Reality of FDI, beyond politics

After Sangwan Ji's analysis here are a few more myths that common people carry about FDI that I will try and answer as well.

Myth No. 1: FDI is a bane for farmers

Walmart has been operating in Punjab for past 4 years and Punjab is one of the few non-congress states supporting FDI. It speaks volume from people who have benefitted from the investment and organizations.

Myth No. 2: FDI will not support backbone

50% money will be invested in supply chain which includes cold storages, collection and processing which right now is 0% for Indian retailers

Myth No. 3: FDI will destroy mom and pop shops

Read this news:http://www.indianexpress.com/news/punjab-to-get-two-more-walmart-stores/597866 Did we for once hear about mom and pop shops going out of business in Punjab or any protest? Mom and Pop shops still exist in US where these retail are every where but due to competition they have also become better for common people

Myth No. 4: BJP is anti FDI cause it genuinly believes its not good for India

BJP wanted to introduce 100% FDI much before because it believed in benefits then why opposition now? (http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/ne...net-note-allowing-100-fdi-anand-sharma/247240)

Myth No. 5: Mamta Banerjee is anti-FDI/America

Since Mamta Banerjee came to power, PepsiCo's contract farming of potatoes has increased. PepsiCo is an american company and is operating on the same lines as Walmart or Tesco will without any 50% commitment to build infrastructure, then by be hypocrite?
http://pepsicoindia.co.in/media/Press-Releases/release_03_23_10.aspx


Myth No. 6: FDI is passed under the pressure or America

Out of all the companies that will benefit there is only 1 american major company Walmart that will benefit where as rest of the companies like Tesco, Carrefour are European companies. It is the leftist agenda that people believe.


Let us start thinking from our minds and experience instead of believing what politicians say whose job is to oppose
 
Last edited:
1. In the same Punjab just few month ago framer has thrown their potato on roads in tons. It speaks Farmer of Punjab not benefited. Might be handful of farmer got the benefit.

Farmers to throw potatoes on road to protest low prices

http://daily.bhaskar.com/article/CH...es-on-road-to-protest-low-prices-2629940.html

2. Again a twisted fact. Indeed they will invest 50% in supply chain which includes cold storages, collection and processing. BUT for WHOM??? The retail chain allowed to import 70% of their products. IN worldwide wherever these retail chain exist they import 70% of their items except china where they import just around 40%. So when these companies will import majority of their product line from outside of the country then who will get the benefit of this supply chain. Countryman, Farmer or the company itself???

3. The Kirana store will certainly affect by coming of these Retail Chain. It;s already start affecting, but the impact is not big right now because the existing retail chain source much of the product within India itself so the price difference is not steep between Indian Retail Chain and Local Kirana store. So lots of people still prefer to buy from local store due to convenience. But when the BIG retail chain will enter, they will enter to kill the existing competition first and that's what they did throughout the world and If consumer will get the item a unsubstantial difference in the price they will surely go to big retail chain and Ultimately majority of Kirana store won't survive at all. At least those who hardly give any discount. Only Thok ki Dukaan walay might survive but not others at all.

4. It's just a twisted presentation of NDTV. During the NDA government BJP has cleared on the floor of the house that they are not going to come up with any FDI in retail.

5. Again twisted representation of fact, Retailing is not Just about selling agricultural product or food product. In retail chain these items not even contribute 20% of total business. In WB Pepsico is not a retail chain, they are just buying potatoes or any other farm product directly from farmer for their own company final product. so the whole example of Pepsico is absurd. Mamta raising the concern of Local Retailer and in none of your comment you've genuinely addressed the concern of the party who will get affect.

6. Indeed US do have the pressure. Walmart is the most successful and biggest company in Retail business in worldwide in comparison to Tesco and other companies.

Final Comment: Yes Think Yourself, You are just also putting the comment similar to politician who are supporting FDI in retail. Otherwise you've not written down the twisted fact here.

After Sangwan Ji's analysis here are a few more myths that common people carry about FDI that I will try and answer as well.

Myth No. 1: FDI is a bane for farmers

Walmart has been operating in Punjab for past 4 years and Punjab is one of the few non-congress states supporting FDI. It speaks volume from people who have benefitted from the investment and organizations.

Myth No. 2: FDI will not support backbone

50% money will be invested in supply chain which includes cold storage collection and processing which right now is 0% for Indian retailers

Myth No. 3: FDI will destroy mom and pop shops

Read this news:http://www.indianexpress.com/news/punjab-to-get-two-more-walmart-stores/597866 Did we for once hear about mom and pop shops going out of business in Punjab or any protest? Mom and Pop shops still exist in US where these retail are every where but due to competition they have also become better for common people

Myth No. 4: BJP is anti FDI cause it genuinly believes its not good for India

BJP wanted to introduce 100% FDI much before because it believed in benefits then why opposition now? (http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/ne...net-note-allowing-100-fdi-anand-sharma/247240)

Myth No. 5: Mamta Banerjee is anti-FDI/America

Since Mamta Banerjee came to power, PepsiCo's contract farming of potatoes has increased. PepsiCo is an american company and is operating on the same lines as Walmart or Tesco will without any 50% commitment to build infrastructure, then by be hypocrite?
http://pepsicoindia.co.in/media/Press-Releases/release_03_23_10.aspx


Myth No. 6: FDI is passed under the pressure or America

Out of all the companies that will benefit there is only 1 american major company Walmart that will benefit where as rest of the companies like Tesco, Carrefour are European companies. It is the leftist agenda that people believe.


Let us start thinking from our minds and experience instead of believing what politicians say whose job is to oppose
 
Last edited:
  • Protest was against government, not pvt players who have been doing fair business. 2 Different issues
  • How does it matter? Have you ever seen what Walmart sells? How much does Farm produce even compromise of their sales? And also, currently Indian retailers can import 100% if they want and most of the non-farm produce is anyways imported from China
  • It is not a NDTV presentation but a paper prepared by NDA govt. Fact remain fact which cant be denied.
  • Mamta is opposing FDI for contract farming issue as well as she feels farmers will be suppressed - double standards and politics
  • To this I have 2 things to say, do a study on Walmart and see how successful have they been outside US and also get to know about Carrefour and Tesco. You will get your our ans.


1. In the same Punjab just few month ago framer has thrown their potato on roads in tons. It speaks Farmer of Punjab not benefited. Might be handful of farmer got the benefit.

Farmers to throw potatoes on road to protest low prices

http://daily.bhaskar.com/article/CH...es-on-road-to-protest-low-prices-2629940.html

2. Again a twisted fact. Indeed they will invest 50% in supply chain which includes cold storages, collection and processing. BUT for WHOM??? The retail chain allowed to import 70% of their products. IN worldwide wherever these retail chain exist they import 70% of their items except china where they import just around 40%. So when these companies will import majority of their product line from outside of the country then who will get the benefit of this supply chain. Countryman, Farmer or the company itself???

3. The Kirana store will certainly affect by coming of these Retail Chain. It;s already start affecting, but the impact is not big right now because the existing retail chain source much of the product within India itself so the price difference is not steep between Indian Retail Chain and Local Kirana store. So lots of people still prefer to buy from local store due to convenience. But when the BIG retail chain will enter, they will enter to kill the existing competition first and that's what they did throughout the world and If consumer will get the item a unsubstantial difference in the price they will surely go to big retail chain and Ultimately majority of Kirana store won't survive at all. At least those who hardly give any discount. Only Thok ki Dukaan walay might survive but not others at all.

4. It's just a twisted presentation of NDTV. During the NDA government BJP has cleared on the floor of the house that they are not going to come up with any FDI in retail.

5. Again twisted representation of fact, Retailing is not Just about selling agricultural product or food product. In retail chain these items not even contribute 20% of total business. In WB Pepsico is not a retail chain, they are just buying potatoes or any other farm product directly from farmer for their own company final product. so the whole example of Pepsico is absurd. Mamta raising the concern of Local Retailer and in none of your comment you've genuinely addressed the concern of the party who will get affect.

6. Indeed US do have the pressure. Walmart is the most successful and biggest company in Retail business in worldwide in comparison to Tesco and other companies.

Final Comment: Yes Think Yourself, You are just also putting the comment similar to politician who are supporting FDI in retail. Otherwise you've not written down the twisted fact here.
 
1. Why against govt? Is Govt decide the price of vegetables You were giving the example of Walmart in Punjab. If Walmart is such an holy company the why Walmart is not purchasing the Potato at a fair price??? If in current scenario Walmart is not purchasing then How they will purchase they agri product at a fair price in future if we'll allow the FDI in retail?? So these are not different issue. You just need to see the things in perspective.


2. Why it's not matter? Walmart sell everything what any local retailer and subji mandi sell and even more than that. You were giving the supply chain example in favor of FDI in retail. I put the things in perceptive and shows you how these companies will utilize there Supply chain. Any neutral person can easily recognize this fact. Current Indian retailers can import 100% but thing is that they are not importing. Why?? Because it's not beneficial for them it will cost them more. But won't be a case with large retail chain like Walmart and Tesco as their whole business depends on import from cheap location. Also Non Farm product doesn't import from china. Most of them Manufactured in India. All FMCG product manufactured in India itself. The electronic items companies import the internal component only and then manufacture and assemble them in India itself. Nokia the phone manufacturer have their unit in Chennai. Similarly LG, Samsung all of them have their unit in India itself.


3. Seems like you didn't read my underline part. Let me repeat it again. During the NDA government BJP has cleared on the floor of the house that they are not going to come up with any FDI in retail. Which opinion matter most? On the floor of the house or in any xyz document of NDA???


4. Reference please. She is only opposing FDI in retail


5. I did some research. In some country they are not getting much expected success. In Many countries they are very successful. The annual revenue of 3 companies as follows


Tesco
Revenue $105.158 billion (2011/12)
===============
Carrefour
Revenue $104.449 billion (2011)


===============
Walmart
Revenue US$ 446.950 billion (2012)


By above mentioned figure you can see that Walmart is 4 time big company then Tesco and Carrefour. So WalMart is Great GrandFather in retail sector.

  • Protest was against government, not pvt players who have been doing fair business. 2 Different issues
  • How does it matter? Have you ever seen what Walmart sells? How much does Farm produce even compromise of their sales? And also, currently Indian retailers can import 100% if they want and most of the non-farm produce is anyways imported from China
  • It is not a NDTV presentation but a paper prepared by NDA govt. Fact remain fact which cant be denied.
  • Mamta is opposing FDI for contract farming issue as well as she feels farmers will be suppressed - double standards and politics
  • To this I have 2 things to say, do a study on Walmart and see how successful have they been outside US and also get to know about Carrefour and Tesco. You will get your our ans.
 
Last edited:
1. Why against govt? Is Govt decide the price of vegetables You were giving the example of Walmart in Punjab. If Walmart is such an holy company the why Walmart is not purchasing the Potato at a fair price??? If in current scenario Walmart is not purchasing then How they will purchase they agri product at a fair price in future if we'll allow the FDI in retail?? So these are not different issue. You just need to see the things in perspective.


2. Why it's not matter? Walmart sell everything what any local retailer and subji mandi sell and even more than that. You were giving the supply chain example in favor of FDI in retail. I put the things in perceptive and shows you how these companies will utilize there Supply chain. Any neutral person can easily recognize this fact. Current Indian retailers can import 100% but thing is that they are not importing. Why?? Because it's not beneficial for them it will cost them more. But won't be a case with large retail chain like Walmart and Tesco as their whole business depends on import from cheap location. Also Non Farm product doesn't import from china. Most of them Manufactured in India. All FMCG product manufactured in India itself. The electronic items companies import the internal component only and then manufacture and assemble them in India itself. Nokia the phone manufacturer have their unit in Chennai. Similarly LG, Samsung all of them have their unit in India itself.


3. Seems like you didn't read my underline part. Let me repeat it again. During the NDA government BJP has cleared on the floor of the house that they are not going to come up with any FDI in retail. Which opinion matter most? On the floor of the house or in any xyz document of NDA???


4. Reference please. She is only opposing FDI in retail


5. I did some research. In some country they are not getting much expected success. In Many countries they are very successful. The annual revenue of 3 companies as follows


Tesco
Revenue £105.158 billion (2011/12)
===============
Carrefour
Revenue $104.449 billion (2011)


===============
Walmart
Revenue US$ 446.950 billion (2012)


By above mentioned figure you can see that Walmart is 4 time big company then Tesco and Carrefour. So WalMart is Great GrandFather in retail sector.
 
1. Very much inter related. Walmart is their in Jalandhar. As per the quote of the the article

JALANDHAR: Terming the proposed freight subsidy on potatoes inadequate potato growers of the state have announced not only to flood the roads of Jalandhar with potatoes, but also provide these free to the people on December 15.
While earlier, only Jalandhar Potato Growers Association (JPGA) was on war path now Confederation of Potato Seed Farmers (POSCON) - an organization of big potato producers- and Bhartiya Kisan Union (Lakhowal) have also joined hands and they have announced to protest jointly.

When Walmart is there is Jalandhar then why potatoes Farmer are not getting the fair price from WalMart even after they have so called supply chain and cold storage house in Jalndhar?? Why Walmart is also buying potatoes at low rate??? Why farmer requesting for subsidies?? If Farmer will get a fair price then they don't require any subsidies and they don't need to throw their potatoes on roads.

2. Indian retailers are very smart but their business model is not similar to Walmart. India retailers are very very small in front of giant like Walmart. The import to local Indian retailers are costly affair while It's beneficial for giant Walmart and others. The foreign companies are coming with partnership because this is only option they have.

Further I've already told you in previous post, Farm products are not even 20% of total business of Walmart. So why only talking about 20% of business what about the 80% of the business????

3. Modi is indeed an FDI man. BJP is not opposing FDI. BJP is opposing FDI in RETAIL. Along with FDI in Retail Govt has also allowed FDI in aviation. Did BJP opposes it????

4. Rant doesn't beomes the News. If it is a news the provide the reference.

5. Who are others??? Others are other big retail giant. Indian local store owner are not Big retail giant.


 
Last edited:
desijat;32064 [LIST said:
[*]But none the less they supported it, Modi is FDI man of India, Just plain low class political oppose is what they are doing.
[/LIST]

Bhai ji kyu khurak dyu ho in bjp aly nai .....na to koi khuud modi k se arr na iss k chalyaa p......farmer ke baat n turant lay awange partybaji p:)
 
This is so ridiculously lousy interconnection of any thing.
Do you any proof that Walmart did contractual farming for potatoes? Do you have any link to show a relation?

Just because I am in US wont mean you will blame me for Afghanistan/Iraq, just because I am here doesnt mean I am into everything.

1. Very much inter related. Walmart is their in Jalandhar. As per the quote of the the article

JALANDHAR: Terming the proposed freight subsidy on potatoes inadequate potato growers of the state have announced not only to flood the roads of Jalandhar with potatoes, but also provide these free to the people on December 15.
While earlier, only Jalandhar Potato Growers Association (JPGA) was on war path now Confederation of Potato Seed Farmers (POSCON) - an organization of big potato producers- and Bhartiya Kisan Union (Lakhowal) have also joined hands and they have announced to protest jointly.

When Walmart is there is Jalandhar then why potatoes Farmer are not getting the fair price from WalMart even after they have so called supply chain and cold storage house in Jalndhar?? Why Walmart is also buying potatoes at low rate??? Why farmer requesting for subsidies?? If Farmer will get a fair price then they don't require any subsidies and they don't need to throw their potatoes on roads.

.
 
Yes, what should we know after going through Walmart store link precisely? Aren't we aware that Walmart sell everything? Even they sell medicine through their stores. So what was the purpose of sharing Walmart store link? I still doesn't find any relevance!:nonchalance:

I have been to enough Walmarts to know what they sell and that is precisely why I shared this link.
 
Bharti Wal-Mart enters contract farming in Punjab

http://www.freshplaza.com/news_detail.asp?id=54260



They are already in contract farming from 2009 onward. Even after contract farming why farmer are throwing potatoes on road in Punjab???



This is so ridiculously lousy interconnection of any thing.
Do you any proof that Walmart did contractual farming for potatoes? Do you have any link to show a relation?

Just because I am in US wont mean you will blame me for Afghanistan/Iraq, just because I am here doesnt mean I am into everything.
 
The purpose is to show you that Agricultre produce is not everything they sell and thus 30% sourcing debate isnt even worthy. Most of what they sell is already being imported from China from local distributors.

BTW open the link, they do sell pharmacy and grocery online too. Dont be in a haste to reply, check that.

Yes, what should we know after going through Walmart store link precisely? Aren't we aware that Walmart sell everything? Even they sell medicine through their stores. So what was the purpose of sharing Walmart store link? I still doesn't find any relevance!:nonchalance:
 
Yes but does it say that those farmers who protested were in contract with Walmart.

Understand contract- An assurance to buy.

Since you cant produce a direct proof, allow me: http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...benefits-punjab-farmers/videoshow/4842437.cms

Bharti Wal-Mart enters contract farming in Punjab

http://www.freshplaza.com/news_detail.asp?id=54260



They are already in contract farming from 2009 onward. Even after contract farming why farmer are throwing potatoes on road in Punjab???
 
Did you read it? If you did you wouldnt share it

“The programme was a success only due to the supply of quality seeds and our continuous motivation to farmers. But lack of interest by the Punjab government in diversification of crops is leading to the closure of this scheme. Now, efforts are being made to bring a new diversification policy, said a senior PAFC official.

[h=1]Contract farming scheme to bring about diversification in crops on verge of closure[/h]
http://www.indianexpress.com/news/c...ication-in-crops-on-verge-of-closure/1008609/
 
Govt enforce farmer what to produce and what to not in Punjab???:nonchalance:

Did you read it? If you did you wouldnt share it

“The programme was a success only due to the supply of quality seeds and our continuous motivation to farmers. But lack of interest by the Punjab government in diversification of crops is leading to the closure of this scheme. Now, efforts are being made to bring a new diversification policy, said a senior PAFC official.
 
Back
Top