Reality of FDI, beyond politics

Bhai, thoda sar pair bhi ger le in baato mein, sirf kahe ne ke lie kuch bhi ool jalool na kah.


When the Input cost is Rs 4/Kg and you'll get Rs 1/Kg or Rs 2/Kg...then it's not a big deal...and if somebody consider it as a big deal then I would say "dil ko behlanay kai liye galib khyal accha hia"

ar bees killay ka jaimndara hia to kheti kai sarvgayata na ho gaye aap jatto mai kellay...saray jattu ka background hi kheti tai related hia...kisi baniya kai aagay aise baat kartay to bhi aise gud ghutti wo hajam kar lete...yahan ek tai ek choudhary baathhay...:cool:
 
When the Input cost is Rs 4/Kg and you'll get Rs 1/Kg or Rs 2/Kg...then it's not a big deal...and if somebody consider it as a big deal then I would say "dil ko behlanay kai liye galib khyal accha hia"

ar bees killay ka jaimndara hia to kheti kai sarvgayata na ho gaye aap jatto mai kellay...saray jattu ka background hi kheti tai related hia...kisi baniya kai aagay aise baat kartay to bhi aise gud ghutti wo hajam kar lete...yahan ek tai ek choudhary baathhay...:cool:
sirji....hamare gaon or aspas 30000 per acre jamin ka theka(annual rent)chalta hai ........app kay yaha bhi iss kay aspas ya thoda kum jayda hoga......app jo 4 ka1or 2 yani
ki kum se kum 50% loss kah rahe ho too koi na khud jamidara karta or na koi jamin thekye p leta...... sari dharti khali rahti.

or maine bees kilaye ka jamidara khud karne ki baat ki hai..............background hone may or kheti khud karne may bhi fark hota h....ye too har jat janta h sirji.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Go to around Baghpat, Shamli, Merrut...the same rate is going on 7K to 10K per bigaha..(1acre = 5 bigah). So I knew very well all these facts.

As you are in agriculture so do have our family as well in agriculture and knew very well how much they can save annually after so much of hard work. At least the farmer of West UP doing cultivation of Sugar cane predominantly so thay are able to save some money. But all farmers are not so lucky in India as farmers like West UP, Haryana and Punjab. India is very much bigger. 1000s of farmer are not suiciding in India just for entertainment. Those who are in vegetable cultivation ain't able to recover even their input cost. So come out from your village and looks in broader perspective.


sirji....hamare gaon or aspas 30000 per acre jamin ka theka(annual rent)chalta hai ........app kay yaha bhi iss kay aspas ya thoda kum jayda hoga......app jo 4 ka1or 2 yani
ki kum se kum 50% loss kah rahe ho too koi na khud jamidara karta or na koi jamin thekye p leta...... sari dharti khali rahti.

or maine bees kilaye ka jamidara khud karne ki baat ki hai..............beckground hone may or kheti khud karne may bhi fark hota h....ye too har jat janta h sirji.
 
ar rahi baat khud khetti karan ki...jo kisaan 100 bighay ki khetti khud karay..us pai itna tame na hotta ki wo JL pai aakay apna mattha foday. So better concentrate of your 20 acre khetti...warna sari fasal shook ja gi khday kahday ar tam yahan JL mai bhidtay rahiyo...:stupid:

sirji....hamare gaon or aspas 30000 per acre jamin ka theka(annual rent)chalta hai ........app kay yaha bhi iss kay aspas ya thoda kum jayda hoga......app jo 4 ka1or 2 yani
ki kum se kum 50% loss kah rahe ho too koi na khud jamidara karta or na koi jamin thekye p leta...... sari dharti khali rahti.

or maine bees kilaye ka jamidara khud karne ki baat ki hai..............background hone may or kheti khud karne may bhi fark hota h....ye too har jat janta h sirji.
 
. 1000s of farmer are not suiciding in India just for entertainment. Those who are in vegetable cultivation ain't able to recover even their input cost. So come out from your village and looks in broader perspective.

sirji yahi to reason h ki mai fdi in retail ki favour kar raha hu...............kyki ye middelmen (bania) na to kissan ko badia rate milne deta or usko higher interest per money
lend karta h or poor farmer ki majboori ka fayda uthta h......i hope you come out from your party line(supporting these 4% greedy banias instead of 55% farmers) and look in to
the broader perspective of farmers welfare
 
ar rahi baat khud khetti karan ki...jo kisaan 100 bighay ki khetti khud karay..us pai itna tame na hotta ki wo JL pai aakay apna mattha foday. So better concentrate of your 20 acre khetti...warna sari fasal shook ja gi khday kahday ar tam yahan JL mai bhidtay rahiyo...:stupid:
sirji ....ghom phir k nai personal attack or bhidane pay aa jayo ho!!
app pe to wa kahawat fit bathe h.....kay maa re bayhe diye kite bhi panogi beri kay mela p :stupid:
 
FDI in retail is not just about Kisan and middleman relationship....FDI in retail is more than that...as the agri product business is not more than 20% of these large retail chain....the 80% of their business is non food base product. Which will hamper other people more drastically.

sirji yahi to reason h ki mai fdi in retail ki favour kar raha hu...............kyki ye middelmen (bania) na to kissan ko badia rate milne deta or usko higher interest per money
lend karta h or poor farmer ki majboori ka fayda uthta h......i hope you come out from your party line(supporting these 4% greedy banias instead of 55% farmers) and look in to
the broader perspective of farmers welfare
 
It was not a personal comment. It was just an observation. Differentiate it.

sirji ....ghom phir k nai personal attack or bhidane pay aa jayo ho!!
app pe to wa kahawat fit bathe h.....kay maa re bayhe diye kite bhi panogi beri kay mela p :stupid:
 
FDI in retail is not just about Kisan and middleman relationship....FDI in retail is more than that...as the agri product business is not more than 20% of these large retail chain....the 80% of their business is non food base product. Which will hamper other people more drastically.
sirji app ki post se mujhe ye lagta h ki app iss baat pay to agree h ki farmers ko to fayda hoga......kya ye sahi hai .
 
Bhai Shamli, Bagpat Meerut mein kitne kisaan Sabzi bote hai jara is par prakash dalna? Sare gande ar gahun mein ladde pade hai kyu? Asaan kheti, nischit sale

Go to around Baghpat, Shamli, Merrut...the same rate is going on 7K to 10K per bigaha..(1acre = 5 bigah). So I knew very well all these facts.

As you are in agriculture so do have our family as well in agriculture and knew very well how much they can save annually after so much of hard work. At least the farmer of West UP doing cultivation of Sugar cane predominantly so thay are able to save some money. But all farmers are not so lucky in India as farmers like West UP, Haryana and Punjab. India is very much bigger. 1000s of farmer are not suiciding in India just for entertainment. Those who are in vegetable cultivation ain't able to recover even their input cost. So come out from your village and looks in broader perspective.
 
And when I said that earlier you retaliated? Bhai ek nao mein pair rakh aur konsi, wo bhi decide kar.

FDI in retail is not just about Kisan and middleman relationship....FDI in retail is more than that...as the agri product business is not more than 20% of these large retail chain....the 80% of their business is non food base product. Which will hamper other people more drastically.
 
I'm very much in one boat. I've retaliated against FDI in retail and specifically these foreign retail chain. As far as Contract farming is concern It's not necessary that it should have to be done through foreign retail chain and I'm not against Contract Farming, It may have to be promoted more, but certainly not through the foreign retail chain. Is that clear mine stand???

And when I said that earlier you retaliated? Bhai ek nao mein pair rakh aur konsi, wo bhi decide kar.
 
Last edited:
Read mine comment again carefully...where did I say that farmers in Shamli, Bagpat Meerut are growing vegetables???

Bhai Shamli, Bagpat Meerut mein kitne kisaan Sabzi bote hai jara is par prakash dalna? Sare gande ar gahun mein ladde pade hai kyu? Asaan kheti, nischit sale
 
I'v already said I'm not against Contract Farming few post above. But for contract farming it doesn't mean that we've to allow foreign retail chain in India.

sirji app ki post se mujhe ye lagta h ki app iss baat pay to agree h ki farmers ko to fayda hoga......kya ye sahi hai .
 
It was not necessary to bring all vegetable in any discussion to prove your point. Potato was just one example to show that farmer not able to recover their input cost. You'll find many more such example as well throughout the India.

But your argument is for vegetable growing farmers, aalu se aage kabhi badha hi nahi?
 
FDI: A local perspective
Maj. Manmohan Singh, farmer

One of the most successful farmers of Amritsar, Singh is also an 'arhtiya' (commission agent) for government purchase agencies. "Whenever big companies come in, the rates of farm products rise and farmers benefit. This happened with basmati and I saw it first hand. The apple lobby in Himachal were happy when a company came in to buy apples directly from the farmers and they got good rates," says Singh.

Being an arhtiya, Singh knows about the cuts imposed on farmers.

"Even government agencies are not sincere, often telling farmers that due to high moisture in their grain they will not buy it at the minimum support price. Underhanded deals also take place to clear the grain for sale," he adds.

He agrees the FDI will let big companies to take over the market which will in turn help farmers get better prices for their produce.

Singh gave an example of basmati variety. In 2010, the rate was around Rs. 3000 per quintal. Last year, the private traders did not allow the price to rise, forcing farmers to sell between Rs. 1500 - Rs. 1700 per quintal. The traders stored and later sold it at higher price.
 
I'v already said I'm not against Contract Farming few post above. But for contract farming it doesn't mean that we've to allow foreign retail chain in India.
sirji contract farming pay to apki or meri baat hui hi nahi.........wo alag issue h.......farmers ko iss may fyda h ye clear kar do to bahoot badia hoga.
 
Back
Top