it mandatory that wear only traditional Jat dress, then I accept that. If it is the need of hour that somebody has challenged the Jat's pride and deserves to be killed, then I may also go for that. I repeat again 'I have been enjoying being Jat.'

I used the exaggeration specifically to show the pitfalls of blindly following any authority. You are just displaying slave mentality if you accept any diktat without agreeing with its logic (which you apparently are doing by saying that you would stop wearing XYZ if Khap tells you to).

Your being born as a Jat is a question of chance. Why are you giving credit to Jat community leadership for your birth? And why are you stressing on "I repeat again 'I have been enjoying being Jat.'" Is your position going to change if the "enjoyment" finishes?

Here is an idea. Maybe you can enjoy being born as a human being. If you are so worried about being born as chamaar, just imagine what if you were born as a street dog or a gutter mouse? It would not only have been humiliating, but you'd have been physically hounded as well. So now if you "enjoy" being human, then probably you can try thinking as a human before bringing caste into equation.
 
I used the exaggeration specifically to show the pitfalls of blindly following any authority. You are just displaying slave mentality if you accept any diktat without agreeing with its logic (which you apparently are doing by saying that you would stop wearing XYZ if Khap tells you to).

Your being born as a Jat is a question of chance. Why are you giving credit to Jat community leadership for your birth? And why are you stressing on "I repeat again 'I have been enjoying being Jat.'" Is your position going to change if the "enjoyment" finishes?

Here is an idea. Maybe you can enjoy being born as a human being. If you are so worried about being born as chamaar, just imagine what if you were born as a street dog or a gutter mouse? It would not only have been humiliating, but you'd have been physically hounded as well. So now if you "enjoy" being human, then probably you can try thinking as a human before bringing caste into equation.

It's not slave mentality, it's loyalty. And please stop talking to me. You seem highly frustrated and irritated of me. I am sorry I replied to your post. ha...ha...ha...
 
And please stop talking to me. You seem highly frustrated and irritated of me.

ROTFL!! Yeah, right!! The whole universe revolves around you.

It's not slave mentality, it's loyalty.

Loyalty is when you work in the interests of the community. Slavery is when you mindlessly follow diktats without thinking right/wrong. Learn the basic difference before you start thinking of yourself as Bhagat Singh.
 
It means rules & regulations, set by Jat community. If 99% Jats are following those guidelines (e.g. No marriage in same gotra), they why some 'modern & educated' couple challenge the whole Jat community?
99% Jats .... where they reside ? For your kind information only 10% of the JAT population reside in these Khap dominated areas of Haryana. Rest 90% of the Jat population reside in the areas like Western Haryana, Rajasthan, Punjab, UP etc. where Jats Khap panchayats don't exist. Ironically, they laugh at these Fatwas when they heard/read about these incidents in News.

Along with dhoti-kurta, Jats' traditional dress is also kurta-pajama and I like that, though I don't put that all time. If there is some Khap Panchayat making it mandatory to put only traditional Jat dress then I may quit wearing trousers, T-shirts or pants etc.

So, according to you it was a right decision when Taliban made it mandantory to wear Burqa in the name of Old Tradition.
Tell me any significant difference between Talibani Fatwas and Khap fatwas.
 
Killing is not a big issue for the Jats. I don't know how much Jatism has left in you but for your kind information mostly murders are committed by the Jats in Delhi, NCR, Western U.P., Haryana etc. and I feel very proud whenever I find any Jat involved in killings.


So, you want to tell me that Jats are basically murderers. There is a lot of difference between a warrior and a murderer. First one kills or dies for some noble cause while the later kills someone for selfish and darogatory motives.

I don't think that any person feels proud of a Murderer.
 
It may be a tad difficult for them to realize that India is their home if they are reminded about Khalistan when two Sikhs are executed by Taliban!!! You are actually telling them that a Khalistan would have been much better as a separate home for Sikhs (just like Israel is for Jews).

I am not sure how you come to the conclusion that all Sikhs wanted Khalistan. There are idiots in every religion and they are the most vocal as well. Why do you think the Sikhs who fought for Khalistan represented all the Sikhs? By the same measure, did the idiots who went on a rampage in Delhi to kill 3000 Sikhs, represent you? By the way, how did terrorism finally end in Punjab? It was Punjab Police, containing Sikhs in majority and led by a Sikh, who rooted out the militancy.

Sikhs have always considered India as their home "since their evolution". There is a Sikh regiment that has fought for India in god knows how many battles. It is a pity if you STILL have to judge them against the Khalistan brush.

The target of my write up was not any common Sikh. They are one of the most patriotic community in India. I was talking about the IDIOTS who used to cry for so called injustice to the Sikhs in past and colored the whole Punjab in blood. Where are they NOW ?
 
99% Jats .... where they reside ? For your kind information only 10% of the JAT population reside in these Khap dominated areas of Haryana. Rest 90% of the Jat population reside in the areas like Western Haryana, Rajasthan, Punjab, UP etc. where Jats Khap panchayats don't exist. Ironically, they laugh at these Fatwas when they heard/read about these incidents in News.



So, according to you it was a right decision when Taliban made it mandantory to wear Burqa in the name of Old Tradition.
Tell me any significant difference between Talibani Fatwas and Khap fatwas.
Vijay bhai baki ka pata nahi...western UP ake dekho khap hi khap dikhengi...or shayad khap system jitna follow yahan kiya jata hai or kahin bhi nahi kiya jata... ar haan yeh baat jarror hai..yahan phaltu rolla nahi machate log...
 
I used the exaggeration specifically to show the pitfalls of blindly following any authority. You are just displaying slave mentality if you accept any diktat without agreeing with its logic (which you apparently are doing by saying that you would stop wearing XYZ if Khap tells you to).

Your being born as a Jat is a question of chance. Why are you giving credit to Jat community leadership for your birth? And why are you stressing on "I repeat again 'I have been enjoying being Jat.'" Is your position going to change if the "enjoyment" finishes?

Here is an idea. Maybe you can enjoy being born as a human being. If you are so worried about being born as chamaar, just imagine what if you were born as a street dog or a gutter mouse? It would not only have been humiliating, but you'd have been physically hounded as well. So now if you "enjoy" being human, then probably you can try thinking as a human before bringing caste into equation.
So you are enjoying being a duplicate JAT.... coz every criticizer of jatism( khap traditions laid down by our elders) is not a JAT in actual sense ...
 
Yes Hitesh is right

Vijay bhai baki ka pata nahi...western UP ake dekho khap hi khap dikhengi...or shayad khap system jitna follow yahan kiya jata hai or kahin bhi nahi kiya jata... ar haan yeh baat jarror hai..yahan phaltu rolla nahi machate log...

Yes Hitesh is right..Khap System is very strong here also in Western UP and people are very much satisfied and following it through bottom of their heart. Like as we belong to "Desh" Khap. :):)
 
Back
Top