The Black Tuesday- Indira Gandhi Shot

bls31

New member
The Black Tuesday- Indira Gandhi Shot

I t was on 31st October 1984 when just back from the foreign otur and busy finalising the report that one of the staff came rushing in my office in Sena Bhawan blurting the incredible news in an agitated voice ‘Mrs Gandhi has been shot’. Though stunned I refused to believe it and told him not to spread rumours. However, it was true she had been shot and that too by her own guards.
Early morning, the next day, coming out of my house in Dhaula Kuan Part II, I noticed in far-distance large columns of smoke bellowing high in the sky. Alarmed I rang up Gyan Bains the Commander, a Sikh Brigadier, of a unit technically under me albeit administratively under Delhi Area.
‘…What are you doing sitting there with Delhi burning’ I asked in an agitated voice.
‘We are preparing for Mrs Gandhi's funeral’ was the reply I got.
Feeling helpless and traumatised, that was the sum total of my initiative on that fateful day

[FONT=&quot][1][/FONT]I was also destined to play a minuscule role in this sad and sordid episode in standing as part of an inter-service guard along with another officer of my rank, in shifts. The body of Indra Gandhi lying in state in Teen Murty Bhawan, me blankly watching, the unending line of humanity with people with folded hands and agony written on their faces silently and slowly shuffle by.
One image from those days still remains etched in my mind is that of a Sikh couple riding, break-neck, on a scooter whom I over-took near the Buddha Jayanti Park one afternoon, when the mayhem had not yet died. They had dared to be on the road, possibly the errand was more important that the perceived risk to life.

Even at this late stage can someone enlighten me, a Hindu married to a Sikh as to how I should have reacted to the events of the day mentally if not physically. Sadly to what depth the so-called civilized human beings can sink!
We learn nothing otherwise such sudden and gruesome incidents, some planned others spontaneous, the emotionally charged and insane crowds mostly lead by criminal elements always on lookout for opportunities like Godhra and what happened subsequently in Gujarat as also immanently forgettable events earlier and later in India and abroad, would not have happened.

bls31




[FONT=&quot][1][/FONT] Indira Gandhi had numerous bodyguards, two of whom were Satwant Singh and Beant Singh, both Sikhs. On October 31, 1984 British Peter Ustinov filming a documentary for Irish television, she passed a wicket gate, guarded by Satwant and Beant. According to information available immediately following the incident, Beant Singh shot her thrice using his side-arm and Satwant Singh fired twenty-two rounds into her using a Sten submachine gun. Beant Singh was shot dead and Satwant Singh was shot and arrested by her other bodyguards.. After her death, sectarian unrest engulfed New Delhi and several other cities in India, including Kanpur, Asansol and Indore, leading to the death of thousands of Sikhs.

they assassinated Indira Gandhi with their service weapons in the garden of the Prime Minister's Residence at No. 1, Safdarjung Road in New Delhi. As she was walking to be interviewed by the actor
 
Last edited:
This carnage would not have happened unless it had approval from the highest level of Indian political leadership. Only the people who suffered at that time are still going through the trauma, others have moved on and the perpetrators have gone scot-free. Welcome to the Indian democracy!
Also welcome to the reality of human nature. Man is a beast. A little separates a man from an animal. People are basically mean and selfish and only concerned with themselves. If bad stuff happen to others it is okay, but if it happens to them it is altogether a different thing. And if they think they can get away with crime, most people would do it!
 
The assassination of Indira Gandhi was destined to happen after she ordered Indian Army to storm the Sikhs' holiest shrine, the golden temple in Amritsar, to flush out Sikh militants holed in there but resulted in death of hundreds of Sikh pilgrims. Revenge came swiftly. Five months later, Indira was assassinated. Her assassins were Sikhs. The response to her killing came even more swiftly. Within hours of her death, stray incidents of violence targeting Sikhs began trickling in from various parts of Delhi.

Later this massacre was indirectly justified by Rajiv Gandhi as he quoted,"When a mighty tree falls, it is only natural that the earth around it does shake a little."

2,733 sikhs were killed in Delhi. The Citizens Justice Committee submitted 3,870 names to an enquiry commission who still roam free. A quarter of a century later, justice is yet to be done. Out of 2,733 officially admitted murders, only nine cases led to convictions. Just over 20 accused have been convicted in 25 years - a conviction rate of less than 1%. Out of these 3,870 names 198 local Congress activists and others, 15 Congress leaders and 143 police officials were included. Jagdish Tytler and H K L Bhagat went on to have successful political careers, even holding cabinet posts.


Now, Indira's assassins, Satwant Singh, the lone surviving assassin (Beant Singh, the other assassin, was shot dead soon after the assassination while he was allegedly trying to escape) and Kehar singh the conspirator, were tried and hanged within four years. But the militants like Kasab and Afjal Guru will carry on living their highly secure life. Thanks to our govt. and to our judicial system.

These were the consequences of Black Tuesday. And the Black Friday resulted in death of about 900 people mainly muslims in 1992-93. Then came the 2002 Godhra kand which cause Muslims massacre in the state of Gujarat by mobs aided by politicians. I don't think there is any day left in Indian calender which is not Black.
lg.php
 
Last edited:
Jyada pata nahi
baaki Indira aur Sikho(Sardaro) par ek program aa raha tha T.V. par jisko dekh ke logo ke man mein sikho ke liye nafrat bhadak sakti hai.
Aise topic ko baar baar kyon uthana pehle hi bahut nuksan ho chuka hai.
 
Akshay, the assassination wasn't destined but Indira Gandhi's blind faith over sikh bodyguards that led to it. Well, Operation Blue Star was inevitable and I value Indira's firm decision to allow Army to eliminate the terrorists from Golden temple. If you do some deep readings of the very operation then you'll respect Indira's decision of ordering operation Blue star. That was extreme need of hour, if she wouldn't order .. for sure Punjab would have been a separate free state as Khalistan. But aftermath of her assassination, the Anti-Sikh Riots is shameful black spot on the history of modern India so is Babri Maszid demolition and Godhra riots.

Please go thro' this link and read, I bet you'll change your perception towards Iron Lady -

http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?p=216393#post216393

http://www.rediff.com/news/2004/jun/03spec.htm

http://www.sikh.com.au/blue/


Rock on
Jit




The assassination of Indira Gandhi was destined to happen after she ordered Indian Army to storm the Sikhs' holiest shrine, the golden temple in Amritsar, to flush out Sikh militants holed in there but resulted in death of hundreds of Sikh pilgrims. Revenge came swiftly. Five months later, Indira was assassinated. Her assassins were Sikhs. The response to her killing came even more swiftly. Within hours of her death, stray incidents of violence targeting Sikhs began trickling in from various parts of Delhi.

Later this massacre was indirectly justified by Rajiv Gandhi as he quoted,"When a mighty tree falls, it is only natural that the earth around it does shake a little."

2,733 sikhs were killed in Delhi. The Citizens Justice Committee submitted 3,870 names to an enquiry commission who still roam free. A quarter of a century later, justice is yet to be done. Out of 2,733 officially admitted murders, only nine cases led to convictions. Just over 20 accused have been convicted in 25 years - a conviction rate of less than 1%. Out of these 3,870 names 198 local Congress activists and others, 15 Congress leaders and 143 police officials were included. Jagdish Tytler and H K L Bhagat went on to have successful political careers, even holding cabinet posts.


Now, Indira's assassins, Satwant Singh, the lone surviving assassin (Beant Singh, the other assassin, was shot dead soon after the assassination while he was allegedly trying to escape) and Kehar singh the conspirator, were tried and hanged within four years. But the militants like Kasab and Afjal Guru will carry on living their highly secure life. Thanks to our govt. and to our judicial system.

These were the consequences of Black Tuesday. And the Black Friday resulted in death of about 900 people mainly muslims in 1992-93. Then came the 2002 Godhra kand which cause Muslims massacre in the state of Gujarat by mobs aided by politicians. I don't think there is any day left in Indian calender which is not Black.
lg.php
 
Please read about Bhindrawala on net also...


It was Indira Gandhi who had given a 'lift' to Bhindrawalan who later became a threat for this arrogant lady !

Throughout his career Jarnail Singh Bhindrawala remained in contact with Indira Gandhi who maintained the contact despite allegations!!

The confusion in the Governor's house in Chandigarh was made worse by Mrs. Gandhi maintaining contact with Bhindranwale. Her go-between was the President of Punjab Congress, Raghunandan Lal Bhatia ... This link, which was well known to officials, enhanced Bhindranwale's status and made the Indian administration even more reluctant to grapple with him."

Read this book : Amritsar; Mrs. Gandhi's last Battle. by Tully, Mark; Satish Jacob (1985).


So, in my opinion, Indira was equally responsible for Blue Star and not only Bhindrawala..! Kya pata kya khichdi pak rahi thee dono mein....
 
Please read about Bhindrawala on net also...


It was Indira Gandhi who had given a 'lift' to Bhindrawalan who later became a threat for this arrogant lady !

Throughout his career Jarnail Singh Bhindrawala remained in contact with Indira Gandhi who maintained the contact despite allegations!!

The confusion in the Governor's house in Chandigarh was made worse by Mrs. Gandhi maintaining contact with Bhindranwale. Her go-between was the President of Punjab Congress, Raghunandan Lal Bhatia ... This link, which was well known to officials, enhanced Bhindranwale's status and made the Indian administration even more reluctant to grapple with him."

Read this book : Amritsar; Mrs. Gandhi's last Battle. by Tully, Mark; Satish Jacob (1985).


So, in my opinion, Indira was equally responsible for Blue Star and not only Bhindrawala..! Kya pata kya khichdi pak rahi thee dono mein....

Lending an ear to a status leader is not wrong!

When she can challenge US President Nixon then ,
then why not our own Bhindrawala..if he mistook that great lady's Wisdom.

कृतज्ञ भारतवर्ष ने नम्न आँखों से श्रीमती इंदिरा गाँधी को उनके बलिदान दिवस पर याद किया |
 
Last edited:
It was really a sad day when Mrs. Gandhi was shot dead. After the heavy loss of such a great leader, Delhi burnt by riots. These are one of worst incidents of Indian history.
Indra Gandhi was great lady with strong decision making power. I always appreciate her decision making ability.
I don't know whether Mrs. Gandhi was responsible for rise of Bhindarawla or not. But one thing is sure, Condition in Punjab was pathetic at that time. Country was on a verge of another division. Bhindrawala was a threat to national security. Operation blue star was necessary to tackle terrorism problem in Punjab. Presently, Punjab is one of the most peaceful state because of operation blue star.
 
What all i can say is that what had happened was really bad but showing it on TV again and again will hit the sentiments of people and we have seen people in last few days people were protesting and asking for the justice it can cause problems in the country some times.
 
The Black Tuesday- Indira Gandhi Shot

I

Even at this late stage can someone enlighten me, a Hindu married to a Sikh as to how I should have reacted to the events of the day mentally if not physically. Sadly to what depth the so-called civilized human beings can sink!
We learn nothing otherwise such sudden and gruesome incidents, some planned others spontaneous, the emotionally charged and insane crowds mostly lead by criminal elements always on lookout for opportunities like Godhra and what happened subsequently in Gujarat as also immanently forgettable events earlier and later in India and abroad, would not have happened.

bls31

Still no one has answered my question. How I should have reacted to the events of the day mentally if not physically?
Bls31




[FONT=&quot][[/FONT]
 
The Black Tuesday- Indira Gandhi Shot

I

Even at this late stage can someone enlighten me, a Hindu married to a Sikh as to how I should have reacted to the events of the day mentally if not physically. Sadly to what depth the so-called civilized human beings can sink!
We learn nothing otherwise such sudden and gruesome incidents, some planned others spontaneous, the emotionally charged and insane crowds mostly lead by criminal elements always on lookout for opportunities like Godhra and what happened subsequently in Gujarat as also immanently forgettable events earlier and later in India and abroad, would not have happened.

bls31

Still no one has answered my question. How I should have reacted to the events of the day mentally if not physically?
Bls31




[FONT=&quot][[/FONT]


Mostly Hindus do not care about religon rather care for self and family. As you were already married to a Sikh girl so I dont think there would have been any dilema in your mind about religious clash of Hindu and Sikhs.

I dont know to what depth Human being can sink but the consequences of human Sins are much worse than its intentions.
 
Terrorism has no face and no religion.
Vikrit mansikta walo ki koi jati nahi hoti. Us waqt jo logo ne sikho ke saath kiya wo galat tha. Ek aadmi ya group ki galtiyo ko sampooran jati par nahi thopa ja sakta.Ham sabki ek jati hai aur wo hai manavta use taak par rakh kar jo do sikho ne ek neta ko maar diya to baaki samaj ne bhi us manavta ko taak par rakh kar baaki sikho ke ghar aur insaan zinda jala diye. Aise halat mein hame apne jan-ne walo ko samjhana chahiye ki khamkha ke behkawo mein aakara manav aur manavta ke khilaaf apradh na karein.
 
The black Tuesday- Indira Gandhi Shot

Brigadier Sahib,

You and your wife had long back transcended your religious identities as Hindu or Sikh.Obviously both of you made the best of your essential identity as a couple.The profession of a soldier did cement it.
Your reaction to the events of 31 October 1984 and the subsequent days could have been only what you have related. It could not be diffeent.All good souls were hurt and sad over both the tragedies- a national tragedy on 31 and a trgic response triggered by lunatic minds oblivious of consequences.
 
I deeply appreciate what you have opined .Thanks,
As we are talking about our relationship what I wrote nine years after he demise posted under will say all. Brig Lakshman

The Gurudawara at Anandpur​
and ​
Kababs at Chandigarh​

It was getting dark on that chilly, remembered, December evening of the year 1999.

From Chandigarh, past Bhakra, climbing up, to Una in Himachal Pradesh and on to Bangara, Dharam Singh’s home, a hamlet of just four houses, mostly in second, gear on the twisting and turning, unpaved track of a road, I have been driving since morning.

Now, returning back to Chandigarh , both of us tired, Jeet frail and weak, back from the recent long and debilitating journey from , New York, possibly deep in her own thoughts, a victim of cancer, that though defeated twice but not been vanquished is, once again, quietly stirring inside her, is unusually quiet.

I am a worried man and a concerned husband, concerned about her and worried, already getting late in the night with Punjab recently returned from the heavy bout of insurgency coupled with so many other imponderables lurking at he back of my mind, of making it safe to Chandigarh.

In a hurry, I am pressing the accelerator down and pushing the NE 118 hard on the lonely narrow dark road lit only by the twin car headlights as it hurtles ahead, with the engine humming smoothly, the reassuring, sound somewhat soothing to my troubled mind.

On our way up as we crossed Anandpur Sihab, Jeet, was keen to pay her respects at the gurudawara, already late and I in a hurry to reach Una, where Dharam Singh, my section JCO from 1962, was waiting for us, had suggested to pend it for the same evening return journey.

Nearing Anand Pur Saihab, I slow down and breaking her reverie indicate to her the gurudawara, now visible from the window of the moving car in far distance, perched on a hillock, flood lit and shining like a jewel.

Sensing the latent tension in my tone, Jeet, perceptible as usual, responds “It is getting late; let us leave it for some other time.”

I know that she would be sourly disappointed if she misses this opportunity and now already late, I reckon that now, another hour or so would not make much of a difference: ‘Who knows when we will come this side again.” I say and spin the steering wheel left, turning the car off the road and on to the track leading to the gurudawara.

At the foot of the hillock, where I park, is a shanty market with the stalls doing roaring business, selling nick knacks, Karas, Kirpans and other souvenirs of the visit to the holy place to the devotees and eatables to the accompanying children.

I wait in the car as Jeet opens her side door, gingerly steps out and starts her slow trudge up on the winding path.

I, in a pensive mood, watch her slow laboured progress. She must have been half up when some thing hit me and exploded inside. “What am I doing here sitting in the comfort of the car, while she is struggling up, taking each step with the force of will power, I ask myself? In desperation I jump out, bang the car door and run up the track, taking the steps two at a time, hoping to catch up and join with her before she vanishes from sight in the milling multitude of the devotees.

Huffing and puffing I do make it, surprising her in the processes. She, seeing me there unexpectedly, possibly experiencing frisson and as I hold her hand gives me a vane smile: both of us enter the portals of the holy place and following the customs, side by side, perform the required rituals and pay our observances.

With the divine hand now looking after us all the way, we made Chandigarh safe and sound. However, on reaching the city, Jeet, though an extremely poor eater had an intense urge for Mutton Kababs. All the restaurants of the town did have Kababs but of Chicken. Mutton, we did manage finally in a five star hotel, after going around all the eateries, as the last resort. That however is another story, another episode, in the Odyssey of our life together to be narrated some other time.
 
Last edited:
The Black Tuesday-Indira Gandhi Shot

Brigediar Laxman Singh Ji,

Your piece was poetry. My eyes were wet as I read through it.
I live in New Delhi. I would have loved to see you when ever I go to see my friend Lt.Col (retd.) J.R. Rana at NOIDA. But that can happen only later as currently I am in Houston, USA for some time.
Regards
Dr. S.S.Rana
 
RIOTS after Indira amma shoot-out were carried on say of Muslim Rajiv Gandhi.

Muslims were traditonally against Sikhs as they have challenged their culture of theft & murders.

Pt Nehru had told Indira not to marry in other religion or caste....
But she never listened to her father's words resulting:

One son was found dead in plane crash , after his works towards Emergency & other atrocities.

Other called for a Massacre of his own people..
Worse than Gen Dyer of Jalliawala bagh , Amritsar.
 
I deeply appreciate what you have opined .Thanks,
As we are talking about our relationship what I wrote nine years after he demise posted under will say all. Brig Lakshman

The Gurudawara at Anandpur​
and ​
Kababs at Chandigarh​


I wait in the car as Jeet opens her side door, gingerly steps out and starts her slow trudge up on the winding path.

I, in a pensive mood, watch her slow laboured progress. She must have been half up when some thing hit me and exploded inside. “What am I doing here sitting in the comfort of the car, while she is struggling up, taking each step with the force of will power, I ask myself? In desperation I jump out, bang the car door and run up the track, taking the steps two at a time, hoping to catch up and join with her before she vanishes from sight in the milling multitude of the devotees.

Huffing and puffing I do make it, surprising her in the processes. She, seeing me there unexpectedly, possibly experiencing frisson and as I hold her hand gives me a vane smile: both of us enter the portals of the holy place and following the customs, side by side, perform the required rituals and pay our observances.



आप बेहद खुबसूरत तरह से बयां करते हैं
 
Thanks . But so can you. Try describing every day events in simple language and see the result. Best of Luck BLS31
 
Back
Top