Thinkink...a perception

Status
Not open for further replies.
D

devdahiya

New member
Five identical questions each were asked to a BANNIYA boy and a JAT boy in olden days.These questions were asked impromptu to get the insight of the thinking pattern of a particular group.Questions and answers given by each boy are given here under.


Question 1] Teri maa tannein dudhh kyun pyaya krei?(why your mother give you milk)

Ans 1) Jat boy: Wa mere tein pyarre ittana kre sei arr mannei taggadda aur tanddarust dekhna chahwei sei( She loves me and wants to see me happy and healthy.

Ans 1) Baniya Boy: Meri maa kehti hei ke doodhh peene se dimaagg badhhta hei.

Question 2) Agar tumhari maa se koi badtameezzee kre tou?

Ans2)Jat Boy: Kiss Saale ki himmatt sei.....unnei dharti par tein kho dyun(how dare some idot...i will ruin him and his family}

Ans 2 Baniya Boy: Mein police mein report kar duunga.

Question 3): Ek cheez jiske binna aaddami kutta ban jata hei?

Answer 3) Jat boy: Izzat ke binna

Answer 3) Bania boy: Paisse ke binna

Question 4) Jindagi meinSabse badda dost?
Ans 4) Jat boy: Appanna Khuun(own blood)

Ans 4) Baniya Boy: Padhhai( Education)

Question 5) Sase baddi Quarbaani(sacrifice)

Ans 5) Jat boy: Desh ki raksha karte -2 jaan de dena

Ans 5) Baniya boy: Apni mehnat ki kammai ko daan karna.





These mindsets say a lot about the mental make up of a group of people.What say you?
 
Last edited:
Kaka mazak ke taur par le toh achha hai lkin agar sachaai aur practally dekhein toh baniya kuch jyada galat nahi hai.


Q No 4 mein mujhe baniye ka reply achha laga.:)
 
dkumars said:
Kaka mazak ke taur par le toh achha hai lkin agar sachaai aur practally dekhein toh baniya kuch jyada galat nahi hai.


Q No 4 mein mujhe baniye ka reply achha laga.:)
Click to expand...



Na bhai..it is not a mazzak......it is a perception...nothing wrong...nothing right per say.......yes it can change...with time..is a different matter all together.Why was this perception can be a question alright but answers have to be researched really....It was so it was....may be it is still and so be it.
 
Sir, the very first perception of these two people had spoken a lot about them.

Jats by nature.....very affectionate
Baniyas by nature.....very calculative

:)
 
devdahiya said:
Five identical questions each were asked to a BANNIYA boy and a JAT boy in olden days.These questions were asked impromptu to get the insight of the thinking pattern of a particular group.Questions and answers given by each boy are given here under.


Question 1] Teri maa tannein dudhh kyun pyaya krei?(why your mother give you milk)

Ans 1) Jat boy: Wa mere tein pyarre ittana kre sei arr mannei taggadda aur tanddarust dekhna chahwei sei( She loves me and wants to see me happy and healthy.

Ans 1) Baniya Boy: Meri maa kehti hei ke doodhh peene se dimaagg badhhta hei.

Question 2) Agar tumhari maa se koi badtameezzee kre tou?

Ans2)Jat Boy: Kiss Saale ki himmatt sei.....unnei dharti par tein kho dyun(how dare some idot...i will ruin him and his family}

Ans 2 Baniya Boy: Mein police mein report kar duunga.

Question 3): Ek cheez jiske binna aaddami kutta ban jata hei?

Answer 3) Jat boy: Izzat ke binna

Answer 3) Bania boy: Paisse ke binna

Question 4) Jindagi meinSabse badda dost?
Ans 4) Jat boy: Appanna Khuun(own blood)

Ans 4) Baniya Boy: Padhhai( Education)

Question 5) Sase baddi Quarbaani(sacrifice)

Ans 5) Jat boy: Desh ki raksha karte -2 jaan de dena

Ans 5) Baniya boy: Apni mehnat ki kammai ko daan karna.





These mindsets say a lot about the mental make up of a group of people.What say you?
Click to expand...


Dev sir u r correct even if have been asked these questions i thought that atleast 4 answers would be same by me as u have posted here.
 
Dev Sir ji,

Well normal perception is right. Bachpan mein Mummy ne ek kahaani sunaai thi which proves it as well.

kehte hai, ek baar Lakshmi Ji went to a baniya's house. Baniya welcomed her and gave her food and everything. After sometime Lakshmi ji got up and getting ready to leave. Then baniya asked her, can she wait till he comes back, he got to do some work? Lakshmi ji bechaari bholi si thi so she said okay. Baniya went to the village well (kua) and jumped in it and died. So he never came back. So tab se leker ab tak Lakshmi Ji is still waiting in Baniya's house waiting for him to come back.
 
I am 100% with Jat Boy's Answers.

Hamarey Dharm Grantho key hisaab say bhee yeahi sahi hai per hamarey kuchh bhai Baniyo key sobat mein rehker paise ko jayada mahatav deney lagey hai isliyea Sehat or apney logo key esthan per paise or padhai ko jayada mahatav detey hai.

devdahiya said:
Five identical questions each were asked to a BANNIYA boy and a JAT boy in olden days.These questions were asked impromptu to get the insight of the thinking pattern of a particular group.Questions and answers given by each boy are given here under.


Question 1] Teri maa tannein dudhh kyun pyaya krei?(why your mother give you milk)

Ans 1) Jat boy: Wa mere tein pyarre ittana kre sei arr mannei taggadda aur tanddarust dekhna chahwei sei( She loves me and wants to see me happy and healthy.

Ans 1) Baniya Boy: Meri maa kehti hei ke doodhh peene se dimaagg badhhta hei.

Question 2) Agar tumhari maa se koi badtameezzee kre tou?

Ans2)Jat Boy: Kiss Saale ki himmatt sei.....unnei dharti par tein kho dyun(how dare some idot...i will ruin him and his family}

Ans 2 Baniya Boy: Mein police mein report kar duunga.

Question 3): Ek cheez jiske binna aaddami kutta ban jata hei?

Answer 3) Jat boy: Izzat ke binna

Answer 3) Bania boy: Paisse ke binna

Question 4) Jindagi meinSabse badda dost?
Ans 4) Jat boy: Appanna Khuun(own blood)

Ans 4) Baniya Boy: Padhhai( Education)

Question 5) Sase baddi Quarbaani(sacrifice)

Ans 5) Jat boy: Desh ki raksha karte -2 jaan de dena

Ans 5) Baniya boy: Apni mehnat ki kammai ko daan karna.





These mindsets say a lot about the mental make up of a group of people.What say you?
Click to expand...
 
skarmveer said:
Hamarey Dharm Grantho key hisaab say bhee yeahi sahi hai per hamarey kuchh bhai Baniyo key sobat mein rehker paise ko jayada mahatav deney lagey hai isliyea Sehat or apney logo key esthan per paise or padhai ko jayada mahatav detey hai.
Click to expand...

Sir g I don't think that Education is wrong beleive me its most important thing to do. And i m felling glad k kissi ke sobat me akar sahe woh Padai kaar rahe hain bhagwan kaare k saara desh inke sobat me aakar padhne laage.
 
This thread is named perception but actually Baniyas are belittled here. This is just a story or just to please Jat crowd otherwise go and do a survey with 100 jats and baniyas ... U will come to know what Jats are and how coward Baniyas are.

I still do not understand why we ppl preach a lot and show such discrimination this or that way. India ek rahe par mazzak mazzak mein kuch bhi keh denge.

Aur kuch bhaisaahb toh aise hai jinhe jat word related sab kuch achha lagta hai(khudh unhone hi kaha tha). Well, I accept Jat bhagwan ka bhi baap hai aur kuch bhi kar sakta hai ... duniya mein iss se baddi jaati(caste) koi hui hi nahi aaj tak ...

Woh kehte hai naa log dusre ki tarakki se khush nahi ... bass baniya logo ki tarakki hazam nahi hoti humse ... Kabhi Baniya, Kabhi Brahmin, kabhi Gujarr, Kabhi Rajput ... huh ... kabhi khatam hoga ya nahi ???

Aap logo ko nahi lagta ki aisi baatein hum logo ko superior feel hone mein support karti hai aur doosri jaatiyon se doori badhaati hai .... atleast mujhe toh aisi feeling aayi.

Thumbs down to many of posts on this thread. There is nothing bad wrriten here but it smells like some hidden unnecessary sarcasm for Baniyas.
 
skarmveer said:
Hamarey Dharm Grantho key hisaab say bhee yeahi sahi hai per hamarey kuchh bhai Baniyo key sobat mein rehker paise ko jayada mahatav deney lagey hai isliyea Sehat or apney logo key esthan per paise or padhai ko jayada mahatav detey hai.
Click to expand...


Mujhe bhi Grantho ka link dijiye ... mein bhi jatton ki sobat mein aakar jatton jaisa ban na chahta hoon ... actually mein baniyon ki sobat mein rehkar baniya bann gaya hoon par abb toh Dharam, granth padh kar jaat ban na hi hai.... huhhh:cool:
 
dkumars said:
This thread is named perception but actually Baniyas are belittled here. This is just a story or just to please Jat crowd otherwise go and do a survey with 100 jats and baniyas ... U will come to know what Jats are and how coward Baniyas are.

I still do not understand why we ppl preach a lot and show such discrimination this or that way. India ek rahe par mazzak mazzak mein kuch bhi keh denge.

Aur kuch bhaisaahb toh aise hai jinhe jat word related sab kuch achha lagta hai(khudh unhone hi kaha tha). Well, I accept Jat bhagwan ka bhi baap hai aur kuch bhi kar sakta hai ... duniya mein iss se baddi jaati(caste) koi hui hi nahi aaj tak ...

Woh kehte hai naa log dusre ki tarakki se khush nahi ... bass baniya logo ki tarakki hazam nahi hoti humse ... Kabhi Baniya, Kabhi Brahmin, kabhi Gujarr, Kabhi Rajput ... huh ... kabhi khatam hoga ya nahi ???

Aap logo ko nahi lagta ki aisi baatein hum logo ko superior feel hone mein support karti hai aur doosri jaatiyon se doori badhaati hai .... atleast mujhe toh aisi feeling aayi.

Thumbs down to many of posts on this thread. There is nothing bad wrriten here but it smells like some hidden unnecessary sarcasm for Baniyas.
Click to expand...

More than Agree
icon14.gif
 
For mee Education is secondery if we compare with our own people.

Bhai yea kesee vaykti vishes key liyea nahi likha hai. Yea mera anubhav hai or mein issey sahi nahi manta. Edu. bahut avashyak hai per parivaar or samaj key sath hee achhi lagti hai agar hamara koi na ho to us edu. ka kya karengey.

nishantrathi82 said:
Sir g I don't think that Education is wrong beleive me its most important thing to do. And i m felling glad k kissi ke sobat me akar sahe woh Padai kaar rahe hain bhagwan kaare k saara desh inke sobat me aakar padhne laage.
Click to expand...
 
skarmveer said:
Bhai yea kesee vaykti vishes key liyea nahi likha hai. Yea mera anubhav hai or mein issey sahi nahi manta. Edu. bahut avashyak hai per parivaar or samaj key sath hee achhi lagti hai agar hamara koi na ho to us edu. ka kya karengey.
Click to expand...


Sir g ye sab bhi education ka hee part hai k apko ye samjhaya jaye k kya important hai kya nahe but agar education hee nahe hai to bhi kuch nahe hai not even family and friends. Education is Primary and i don't think it creates any gap between family and u. Maine iss liye 4 answers k liye haan kaha tha because iss answer me mera bhi answer yaahe hota Education. Issme Baniya ke baat nahe hai koi bhi Samajhdaar admi ye he answer dega.
 
skarmveer said:
Bhai yea kesee vaykti vishes key liyea nahi likha hai. Yea mera anubhav hai or mein issey sahi nahi manta. Edu. bahut avashyak hai per parivaar or samaj key sath hee achhi lagti hai agar hamara koi na ho to us edu. ka kya karengey.
Click to expand...


Bhaisaab iska matlab Baniyon ka koi nahi hota ????
 
Bhai aapkey liyea nahi likha na hee aapka reply quote kiya hai.

yea mujhey easa lagta hai or yeasey bahut log hai jo easa mantey hai kee apno say jayada paise or padhai kee jarurat hai.


dkumars said:
Mujhe bhi Grantho ka link dijiye ... mein bhi jatton ki sobat mein aakar jatton jaisa ban na chahta hoon ... actually mein baniyon ki sobat mein rehkar baniya bann gaya hoon par abb toh Dharam, granth padh kar jaat ban na hi hai.... huhhh:cool:
Click to expand...
 
Eucation ... hmmm ... Jab chotte bachhe ko sikhaya jata hai hai bete papa bolo , wo bhi education hi hoti hai usko kabhi ye nahi sikhaate ki bete apne baap ko kutta bol ... kyu ye jaroori hai ya nahi ???
 
Baap hoga to baap bolna sikhogay na. or sikhaney wala bhee koi aapne hee hai.

Sikhaney key liyea pahey koi hona to chahiyea jo sikha raha hai wo aapna pahley hai or jo sikhaya gaya wo baad mein.
dkumars said:
Eucation ... hmmm ... Jab chotte bachhe ko sikhaya jata hai hai bete papa bolo , wo bhi education hi hoti hai usko kabhi ye nahi sikhaate ki bete apne baap ko kutta bol ... kyu ye jaroori hai ya nahi ???
Click to expand...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top