What Shuold be Indian Stand on War against Iraq?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dear All,
It is nice to go through your views, and I am happy that most of you have done your home work. I would like to draw your attention to few points here:
1. As Vice President of Iraq, Saddam Hussain himself signed a treaty with Iran to share the waters of Shet Al Arab. As per the international laws when the water is the border between the two countries the center of the stream/water is to be international boundry. On becoming President, he argued that Iran can not use Shet Al Arab waters as it is the extension of the two rivers (Tigris and Euphretis) both belonging to Iraq. He attacked Iran and made the region unstable.
2. On the day of Security Counsil meeting (14th Feb 2003) he issues the decree not to import any thing that can be used to produce WMDs.
3. His hatered for Israel is well known. During the Gulf War, he fired missiles on Israel, who was not the active ally of US in War against Iraq. Why?
4. Suicide bombers whether in the Indian Parliament or in Israeli markets are dangerous to civilization. It is a known fact that he provides funds to them.
With all this back ground, do you still trust Saddam Hussain? Further, muslim fundamentalism needs to be brought to an end what ever be the cost of it.
Now purely from the Indian point of view. We are suffering from the Islamic fundamentalism and terrorism, thus morally we need to take a stand on this basis.
I am pretty convinced that the US presence in Afghanistan,Iraq and Pakistan will be beneficial to us. US Presence in Iraq would also be useful in monitoring the terrorist activities under taken from the soils of Syria, Saudi Arabia and UAE.
If the US coilation succeds in Iraq, which it will, then we would still be needing the badly needed oil from that country. And if we are with the government in that country, we will be that much better off.
Further, by supporting US in this war, we must also bargain with them for their support to us against Pakistan. Imagine, with a friendly government in Afghanistan, and no US support to Pakistan, how much advantage we will have while negotiating any thing with Pakistan?
Surely, no one can guarantee any thing in International relations, but one can foresee. US would need Indian support for a long time in the region and we must make best use of this situation.
 
The other day i watched Pakistan's foreign ministers interviwe by Charlie Rose on PBS.

The defence minister was having a hard time defending his country for its nuclear dealings with N.Korea. America knows Pakistan is a rouge state but his hands are tied because of Afganistan happenings. China

is no less opportunistic than anyone else (gave N.weapons to Pakistan to get even with India). It is indeed a little unfortunate for India to have 2 notorious countries surrounding a long stretch of its international border.
 
notorious Ms Duhan? Can countries acting in self interest be notorious? It is people and the rulers who are notorious

Rajiv
 
These 2 countries are notorious for breaking agreements that they sign, repressing their people, subjugating and persecuting minority cultures, unlimited territorial ambitions, and a militaristic attitude towards their neighbours.

You could also say that a mafia acts in its own interest but a mafia acts in the interest of its leader and it is always notorious for keeping itself above the law.
 
Here is the answer:

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/ap/20030216/ap_on_re_eu/world_war_protests_23

Eventually everyone will see thru' this game
 
India always says it wants to be a super power... let us show some guts ans stop America in its tracks... India should do this..
1) enter into an understanding with China and wins it support.
2) Ask Saddam to step down in return for sending Indian troops in Iraq..
INDIA SOULD SEND ITS ARMY INTO IRAQ TO STOP US AGGRESSION !
to become a world power, one has to act like one... india's soft and ambivalent stand will get it nowhere.
Shocking ? but this is a golden chance for India to make a mark in the international forum.
 
Years back during kuwait war,( i was a kid at that time;))) i remember kuwait doing some sort of slant drilling in Iraq, which was supposedly the immediate reason for war.
Can soemone confirm..?
Parul
 
Before Saddam Hussein there has not been a government in Iraq that lasted more than three years.
He is the man who brought stability to the region, every other regieme was overthrown by coups. He has done it by being ruthless, as there was no other way it could have been done.

Ok he is ruthless but that very personal trait is responsible for the stability of Iraq. He is the man who built a modern state of Iraq and for sure is no terrorist.

The N-Korean crisis is much bigger than the Iraqi state of affairs. Nobody has yet established that Iraq has any WMD'S but N-Korea for sure does have nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles.

So why Iraq why not N.Korea?
The reason is simple there is nothing for USA in korea except hunger and poverty.
If they go for N.Korea they will have to pay from their pocket to feed the people.
Whereas Iraq is a diamond mine, a big treasure waiting to be looted and exploited, and that's exactly what the Americans are doing.

VJ Kharub
 
Oh Lordy.

Why would Saddam listen to India and step down and not do same for the US? Indian Army has its hands full with Kashmir Agression, and trouble in the Northeast...what makes you think that Indian army has spare capital and troops to send to Iraq and take on the US. Why would you want to support a dictator who has helped the cause of Jehadis in Kashmir and blow one chance of alliance with US to contain terrorist in Pakistan. Indian Army suffered humiliating defeat in an alien territory in Sri Lanka...what makes you think they will have success against state of the art weapon that US posesses.

Guts and intelligence together wins war. I hope for India's sake that you are in low level management somwhere...All guts no glory...like the Taliban. Seriously dude...what are you smoking?




Arjun Rana (Feb 16, 2003 09:23 a.m.):
India always says it wants to be a super power... let us show some guts ans stop America in its tracks... India should do this..
1) enter into an understanding with China and wins it support.
2) Ask Saddam to step down in return for sending Indian troops in Iraq..
INDIA SOULD SEND ITS ARMY INTO IRAQ TO STOP US AGGRESSION !
to become a world power, one has to act like one... india's soft and ambivalent stand will get it nowhere.
Shocking ? but this is a golden chance for India to make a mark in the international forum.
 
Indian Army suffered humiliating defeat in an alien territory in Sri Lanka...
***************
alien territory in Sri Lanka...
Oh! so you do know this!!

***************

OMG- Which N.paper gave you such "gems of knowledge"!!!! It is obvious you have not taken any interest in Indian politics in a long time. Here is some Indian Politics 101:

It was because of India's timely intervention that the SriLankan's Tamil Gorrilas
had to back off from taking over SriLankan Territory and hence India won (and not "humiliating defeat in an alien SriLankan territory as you put it). The reason India interviened in Srilankan affairs was because India knew situation was getting out of S.Lankan governments hands and American forces would be
invited soon for help by the S.Lankans. To avoid an American presence in its neighbourhood, Indian
forces stormed the terrorista out for Sri Lanka and temporarily disintegrated their organization. The
Tamilians were very mad with India and for this reason they assasinated Rajiv Gandhi.
You would save a lot of time of the readers if only you check your facts before you post.
 
Dear All,
I think this forum is for all of us to express our views, however meaning less they may be. I would say, that we must maintain a decorum while addressing other contributors.
Mr. Rana's idea of sending Indian troops to Iraq to contest US is obviously not very well thought off. You don't commit force to attain the status of super power. To become super power we need to have a very strong economy backed up by a technologically advanced strong military. I think we have a long way to go in this field. It is not in our interest to use our troops on foreign soil except with the UN. If the war against Iraq is approved by UN and Indian help is needed, then off course there is no harm in committing some force as part of UN against Iraq and not for Iraq.

Now the question about debate on Indian Army's involvement in Sri Lanka. Well, we didn't do well there. There were two main reasons for that. Firstly we were committed prematurely by our leaders and thus were not prepared. The leadership under estimated the enemy strength.
Secondly, we had no cause to fight for. This is an important factor. It was purely this reason that inspite of superior technology and strength, US army didn't do well in Vietnam. There are numerous examples of this nature in the history. Unfortunately our policies towards Sri Lanka are greatly influenced by our domestic politics in Tamil Nadu.

We have no business to fight for Iraq specially when it is violating the UN resolutions.

Regarding Parul's questions about Kuwait carrying out slant drilling, I have not heard if that was the reason for war against Kuwait. I believe that the main reason was that Saddam asked Kuwait to pay a huge amount of money to Iraq as compensation for its war against Iran.

In my opinion Mr. Saddam Hussain is a danger to the world peace. WMD's in any country ruled by a dictator are dangerous for the world peace. Imagine some of these weapons landing in Kashmir or in any other Indian City. We are running out of time and in my opinion India should support the war against Iraq even though Mr. George Fernandes feels otherwise. Obviously he might be having his voters in mind as elections are fast approaching. After Iraq, we must impress upon US to take on Pakistan. We need to root out islamic fundamentalism and we as a country must support all actions against it. After all we have suffered a lot and will continue to suffer if we don't take a correct stand. As far as the economic repercussions are involved, I think the link given by Mr. Nitin Dahiya explains it well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top