Sir,I doubt if NCBC had “serious mind of application” whilepreparing report for inclusion of Jats in OBC category. I am totally surprisedhow NCBC had accepted absurd and non-sense pleas of non-jats. There was notruth and reality in the pleas given by non-jats and most of facts theypresented before NCBC were fabricated.
First of all Non-Jats were laying stress on the credibility and authenticity ofKC Gupta Commission report. When they say 2 out of 6 members of commission hadinfluenced the report and gave favourable report to Government of Haryana,thenwe can also say that 1 member named Shri A.K. Saini out of 4 members of NCBCpanel was from Haryana that too from OBC category. We can also allege that hemight have influenced other 3 members and gave report in favour of non-Jatbackward castes.
Now about Prof. KS Sangwan and RP Hooda being Jats .. HoD,Sociology departmentand Vice-Chancellor are not direct posts . They have been appointed at theseposts after their service of minimum 25 years.Again CM does not directlyappoint Vice-Chancellor.The Cabinet Ministers and Education Secretaries alsohave say in the appointment of Vice-Chancellor. These 2 persons are veryexperienced and possess the essential qualifications and excellent track recordto be appointed at these posts . Again it is the absolute authority of HaryanaGovernment and KC Gupta Commission to consider any valid report to proveBackwardness of Jats .
Throughout the NCBC report,non-Jats were laying stress on the representationsof Jats in 3 areas:Armed Forces,Sports and Civil Services.
First let us consider Armed Forces and Sports. Jats have large representationsin these 2 fields because they are physically fit. It is very amusing to saythat due to Social,Economic and Educational Dominance,Jats run faster,Jats jumplonger and higher,Jats throw discuss at large distance and win medals and so on…
Similar is the case of Police Forces.. Every person tries it best to get job inhis home state .. Due to this Jats have large representation in Police Forcesof Haryana,Delhi and Western UP.
These non-Jats cited many examples where Jats were appointed on the posts ofVice-Chancellors of various State Universities of Haryana especially. Again letme clarify it is not a direct recruitment,it is subjected to essentialqualifications and experience. Again every person tries to be appointed in hishome state. That’s why they occupy posts of Vice-Chancellors.
If a Jat is made Vice-Chancellor of an University,then it does not mean thatJats will be given preference in admission,there will be more Jat lecturers,Jatstudents will be awarded more marks,etc. There is a secrecy branch in everyUniversity which conducts examination.
Now about Civil Services. Eligibility conditions for appearing in CivilServices is already very relaxed. There is no need for getting maximum qualification for giving civil services exam.
A preson holding B.A. degree with 41% marks and other person holding PhD degreewith 98% marks will be treated equally in Civil Services. There is a prescribedsyllabus and a person has to prepare according to that.
There are many examples where a person from a poor family background clearedCivil Services exam but an extreamly rich person could not clear even Prelims ofCivil Services.
Thus,job in Civil Services is totally based on talent,hard-work and level ofpreparation of a person.. Educational and Economic Status plays no role in it.
No they talk about Jats becoming Chief Ministers of Haryana.. Uttar Pradeshwhich is largest state had Chief Ministers from Dalits and Backward Classes..
The main problem is that these non-Jats talk about representation of Jats inArmed Forces but not about Government Banks and Railways.
They say that there are many Jats are there in Army then what about DRDO,Navy andAir Force.
They say that many Jats are lawyers/advocates then what about Judges.
They say that many Jats are Vice-Chancellors of State Universities then whatabout Central Universities and prestigious institutes like IITs,IIMs and AIIMS.
They say that there are many Jats in Police Forces then what aboutPara-Military Forces.
Non-Jats gave plea that Jats are owners of Lands,Petrol Pumps and Gas Agencies.Can they prove that due to owners of Petrol pumps being Jats,we getpetrol,diesel and gas at more subsidized prices.
When they talk about Sir Chhotu Ram then must not forget B.R. Ambedkar andJyotibha Phule. Dalits and Backwards always enjoyed support of Mahatama Gandhibut Jats never got support from Gandhi.
When non-Jats can give 2 hundred examples of Rich Jats to prove forwardness ofJats then we can also give 2 lakh examples of poor Jats to prove backwardnessof Jats.
Why don’t these non-Jats understand that only Jats belonging to Non-Creamylayer would be benefitted.
I expect Hon’ble Supreme Court to give judgement wisely without any bias anddeclare Jats as backward community on the basis of present Socio-Economic conditionsof majority of landless and poor Jats.
