Contribution of Indian Immigrants to Life abroad

...और ब्रितानिया का हाल तो दशको से ख़राब चल रहा है....और उत ना धरया कुछ

Friend,
Leaving other things aside, the fact is that in the field of higher education several international level institutions are there in England where students from all around world take admission.
Thanks
 
Yes there are. But high cost of living, racial discrimination people face on streets, lack of sufficient scholarships, etc. make students hesitant to enroll there. Most of middle class Indian students go abroad to study science & technology, healthcare and for that north America and other European countries, may be Australia too, provide better environment than UK. But students still go to UK if they get admission at good institute, for example London School of Economics



Friend,
Leaving other things aside, the fact is that in the field of higher education several international level institutions are there in England where students from all around world take admission.
Thanks
 
Yes there are. But high cost of living, racial discrimination people face on streets, lack of sufficient scholarships, etc. make students hesitant to enroll there. Most of middle class Indian students go abroad to study science & technology, healthcare and for that north America and other European countries, may be Australia too, provide better environment than UK. But students still go to UK if they get admission at good institute, for example London School of Economics

I think Indian students choose American universities as they are generally considered the best and Australian ones as they are easier to get admission into. UK is definitely not the first choice, but probably still second or third in the list. There are lots of Indian students in the UK. Racial discrimination is not a factor for not choosing UK over other countries. Between the US, Europe and Australia; UK is probably the best from race perspective. Incidents of racial discrimination occur every where (including India).
 
This was done by UK in response to a deal that was done between India and France for fighter planes (Rafael-Dassault). 95000 crore is by no means a small amount especially for a country whose economy was already heading towards double-dip recession. Khunnas nikal di UK ne apni.

Bhai, the timing is just coincidental in my opinion. UK may be very angry and may want to retaliate, but there are more logical ways of doing it like stopping outsourcing to Indian companies or putting other trade restrictions. Not getting genuine students hurts the econonomy (education sector) as they charge 3-4 times the national fees to international students.

These restrictions have been in discussion for a long time. In fact, they are making immigration rules tighter for some time trying to go in the US way. UK was known for easiest immigration rules earlier. The student route was misused by many people who just got admission in any course and then came over, started working and never went back. Immigration is a big political issue in the UK. Even if India gives lots of business to the UK, they will still tighten these rules as that is what appeals to many English voters (By the way, all Indians, Pakistanis and Bangladeshis on a visa in UK also have a vote (commonwealth) in national elections, but this vote bank is not that huge).
 
As most members have said, it is upto each country to decide their rules. Immigration is always done for personal aspirations, whether it is career, political freedom, better lifestyle or whatever. Whatever contribution happens is coincidental. In any case, it is upto the host country to recognize the contributions. And only a host country's acknowledgment of contributions means something. India should worry about the safety and well being of its citizens abroad, not their contributions abroad. If at all, it should worry about how to increase their contribution to India.
 
As most members have said, it is upto each country to decide their rules. Immigration is always done for personal aspirations, whether it is career, political freedom, better lifestyle or whatever. Whatever contribution happens is coincidental. In any case, it is upto the host country to recognize the contributions. And only a host country's acknowledgment of contributions means something. India should worry about the safety and well being of its citizens abroad, not their contributions abroad. If at all, it should worry about how to increase their contribution to India.

Bhai,

Good post.
Mehman thode samaya ke liye hota hai kuch samaya baad use bhi kaam pe lagana padta hai; Yahi baat videshon mein jakar rahane walon pe lagoo hoti hai. Unhe wahan rahate wahan ke qanun kaiydon ka palan karate huye apna karobar, service karake wahan ki economy mein contribute karana hota hai aur us desh mein pradaan kee jane wali suwidhaon ka laabh apne aap unhe mil jata hai.
NRI's ke jaan maal kee surksha INDIA government ki hone ke saath, us desh kee aantrik aur bahya halat se bhi judi hoti hai.

Thanks.
 
It's true, Indian immigrants have contributed in myriad ways towards the improvement of the host country. But at the same time they have also carried over the Indian attitude to subvert law and find loopholes in regulations whereever possible.

I being from the region which is perhaps the largest contributor of Indian immigrants have seen first hand the method and tactics used by people. Getting enrolled just for the purpose of immigration into courses like hair dressing, cookery, carpentry by sons of farmers isn't uncommon. These courses arw shorter and cheaper so provide an easy way to immigrate. The scam marriages perpetrated are another tactic to get quick immigration. So after all this, who would blame the host country to enact stricter laws. But the most affected by these laws are the genuine aspirants who have to pay for the follies of a few.
 
But the most affected by these laws are the genuine aspirants who have to pay for the follies of a few.

Genuine aspirants would get visa if they are truthful during the interview. Thats what I observed in both French and US Embassies in Mumbai and Chennai.
The ones who were missing out the visas were either those who were not able to tell what their support letter tells about them or those who were trying to boast that I know this n that which will help their country (even though it might not be present in the support letter).

----------------

Bhai Kapil, I agree with the facts that there have been lot of misuse of visas by foreigners. Recently I saw a report that was claiming that 59% of immigrants are fake. But, timing part, I don't think it was coincidental. It was a retaliation and that too immediate. There was severe pressure that was being put on Indian govt to cancel the deal with France. UK's economy is already facing huge turmoil with growth data indicating it is heading towards double dip recession, and when India signed such a big deal with France, it hurt them badly. If India would have striken the deal with UK, it would have been BIG NEWS for the UK markets. A certain mood lift was apparent.

If these regulations were coming, then why UK waited for the deal to be over? Why they didn't come up with these regulations earlier? Are such reports of fake migrants new to them that they had to strengthen the norms immediately after the deal? Since you have been in UK for quite some time now and would know circumstances in UK much better than any of us, can you please shed some more light on this?
 
......... they have also carried over the Indian attitude to subvert law and find loopholes in regulations whereever possible.........

Friend,
This is one side of immigration/migration problem. This does not fall in the category of the debate on the thread posted " Contribution of Indian Immigrants to Life Abroad." Since you are a valued contributor to such type of discussion but such type of post leaves one in bewildeerment.

You are using only black brush to paint the picture of the contribution of the Indians, otherwise, the contribution of the Indians in the field of science, technology, medical profession, academics and economic affairs in various nooks and corners of the world would have surely come to your notice.

I cannot buy the idea that you do not know about it. Everybody knows about the contribution of Dr. S. Chandrashekhar, Dr. Hargobind Khurana, Kalpana Chawla, Dr. Amritya Sen, Swaraj Paul, Mittal and many more in different fields. could anybody add more to this list.

Thanks
 
Friend,
This is one side of immigration/migration problem. This does not fall in the category of the debate on the thread posted " Contribution of Indian Immigrants to Life Abroad." Since you are a valued contributor to such type of discussion but such type of post leaves one in bewildeerment.

You are using only black brush to paint the picture of the contribution of the Indians, otherwise, the contribution of the Indians in the field of science, technology, medical profession, academics and economic affairs in various nooks and corners of the world would have surely come to your notice.

I cannot buy the idea that you do not know about it. Everybody knows about the contribution of Dr. S. Chandrashekhar, Dr. Hargobind Khurana, Kalpana Chawla, Dr. Amritya Sen, Swaraj Paul, Mittal and many more in different fields. could anybody add more to this list.

Thanks

Your bewilderment bewilders me. I dont think you understood my post. It was to offer another angle to immigrants contribution. With the good comes the bad.

And how is the post off topic, can you please explain? There isnt always positive contribution by any community. Some negative comes in too. And as we had already posted a lot on the positive, I wanted to cover some negative angle as well and loo at reasons that lead western countries to increase scrutiny on Indian applicants.

Many countries tighten their immigration laws for Indians on seeing instances of abuses. They put in extra checks and balances in the visa and immigration process to make sure only legitimate application go through. While this makes the process more effective, it also inconveniences the genuine candidate to collect additional paperwork and show adequate bank balance etc.
 
If these regulations were coming, then why UK waited for the deal to be over? Why they didn't come up with these regulations earlier? Are such reports of fake migrants new to them that they had to strengthen the norms immediately after the deal? Since you have been in UK for quite some time now and would know circumstances in UK much better than any of us, can you please shed some more light on this?

Deepak bhai, yahaan to aisi news aati rehti hain kai saal se.

They keep making changes, small and big. This is the official page that shows all announcements in chronological order.
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/n...&filterMonth=&filterYear=&filterDateSubmit=GO

The big change came in March 2011. See this link:
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/newsarticles/2011/march/54-student-visas

Then other big changes announced in Feb/March this year:
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/newsarticles/2012/march/43-changes-rules
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/newsarticles/2012/february/27-new-student-rules

There is a new interview system announced on 9th July, but they were already running a pilot for this. This is the usual process here. They come up with a proposal, then a pilot is run and then it becomes official. So I don't think even this one came from the blue. And anyways, I think the other changes above already put much bigger restrictions in place.
 
Your bewilderment bewilders me. I dont think you understood my post. It was to offer another angle to immigrants contribution. With the good comes the bad.

And how is the post off topic, can you please explain? There isnt always positive contribution by any community. Some negative comes in too. And as we had already posted a lot on the positive, I wanted to cover some negative angle as well and loo at reasons that lead western countries to increase scrutiny on Indian applicants......

Friend,

Do not try to under estimate others as they are also capable to understand a bit of what others give in black and white. I do not say that good and bad both sides do not go with the people. But where are the positive angles in your post; yes negatives were there in your earlier post and same is true with the present one. Therefore, I am not bewildered at all now as you have admitted that you are interested in offering 'another angle'.

Thanks for making me wiser by repeating your plea and argument regarding Indian immigrants contribution in inviting trouble for themselves.

But let me state here that I could not find a line about the contribution of Indians abroad in any of your posts; then, where does the question arise of what you claim to be your offer of 'another angle.' If you try to go to the letter and spirit of the thread, you would definitely write something on the positive side of the contribution too. If not, it is your sweet will none has right to make you to do so! The choice is yours and the decision too rests with you.

Thanks and regards
 
Last edited:
Deepak bhai, yahaan to aisi news aati rehti hain kai saal se.

They keep making changes, small and big. This is the official page that shows all announcements in chronological order.
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/n...&filterMonth=&filterYear=&filterDateSubmit=GO

The big change came in March 2011. See this link:
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/newsarticles/2011/march/54-student-visas

Then other big changes announced in Feb/March this year:
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/newsarticles/2012/march/43-changes-rules
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/newsarticles/2012/february/27-new-student-rules

There is a new interview system announced on 9th July, but they were already running a pilot for this. This is the usual process here. They come up with a proposal, then a pilot is run and then it becomes official. So I don't think even this one came from the blue. And anyways, I think the other changes above already put much bigger restrictions in place.

Friend,

Thanks for your very enlightening and fact based input.

Regards.
 
....... And as we had already posted a lot on the positive, I wanted to cover some negative angle as well and loo at reasons that lead western countries to increase scrutiny on Indian applicants.

Many countries tighten their immigration laws for Indians on seeing instances of abuses. They put in extra checks and balances in the visa and immigration process to make sure only legitimate application go through. While this makes the process more effective, it also inconveniences the genuine candidate to collect additional paperwork and show adequate bank balance etc.

Friend,

Have many countries really tightened their immigration laws for Indians exclusively!

It would be kind of you if you could put a list of the names of such countries as have targeted just Indians separately and have enacted another set of immigration laws to deal with people from other countries of the world.
 
in agreement

my country my rules,
as long as I m getting benefit from foreigners-its ok
else out

i have enough of mine people to take care about

N who give a damn about culture ----globalization

its all profit n loss--------its fair as well

If I m not wrong----no matter where u go , u would always love ur motherland more that where u r now -----




यूके / कनाडा / ऑस्ट्रेलिया / अमरीका की सरकार ने ठेका ले राख्य स के Indians की भलाई करन का...? क्यों करेंगे ये भारत के लोगों के हिसाब तें? इंडिया थोड़ी स, आक कसाब भी बिरयानी खा स कांग्रेस के राज में .....ये देश जो आप ने बताये अपने खुद के हित आर मतलब के हिसाब तें रुल बनावें सें... जो की अच्छी बात स ( आर भारत में कोणी होती )...... जब इन ने जरुरत थी तो gate खुले थे... एब देखा आक बढ़िया माल के गेल कूड़ा भी आवे स तो सख्ती कर दी.... आर आप की जानकारी खातिर बता दयून..... सारे के सारे इंडियन इन देशां में जाके सुपर successful कोणी होते...... गलत काम भी बहुत करें सें....आर इसे लोग बहुत बड़ी तादाद में सें...... इतने इतने सुर्ड़े लोग आ रे सें इन देशां में... आक बूझो मत.....स्टुडेंट भी निरे नकली सर्टिफिकेट ले के बड रे सें यूके में.... एब चना पिसेगा तो घुन भी पिसेगा आक न?..... सब या तो पढ़ के बढ़िया नौकरी कारन आवें सें... या फेर काम के चक्कर में ....या पीसे कमा के उल्टा जान.... मेंने आज ताई एक भी इंडियन नहीं फेट्या स जो न्यू कह आक में तो इस देश का भला करण आया सु.... उ भी अगर यहाँ इतने महंगी पढाई पढ़ के कोए उल्टा इंडिया जागा तो उसका बाबू सर में लठ मारेगा....!!!!!
 
" may be Australia too, "

really-----
i once saw some families protesting outside Australian embassy----some case their kids beaten up in australia ----news mei tha


Yes there are. But high cost of living, racial discrimination people face on streets, lack of sufficient scholarships, etc. make students hesitant to enroll there. Most of middle class Indian students go abroad to study science & technology, healthcare and for that north America and other European countries, may be Australia too, provide better environment than UK. But students still go to UK if they get admission at good institute, for example London School of Economics
 
absolutely

how can we forget Maharashtra and Bihar case

we could not even tolerate fellow Indians , how can we expect foreigners to treat us equal

I think Indian students choose American universities as they are generally considered the best and Australian ones as they are easier to get admission into. UK is definitely not the first choice, but probably still second or third in the list. There are lots of Indian students in the UK. Racial discrimination is not a factor for not choosing UK over other countries. Between the US, Europe and Australia; UK is probably the best from race perspective. Incidents of racial discrimination occur every where (including India).
 
Friend,

Have many countries really tightened their immigration laws for Indians exclusively!

I do not think any developed country has framed the immigration law for Indians exclusively. Pakistan may have some stricter lmmigration laws for Indians exclusively.
 
" may be Australia too, "

really-----
i once saw some families protesting outside Australian embassy----some case their kids beaten up in australia ----news mei tha

ठीक ए रोवें थे वे फेमिली आले ...ऑस्ट्रेलिया में तो आते आते एअरपोर्ट पे इ हंटर ले के खाल तार लें सें इंडियन की...... इस साइड रुख मत करिए रेखा......! :triumphant:
 
Last edited:
in agreement

my country my rules,
as long as I m getting benefit from foreigners-its ok
else out

i have enough of mine people to take care about

N who give a damn about culture ----globalization

its all profit n loss--------its fair as well

If I m not wrong----no matter where u go , u would always love ur motherland more that where u r now -----

In this age of globalisation, it is very difficult, if not impossible, to discriminate among people of one or the other nations by any country. They have to keep maximum possible parity in rules and regulations pertaining to international issues.

Tightening of rules by different nations to control immigration does not mean this step targates Indians only.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top