Taliban beheaded two Sikhs and deported their heads to a gurudwara !

  • Thread starter Thread starter sihagjat
  • Start date Start date
So you are enjoying being a duplicate JAT.... coz every criticizer of jatism( khap traditions laid down by our elders) is not a JAT in actual sense ...

Why we define things as per our taste.. Everything can't be judged with vested interest....

Did our elders set tradition for Reservation that jats are asking today?

I condemn Khap tradition when they pass stupid orders to punish some poor person... It doesn't mean that someone is duplicate or original..
 
Why we define things as per our taste.. Everything can't be judged with vested interest....

Did our elders set tradition for Reservation that jats are asking today?

I condemn Khap tradition when they pass stupid orders to punish some poor person... It doesn't mean that someone is duplicate or original..

Bhai Yudhvir,
Khap system is linked with our traditional culture and social system. Reservation is not a JAT social culture but its a social backwardness related to our economical, social and poltical participation. JAT RESERVATION is a demand KHAP SYSTEM exist and implemented by social consensus.
 
Bhai Yudhvir,
Khap system is linked with our traditional culture and social system. Reservation is not a JAT social culture but its a social backwardness related to our economical, social and poltical participation. JAT RESERVATION is a demand KHAP SYSTEM exist and implemented by social consensus.

Yeah I agree with you Piush.. However just branding somebody as duplicate Jat because he/she doesn't agree with Khap Panchayat is beyond my understanding..

We all are different so our thoughts...
 
So you are enjoying being a duplicate JAT.... coz every criticizer of jatism( khap traditions laid down by our elders) is not a JAT in actual sense ...

Ohho, ek aur aaya...ORIGINAL Jat. Tere certificate ki baat na dekh raha tha main. Being a jat means being free in true sense of the word. And freedom is right to tell people what they do not want to hear. Especially people like you. But how would you know. You belong to the slave class. Most Jats I know are more than willing to challenge authority and speaking their mind out. Respecting your elders and following traditions is different from not using your brain and blindly accepting whatever is thrown at you.
 
By the way, what is the definition of Khap? What are they for? I am from western UP and never heard of any Khap traditions that are different from Jat traditions. Can you tell how is a Khap tradition different from Jat tradition? by your definition every muslim criticizer of these sick talibans is a non Muslim. Jat is a jat whether he or she follows your definition of jat traditions or not. A person becomes Jat by birth, not by following a Khap.

So you are enjoying being a duplicate JAT.... coz every criticizer of jatism( khap traditions laid down by our elders) is not a JAT in actual sense ...
 
By the way, what is the definition of Khap? What are they for? I am from western UP and never heard of any Khap traditions that are different from Jat traditions. Can you tell how is a Khap tradition different from Jat tradition? by your definition every muslim criticizer of these sick talibans is a non Muslim. Jat is a jat whether he or she follows your definition of jat traditions or not. A person becomes Jat by birth, not by following a Khap.

i am not Hitesh, neither do i subscribe to his definition of Jatism... but if your questions (regarding Khap) are sincere, then:

1. Khap is nothing but a group of village panchayats... sort of superset of panchayat.

2. Khap is NOT Taliban. Please do Not compare these two (especially when you have NO idea {as u admit} about the functioning or constituents of a khap ; It look stupid) :)

3. Khap does not have any fixed agenda or fixed regular meeting or any set of fixed rules.

4. Khaps are for: resolving 'issues' between villages (which are beyond the ability of a single village panchayat). More often than not issue is same gotra/gotras marriage!

5. Why are the khaps being branded as some sort of evil (specially in media)?? Because khap ruling / fatwas on an issue are in accordance with the traditions (sensitivities, practices, customs) of the majority of people involved in that 'issue'; which looks absurd to a third person who is ignorant about the local traditions. Also being a unconstitutional body khap ruling generally go against the law. e.g. same village, same gotra marriage are fine with police and law but not with khaps.

Anyways, khap issue has been discussed in details on Jatland. Give a search if you are really interested. Some good arguments in favor of (and against) khap had been put by fellow members!!
 
99% Jats .... where they reside ? For your kind information only 10% of the JAT population reside in these Khap dominated areas of Haryana. Rest 90% of the Jat population reside in the areas like Western Haryana, Rajasthan, Punjab, UP etc. where Jats Khap panchayats don't exist. Ironically, they laugh at these Fatwas when they heard/read about these incidents in News.
The fatwas are generally against the same gotra marriage. Do you want to say that only 10% Jats marry in different gotras and 90% marry in same gotra? As a matter of fact almost whole Western U.P. and Haryana are under the influence of these Khaps. If jats don't want to continue with old traditions then they should get together over the same gotra marriage issue.
So, according to you it was a right decision when Taliban made it mandantory to wear Burqa in the name of Old Tradition.
Tell me any significant difference between Talibani Fatwas and Khap fatwas.
Talibani decision was wrong because they want their women to put burqa, but don't want males to put the same. Khap's fatwa against same gotra marriage is different thing, because 99.99% Jats don't marry in same gotra and when some so called ultra-modern Jat couple tries to defy the whole Jat community then they deserve punishment. But I think such couple should be expelled from the Jat community rather than killing them or declaring them brother and sister.
What do you want? If some Jat couple of same village or same gotra marries, then it's OK? If you say why not, then I ask you "are those 99.99% Jats fool who abide by the tradition and guidelines, set by our elders?"
 
So, you want to tell me that Jats are basically murderers.
Jats are all in all. They are hard core criminals (much more lethal than the Muslims), they are brave policemen, brave soldiers, hardworking farmers, wrestlers, smart, healthy, wealthy, world level businessman, top leaders...All in all. They bloody are No. 1 in world. Best caste of the world.
There is a lot of difference between a warrior and a murderer. First one kills or dies for some noble cause while the later kills someone for selfish and darogatory motives.
Vijay Ji, do you know why a chamaar is not brave? (Though exceptions are always there). According to me when fighting on border having gun in hand, a chamaar asks himself 'can you kill the enemy?' Then his heart says 'No. you can just mend shoes. Chamaar are not known for killing.' And then his self-confidence loses. But when a Jat asks himself 'can you kill the enemy?' Then his heart says 'Why not, you are known for this.' And he gains confidence. I think you got the point.
I don't think that any person feels proud of a Murderer.
Different people have different views. May be you are right, but I think if your thinking is followed by the Jats then they will become nothing but Brahmins or Baniyas. No self-respect, no dominance, no pride, nothing else...

With best regards
 
Last edited:
Very well said

Very well said Sunil Lathwal

i am not Hitesh, neither do i subscribe to his definition of Jatism... but if your questions (regarding Khap) are sincere, then:

1. Khap is nothing but a group of village panchayats... sort of superset of panchayat.

2. Khap is NOT Taliban. Please do Not compare these two (especially when you have NO idea {as u admit} about the functioning or constituents of a khap ; It look stupid) :)

3. Khap does not have any fixed agenda or fixed regular meeting or any set of fixed rules.

4. Khaps are for: resolving 'issues' between villages (which are beyond the ability of a single village panchayat). More often than not issue is same gotra/gotras marriage!

5. Why are the khaps being branded as some sort of evil (specially in media)?? Because khap ruling / fatwas on an issue are in accordance with the traditions (sensitivities, practices, customs) of the majority of people involved in that 'issue'; which looks absurd to a third person who is ignorant about the local traditions. Also being a unconstitutional body khap ruling generally go against the law. e.g. same village, same gotra marriage are fine with police and law but not with khaps.

Anyways, khap issue has been discussed in details on Jatland. Give a search if you are really interested. Some good arguments in favor of (and against) khap had been put by fellow members!!
 
2. Khap is NOT Taliban. Please do Not compare these two (especially when you have NO idea {as u admit} about the functioning or constituents of a khap ; It look stupid) :)

Sunil, I don't think vijay123 was saying that Khaps are like Taliban. He said "by your definition every muslim criticizer of these sick talibans is a non Muslim." The question is if any Muslim (say in Taliban ruled areas) defying Taliban's authority would become a non-muslim? Or any Christian defying Vatican's diktats becomes a non-Christian? Or any Indian criticising govt's policies becomes a non-Indian? The answer is no and I am sure you'd agree. So why would a Jat questioning Khaps become a non Jat or a duplicate Jat? (By the way, I didn't even question Khaps here. I was just asking Upender if he was using his brain or following blindly). There is a problem when some people don't want to use their brains and it only becomes bigger when the same people abuse and shout down those who dare to use theirs'.
 
Yes, you are correct about what I intended to say in the post. Khaps used to be a governing / guiding body of 84 villages and following them is not binding, otherwise every jat would have known more details about his khap. Does most of us know who is the head of their khap? They used to be relevant in older days when their was no constitution, no boundaries etc. I do not believe in them and that does not make me a lesser Jat. I dont think there is any such thing as Jat Khap, if there is I would like to know about it.

Sunil, I don't think vijay123 was saying that Khaps are like Taliban. He said "by your definition every muslim criticizer of these sick talibans is a non Muslim." The question is if any Muslim (say in Taliban ruled areas) defying Taliban's authority would become a non-muslim? Or any Christian defying Vatican's diktats becomes a non-Christian? Or any Indian criticising govt's policies becomes a non-Indian? The answer is no and I am sure you'd agree. So why would a Jat questioning Khaps become a non Jat or a duplicate Jat? (By the way, I didn't even question Khaps here. I was just asking Upender if he was using his brain or following blindly). There is a problem when some people don't want to use their brains and it only becomes bigger when the same people abuse and shout down those who dare to use theirs'.
 
Sunil, I don't think vijay123 was saying that Khaps are like Taliban. He said "by your definition every muslim criticizer of these sick talibans is a non Muslim." The question is if any Muslim (say in Taliban ruled areas) defying Taliban's authority would become a non-muslim? Or any Christian defying Vatican's diktats becomes a non-Christian? Or any Indian criticising govt's policies becomes a non-Indian? The answer is no and I am sure you'd agree. So why would a Jat questioning Khaps become a non Jat or a duplicate Jat? (By the way, I didn't even question Khaps here. I was just asking Upender if he was using his brain or following blindly). There is a problem when some people don't want to use their brains and it only becomes bigger when the same people abuse and shout down those who dare to use theirs'.

Kapil, thats why i said i don't agree with 'their' definition of Jat or duplicate jat;
may be you and others don't feel but somehow i found the taliban analogy a bit harsh here. Earlier also many ppl have used the "desi talibani" etc. for khaps [without having an iota of idea about khap functionality (understanding of their khap is mostly media fed or read from comments section of shitty wesbites).
Anyway, we already had the discussion about the "khap should...." and "khap shouldn't... ". and only reason i replied to Vijay post was to give a brief account of khaps [more so because he said he doesn't have any idea about khaps)]!!
 
So why would a Jat questioning Khaps become a non Jat or a duplicate Jat? (By the way, I didn't even question Khaps here. I was just asking Upender if he was using his brain or following blindly). There is a problem when some people don't want to use their brains and it only becomes bigger when the same people abuse and shout down those who dare to use theirs'.

Kapil, there is no point in 'engaging' such ppl; when they have no logical answer, they call you non-this, non-that, Jaichands, etc... someone going personal is the first sign that he/she doesn't have any sensible argument or fact to prove/strengthen his/her claim, it is futile to have any kind of argument from there.. Replying in 'same words' does not help much.. some ppl relish muddy words too :D Best bet is to totally ignore them and move on. :D
 
Last edited:
Jats are all in all. They are hard core criminals (much more lethal than the Muslims), they are brave policemen, brave soldiers, hardworking farmers, wrestlers, smart, healthy, wealthy, world level businessman, top leaders...All in all. They bloody are No. 1 in world. Best caste of the world.


I don't understand what you want to say????? Please have good english lessons if you don't have command over english language,you are maligning the whole community by saying they are criminals.And to my horror you are equating criminals with being brave.
Its a shame!!!!! that you have equated every brave jat soul in whatever occupation they might have been and served the country to be criminals.
If your problem is, that you cant express yourselves in english and have committed such errors in your posts ,then you should opt to reply in hindi their is no shame in it.But if you think you are a shakespeare and still say you are right then you are not a jat for sure.
 
I don't understand what you want to say?????
I want to say that Jats have all qualities in themselves. 3 in 1 is greater than 2 in 1 and All in 1 is greater than 3 in 1 and All in All is greater than All in 1. So I meant to say Jats are All in All. They have all type of qualities and they are not only murderers as Mr. Vijay was unhappy about it in his earlier post.
Please have good english lessons if you don't have command over english language,you are maligning the whole community by saying they are criminals.And to my horror you are equating criminals with being brave.
Ha...ha...ha...I first time heard this line from some one in last 18 years of my life that I should have good English lessons. (LOLz). Well, what do you want Sir, Jats should not carry weapons, should not kill who challenge their dominance. You must know that carrying weapon is a very well known Jat tradition. I remember some years back a Dalit boy Rakesh @ Lara killed a Jat boy in Gohana I think and the kins of that victim Jat boy shot down that Dalit boy on same date of next year. What would you say? They did wrong by taking revenge? I don't care what other think but I like such Jats, who go to any extent to maintain their self-respect. Though I don't support petty criminals, autolifters, thieves etc.
Its a shame!!!!! that you have equated every brave jat soul in whatever occupation they might have been and served the country to be criminals.
If your problem is, that you cant express yourselves in english and have committed such errors in your posts ,then you should opt to reply in hindi their is no shame in it.But if you think you are a shakespeare and still say you are right then you are not a jat for sure.
You believe or not, but it is a fact that where the crime rate is high, people of that region always try to impress and intimidate others with their crime culture, be it Bihar or Italy's Sicily. I just wanted to say that Jats have authoriy in this field too. Go to the Rai Police Station of Sonepat district sometime, you will find dozens of 50,000 Rs. rewardee wanted criminals there and mostly of them are from well to do families. You or me can't change this Jatism. I was not comparing the brave souls to the criminals. I will never like to be Shakespeare (A petty drama writer) or you can say I can't become like him ever.:):):)
 
Kapil, there is no point in 'engaging' such ppl; when they have no logical answer, they call you non-this, non-that, Jaichands, etc... someone going personal is the first sign that he/she doesn't have any sensible argument or fact to prove/strengthen his/her claim, it is futile to have any kind of argument from there.. Replying in 'same words' does not help much.. some ppl relish muddy words too :D Best bet is to totally ignore them and move on. :D

Strong agreer. But there is a caveat. An online forum is not only a one to one reply. There is a need to challenge those engaging in mindless rhetoric lest it becomes the default voice. But yes, one has to be careful on how you challenge it without making it mindless to-and-fro mud-slinging; not that easy I admit.
 
Khaps are opposed to the marriages of same gotra and in there bhai chara.....Media gives logic of marriage act....our traditions are from many years before the constitution even thought of.

If the Khaps allow these kind of marriages then it's an approval of marrying you own sisters with their brothers. I think for the future of ours it's NOT GOOD and it should be in law and if not mentioned in the Hindu Marriage act then it should be amended as per our traditions (which are scientifically proved true).

On the other hand Khaps does not have right to take someone's life but the solution is make a law and create awareness among public to follow the suit.
 
Back
Top