History and Historians on Jat Mauryan Empire[ founded by Chandragupta in c 323 BC]

Ravi,

Good questions in this post and the earlier one. My understanding of Chandra Gupta's religion as Jain was only in his old age. During his reign as a king, I would claim that I have no idea about his religion but now with your questioning would lean towards Hinduism if what you claim is Magasthenes accounts. Here is a slightly different issue, if we question just this aspect of Greek sources then what other aspects can be rejected from Greek works, who I am sure had their own bards. If we believe them then yes Hinduism can be taken as the prevalent religion during Mauryan period.


Bhai Sahib,

According to Jain text under the influence of Bhadrabahu, a Jain teacher, he adopted Jainism and abdicated his throne in favour of his son. [see, Parishistaparvana, Jacobi 2nd ed. p lxxix, VIII, 415 ff]

Magasthenes is also quoted to have said that during this period, Brahmans and Sarmanas were divided into various categories and were held in high esteem by general public and the ruling class for their qualities of head and heart.

But we do not know exact attitude of the founder of the dynasty towards Buddhists. However, if the Tathagat commentary is to be believed, he put into prison the father of an elder [Thera] at the instigation of Chanakya [Malasekara, pp. 846, 860]. But it is also averred that the person was put into prison for his political views and conduct not due to his religious leanings.

This shows all the three religions were existing and more or less flourishing in India at that time.

Thanks and regards
 
Last edited:
Some writers, e.g K D Sethna " Ancient India in new light' , think that the Greek portion is a later addition.

The greek portion is compressed, as if the inscriber had to inscribe the greek portion into a limited space, and the inscription is compressed to fit in.

That would push the greeks out of the Asoka time space.


Ravi Chaudhary

Chaudhary Sahib,

Very interesting point, needs due attention of the scholars of ancient Indian History. Could you make us available the full quote of Dr. Sethana on the issue as I have not been able to lay my hands on the book referred to in the post.

Thanks and regards
 
Some writers, e.g K D Sethna " Ancient India in new light' , think that the Greek portion is a later addition.

The greek portion is compressed, as if the inscriber had to inscribe the greek portion into a limited space, and the inscription is compressed to fit in.

That would push the greeks out of the Asoka time space.


Ravi Chaudhary

Friend,

It is impossible task to ''push the greek out of the Asoka time space," because, to achieve this end we will have to first erase the following testimony deciphered from Asoka's Inscriptions:

Rock Edicts second and thirteenth of Asoka, reference has been made to a number of contemporary Yona, i.e. Greek Kings:
RE II, A mentions 'the Yona king Antiyoka [Antiyaka at Girnar, Antiyoga at Kalsi and Mansehra] and the kings who are the neighbouring of this Antiyoka';
and the RE XIII, Q, 'the Yona king Antiyoka [Antiyoga at Kalsi and Mansehra] and beyond him four kings, viz. Turamaya [Tulamaya at Kalsi], Antekina [Antikini at Shahbazgarhi], Maka [Maga at Girnar], and Alikasudara [Alikyashudala at Kalsi.'*

*[CII,vol I, Inscriptions of Asoka, Introduction XXX by E Hultzsch.], New ed. 1969.]

This description shows Sethana Sahib's statement is not tenable and is worthy of outright rejection.

In addition to it there is one more hurdle in our way to make Asoka's history as per wishful thinking of some scholars that he had no relation with the Yavanas to which references are being collected and analyzed.

With warm regards.
 
Last edited:
As the thread title says, See if this is helpful in any way :
http://hi.wikipedia.org/wiki/मौर्य_साम्राज्य

Wikipedia is basically a collection of published sources, with no regard to critical views. The bias is towards English sources. The Indian sources- Hindi etc are steamrolled over.

It can be and is edited by anyone. See the Jat page/pages, which have deteriorated into a bunch of quotes from unreliable British authors. Other pages Harsha etc have been reduced to a regurgitation of whatever in the textbooks.

It is not reliable itself and needs to be checked with other sources.

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Friend,

It is impossible task to ''push the greek out of the Asoka time space," because, to achieve this end we will have to first erase the following testimony deciphered from Asoka's Inscriptions:

Rock Edicts second and thirteenth of Asoka, reference has been made to a number of contemporary Yona, i.e. Greek Kings:
RE II, A mentions 'the Yona king Antiyoka [Antiyaka at Girnar, Antiyoga at Kalsi and Mansehra] and the kings who are the neighbouring of this Antiyoka';
and the RE XIII, Q, 'the Yona king Antiyoka [Antiyoga at Kalsi and Mansehra] and beyond him four kings, viz. Turamaya [Tulamaya at Kalsi], Antekina [Antikini at Shahbazgarhi], Maka [Maga at Girnar], and Alikasudara [Alikyashudala at Kalsi.'*

*[CII,vol I, Inscriptions of Asoka, Introduction XXX by E Hultzsch.], New ed. 1969.]

This description shows Sethana Sahib's statement is not tenable and is worthy of outright rejection.

In addition to it there is one more hurdle in our way to make Asoka's history as per wishful thinking of some scholars that he had no relation with the Yavanas to which references are being collected and analyzed.

With warm regards.



Yona does not mean Yavana.

Yavana does not mean Greek.

The names by Hultzch, Amtiyoka ( a Yona king),Maka or Maga, Turamaya or Tulmaya, Antikena, can be explained by domestic languages.

There are problems with the equation to Ptolemy Alexander etc.

1) time lines,

2) selection of minor kings when major Greek kings exist, who would be more natural selections.

3) None of the Greek Kings chosen ( nor for that matter ANY Greek source) mention even once an embassy from our friend Askok.


Hultzsch and other scholars are forcing a Greek connection. They got away with it.

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Agreed it may be so.


To make the record straight, Kindly share with us the study in your knowledge of the RE 2 and RE 13 of Asoka and oblige us, Chaudhary Sahib.


Thanks and regards.
 
Last edited:
Puranas on successors of Asoka*:


The Vayu Purana gives to Kunala a reign of eight years and names five of his successors, the last of whom was Brihadratha.

The Matsya Purana, however, gives the following list of Asoka’s successors:
Dasaratha, Samprati, Satadhanva and Brihadratha; though it puts the total number of kings as ten.


The Vishnu Purana has its own list of seven kings, after Asoka, including Dasaratha, Salisuka, and the last king Brihadratha.

*(ed.) R.C. Majumdar, The Age of Imperial Unity, (Bombay, 1960), p.89.
 
Burdak ji,

इत्नी ताव्ली न करो, के बेरआ गल्दाई हो जा | I hope you do not mind.

But thank you anyways. These are Dr Lal's views and I respect his work quite a lot. You should explore other views as well. A date of 1400 BC is also worthy of exploration.

But since this is a Maurya thread so at the moment we can leave it for now.

Thanks Naveenji,

This gives Mahabharata War to be in 900 BCE generally accepted by historians.

3102 BCE is rejected.
 
There was some controversy about the third Mauryan Emperor’s name and about the authorship of the inscriptions found in length and breadth of the country. However, the identity of Piyadasi of inscriptions with Asoka has been confirmed since 1915 with the finding of Maski inscription which begins: “devanampiyasa Asokasa”.....

This inscriptions reading is in agreement with Asoka of the Buddhist sources and Asokavardhana of the Puranas which had long been a matter of inferences. Asoka the Maurya is mentioned in the Girnar inscription of Rudradaman [A.D. 150]. In the Calcutta-Bairat inscription Asoka refers himself as ‘Piyadasi laja Magadhe’, i.e. the King of Magadha.

According to KA Nilakantha Sastri, “the more usual formula is ‘devanampiya piyadasi laja’. The compound word devanampiya, meaning dear to gods’, was in Asoka’s time and until much later, an honorific term, sometimes used also as a synonym of rajan... Piyadasi and slightly altered form Piyadassana occur repeatedly in Dipavamsa as equivalent of Asoka.....it is applied to Chandragupta Maurya in the Mudraraksasa; the expression means both ‘of amiable appearance’ and ‘who sees with affection’. Whether piyadasi was the proper name and Asoka the biruda as has been thought, or the other way round, this great king will ever be known to history as Asoka,”

[see for details,KA Nilakantha Sastri, The Age of Nandas and Mauryas, 1952, Banaras.]
 
Last edited:
You are right. My earlier reply was off topic. Regarding revised dates of Mauryas, it seems like another ghotala which is quite prevalent nowadays.

Friend,

There is no 'ghotala' at all as the thread has been started for getting feed back on the subject from different corners and this churning of ideas and various theories would surely lead us to illuminate the dark corners of Indian History with the help of original sources.

Your active co operation in making the discussion more fruitful through your valuable inputs is eagerly being awaited.

Regards and best wishes.
 
Salisuka Maurya has been mentioned as one of the post-Asokan period rulers from this dynasty and assigned 13 years of his rule over Magadha. His name is testified by the Vayu and Vishnu Puranas.

In the 'Yugpurana' section of the 'Gargi Samhita' he is said to have done much to further the cause of Jainism even by the use of force.[For Purana text see Pargiter, Dynasties of the Kali Age, pp 27-29.]
 
McCrindle has translated the Greek sources into English for the use of researchers on various facets of the History of Ancient India in general and the Maurya dynasty in particular. His ''Ancient India as described by Magasthnese and Arrian [Calcutta, 1877]'' is one of his best books on sources of Indian History. Those persons who are not expert in Greek take advantage of the translated version but original sources of course stand on higher pedestal as they cannot be replaced by their translation or transliteration.

Thanks
 
Two more studies by the same author which are of use to the study of the topic under discussion are:

McCrindle, The invasion of India by Alexander the Great, (Westminster, 1896).
McCrindle, Ancient India as described in Classical Literature, (Westminster, 1901).

Thanks
 
Last edited:
Dr Rajpal Singh,

That is what I wrote originally and you just confirmed that "he adopted Jainism and abdicated his throne in favour of his son", which means in his old age. Do you know his religion when he was young or when he was the king - by way of Jacobi quoting Parishistaparva?

nrao said:
Originally Posted by nrao
Ravi,

Good questions in this post and the earlier one. My understanding of Chandra Gupta's religion as Jain was only in his old age. During his reign as a king, I would claim that I have no idea about his religion but now with your questioning would lean towards Hinduism if what you claim is Magasthenes accounts. Here is a slightly different issue, if we question just this aspect of Greek sources then what other aspects can be rejected from Greek works, who I am sure had their own bards. If we believe them then yes Hinduism can be taken as the prevalent religion during Mauryan period.

Bhai Sahib,

According to Jain text under the influence of Bhadrabahu, a Jain teacher, he adopted Jainism and abdicated his throne in favour of his son. [see, Parishistaparvana, Jacobi 2nd ed. p lxxix, VIII, 415 ff]

< ..snip.. >
 
Last edited:
Dr Rajpal Singh,

That is what I wrote originally and you just confirmed that "he adopted Jainism and abdicated his throne in favour of his son", which means in his old age. Do you know his religion when he was young or when he was the king - by way of Jacobi quoting Parishistaparva?

Friend,

Thanks for your both posts on the religion of Chandragupta Maurya.

So far, I have not come across any direct source on his religious leanings during his earlier life. But if we could place reliance on the statement of Chankya, it is found that in his administrative departments, there existed one post of Devatadhyaksha i.e. Superintendent of Religious Institutions to look after all temples of towns and villages of his realms. He was incharge of temple properties and could set up new Siva-Linga in old temples or set up new temples. [V.2].

If it is true then Chandragupta Maurya placed faith in Siva before his conversion to Jainism as claimed by the Jain Traditions quoted earlier.

Thanks
 
Last edited:
Sources on the Maurya Empire: 1.

Though original book remains unavailable yet fragments of Megasthenese's Indica have been collected and edited by Schwanbeck under the title of Megasthenis Indika (Bonn, 1846); and translated by McCrindle in Ancient India as described by Megasthenese and Arrian (Trubner, London, 1877). Arrian (Indica, 17) rightly brackets Nearchos and Megasthenese as trust worthy persons. Strabo, who was disgusted by some of the travellers' tales repeated by Megasthenese, unjustly stigmizes him as a liar. The information collected by Megasthenese was supplemented by other works of other writers, of whose books fragments have been preserved y the authors to whom we are indebted for our knowledge of Megasthnese. for a list of these authors see Schwanbeck, op.cit., Index I. McCrindle's books, six in number,give nearly complete collection of the passages in Greek and Roman authors treating of Ancient India.

Cited from VA Smith, The Early History of India, Oxford, 4th Ed.1962, p 127 note 1.
 
Sources on Mauryas: 2

For an analysis of the Mauryas' chronological sequence on the basis of original sources kindly refer: Chapters IV by Prof. H C Raychadhuri in [ed.] K A Nilkantha Sastri, Age of the Nandas and Mauryas, [1952, Banaras] is a well researched treatise on Chandragupta (Maurya) and Bindusara.

Thanks
 
Sources on Maurya History:4

Chapters in VA Smith, The Early History of India, Oxford, 4th Ed.1962 on various aspects of Mauryas' History contain good quotes from the Puranas and the Greek and Roman sources which could be usefully utilized by the researchers to reach to the originals on the topics of their choice.
 
Back
Top