The acquittal of the defendants in the Air India bombing is sad but it could have been predicted long time ago.
We all know that a case is judged on the basis of evidence presented in the court and not by public opinion. Although there is near unanimous agreement on the guilt of both the defendants, the process was fouled up from the beginning. However, it has absolutely nothing to do with the national origin of the victims.
The problems lie with the investigation. As some of you may know Canada's Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) have a great reputaion for competent police and investigative work for a long long time. But, a new organization called Canadian Security and Intelligence Service (CSIS), somewhat equivalent of CIA, was set up in 1980s and it proved to be a disaster from the first day. There was immediate rivalary between in CSIS and RCMP (similar stories are abundant about CIA and FBI) and some of the initial bigwigs of CSIS were not exactly competent people.
Most of the tapes of evidence gathered throgh hard work of investigators by tapping phones of the people involved were erased. When such a thing happens everyone thinks of a conspiracy but there is ample evidence that it was really due to incompetence as the tapes were used again for taping new material without realizing there was important information being erased.
Once the evidence was erased the case should have been dropped but by that time the government had spent hundreds of millions of dollars and it was politically unwise to drop the case.
I know several of the people who died in the crash and it is truly sad that the investigation was bungled up. But the decision to acquit the defendants is correct on the basis of evidence presented in the court.
Those who try to make the issue as a racial one are totally off the mark. I have seen lot of murderers acquitted because of the ineptness of prosecutors over the years and this case is no different. Our best family friend in town happens to be one of the best known criminal defence lawyers in Canada and he told us long time ago that the Air India trial is an exercise in futility.