Water Problem in India

Status
Not open for further replies.

rkumar

Active member
Dear Friends,

Just to let you know that where we in India stand on water availability, here are some figures;

USA= 5000 cu m per capita
South Africa, Mexico, Morocco, China= 1000 cu M
India= 200 cu M

India can store only 30 days of rainfall compared to 900 days in major river basins in arid areas of developed countries. This a matter of great concern as we all know. Whereas there are inter-state disputes on water, no one seems to feel agitated on the lack of progress on various dam constructions. Don’t you think there is need of public pressure groups on this major national issue? Isolated fights like SYL canal and Krishna Godavri water disputes alone will not help to address the problem. Government has to initiate the construction of new water reservoirs and complete the ongoing ones faster. Like there are active environmental groups opposing the construction, can’t we have the groups who can agitate for speedy construction and completion?

Rajendra
 
Thanks for a Nice Issue

Dear Rajendra Ji,
Thanks a lot for raising an interesting and important issue. Availability of water for drinking as well as irrigation purpose is a major problem in our country. The irony is that it is not being given that attention that it deserves while energy, resources and time is being devoted to trivial issues, like reservations for muslims, Babri Maszid and so on. We have probably a large reservoir of water resources with Great Himalayas bordering our Northern boundry. If we can manage our water resources, not only we will be able to generate enough energy, but also would be able to control the water in a manner to avoid the flood situations in some part of the country and draught in the other part of the country. I think the subject deserve an emergent attention and has to be addressed at priority. Once again thanks a lot for initiating a very important issue.

Just to let you know that where we in India stand on water availability, here are some figures;

USA= 5000 cu m per capita
South Africa, Mexico, Morocco, China= 1000 cu M
India= 200 cu M

India can store only 30 days of rainfall compared to 900 days in major river basins in arid areas of developed countries. This a matter of great concern as we all know. Whereas there are inter-state disputes on water, no one seems to feel agitated on the lack of progress on various dam constructions. Don’t you think there is need of public pressure groups on this major national issue? Isolated fights like SYL canal and Krishna Godavri water disputes alone will not help to address the problem. Government has to initiate the construction of new water reservoirs and complete the ongoing ones faster. Like there are active environmental groups opposing the construction, can’t we have the groups who can agitate for speedy construction and completion?

Rajendra[/QUOTE]
 
Tavathia Sahab,

If one compares the prices of milk and bottled water, understanding the economics of water won't take even one minute. Rainwater is the purest form of water and most expensive commodity, which needs no technology and nothing. All it needs is collection. I have been shouting for years that if India should focus on one thing, it has to be just water management. We had so much of rain and flood just last month and now we will be heading for draught just within a month or so. Storing water does not require nuclear technology, which we have to import from USA and Russia. Our riverbeds can be used as reservoirs. Unfortunately such topics do not create the type of heat what Gohana incidences create and therefore no one is interested in discussing them or raising them. I was just scanning World bank report on the subject. This what WB has to say on India, which one won't have to work hard to agree;

...........................................................................................................................................................
India will face water shortage in 20 years: WB

NEW DELHI, Oct 5: India will face a severe water crisis in 20 years if the government does not change its ways and clashes are already taking place because the resource is so scarce, the World Bank warned on Wednesday.

“There’s virtually no country in the world that lives with a system as bad as you have here,” John Briscoe, author of the Bank’s draft country report on India, told a media conference in New Delhi.

“There is a widespread complacency in the government about water.”

The report says that India has no proper water management system in place, its groundwater is disappearing and river bodies are turning into makeshift sewers.

“Estimates reveal that by 2020, India’s demand for water will exceed all sources of supply,” the report says.

“There is no question that the incidence and severity of conflicts (over water) has increased sharply in recent times ... There is a high level of vitriol in the endemic clashes between states on inter-state water issues,” it adds.

With the Indian government unable to provide its citizens a 24-hour supply of water even in the national capital, those who can afford to have found other ways to turn on the tap.

The result is an unregulated system with no incentive to conserve water.

“What has happened in the last 20 or 30 years is a shift to self-provision. Every farmer sinks a tubewell and every house in Delhi has a pump pumping groundwater,” said Mr Briscoe, an expert on water issues at the World Bank. “Once that water stops you get into a situation where towns will not be able to function.”

According to the report, 70 percent of India’s irrigation water and 80 percent of its domestic water supplies now come from groundwater, which is being rapidly depleted.

The Delhi-based Centre for Science and Environment said that in parts of the capital city, the groundwater level is dropping by 10 meters (33 feet) each year.

“Especially in South Delhi there are a lot of borewells because piped water supply is not coming,” said R.K. Srinivasan, deputy coordinator of natural resource management at the organization.

The independent group has begun a project to use city buildings to harvest rain water and return it underground.

The issue of water management is particularly pressing in a country where many states get as much as 90 percent of their rainfall in the four months of the summer monsoon season, leading to a drought-flood cycle.

The World Bank report also worries about the impact of climate change in India, particularly the melting of glaciers in the western part of the Himalayan mountain range.

It makes specific recommendations for India that include negotiating clear-cut water entitlements for states that spar over river water, increasing storage capacity and charging water users appropriately. —AFP

.......................................................................................................................................

Rajendra
 
Last edited:
You are right in pointing out the problem. But we, the people of India, and our govt. are equally responsible for this.

All the major Hydel projects were carried out in 60s. After that almost nothing has been done. All govt. are more concerned about thermal plants, gas based plants and nuclear energy. These are also good options but as compared to hydel projects, they serve only the purpose of electricity.

First of all govts. don't come forward to propose hydel projects and if they come, they don't give enough compensation to affected villages. It takes hell lot of years to formalize a plan to distribute compensation. Then comes protests like 'Narmada Bacho' and Sunder Lal bahuguna aandolans...the whole matters gets stuck there only. Jitna aagey chalney ki koshish karte hain, usse do guna peechey hatna padta hai...There is no hope!!

Waiting for time to change...plus change of mentality of govt. and NGOs plus people's attitude...and it's a big change.

Dekho kab kya hota hai.

Navin
rkumar said:
Tavathia Sahab,

If one compares the prices of milk and bottled water, understanding the economics of water won't take even one minute. Rainwater is the purest form of water and most expensive commodity, which needs no technology and nothing. All it needs is collection. I have been shouting for years that if India should focus on one thing, it has to be just water management. We had so much of rain and flood just last month and now we will be heading for draught just within a month or so. Storing water does not require nuclear technology, which we have to import from USA and Russia. Our riverbeds can be used as reservoirs. Unfortunately such topics do not create the type of heat what Gohana incidences create and therefore no one is interested in discussing them or raising them. I was just scanning World bank report on the subject. This what WB has to say on India, which one won't have to work hard to agree;
Rajendra
 
Problem Is Real And Dangerous

While i tend to agree with you both,unfortunately the problem is men made. We human beings are the worst kinda creatures and for the sake of our comfort and self interest we are ready to abuse any thing and every thing. The greed of men has taken the water levels to the depth of no returns and if we continue abusing NATURE like this ,the day is not far off when this very NATURE pays us back with interest in the shape off mass destructions in the shape of diseases and clamities.We have crossed all limits and things seem BEYONG ECONOMICAL REPAIRS. Only hope is Nature's way and i for one has lost faith in the so called....LET US DO IT.
 
Dear RK uncle

This is indeed a critical issue in India. I heard about previous government's plan to join all the rivers in order to solve this problem. Am not sure whats happening on that front. Would be happy if anyone could share that info.

On water problems, it seems like the multinational companies are adding to the water scarcity problem for many communities in India. The Kerala state joined its community in opposing coca cola which was about to set up a bottling plant making it harder for the community to access their own water resources. Makes one think if Globalisation is actually a solution for basic development problems. For the complete story please follow the link below:

http://www.indiaresource.org/campaigns/coke/2005/gangaikondan.html

Apologies.....I know this is in tangent to the actual topic but thought its worth sharing on this thread as it does bring out another side of water problem and the good work some of the 'groups' are doing in making community interests visible over the giant corporate interests who pack our own water and sell it to us!:rolleyes:




rkumar said:
Like there are active environmental groups opposing the construction, can’t we have the groups who can agitate for speedy construction and completion?

Rajendra
 
Mere dil ki baat chheen li, priti:-))))... This Sat we (DESI) are hosting a talk in our campus by Dr. Kalyanraman, the guy who proposed and worked on the idea of inter-linking of rivers of India to take water from flooded areas to where people need it... I know noone will be able to attend but I just wanted to share, I will add more thoughts here after getting fundes from him.... Dr. Kalyanraman (who also wrote a 7 volume epic on research on Saraswati river and civilazation) is one of our mentors among Dr. B.B. Lal, Sandhya Jain, Dr. Kiran Bedi, Dr. Subhash Kak, Sonal Shah (remember Indicorps?) whom we have invited to talk in campus...
Now we have opened a chapter in NCSU(north carolina state univ) too, in long term we hope to be in most of campuses in US:-)))..
Ok enuf bragging!!!! anyway if you wanna join us, visit http://www.desiumd.org

-Vinod

priti said:
This is indeed a critical issue in India. I heard about previous government's plan to join all the rivers in order to solve this problem. Am not sure whats happening on that front. Would be happy if anyone could share that info.
:
 
National Interests: Supreme

There are certain core problem every country faces and ours is no different. The shortage of water or "Water Management" is a very important issue that every successive government needs to address. Unfortunately, the petty politics and the lust to remain in power keeps the core issue at the back seat. Compound with this problem is the general attitude of the common man. So long he is not affected he/she does not care about it. Then from where do we start?
In my opinion, the nation needs to identify all these core issues and a live debate needs to be carried out so that a common man knows as to what the power brokers and the politicians think about these problems and once they are in power what they actually do to solve them. The social organizations are doing their bit some times to seriously help the society and some times just to keep themselves in the business. In a democratic set up these problems will remain, but we the educated class has to do more than the lip service on these issues. One of the thing each one of us can do is to educate fellow citizens about the gravity of the situations and motivate them to vote those to the power who can take care of these problems. The coilation governments have their own pitfalls and more often than not are not able to serve the nation well.
The issue here is of Water. We do need to make water management a Federal Issue and all states need to follow the ruling of the central government. Central government then can be made accountable for implementation of the projects. There is a lot one can write on as to how a porject of this nature can be executed. I would request members to contribute to this importan subject
 
Really serious

I know its a serious problem in India, but different political parties are just only sitting and doing nothing on this. But i think the Pani Pariyojna started by ex PM Vajpayee jee in which he said abt "Sabhee Nadiyon ko Jodne Ki baat" is really a gr8 effort and now Manmohan govt. has finalised the decision. But still im not sure is this going to solve the problem or not.

AbhimanyunPHougat
 
The issue has been discussed several times in past under several threads. People say that a day will come when there will be no petrol left. Let's see whether the world will be deprived of the petrol first or we Indians of the water first.
 
Rain Water Harvesting- A strong tool...

Hi all

interested members, please visit this webpage....very compelling (logical and economical) argument for rain water harvesting as a solution for water problem in the villages.

http://www.rainwaterharvesting.org/Crisis/AA-on-drought.htm

People interested in starting such projects in UP and Haryana can contact the following Raincentre:

Raincentre at Meerut
C-28, Shastri Nagar, Meerut
Uttar Pradesh-250002
Phone: 0121-2763418, 3101548


All the best!
 
Dear Friends:
This is indeed a critical issue;i am not sure whether the river interlinking project will help or not but i am sure that some regulated effort to curb overexploitation of underground water has to be put in practice urgently.
Yesterday, I met and discussed the issue with Dr.Sandeep Pandey,Magsaysay award winner who is engaged in an ongoing battle with several Coke plants across the country.(Dr.Pandey visited the university campus for a talk and was a part of the peace march in the morning.) It was a revelation that a typical bottling plant of coke uses 5 lakh litres of underground water everyday which has reduced water level drastically in nearby villages rendering cultivable land useless in the absence of groundwater support for irrigation. And the way this issue has been handled by UP gvernment and before that in Kerala raises questions about the conduct of respective state governments.
Hope you can share your views if u have experienced sth similar.
Anmol.
 
Good link dear

Yup, water harvesting can be a viable solution to the fast depleting water levels but then these are serious efforts and without beind undertaken at mass population level, results will not be possible.Water tables are at dangerously low and it is we, the crazy human beings have caused this danger to this planet and doing it still. Something needs to be done else the fury of nature will take care of things.
 
Hi Anmol

Thanks for the info. I share Mr. Pandey's sentiments on coke's utilisation of underground water. Its hard for multinational companies to gauge local problems if the government and people are themselves so passive about such critical issues. Why would the multinationals bother unless they are made to realise that without sustainable strategies they risk their business in the long term. Could you pass on some of Mr. Pandey's talk's and his details if you have any.

Vinod, I'm waiting for the promised details of Mr. Kalyanraman's talk....

Dev, you're absolutely right, water harvesting should be taken as a mass strategy to combat this problem. And the beauty of this is that villages can adopt this system at least cost and without depending on the government!

Priti
 
Hi Preeti:
I think the movie which displays the ongoing tussle between coke and local people would be soon available at www.aidindia.org.
I supported the peace march from the Pakistan embassy to Indian embassy yesterday i had a long walk with Dr.Pandey and you can see those pics too. By this time AID has raised about $12000 which would be handed to a US based NGO working in Pakistan for earthquake relief.(My affiliation with AID goes to the extent that one of my roomies runs the local AID chapter; i enjoyed the nice walk and wish I could do more for peace in the subcontinent).
Best
Anmol.
 
Last edited:
Here is an interesting article on the subjec. Hope our policy makers take note of such views and act urgently..
........................................................................................................
How to solve India's water troubles
Shankar Acharya



October 25, 2005


Official and demi-official reports from national and international organisations are a dime a dozen these days.

If there is only one report you have time to read in the next three months, then I recommend India's Water Economy: Bracing for a Turbulent Future (IWE, for short), written by a team headed by the World Bank's senior water advisor, John Briscoe, and drawing substantially on a dozen background papers by Indian scholars and practitioners such as Ramesh Bhatia, George Varughese, Tushaar Shah, Sebastian Morris, Nirmal Mohanty and Vijay Vyas.

The final draft is available at www.worldbank.org.in. Why do I pick this report from the zillion others that float across my desk? Yes, it's cogent, well written, marshals a tremendous range of information and analysis and puts it across in an accessible, user-friendly format.

But perhaps above all, because IWE is about water, something that affects us all. . . and is likely to do so increasingly as this precious fluid becomes steadily scarcer for all of India's citizens, in large part because of our collective failure to manage water systems well.

In this brief column I can't hope to do justice to the rich analysis in IWE and its well-nuanced advocacy for a charter of water sector reforms. I can only offer a 'trailer' by summarising some of the key messages and themes of diagnosis and prescription that are on offer. It's no substitute for reading this excellent report.

India has always faced a severe water management challenge with its highly seasonal pattern of rainfall, resulting in 50 per cent of precipitation in just 15 days and 90 per cent of river flows in only four months. Massive investments in water storage, control and distribution were clearly warranted.

In the century or so up to around 1970, British and Indian water engineers undertook major projects of dams, canals and municipal water systems, which brought rapid economic development to the once-arid north-west India and large parts of the Deccan.

Such investments in water infrastructure spearheaded major advances in food security and hydro-power production. They also played a crucial role in generating rural development and reducing poverty, not least through enormously augmented demand for labour on irrigated farm lands.

Despite these water investments, India's dams can store only about 200 cubic metres per person, compared to around 1,000 cubic metres per capita in China, Mexico and South Africa. What's more, the likely effects of global climate change will lead to greater storage needs to manage more variable glacier melt and more variable monsoons.

One important message of IWE is a call for much greater investment in dams and reservoirs, in contrast to the World Bank's 1990s opposition to big dams (fanned partly by the shrill advocacy of a set of international and national anti-development NGOs).

The second major problem relates to the woeful maintenance of the water infrastructure assets created by 1970. For a variety of reasons (not adequately explained in IWE), the systems of maintenance and operation of public water infrastructure went into steady decline from around the 1960s.

The familiar litany of woes grew: low user charges, poor accountability, endemic corruption, massive over-staffing preempting meagre finances, and a generally bureaucratic and unresponsive approach to water users.

The mounting backlog of deferred maintenance and crumbling assets earned the Indian water investment strategy the unflattering sobriquet of 'Build-Neglect-Rebuild'!

Rural and urban water problems would have assumed crisis proportions long ago but for the advent of the new 'transformational technology' of tube wells around the 1960s. Faced with malfunctioning public water systems, farmers and urban dwellers switched massively to tube wells to meet their mounting water needs.

IWE estimates that today 70 per cent of irrigation needs and 80 per cent of domestic water supplies in India are met through pumping up groundwater through tube wells. But this massively deployed private response to public failure can only be temporary. Water tables are plummeting and aquifers are running dry.

Estimates show that 15 per cent of aquifers are already critical and the number is projected to rise to 60 per cent in a couple of decades. The consequences of such water stress are simply unimaginable, especially since the phenomenon of aquifer depletion is concentrated in the most populated and economically productive areas of the country. In a word, the usual Indian ploy of 'muddling through' is simply unsustainable.

So what's to be done? There is no single magic bullet. But the broad outlines of a recuperative strategy seem clear. First, state agencies and water users have to work together to bring aquifer withdrawals in line with recharge. Simply passing laws and regulations won't work.

They have to be buttressed by systems of tradable water entitlements, credible user associations, and a creative approach to pricing and incentives.

Second, with the obvious limitations on ground water, there will have to be much greater reliance on surface water systems, both through recuperation of existing, under-maintained systems and also through 'large-scale investment in public infrastructure' of new dam systems, canals, municipal distribution networks and wastewater treatment plants.

Third, and perhaps above all, 'it is going to require a dramatic transformation in the way in which public water services are provided to farmers, households and industries, in which the watchwords are water entitlements, financial sustainability, accountability, competition, regulation and entry of alternatives to government provision including cooperatives and the private sector.'

If all that sounds to you like higher prices for water from formal systems, you heard right. It would be absurd to imagine that an increasingly scarce and valuable resource can be intelligently managed without significant recourse to prices and markets.

On the path to reform beware of all those well-heeled celebrities who will resist change in the name of the poor. Just remember two things: first, today's massive subsidies are enjoyed not by the poor but by those who actually consume most of the water and electricity, namely the well-off farmers and town-dwellers, including the anti-reform celebrities from up-market city areas.

Second, the poor typically pay huge prices today to water vendors and other intermediaries. Reforms which augment water supply and give some real substance to the entitlements of the poor are much more likely to benefit them.

Can the broad strategy of reform outlined by IWE actually work? I certainly hope so. Otherwise the future is too fearsome to contemplate!

The author is Honorary Professor at ICRIER and former Chief Economic Adviser to the Government of India. The views expressed are personal.
 
Yamuna river front development

Dear Friends,

As mentioned time and again. Each summer we will face draught and then followed by floods during monsoon. Inter and intra state disputes will continue unless we address the problem immediately. Though I am not sure, how far Delhi will go, but this is what has been taking shape;

http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1745429,000600010001.htm

There are plans to develop Yamuna front in Delhi in a big way. Each and every India town on the banks of a major or minor river needs to develop same way if we wish to solve our water problems. Our rivers have to be tamed and water needs to be stored. All along the rivers we need to have large reservoirs. Most of our irrigation canals also need to be part of such system. We can have enough water even without linking our rivers and without violating any international water treaty.

RK^2
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top