Acquittal of the Kanishka accused

Status
Not open for further replies.

nvedwan

New member
In a court judgement this past week, the two alleged co-conspirators who were being tried for the bombing of an Air India( Kanishka) airplane, which resulted in the deaths of 329 people, were acquitted. The relatives of the victims of this bombing who had been waiting since 1985 for justice, and some sense of closure, were understandably devastated. What do you think happened in this case? Was this primarily a case of shoddy and inept prosecution, or were these guys really not guilty? Comments from Canada-based members will probably be most helpful in understanding what derailed the case. How is the outcome of this case being discussed and interpreted in Canada, as a miscarriage of justice, or, otherwise? I read somewhere that there were celebrations in the village in Punjab where the defendents came from.
 
Extremely unfotunate. Let us see how does Indian Government reacts to it. Again we can't interfere in the judicial system of another country. We should have tried to extradicate them to India and should have tried them there.
 
This will definitely give a filip to terrorists. I agree with you Col. sahab, these two should be brought to India and tried there. After all their attack was against the Indian state. This Bagri fellow had openly called upon terrorists to kill 50,000 Hindus daily in Punjab.
 
Quoting from a report in HT
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1285581,00410011.htm

As one victim pointed out, ``Had this been a tragedy that affected mainstream, white Anglo-Saxon Canadians, I think the response would have been very different."

They feel the Kanishka bombing was never perceived as a Canadian tragedy. For Canadians, it was the result of an India-specific issue. It involved an Indian carrier. It involved passengers of Indian origin. Its perpetrators were of Indian origin. So much so that Prime Minister Mulroney had called Rajiv Gandhi to express condolences on the `Indian' tragedy despite the fact that more than 200 passengers were Canadian citizens
 
The acquittal of the defendants in the Air India bombing is sad but it could have been predicted long time ago.

We all know that a case is judged on the basis of evidence presented in the court and not by public opinion. Although there is near unanimous agreement on the guilt of both the defendants, the process was fouled up from the beginning. However, it has absolutely nothing to do with the national origin of the victims.

The problems lie with the investigation. As some of you may know Canada's Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) have a great reputaion for competent police and investigative work for a long long time. But, a new organization called Canadian Security and Intelligence Service (CSIS), somewhat equivalent of CIA, was set up in 1980s and it proved to be a disaster from the first day. There was immediate rivalary between in CSIS and RCMP (similar stories are abundant about CIA and FBI) and some of the initial bigwigs of CSIS were not exactly competent people.

Most of the tapes of evidence gathered throgh hard work of investigators by tapping phones of the people involved were erased. When such a thing happens everyone thinks of a conspiracy but there is ample evidence that it was really due to incompetence as the tapes were used again for taping new material without realizing there was important information being erased.

Once the evidence was erased the case should have been dropped but by that time the government had spent hundreds of millions of dollars and it was politically unwise to drop the case.

I know several of the people who died in the crash and it is truly sad that the investigation was bungled up. But the decision to acquit the defendants is correct on the basis of evidence presented in the court.

Those who try to make the issue as a racial one are totally off the mark. I have seen lot of murderers acquitted because of the ineptness of prosecutors over the years and this case is no different. Our best family friend in town happens to be one of the best known criminal defence lawyers in Canada and he told us long time ago that the Air India trial is an exercise in futility.
 
That Ajaib Bagri said "we should kill 50,000 hindus". He was caught on tape saying it.

Chalo, canada ke adaalath se bach gaya.

He wants to come back to India.

Chalo, aan deo.

Teach that fat racist Rajput a lesson or two KPS Gill style!

Regards, and RAM RAM.
 
birbal said:
The acquittal of the defendants in the Air India bombing is sad but it could have been predicted long time ago.

We all know that a case is judged on the basis of evidence presented in the court and not by public opinion. Although there is near unanimous agreement on the guilt of both the defendants, the process was fouled up from the beginning. However, it has absolutely nothing to do with the national origin of the victims.

The problems lie with the investigation. As some of you may know Canada's Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) have a great reputaion for competent police and investigative work for a long long time. But, a new organization called Canadian Security and Intelligence Service (CSIS), somewhat equivalent of CIA, was set up in 1980s and it proved to be a disaster from the first day. There was immediate rivalary between in CSIS and RCMP (similar stories are abundant about CIA and FBI) and some of the initial bigwigs of CSIS were not exactly competent people.

Most of the tapes of evidence gathered throgh hard work of investigators by tapping phones of the people involved were erased. When such a thing happens everyone thinks of a conspiracy but there is ample evidence that it was really due to incompetence as the tapes were used again for taping new material without realizing there was important information being erased.

Once the evidence was erased the case should have been dropped but by that time the government had spent hundreds of millions of dollars and it was politically unwise to drop the case.

I know several of the people who died in the crash and it is truly sad that the investigation was bungled up. But the decision to acquit the defendants is correct on the basis of evidence presented in the court.

Those who try to make the issue as a racial one are totally off the mark. I have seen lot of murderers acquitted because of the ineptness of prosecutors over the years and this case is no different. Our best family friend in town happens to be one of the best known criminal defence lawyers in Canada and he told us long time ago that the Air India trial is an exercise in futility.

Dear Dr. Sahib,
What has been the reaction of major Indian Population on this verdict? Are there any celebrations in Toronto area? That would give the indication of the public whether it supports a criminal from the majority Indian Community in Canada or it supports the innocent victims of these terror attacks. I have been told that there are big portraits of Mr. Bhindrawale in Canadian Gurudwaras and he is worshipped as freedom fighter there. What is the truth and what are your views on this? May we get an insight in to the Indian Community in Canada?
 
Colnel Sahib,

Things have changed a lot since the heydays of Khalistani movement in Canada. There is no support for those people in the Sikh community, not at least openly. The regular Saturday Vision TV show on which they used to talk so much nonsense stopped many years ago. Ujjal Dosanjh (the most respected Jat Sikh), who the Khalistanis beat up badly in an attempt to kill went on to become Premier of British Columbia and now is the Health Minister of Canada.

The people, Indo-canadians as well as mainstream Canadians are greatly disappointed at the outcome of the trial, but it is one of those situations where nothing much can be done.
 
Dear Dr. Sahab,

Thanks a lot for the update. I hope this gentleman does not travel to India as he has mentioned. While the court may have acquitted him, there may be many who might take law in their own hand. This will only lead to their prosecution for the silly person like him.
 
Uninformed conspiracy theorist would say:


The acquittals, that too after a long time, where public unanimously believed that both these men were behind the bombings, suggest that politics was involved. May be Canada didn't want to "disturb/irritate" whatever, it Sikh population, for Indian cause.

The only point to take home from this is the in competency of Indian government/judiciary, which failed to deliver justice to so many Indian who died in that bombing.

But who care, when justice is not being done for incidents happening in it's own territory, for example the Gujrat Riots/Mumbai blasts etc
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top