Reality of FDI, beyond politics

It was not necessary to bring all vegetable in any discussion to prove your point. Potato was just one example to show that farmer not able to recover their input cost. You'll find many more such example as well throughout the India.
sirji app to kissan family se ho................subji ki kheti sahro kay pass profitable hai na ki dor kay area may ....due to costly dilevery.......or sahro kay najdik ka 4 acre ka
farmer moti kheti walle 10 acre se faltu h.
 
The pro FDI in retail people promoting it in the same manner that once FDI in retail wiil come up, these foreign retail chain will do the contract farming and farmer will get the benefit. So how we can exclude the issue of contract farming??

I'm not against contract farming which certainly help the farmer but not in favor of these foreign retail chain whose business is not just contract farming. They are much more than that.

sirji contract farming pay to apki or meri baat hui hi nahi.........wo alag issue h.......farmers ko iss may fyda h ye clear kar do to bahoot badia hoga.
 
FYI: The onion that you are eating in Delhi daily comes from Maharastra. You can't grow all kind of vegetables just around the cities.

When we talk about farmer then we have to take into account of farmer of all over the India.

sirji app to kissan family se ho................subji ki kheti sahro kay pass profitable hai na ki dor kay area may ....due to costly dilevery.......or sahro kay najdik ka 4 acre ka
farmer moti kheti walle 10 acre se faltu h.
 
The pro FDI in retail people promoting it in the same manner that once FDI in retail wiil come up, these foreign retail chain will do the contract farming and farmer will get the benefit. So how we can exclude the issue of contract farming??

I'm not against contract farming which certainly help the farmer but not in favor of these foreign retail chain whose business is not just contract farming. They are much more than that.
sirji agree to karo so per seedhe haan na bahrte......ghoma kay bolo ho.
 
Rakesh bhai nai jamma ek number ki baat kahi sai :victorious:. Phir chipka deta hoon yahan wo post

चलिए आपको गाँव की एक दुकान पे ले चलते हैं ! यहाँ एक लकड़ी का टूटा सा काउंटर है और ऊपर दोनों चौखट के बीच में एक रस्सी बंधी हुई है ! उस रस्सी पे चमचमाते कुछ पैकेट टंगे हुए हैं ! पहले कुछ पैकेट हैं शैम्पू के पेंटीन, सनसिल्क, हेड एन शोल्डर, क्लिनिक प्लस डव इत्यादि , दूसरी तरफ कुछ पैकेट टंगे हुए हैं कुरकुरे लेस चिप्स इत्यादि बीच में एरिअल शम्पू, एजी इत्यादि की पुडिया हैं ! काउंटर के शीशे से झांकते हैं तो वहां कैडबरी की चोकलेट, ब्रितानिया के बिस्किट , मिनट पोलो इतियादी ! नीचे वाले खानों में ऊपर लिखी कंपनियों के शम्पू की शीशियाँ और डाबर के तेल ! पीछे बने हुए खानों में फिलिप्स के बल्ब और सी ऍफ़ एल ! जिललेट के रेजर ब्लेड , क्रीम फेशवाश, पेप्सोडेंट के क्लोसेअप के दन्त मंजन, लक्स, डव, लिरिल के साबुन, लिप्टन की चाय, शीशे के फ्रिज से झांकती कोका कोला के रंग बिरंगे पेय पदार्थ ! और कुछ डब्बो में रखे नारियल और बेसन के लड्डू , कुछ केले और कुछ सब्जियां ! इनमे से कितने सामान इस देश के हैं !
भिखारियों को चुनने की ताकत नहीं होती !
इस देश की जो जनता ऍफ़ डी आई का विरोध कर रही है मेरे ख्याल से वो गलत है ! क्योंकि आज भी हम उन्ही विदेशी आकाओं के फैंके टुकडो पे जिंदा हैं ! इस देश की रिटेल की दुकानों में भी उन्ही का सामान बिकता है और वालमार्ट भी वही बेचेगी ! फर्क क्या है ? इनकी और छोटे दुकानदारो की दुकाने बंद हो जाएँगी और हमें काले अंग्रेजो की बजाये गोरे अंग्रेज लूटेंगे ! गोरे अंग्रेजो में एक फर्क होगा और वो ये होगा की वो फैक्ट्री और दुकान के बीच बैठे बिचोलियों को नहीं खाने देंगे ! सामान आज भी उनका है आगे भी उनका रहेगा और हमें सस्ते में मिलेगा !
इस देश में सबको वालमार्ट का मॉडल पता है और इस देश के कुछ धनाढ्य लोगो ने वो कॉपी भी किया मिसाल के तौर पर ६ टेन, रिलायंस, बिग बाजार, अमर्तेक्स, इजी डे, सुभिक्षा! इनमे से कुछ दुकाने बंद हो चुकी हैं और कुछ होने के कगार पर हैं ! अम्बानी के पास पैसे की कमी नहीं थी फिर भी उन्हें मुह की खानी पड़ रही है! वाल्ल्मार्ट कौनसी जादू की पुडिया लेके आयेगा की वो कामयाब ही होगा ? और अगर होगा तो भी क्या नुक्सान है ?
आज भी दुकाने (छोटे किरियाना स्टोर ) खुल रही हैं और बढ़ रही हैं ! तो ऐसा क्या है जो ये दुकाने चलती हैं ?आइये इनके पीछे कारण पे नजर डालते हैं !
१) ये दुकाने उधार में सामान देती हैं ( ये सबसे बड़ा और पहला कारण है )
२) ये दुकाने छोटी हैं ! इनका किराया बड़ी दुकानों के मुकाबले १०० से १००० गुना कम है !( बंधे हुए खर्च कम )
३) ये दुकाने आवश्यकता का सारा सामान रखती हैं अनावश्यक सामान कम होने से इनकी इन्वेंटरी कम है !
४) इन दुकानों में ए सी जैसी सुविधा न होने से इनका मासिक खर्चा कम आता है!
५) इनमे १५-२० फोर्मल वस्त्र पहने स्मार्ट लड़के लड़कियां नहीं है बल्कि लुंगी बनियान वाला बिजना झलता हुआ लाला और एक दो हजार रुपये मासिक वाला छोटू है यहाँ भी खर्च में कटौती है !
६)लाला जी अपनी कमाई सार्वजनिक नहीं करते तो उनका इन्काम टैक्स नहीं जाता !
७) अगर कमाई और खर्चे का हिसाब लगाया जाये तो लाला जी ज्यादा कमाई कर रहे हैं !
८) एक ग्राहक अगर सामान लेने वालमार्ट जाता है तो उसे अपनी गाडी का तेल / आने जाने का किराया, पार्किंग फीस, आने जाने का समय, वहां पर जाके १५० रुपये के मक्की के फुलले इतियादी सब हिसाब लगाने पड़ेंगे ! ऐसे में वो अगर तीन चार हजार का सामान नहीं खरीदता तो उसे खास फर्क नहीं पड़ता ! जोकि एक आम आदमी कम ही करना पसंद करता है वो भी इस देश में जहाँ की ६७.८ प्रतिशत आबादी २ डॉलर प्रति व्यक्ति प्रति दिन से नीचे गुजरा करता है उसके लिए एक मुश्त ६० डॉलर खर्च करना थोडा मुश्किल दिखाई देता है !

अब समस्या ये ही की एक आम आदमी इस मामले में सबसे आगे झंडा लिए खड़ा है उसको क्या नुक्सान है ! मै एक उपभोक्ता हूँ और आज भी विदेशी सामान इस्तेमाल करता हूँ तो मुझे कौनसा नुक्सान होने वाला है ?
आज सबसे महंगा खरीदने वाला उपभोक्ता है एक गरीब जो एक ८गुना १० फूट के कमरे का किराया एक फ्लैट से ज्यादा देता है उसका पर फुट किराया महंगे फ्लैट से कम नहीं है ! और उसे पाइया चावल सवा से डेढ़ गुना दाम पे मिलते हैं जिसके साथ दो चार घुड़कियाँ मुफ्त मिलती हैं ! उसे वालमार्ट कौनसा फायदा /नुक्सान पहुंचाएगी ?
आज वक़्त की जरूरत है स्वदेशी उत्पाद बनाने की और उस क्वालिटी का बनाने की की वो बेहतर नहीं तो बराबर हो इन विदेशी चीजो के और उनसे दाम में सस्ता हो ! अफ़सोस के साथ कहना पड़ रहा है की ऐसी कोई उम्मीद निकट भविष्य में नहीं है !अपना तो हम लेंगे पर कुछ हो तो ! हमारे यहाँ दिवाली की लड़ियाँ भी नहीं बन सकती जिसको चीन ने इस देश के घर घर पहुँचाया वरना घटिया क्वालिटी की लड़ियाँ दस से पचास गुना दाम पे मिलती थी और गरीबो की छोड़ो मध्यवर्गीय परिवार भी सरसों के दिए जलाते थे !
 
Last edited:
Why nobody buys the Congress story on ‘reforms’.

And the best extract from the whole story is....
"Getting excited about these moves is, as this columnist observes, “similar to the crowd cheering a batsman with a strike rate of 30 hitting a six in the 46th over after the asking rate had climbed to 20 per over for the remaining five overs.”

The party faithful may cheer and applaud, but the paying public aren’t buying any of this. Particularly when what passes for ‘reforms’ haven’t yet made a material difference to the lives of anyone."

http://www.firstpost.com/politics/why-nobody-buys-the-congress-story-on-reforms-480858.html

And this is the Reality of FDI, beyond politics.
 
Last edited:
  • "They train us and assist us right from when the crop is sown to when it's harvested. They give us a higher price than the market for better quality," said Todkari, 29, who works the field in western India with his elderly father.
  • "We plan to procure as much as we can via direct farming so the procurement from traders in local markets is as little as possible," said Krishnakant Reddy, who is in charge of direct farming in south and west India for Wal-Mart, which already operates in India through 17 wholesale stores
  • Wal-Mart plans to sign up 35,000 farmers over the next three years, up from the 6,700 it has now. Fresh produce accounts for about 30 percent of Wal-Mart's sales in its wholesale outlets in India.
  • The farmers Wal-Mart selects are suited to modern irrigation, have higher yields and are capable of crop rotation. Wal-Mart's investment in farmers is part of the $100 million initial spending India requires foreign chains to make under the retail reforms.
  • Wal-Mart says it pays farmers a premium of at least 3 percent above the market price for better quality produce. What Wal-Mart doesn't buy, the farmer can sell at the local market.
  • "If their requirements go up and they want to work with us, we will be open. They give a good price and make timely payments ... which is all a farmer wants

I read an insteresting article, thought it will be worth while to share key pointers: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/15/us-walmart-india-suppliers-idUSBRE89E1G320121015
 
"Getting excited about these moves is, as this columnist observes, “similar to the crowd cheering a batsman with a strike rate of 30 hitting a six in the 46th over after the asking rate had climbed to 20 per over for the remaining five overs.”

.[/B]

dont be Kumar Vishwash and comment in a haste without understanding the meaning(Banana republic incident). What this means is that FDI has come in late and it was stuck because of stupid opposition and Mamta like politicians.

And look at what are you doing now? not supporting the reforms at all?

That last 6 might be too late but atleast it avoids a shameful defeat in economic arena.
 
Then we have nothing to lose, losers will be investors like Walmart or Tesco.

In the mean time, we would have already built infrastructure, supply chain, learnt best practices and made some money. :triumphant: win win

What if there is hardly anything beyond proposed reality?
 
Then we have nothing to lose, losers will be investors like Walmart or Tesco.

In the mean time, we would have already built infrastructure, supply chain, learnt best practices and made some money. :triumphant: win win

To add, I think people are losing cite of the fact that private players buying directly from farmers will not replace the government procurement of foodgrains. The private system will supplement the govt. one. As noted in one of your previous posts, if the farmer doesnt get a good price from Wal-Mart etc., he can go to the mandi and sell at or above MSP.

The whole premise by which big retailers make money is that there are inefficiencies in the system. Right from guiding the farmer to transporting and selling the end-product, there are a lot of middle-men, delays and wastages that increase costs. Removing these can benefit all parties if done well.
 
I dont less understanding of this thing if someone could help understanding Few Questions:

Some facts as per my knowledge :
1. The big retail chain, i assume, would sell a lot of products not just the main crops.
2. They can get 70% products outside India (whereever they will get quality and price).
3. They will try to beat small retailers price and hence will be forced to sell cheap or will provide higher quality otherwise people wont go there.
4. They will try to have certain products throughtout the year.

Few questions comes to mind.

1. Its not like selling things on bidding website that if you dont buy someone else will buy and the one with highest bid will get it. Its a serious business where there is competition who need to be checked in moreover these people will forcast their inventory based on trends/buyer's behaviour. They buy based on forcast. They will enter in contracts. Its not like they want to sell apple today so they will go to a village an buy an apple.

2. Dont understand why their is too much emphasis on infrastruture. Are they going to build roads, rails?

3. Dont understand what supply chain they will build? They will procure the goods either directly or through 3rd party and probably store in their wharehouse. They will build it for themself and will sell it when they leave. How will it improve our living standard.
Any company who need this can still build this.

4. The people who sell vegetables to the end user will have a hard time and many will be out of the job. These people need to be re skilled.

5. I heard from an economics student such companies only provide cheap goods initially to capture the market once the compitition is out then its buyers market (for the retailers). These people will force farmers to sell them on cheap rates so that they can sell end user cheaper. Not sure who it will help farmers in long run? I have hardly seen any big buyer doing favours to the supplier.

India already have many companies who got good supply chain like Cadbury. I am not sure what value has their supply chain added in lifting our living standard(relatively). Such companies have done long contracts with farmers in Africa and other countries (some are as long as 40 years) farmers has to grow what they want. They are not charity they are not coming here to help our farmers.



Excuse spellings mistake.
 
Few questions comes to mind.

1. Its not like selling things on bidding website that if you dont buy someone else will buy and the one with highest bid will get it. Its a serious business where there is competition who need to be checked in moreover these people will forcast their inventory based on trends/buyer's behaviour. They buy based on forcast. They will enter in contracts. Its not like they want to sell apple today so they will go to a village an buy an apple.

That is how every organised format business operates, trends, nothing wrong with it. Contact is even better, farmers sell their product even before it is produced at an agreed rate. Those 6700 mentioned farmers are happy with it. Punjab is another state where in spite of opposition rule the govt has come in favor because farmers are happy with contract farming. If you look through, you will find an article on the topic

2. Dont understand why their is too much emphasis on infrastruture. Are they going to build roads, rails?


Infrastructure if supply chain, cold storages, quicker route to market. Right not 30-40% produce goes for a waste which will not happen with organised retail

3. Dont understand what supply chain they will build? They will procure the goods either directly or through 3rd party and probably store in their wharehouse. They will build it for themself and will sell it when they leave. How will it improve our living standard.
Any company who need this can still build this.

Procurement will be direct, thus avoiding middleman and giving right rate to farmers and cheaper to consumers. Second, once the food is processed, the black marketing of food items stop thus no price manipulation. It will also stop wastage, like mentioned above.

4. The people who sell vegetables to the end user will have a hard time and many will be out of the job. These people need to be re skilled.

Not true, vegetable sellers are outside your house but Walmart or Tesco will be a bit away where you will go once or twice the month. In India where retailers like More For You have existed it is found that the small retailers did run out of business because of the reason mentioned. Also, they will keep more processed food.

5. I heard from an economics student such companies only provide cheap goods initially to capture the market once the compitition is out then its buyers market (for the retailers). These people will force farmers to sell them on cheap rates so that they can sell end user cheaper. Not sure who it will help farmers in long run? I have hardly seen any big buyer doing favours to the supplier.

That is an assumption, they are operating in several countries and havent heard farmer issue anywhere. On cheap goods, it is a business model that is debatable. Economics also tells that when you reduce the price of your goods you are setting expectations of consumers which is hard to break. Also, most of the items they sell are resold and have MRP fixed by manufacturers

India already have many companies who got good supply chain like Cadbury. I am not sure what value has their supply chain added in lifting our living standard(relatively). Such companies have done long contracts with farmers in Africa and other countries (some are as long as 40 years) farmers has to grow what they want. They are not charity they are not coming here to help our farmers.

Indian companies like Reliance, Aditya Birla who ventured into retail have been quoting losses due to inefficiency and thus it is important to build this industry by getting experts with FDI.

Excuse spellings mistake.


Answers above :redface:
 
That is how every organised format business operates, trends, nothing wrong with it. Contact is even better, farmers sell their product even before it is produced at an agreed rate. Those 6700 mentioned farmers are happy with it. Punjab is another state where in spite of opposition rule the govt has come in favor because farmers are happy with contract farming. If you look through, you will find an article on the topic.

nothing wrong with it?? What if farmer cant deliver the goods. Who will bear the loss. Walmart?? You must be joking.
We have small farmers and agriculture produce is bit unpredictable. You start growing something for someone. You have to produce the same quality and same quantity otherwise its your loss.
They can even alter the price depending on contract. If opposition is selling a banana free with apple (just to get foot in the market) they will force farmers to reduce the price. Our agriculture sector is not that mature to handle all this. In other countries there are big farmers who have insurance on their produce too.


Infrastructure if supply chain, cold storages, quicker route to market. Right not 30-40% produce goes for a waste which will not happen with organised retail.


What about the over produce and unwanted products? They are not going to store vegetables/fruits for you?? They will store for themselves. Any business will try to have less shelf life of any products. Why would they store our products. Above you say they will buy based on trend so as to have less shelf life.

Procurement will be direct, thus avoiding middleman and giving right rate to farmers and cheaper to consumers. Second, once the food is processed, the black marketing of food items stop thus no price manipulation. It will also stop wastage, like mentioned above.


Didnt quite get this point. Are you saying that they will buy all wheat at once and start making Atta immediately so other people wont be able to store?


Not true, vegetable sellers are outside your house but Walmart or Tesco will be a bit away where you will go once or twice the month. In India where retailers like More For You have existed it is found that the small retailers did run out of business because of the reason mentioned. Also, they will keep more processed food.


Vegetable market (Sabji Mandi) is about 3-4 KM from my house. Its a big market. The people who come to your door buy from these mandis. I meant few people in these mandis will be out of the job because going by your logic Supermaket chain will be cheapest options so more and more people will try to buy from there rather than mandis.

That is an assumption, they are operating in several countries and havent heard farmer issue anywhere. On cheap goods, it is a business model that is debatable. Economics also tells that when you reduce the price of your goods you are setting expectations of consumers which is hard to break. Also, most of the items they sell are resold and have MRP fixed by manufacturers


Everything is an assumption or prediction here isnt it? Unless you can really see the future? Anyway there can be thousands of incidents where farmers get exploited by Multinational Giants. Here is one new for your reference. http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/jul/02/british-farmers-supermarket-price-wars.

Read the new in a developed country farmers have no say in price. Now dont tell me the farmers can go and sell to govt if they dont buy. It doesnt work like this in real life scenerio.
You can read 1000s such news or you decide to read one type of paid news. If they dont care about farmers in their own country would they care abour farmers in our country.

India already have many companies who got good supply chain like Cadbury. I am not sure what value has their supply chain added in lifting our living standard(relatively). Such companies have done long contracts with farmers in Africa and other countries (some are as long as 40 years) farmers has to grow what they want. They are not charity they are not coming here to help our farmers.

Indian companies like Reliance, Aditya Birla who ventured into retail have been quoting losses due to inefficiency and thus it is important to build this industry by getting experts with FDI.

I am not an expert on these companies. What are they inefficiency you talking about? Please be precise with some numbers from P &L. This is a general statement picked out of hat.

I am not against FDI but to say we are doing it for the betterment of farmers doesn’t look correct. More than farmers it will be good for other people. Small farmers will be reduced. Still if someone give convincing replies I can change my opinion.
 


nothing wrong with it?? What if farmer cant deliver the goods. Who will bear the loss. Walmart?? You must be joking.

Farmers get the know how and support from these retailers, the crops are insured as well in most of the cases. Even if you say the produce isnt worth quality, the farmers can sell it to open market at msp

Please read this: http://www.deccanchronicle.com/editorial/op-ed/‘fdi-retail-will-help-farmers-reach-markets’-431



What about the over produce and unwanted products? They are not going to store vegetables/fruits for you?? They will store for themselves. Any business will try to have less shelf life of any products. Why would they store our products. Above you say they will buy based on trend so as to have less shelf life.
Usually the entire procurement is done after careful analysis, this is the very nitigrity of the business that I wouldnt have an expertise on but I can assure you that the demand of such goods is far more than supply and this these companies can process and sell it in international markets too. Even right now a lot of our produce is exported like rice

Didnt quite get this point. Are you saying that they will buy all wheat at once and start making Atta immediately so other people wont be able to store?

No, in fact I dont think Walmart will even get into wheat and sugarcane business as India already has processing plants. They will be more interested and vegetables and fruits. They will not and of course can not buy it all because monopoly will never be the case but they will introduce competition in the market which will benefit the farmers in terms or better rates for their produce



Vegetable market (Sabji Mandi) is about 3-4 KM from my house. Its a big market. The people who come to your door buy from these mandis. I meant few people in these mandis will be out of the job because going by your logic Supermaket chain will be cheapest options so more and more people will try to buy from there rather than mandis.

So far we have Indian retailers operating and never has been a case that a sabziwala was wiped off business. Also, organized retail will focus more on processed food than unprocessed to competition wont be much. Second, I am not saying not anyone will lose their job, but there will be a balancing act of others getting jobs too, farmers getting prices and better than all no middleman to suppress them



Everything is an assumption or prediction here isnt it? Unless you can really see the future? Anyway there can be thousands of incidents where farmers get exploited by Multinational Giants. Here is one new for your reference. http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/jul/02/british-farmers-supermarket-price-wars.

like I said, there are several contradictions and the link pasted by me proves it too, farming in our country is much different than UK or US where farmers get subsiby, farming cost is high and several other reasons. In India farming is cheap, farmers dont get the right price and is a suppressed community and with these big retailers the competition for produce will increase, benefitting them


Also, none of my above statement is general, I have followed debates on the issue very closely. I can also tell you that the road to India for these retailers is not that easy and a few things like high rental, lack of stores will be a big challange which is hitting indian retailers too but these people have the know how and deep pockets to invest for a longer time
 


Farmers get the know how and support from these retailers, the crops are insured as well in most of the cases. Even if you say the produce isnt worth quality, the farmers can sell it to open market at msp

Please read this: http://www.deccanchronicle.com/editorial/op-ed/%E2%80%98fdi-retail-will-help-farmers-reach-markets%E2%80%99-431





Ok I understand now your logics more clearly after reading this piece of news. The important piece in this new is if things go wrong you have Govt to make the policies to protect farmers. To me this is bit contradictory. Are you favouring FDI because the current Govt policies are against Farmers? And in future you are expecting Govt to come to your rescue?


I dont think it is goiing to help our small farmers. We indians (including me) just believe in everything what we hear.

like I said, there are several contradictions and the link pasted by me proves it too, farming in our country is much different than UK or US where farmers get subsiby, farming cost is high and several other reasons. In India farming is cheap, farmers dont get the right price and is a suppressed community and with these big retailers the competition for produce will increase, benefitting them

I dont understand this. Are you saying farming cost in UK, US is dearer because of subsidy or you saying they dont get subsidy that is why farming cost is high? You saying in india farming is cheap? but the selling price is even cheaper?- not quite clear what is being conveyed here.
 
ek bar samjha de k matlab hai tere Banana Republic ka??? Or fir uske baad ye bhi samjha diyo ki agar India "Banana Republic" bana to kaise bana!!! achanak ek fastest growing economy kaise economicaly unstable ho gai???khair... ye baat to India ke best economist (tera PM or guru) ki samajh mai nahi aai to chele ki samajh mai kit te aave thi???

Nobody is opposing the reforms. Change is only the permanent thing in this world and that is going to happen for sure. We should welcome the changes. But it doesnt means that we should welcome the meaningless, visionless and pointless changes. All i want to say is to prepare our system (Social and Judicial) to tackle with the problems, which will come along with those changes (or FDI). Do you remember the episode of bringing the episode of, so called "better breed wheat seeds"? Congress grass weed came along it and countless human efforts had been spent yet to get rid over it. This is just one aspect of it. Others are Judicary and Govt. Can you tell me with this existing system, if any Big Company will fail to keep their promises (which they had/shall/would/will make while putting their money in India.) with farmers. What will/should be the course of action of the farmers?

Dekh bhai do cheez hain.

1. FDI in Infrastructure (Bridges/Highways/Metro Trains/Airports) isme Law bhi strong hain, Labor Welfare Associations bhi strong hain, Lawyers bhi expert hain, Vendor experienced bhi hain to paise wale bhi, Court ke ander or bahar ladne ke liye bhi capable hain. Client bhi usi level ke hain. Or paise jayada lagta hai to political log, Media persons and Courts proactive action lete hain.
2. FDI in Retails pe upar wale sare pros and cons apply karo. sabka response negative hi aayega.

So, I suggest FDI, Retails and agriculture mai le aao. Koi problem nahi hai. But pehle khud to prepare kar lo. FDI ke bahot fayede hain. But jayada lecurative deal jayada nuksaan bhi kar sakti hai...Let me put this in other and simple way... Desi Ghee khane ke bhi bahot sare fayede hain. lakin usko hajam karne ke liye pehlwan ka haajma chahiye. agar aapko khana hai to uska fayeda uthana hai to thodi warjish jarori hai, warna ya short term mai dast laag jayenge ya long term mai heart attack ke mareej ban jaoge... So, FDI le aao, but Govt should prepare system first. (to avoid any upset sooner or later.)... haan kuch chooti-moti problem hongi jo time ke saath hi pata chalengi to tab hi resolve ki jayengi, but badi problems to pehle se hi door karni padengi... I hope, I made it clear enough....


dont be Kumar Vishwash and comment in a haste without understanding the meaning(Banana republic incident). What this means is that FDI has come in late and it was stuck because of stupid opposition and Mamta like politicians.

And look at what are you doing now? not supporting the reforms at all?

That last 6 might be too late but atleast it avoids a shameful defeat in economic arena.
 
In this thread somebody has asked me why Rs got stronger against Dollar after allowing the FDI.

Now again Dollar at Rs 54...why??:tongue:
 
Back
Top